Gun violence makes sharp decline

  • Thread starter Thread starter markomalley
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unlike the ATF study, this one does not trace the origin of trafficked guns i.e. where the guns on the streets originated. The buck doesn’t stop at the street; you also have to determine how they got there. What the ATF proved was that gun shows are a goliath in illegal arms trafficking and the originating source of guns used in the commission of 30% of gun crimes.
Here’s the absurdity of your argument. The criteria you are proposing will automatically penalize the venue at which most guns are sold. Think it through:
  1. Law abiding man buys a gun at a gun show.
  2. Said man (foolishly, IMO) stores his gun in his dresser.
  3. Said man is burglarized and gun is stolen among other things.
  4. Gun is used in a crime and recovered by police.
  5. Gun shows up on ATF list as a gun originally sold at a gun show.
Until and unless you can separate out how many of those guns “acquired” at a gun show were later stolen from their legitimate owner, the statistic is useless. What is needed is to figure out where the actual crime perpetrator GOT the gun, not whether it was ever sold at a gun show. See what a difference that is?
 
Not true on Detroit, MI preempts any local ordinances, and MI is a ‘shall-issue, open carry’ state.

There is registration of handguns, and required background check on all handgun sales ( technically, it’s permit to purchase done ahead of time that is valid for any handgun purchase, a CPL also suffices for the permit to purchase)
I was referring to the fact that Detroit topped Forbes’ list of America’s most dangerous cities for the fourth year in a row.
 
Until and unless you can separate out how many of those guns “acquired” at a gun show were later stolen from their legitimate owner, the statistic is useless. What is needed is to figure out where the actual crime perpetrator GOT the gun, not whether it was ever sold at a gun show. See what a difference that is?
Except that burgled guns and guns bought via illegal arms trafficking are two separate categories. It matters that illegally trafficked guns are purchased at gun shows and it matters that those guns wind up on the street and are used in the commission of 30% of gun crimes. The criminal got them ultimately because unlicensed dealers are allowed operate at gun shows free of regulation.
The criteria you are proposing will automatically penalize the venue at which most guns are sold.
Why shouldn’t liability be introduced? The regulations would largely enforce themselves if gun dealers were held liable, ie charged as an accessory, for crimes committed with guns improperly sold.
 
Except that burgled guns and guns bought via illegal arms trafficking are two separate categories. It matters that illegally trafficked guns are purchased at gun shows and it matters that those guns wind up on the street and are used in the commission of 30% of gun crimes. The criminal got them ultimately because unlicensed dealers are allowed operate at gun shows free of regulation.

Why shouldn’t liability be introduced? The regulations would largely enforce themselves if gun dealers were held liable, ie charged as an accessory, for crimes committed with guns improperly sold.
You seem to want to ban the private sale of firearms. I think that’s unfair, unwarranted and anti-constitutional. (I am thinking in terms of a property right, not only the Second Amendment is at risk but also the Fifth) It’s also unavailing as crime prevention. Extending liability for unlawful acts to those merely engaged in commerce is unjust. When all is said and done, it comes down to politics, politics and more politics.
 
You seem to want to ban the private sale of firearms. I think that’s unfair, unwarranted and anti-constitutional. (I am thinking in terms of a property right, not only the Second Amendment is at risk but also the Fifth) It’s also unavailing as crime prevention.
Regulating firearm sales at gun shows is not unavailing considering the fact that 30% of guns used in the commission of a crime are traced there.
Extending liability for unlawful acts to those merely engaged in commerce is unjust.
Unjust for whom? Certainly not the victim who was blown away ultimately because an unlicensed dealer at a gun show didn’t want to ask any questions. We already extend liability to businesses for unlawful acts committed by their customers with the aide or cause of their product. Bar owners and other alcohol servers can be held liable in 43 States for injuries or death when one of their over-served customers maims or kills someone while driving drunk. Why not apply a similar law to gun dealers engaging in irresponsible and improper sales?
 
Can you cite the passage which specifically and unequivocally refutes the ATF’s finding that 30% of guns used in the commission of a crime are traced to gun shows?
You are mis-citing the report. 30% of the guns purchased from gun shows were used in the commission of a crime. That is different than 30% of all guns used in the commission of a crime were bought in a gun show.

The report summarized a study of 314 investigations that involved gun shows in some capacity. 100% of the cases were related to gun shows. The 30% figure you cite is of the 314 investigations. Note that that includes criminal activity by federal fire arm license holders who are required by law to do background checks.

So, I will use your source to specifically and unequivocally refute YOUR reading of the ATF report.

Peace

Tim
 
Regulating firearm sales at gun shows is not unavailing considering the fact that 30% of guns used in the commission of a crime are traced there.

Unjust for whom? Certainly not the victim who was blown away ultimately because an unlicensed dealer at a gun show didn’t want to ask any questions. We already extend liability to businesses for unlawful acts committed by their customers with the aide or cause of their product. Bar owners and other alcohol servers can be held liable in 43 States for injuries or death when one of their over-served customers maims or kills someone while driving drunk. Why not apply a similar law to gun dealers engaging in irresponsible and improper sales?
Very simple to answer. First your 30% is not credible without sourcing and proper interpretation. I understand it to be but a small fraction of that. Also, you do not discern that many guns used in crime were stolen from the lawful buyer/owner. You characterize legitimate transactions as “irresponsible and improper” without supporting data. Are you sure that you are not engaging in hyperbole? But that’s a side issue. My more serious objection is that there is a comparison between a bartender who can see when a customer has had too much to drink and the seller of a firearm for events beyond his control or reckoning. That is unjust. Tell me, in logical terms, where I am mistaken.
 
Very simple to answer. First your 30% is not credible without sourcing and proper interpretation. I understand it to be but a small fraction of that. Also, you do not discern that many guns used in crime were stolen from the lawful buyer/owner. You characterize legitimate transactions as “irresponsible and improper” without supporting data.
It is all sourced in post #26.
My more serious objection is that there is a comparison between a bartender who can see when a customer has had too much to drink and the seller of a firearm for events beyond his control or reckoning. That is unjust. Tell me, in logical terms, where I am mistaken.
You are mistaken in the fact that you seemingly don’t believe that gun dealers have a responsibility to do their due diligence in vetting potential customers.
 
It is all sourced in post #26.

You are mistaken in the fact that you seemingly don’t believe that gun dealers have a responsibility to do their due diligence in vetting potential customers.
How can you say that? Gun Dealers have a long-standing obligation, by present law, to run every buyer through the background check system. I support this. Never said otherwise. What I do not support is the Federal government getting between transactions conducted among family and friends. That is too intrusive. It is draconian. It is tyrannical. It is also stupid.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top