Guess who dropped in to Kanadahar Air Field?

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

gilliam

Guest
INSTAPUNDIT’S AFGHANISTAN CORRESPONDENT, Maj. Robert Macaraeg, reports:

Instapundit who dropped in to Kanadahar Air Field (KAF)? Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld. Earlier he flew out to a Forward Operating Base, returned to KAF and then reenlisted 11 soldiers, gave a speech, did a question and answer session and then posed for photos with soldiers, airmen, marines and sailors.

He gave a 10 to 15 minute speech on why we are in Afghanistan. He mentioned after 2000 years Afghanistan had its first free election after the Soviets occupation and brutal rule of the Taliban. He was optimistic about the future of Afghanistan and said that the Afghan people wanted a bright future. Also he mentioned the devotion to duty that SFC Smith who was just awarded the Medal of Honor.
http://instapundit.com/archives/images/rumsfeld2.jpg
Then it was the question and answer session. He has a good sense of humor, but did not sugar coat his answers. The questions ranged from the new XM-8 rifle for the infantry, immigration and citizenship for foreigners who serve in the US military, shorter rotations for the US Army and why not military police can earn the new Close Combat Badge. One thing that struck me that he did not B.S. anybody. When he did not know the right answer, he said he would get back to you or deferred to one of Generals to give the straight answer.

One soldier asked the question on why America gets such a negative view of events here. Rumsfeld asked the soldier to repeat the question to make sure that he understood then smiled and laughed. He said “do you think I control the press?” That got a good laugh out of everybody; then he said if you look at any newspaper or TV news program all the headlines are negative. Negative headlines sell. He said with our (military) emails and letters that we send home, people in America will see the good that the military is accomplishing. Also Americans can sort through the news and see the truth. I totally agree with him.

After that he stood with service members for 30 minutes and took photos and shook hands. You can see that he enjoys meeting the troops. I have seen in the previous Sec Defs and Presidents who just did a five minute grip and grin, but Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld impressed the troops and in the dining facility (DFAC) comments were made that he should serve his full term.
 
I know the troops appeciate Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld being there…and they do seem to like him…
 
The man has been an abysmal failure and has turned it into a badge of honor.
 
40.png
Thekla:
The man has been an abysmal failure and has turned it into a badge of honor.
Nonsense. He has been revolutionary for the DoD at a time that it needed changing from a cold war organization to one ready to fight this new asymetrical warfare we have now. There is still a lot of work to do, but he was there to butt heads when needed. He has been much more productive than his predecessor, that is for sure.
 
40.png
Thekla:
The man has been an abysmal failure and has turned it into a badge of honor.
Perhaps you would like to throw some logic into that statement?
 
What is it you are looking for? I certainly can’t explain how rewarding failure has become SOP.
 
I’m asking what logic leads you to believe that the SecDef is an “abysmal failure.” What leads you to that determination?
 
Rumsfeld reminds me very much of Robert MacNamara (sp) from the Kennedy years. I wouldn’t call him a total failure but his refusal to consider any opinions other than his own certainly limits his effectiveness.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top