Gun violence makes sharp decline

  • Thread starter Thread starter markomalley
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I find these studies saying that crime has decreased completely bogus. In the inner city most people don’t report crime unless there is insurance money involved. In gang infested areas people are burglarized and robbed all the time but don’t report it since doing so will put your life in danger. 60 minutes just did a story on an inner city neighbored where the residents were constantly harassed and robbed by gangs and the criminal element. One man admitted he had been robbed over fifty times. Those people never reported those crimes to the police.
All things being equal if the inner city didn’t report crime before and don’t report crime now then you haven’t made your point.
 
All things being equal if the inner city didn’t report crime before and don’t report crime now then you haven’t made your point.
But it does make the point that the police are not legally obligated much less physically capable of preventing crime or protecting the public. Hence, in inner cities where folks are deprived of the means of self-defense, crime becomes so prevelant and the police so overloaded in even taking reports much less investigating crimes the public loses confidence/trust in the judicial system.
 
Gun violence makes sharp decline … except of course in places like Detroit, Baltimore, Oakland, Philadelphia, Chicago, Washington, DC, etc. (all of which are known for having strict gun control laws).
Not true on Detroit, MI preempts any local ordinances, and MI is a ‘shall-issue, open carry’ state.

There is registration of handguns, and required background check on all handgun sales ( technically, it’s permit to purchase done ahead of time that is valid for any handgun purchase, a CPL also suffices for the permit to purchase)
 
I find these studies saying that crime has decreased completely bogus. In the inner city most people don’t report crime unless there is insurance money involved. In gang infested areas people are burglarized and robbed all the time but don’t report it since doing so will put your life in danger. 60 minutes just did a story on an inner city neighbored where the residents were constantly harassed and robbed by gangs and the criminal element. One man admitted he had been robbed over fifty times. Those people never reported those crimes to the police.
I saw that show. Yeah… that tripped me out. It was an old white man. I couldn’t believe the guy got robbed 50 times. I remember some older white man I shared a class with at MATC in Milwaukee telling me he had house broken into over several years to the tune of something like 10 times. I’ve been robbed myself, assaulted in one while I was drunk and street lights were out, but I’ve never been robbed 10 or 50 times.

That city on the 60 Minutes show was in Massachusetts and some crazy Wild West part of the town were gang members where openly riding around on bikes with AK-47’s slung over their backs. Until the police under and Army Special Forces commando from the Afghanistan war retook the neighborhood using counter insurgency methods he learned in Afghanistan. Now he plans to take some of what he learned in this city back to Afghanistan.

I would say certain things are down in Milwaukee. I can’t speak for other cities. But even in Milwaukee I would not say they are down by any dramatic degree. Chances of getting robbed, stabbed, beat, rapped, or shot still exist pretty much to the degree they always have. But aggressive policing seems to me to have worked to bring down the cockiness of some of the career thugs and has broken up a number of organized crime cliques. That’s the positive news.

I think petty theft is still same. I still hear the TV when I’m in another room and the news is on talking about someone being shot to death.

I would agree with you that most crimes–except for stabbing, shootings, and car thefts–tend to go unreported in inner-cities. There is an unwritten rule among many that you don’t call the cops. I’m not one of them. People can label me a snitch, I don’t care, you shoot me and I’ll probably call the cops on you. The major reason is I know cats hate going to prison, especially if the person they hate is free on the outside. So, why should I do what you like? No, if this is war I’ll do what you don’t like. I don’t care about “honor,” I have none.

Here is that 60 Minutes show you were talking about: cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=50146233n

Edit:

Eh… wrong link. Here is the specific one: cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=50146229n
 
Still no source for that claim.

According to an NIJ study released in December 1997 (Homicide in Eight U.S. Cities, a report that covers much more than homicide), only 2% of criminal guns come from gun shows. Even more amazing the same study found that 25% of crime guns came from gun stores, even though FBI permission is required for every purchase from a gun store.

Why is the FBI allowing criminals to purchase firearms?
I’m waiting too.:rolleyes:
 
Do you have a link or reference?
A highlight of the report:

“Together, the ATF investigations paint a disturbing picture of gun shows as a venue for criminal activity and a source of firearms used in crimes. Felons, although prohibited from acquiring firearms, have been able to purchase firearms at gun shows. In fact, felons buying or selling firearms were involved in more than 46 percent of the investigations involving gun shows. In more than a third of the investigations, the firearms involved were known to have been used in subsequent crimes. These crimes included drug offenses, felons in possession of a firearm, assault, robbery, burglary, and homicide.”
 
A highlight of the report:

"Together, the ATF investigations paint a disturbing picture of gun shows as a venue for criminal activity and a source of firearms used in crimes. Felons, although prohibited from acquiring firearms, have been able to purchase firearms at gun shows. In fact, felons buying or selling firearms were involved in more than 46 percent of the investigations involving gun shows. In more than a third of the investigations, the firearms involved were known to have been used in subsequent crimes. These crimes included drug offenses, felons in possession of a firearm, assault, robbery, burglary, and homicide."
Thanks for the report that is 14 years old.:rolleyes:
 
This just gets better and better…From the “report”…

In the 105th Congress, Representative Rod Blagojevich introduced legislation addressing
gun shows…Yes a guy we want to trust!

There was widespread agreement among United States Attorneys that it can be difficult
to prove that a nonlicensed person is “engaging in the business” of firearms dealing
without a license under current law. The definitions create substantial investigative and
proof problems.52 Significant undercover work and follow-up by ATF are required to
prepare a case against someone for “engaging in the business.”

Finally, in reply to open letters posted on the Internet, ATF received 274 responses. The
vast majority of these responses either opposed any new restrictions on gun shows or
favored enforcement of existing law

Yes, enforce existing laws!
 
This just gets better and better…From the “report”…

In the 105th Congress, Representative Rod Blagojevich introduced legislation addressing
gun shows…Yes a guy we want to trust!

There was widespread agreement among United States Attorneys that it can be difficult
to prove that a nonlicensed person is “engaging in the business” of firearms dealing
without a license under current law. The definitions create substantial investigative and
proof problems.52 Significant undercover work and follow-up by ATF are required to
prepare a case against someone for “engaging in the business.”

Finally, in reply to open letters posted on the Internet, ATF received 274 responses. The
vast majority of these responses either opposed any new restrictions on gun shows or
favored enforcement of existing law

Yes, enforce existing laws!
What exactly is the point of posting this? To demonstrate that gun shows are an unregulated goliath in illegal arms trafficking with dealers who are difficult to prosecute? Thanks for proving my point.
That article has nothing to do with where criminals get their guns and it certainly doesn’t refute the ATF report. 🤷
 
What exactly is the point of posting this? To demonstrate that gun shows are an unregulated goliath in illegal arms trafficking with dealers who are difficult to prosecute? Thanks for proving my point.

That article has nothing to do with where criminals get their guns and it certainly doesn’t refute the ATF report. 🤷
It was to show that you are absolutely clueless about where and how criminals obtain illegal weapons.

But that’s OK it isn’t the first time you let your politics get in the way of reality.
 
Do you have any source which cites an improvement in those figures? Don’t ask for sources if you don’t want to know the facts.
You are a student aren’t you? Now what would your professor say about 14 year old citations? Don’t lie now, I know the answer!😃
 
It was to show that you are absolutely clueless about where and how criminals obtain illegal weapons. But that’s OK it isn’t the first time you let your politics get in the way of reality.
Lets see a source which refutes the ATF report. Still waiting.
 
No need to wait provided in post 31.
Can you cite the passage which specifically and unequivocally refutes the ATF’s finding that 30% of guns used in the commission of a crime are traced to gun shows? I seem to be unable to find such a passage in that link. There are lots of figures about what crimes guns are being used to commit but not a single sentence about where those guns are acquired.
 
Can you cite the passage which specifically and unequivocally refutes the ATF’s finding that 30% of guns used in the commission of a crime are traced to gun shows? I seem to be unable to find such a passage in that link. There are lots of figures about what crimes guns are being used to commit but not a single sentence about where those guns are acquired.
Here is a Dept of Justice study from 1995-2001 on where criminals acquired their guns. It involved the DoJ interviewing over 230,000 felons on where they obtained the guns they used in their crimes.

bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/pub/pdf/fuo.pdf

Table 8 has the relevant data.

About 40% got theirs from the street or from an robbery or burglary etc…

33% got them from friend or acquaintance (straw purchase)

1.9% got them from a gun show or flea market

The gun show metric does not break down FFL purchases that would have included a background check vs private sellers, which would not have involved a background check.

 
There were 192 million guns in 1994 and the National Institute of Justice said there were 310 million guns in 2009. Gun ownership increased and gun homicide has declined.
 
The gun show metric does not break down FFL purchases that would have included a background check vs private sellers, which would not have involved a background check.
Unlike the ATF study, this one does not trace the origin of trafficked guns i.e. where the guns on the streets originated. The buck doesn’t stop at the street; you also have to determine how they got there. What the ATF proved was that gun shows are a goliath in illegal arms trafficking and the originating source of guns used in the commission of 30% of gun crimes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top