Zoltan Cobalt:
Autos kill more people than guns (FACT) why are autos not considered to be a “health hazard” to be controlled and regulated by a public health agency???
Of course autos are a health hazard, and I wouldn’t be surprised if the statistics indicated that the more one drives the lower one’s life expectancy is due to higher likelihood of being in an accident. They are, however, regarded as a necessary health hazard, as they are our primary means of transportation.
Because this is nothing more than a political agenda rather than any real concern for public safety.
There need be no distinguish between the two. Clearly it is a concern for public safety that drives gun control advocacy. It is a belief that the lack of sufficient regulation of guns contributes to an unnecessary increase in risk of harm done. Right or wrong, that’s the belief, it is not merely a phobia of firearms. I’m not sure what difference it makes calling it a “political” agenda as opposed to some other kind of agenda.
Though I suppose it would be correct to say it would be a ‘public safety’ issue rather than a ‘public health’ issue.
Since the right to keep and bear arms is PROTECTED by the U.S. Constitution…any infringement would certainly be an "attack on freedom.
All infringements on freedom are not equal though. Again, a civilian is not and should not be free to carry active explosives around in public. This is not merely because explosives are dangerous (as you mention so are cars) but because it is generally accepted that pretty much the only reason one would carry explosives in public is to do something bad. Now, a person may possess a gun for reasons other than doing something bad, so I would put it somewhere between active explosives and automobiles on the spectrum of how legitimately necessary/useful a dangerous object is. Hence why their possession shouldn’t be (and isn’t) as severely restricted as that of active explosives, but should be more restricted than possession of an automobile, which could not be so restricted simply because they are so necessary and useful compared to guns.
Regarding the 2nd amendment, I entirely agree that more gun control advocates should formally state that they support the amendment of the constitution rather than trying to contort it. It would be more honest; there’s no shame in disagreeing with the constitution, if one is honest about it. Hence how we got so many amendments, and it is quite clear that the writers of the constitution were not omniscient nor infallible. In their times, guns were more necessary, mainly for hunting, but perhaps also for protection given the absence of organized law enforcement and a formidable standing army. But they are not so necessary anymore, and have become considerably more deadly than they were back then as well.