Gun violence makes sharp decline

  • Thread starter Thread starter markomalley
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

markomalley

Guest
From the Ogden Standard-Examiner
Gun violence has dropped dramatically nationwide over the past two decades, but nearly three-quarters of all homicides are still committed with a firearm, the Justice Department said in a report released Tuesday.The report, by the department’s Bureau of Justice Statistics, painted an encouraging picture of long-term trends at a time of divisive political debate over guns and legislation to regulate them. Firearms-related homicides declined 39 percent between 1993 and 2011, the report said, while nonfatal firearms crimes fell 69 percent during that period.
The DOJ Press Release on the subject says:

Firearm-related homicides declined 39 percent and nonfatal firearm crimes declined 69 percent from 1993 to 2011, the Justice Department’s Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) announced today. Firearm-related homicides dropped from 18,253 homicides in 1993 to 11,101 in 2011, and nonfatal firearm crimes dropped from 1.5 million victimizations in 1993 to 467,300 in 2011.

For both fatal and nonfatal firearm victimizations, the majority of the decline occurred during the 10-year period from 1993 to 2002. The number of firearm homicides declined from 1993 to 1999, rose through 2006 and then declined through 2011. Nonfatal firearm violence declined from 1993 through 2004 before fluctuating in the mid- to late 2000s.
It makes this other pertinent observation:

In 2004 (the most recent year of data available), among state prison inmates who possessed a gun at the time of the offense, fewer than two percent bought their firearm at a flea market or gun show. About 10 percent of state prison inmates said they purchased it from a retail store or pawnshop, 37 percent obtained it from family or friends, and another 40 percent obtained it from an illegal source.
Please note this carefully. Out of state prison inmates who were busted in possession of a gun, 77% of them got that gun from sources that would not have been impacted by a background check. Only 2% of them might have been stopped by restricting flea market or gun show sales.

Here’s a link to the whole study (PDF)
 
Only 2% of them might have been stopped by restricting flea market or gun show sales.
I think that statement is inaccurate considering the fact that the ATF traced 30% of guns used in a crime to unlicensed dealers at gun shows and the fact that private sellers, with no legal obligation to perform background checks, seem to be primarily responsible for putting guns in the hands of criminals.
 
If the argument was about logic, the study would have high value in the conversation. Alas, politics is the driver.
 
I think that statement is inaccurate considering the fact that the ATF traced 30% of guns used in a crime to unlicensed dealers at gun shows and the fact that private sellers, with no legal obligation to perform background checks, seem to be primarily responsible for putting guns in the hands of criminals.
Do you have a link or reference?
 
I think that statement is inaccurate considering the fact that the ATF traced 30% of guns used in a crime to unlicensed dealers at gun shows and the fact that private sellers, with no legal obligation to perform background checks, seem to be primarily responsible for putting guns in the hands of criminals.
Criminals will get guns no matter what.

I wouldn’t count on unionized government workers to stop that.
 
I think that statement is inaccurate considering the fact that the ATF traced 30% of guns …
Keep in mind ATF is actively involved operations to allow strawman purchases of firearms, which then are sold in Mexico … and now the claims of the travesty of US guns in Mexico. It would not surprise me in the least if they were doing similar operations they haven’t been caught at too. Their numbers are suspect.
 
Criminals will get guns no matter what. I wouldn’t count on unionized government workers to stop that.
If the rebuttal to stricter gun laws is that someone will always find a way to break the law then why have any laws at all?
 
If the rebuttal to stricter gun laws is that someone will always find a way to break the law then why have any laws at all?
Good question, Emperor Napoleon. Why have inefficacious laws of any kind? Cesare Beccaria, a Milanese jurist, economist, and criminologist observed long ago concerning such laws that, “They disarm those only who are neither inclined nor determined to commit crimes”. ~On Crimes and Punishment - 1764
 
Good question, Emperor Napoleon. Why have inefficacious laws of any kind? Cesare Beccaria, a Milanese jurist, economist, and criminologist observed long ago concerning such laws that, “They disarm those only who are neither inclined nor determined to commit crimes”. ~On Crimes and Punishment - 1764
Civilized thinking has progressed a lot since 1794. Its pure folly to just give someone a deadly weapon operating merely under the assumption that they would use it legally and responsibly.
 
If the rebuttal to stricter gun laws is that someone will always find a way to break the law then why have any laws at all?
It depends on what you consider the purpose of laws. A criminal law is, by defention, a post facto punishment. It is enforced after the fact.

A law can only deter those who fear the punishment. A speeding law deters by the threat of a fine, but it one is not impacted by the fine, there is no deterrence in the speeding law.

Likewise with a firearms law. The threat of punishment would only deter those who fear the punishment of the crime. Those who look to commit a crime, by definition, do not fear the punishment of the law. They have set their mind and will to it, and the added punishment of possessing an illegal firearm in the act they intent adds no deterrence.

Adam Lanza, for example, did not have a valid drivers license-]/-], yet he drove to Sandy Hook. Would you claim that traffic law was an effective deterrence to the shooting there? Would increasing the fines for driving without a license have had a deterrent effect on future shootings? Or is it just one more thing to prosecute for after the fact?
 
I think that statement is inaccurate considering the fact that the ATF traced 30% of guns used in a crime to unlicensed dealers at gun shows and the fact that private sellers, with no legal obligation to perform background checks, seem to be primarily responsible for putting guns in the hands of criminals.
Still no source for that claim.

According to an NIJ study released in December 1997 (Homicide in Eight U.S. Cities, a report that covers much more than homicide), only 2% of criminal guns come from gun shows. Even more amazing the same study found that 25% of crime guns came from gun stores, even though FBI permission is required for every purchase from a gun store.

Why is the FBI allowing criminals to purchase firearms?
 
If the rebuttal to stricter gun laws is that someone will always find a way to break the law then why have any laws at all?
It would be fairer to describe the objections as “Laws that create restrictions and burdens on responsible citizens should only be considered if they can reasonably be expected to significantly affect the behavior of those inclined towards CRIMINAL activity.”

I’m not a gun owner myself at the moment and I can understand why other non-gun owners see no issue with heaping lots of feel-good restrictions on gun ownership. It’s kind of like raising cigarette taxes: who cares if you don’t smoke? But this IS a liberty issue and I am personally alarmed at the way gunophobes are trying to characterize all semiautomatic rifles as being “assualt rifles.” It’s not only unwarranted, but absurd. My dad’s hunting buddies almost all use semi-autos. They’re just hunters! There really is an agenda going on and it does make me nervous about liberty in this country. Does that mean I’m with the NRA and oppose all reasonable restrictions? Nope. But I oppose the unreasonable ones, and there are plenty.
 
Still no source for that claim.

According to an NIJ study released in December 1997 (Homicide in Eight U.S. Cities, a report that covers much more than homicide), only 2% of criminal guns come from gun shows. Even more amazing the same study found that 25% of crime guns came from gun stores, even though FBI permission is required for every purchase from a gun store.

Why is the FBI allowing criminals to purchase firearms?
Bolding mine.

Would those guns be purchased at gun shows without a background check?
 
Well, things pushing the drop in crime were more states relaxing gun laws. That is, more and more moving to ‘shall-issue’ CCWs and stronger castle doctrine laws, immunity from liability in self-defense actions etc. Additionally, laws placing longer prison terms on repeat offenders. For example, CA saw a significant drop in crime after passing the ‘three strikes law’. Makes sense, since a large proportion of crime is carried out by the repeat offenders.

I expect that in CA the gun crime will start to rise again. since the courts have ordered CA to release prisoners due to overcrowding (our legislature would rather screw around with funding high-speed rail and other boon-doggles than new prisons). As well as, a recent ballot initiative significantly weakened the ‘three strikes’ law. Sheriffs have already reported rising crime since the releases and several high profile multiple murders have been attributed to the released prisoners.

Since our legislature is also pursuing ‘Chicago’ style anti-gun paradise laws; I expect we’ll soon have the Chicago style murder/gun crime rates that go along with it.
 
Bolding mine.

Would those guns be purchased at gun shows without a background check?
As I understand it, most states already require gun show purchase to go through background checks. I know they do in CA.
 
Gun violence makes sharp decline … except of course in places like Detroit, Baltimore, Oakland, Philadelphia, Chicago, Washington, DC, etc. (all of which are known for having strict gun control laws).
 
Gun violence makes sharp decline … except of course in places like Detroit, Baltimore, Oakland, Philadelphia, Chicago, Washington, DC, etc. (all of which are known for having strict gun control laws).
If only they had reasonable gun control laws like Wyoming and New Hampshire.
 
I find these studies saying that crime has decreased completely bogus. In the inner city most people don’t report crime unless there is insurance money involved. In gang infested areas people are burglarized and robbed all the time but don’t report it since doing so will put your life in danger. 60 minutes just did a story on an inner city neighbored where the residents were constantly harassed and robbed by gangs and the criminal element. One man admitted he had been robbed over fifty times. Those people never reported those crimes to the police.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top