Have you ever walked out of Mass?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Paul_theApostle
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Only once when there was a time mix-up and I realized that I had just walked in door at the moment of Consecration … :eek: I quickly left and drove to another parish nearby so I could attend the entire Mass from start to finish … My bad. :o

 
Yup.
Once when we were traveling. The Mass was so far out in never-neverland that we thought that we were in a Protestant church. Turned out that the church was actually Catholic (at least in name).

Another time was an Easter Sunday about ten years ago in our home parish. The music was so sacrilegious that we left at the Offertory and drove more than 100 miles to a parish that we could be sure would have a reverent Easter Mass. I believe that staying at Mass under those circumstances is tantamount to condoning sacrilege.
 
Have you ever walked out of Mass? particularly Modern Masses where you couldnt bear the music or a certain Priest or sermon? or other reasons?
No. At least not in response to the liturgical action. I have sometimes been uncomfortable. But I have not ever walked out.

As far as for illness, an issue with a child, or something like that, sure. But that would have been an issue with me or mine, not an issue with the Mass.
 
A few Sundays ago we had our annual “Newman Sunday” where the priests from the local Newman center visit to celebrate the Mass and take-up a collection at the end of Mass. It was nice to see that a Newman member did not preach this time. They actually did give a “reflection” (and a good one) after one of the priests preached.

But as I watched and listened I was a little taken aback. The celebrant tried to emasculate the Mass by changing words. In some cases he just made up new parts. He did not pour the wine before the consecration even though the server correctly placed the chalices on the altar. The second priest simply sat in the pews when he could have easily concelebrated or at least distributed communion.

I didn’t leave Mass but I didn’t contribute any money either. It’s precisely those sorts of things that WOULD have made me thought of walking out in the past.
 
For what it’s worth, if I were to talk out of church, few would notice and those that did would think I was visiting the lavatory.
 
Yup.
Once when we were traveling. The Mass was so far out in never-neverland that we thought that we were in a Protestant church. Turned out that the church was actually Catholic (at least in name).

Another time was an Easter Sunday about ten years ago in our home parish. The music was so sacrilegious that we left at the Offertory and drove more than 100 miles to a parish that we could be sure would have a reverent Easter Mass. I believe that staying at Mass under those circumstances is tantamount to condoning sacrilege.
Agreed. I can ignore slight cheesiness and make allowances for the wide and lax rubrics being used (or not used) many places, but when you stray the lines and lose the reverence and indeed obscure the point of the Mass, staying there is condoning it. If there is ever any reason to suspect that the consecration isn’t right, or the priest is playing fast and loose with the Canon, you have to get out and find a valid, licit Mass. VII made a lot of inroads for adding variety or whatever to the Mass, but there are parts you do not mess with.

I have never walked out, but I’ve been close to my limit and looking for the nerve to do so (or the self-restraint to not do it in a huff and make a scene). I have had some stern chats with priests after Mass, the kind that can be boiled down to “What the heck was that?!” In those cases I pray for the priest and congregants, and make sure I kneel and receive on the tongue, out of reverence for Christ, to show the hippies how it should look, and yeah, maybe to be a little rebellious to the rebellion.

I’ve never walked out, but my stress dreams tend to be about attending Masses rife with liturgical abuse or sacrilege and throwing down the blasphemy flag. I don’t think I’d have the guts to be that vocal right in the middle, even if it was blatantly invalid (but I hope I would), to come to the defense of Christ’s holy Mass.
 
Yup.
My Mrs. was in a wheelchair at the time. When the hootnanny music started, she leaned over to me and said “Can we still make the 11:00 at Holy Rosary”? I answered “Yup, if we hustle”. She responded “I am out of here” and rapidly propelled her wheelchair down the aisle to the door.
It didn’t help that the Easter before we had been “treated” to a piano rendition of Here Comes Peter Cotton Tail after the recessional as we were leaving church.
 
Yup.
My Mrs. was in a wheelchair at the time. When the hootnanny music started, she leaned over to me and said “Can we still make the 11:00 at Holy Rosary”? I answered “Yup, if we hustle”. She responded “I am out of here” and rapidly propelled her wheelchair down the aisle to the door.
It didn’t help that the Easter before we had been “treated” to a piano rendition of Here Comes Peter Cotton Tail **after the recessional **as we were leaving church.
After the recessional Mass is over. 😉
 
Not trying to pick a fight here, but I think we’d be required to walk out under some circumstances. Anyone have a thought on this?
I wouldn’t say “required” but there are times it is the prudent thing to do. For example, if you have your children with you and the priest is preaching against Church teaching or if you are witnessing something highly irregular such as lay women joining in the Consecration.
 
No, never walked out.
If I don’t agree then I attend another parish but I have patience and respect for the Mass, no matter how awful the music, Priest, or whatever, to stay till that Mass has ended.
I nearly did one weekday Mass when the priest during his homily spoke about the poor in a manner I believe was improper. Had it not been I was there in remembrance of my mother’s birthday I would have. Now when I attend Catholic Mass it is at a different parish.
 
After the recessional Mass is over. 😉
Does that make it OK?
Easter is the most solemn feast in the Church calender. The Blessed sacrament is present in the tabernacle. Folks have not even made it out the door of the church.
Peter Cottontail?
Sheesh.
We have sure changed in the last fifty years.
 
Yes, two times but each time was health related. For example once my asthma was acting up. I was coughing like crazy and I was having trouble breathing. I left out of respect because I didn’t want my coughing to disrupt the mass. The second time, I managed to get my thumb stuck in a kneeler during mass. (don’t ask how I managed that.) Needless to say, I spent rest of the mass in the parish kitchen icing my thumb. I was fortunate to only sprain it.
 
I have for health, too. Our church gets pretty packed, and I get pretty sick when it’s warm and stuffy. I’ve had to step out to get air, and a few times wasn’t able to get my green stomach down until it was over. I usually stand by the window so I can still hear and see.
 
Not trying to pick a fight here, but I think we’d be required to walk out under some circumstances. Anyone have a thought on this?
I am fairly certain this is not something that the Church teaches. Have you ever read this or seen this in any Church document?

No. I would never walk out on Jesus. As someone already said, if a meeting was not actually Mass, that would be different.
 
I am fairly certain this is not something that the Church teaches. Have you ever read this or seen this in any Church document?

No. I would never walk out on Jesus. As someone already said, if a meeting was not actually Mass, that would be different.
I agree, it’s not something the church teaches and it’s not something Jesus taught either. In fact, when the Pharisees were condemned for not following what they taught, Jesus didn’t say run to another Rabbi and ignore him, he said “Do what they say, not what they do.” He reminded them that the person still had the authority of the seat of Moses.

We as Catholics have to remember that the priest still has authority, and we are to do what the church teaches, and not follow the bad examples of men who just like us can make mistakes.
 
Agreed. I can ignore slight cheesiness and make allowances for the wide and lax rubrics being used (or not used) many places, but when you stray the lines and lose the reverence and indeed obscure the point of the Mass, staying there is condoning it. If there is ever any reason to suspect that the consecration isn’t right, or the priest is playing fast and loose with the Canon, you have to get out and find a valid, licit Mass. VII made a lot of inroads for adding variety or whatever to the Mass, but there are parts you do not mess with.

I have never walked out, but I’ve been close to my limit and looking for the nerve to do so (or the self-restraint to not do it in a huff and make a scene). I have had some stern chats with priests after Mass, the kind that can be boiled down to “What the heck was that?!” In those cases I pray for the priest and congregants, and make sure I kneel and receive on the tongue, out of reverence for Christ, to show the hippies how it should look, and yeah, maybe to be a little rebellious to the rebellion.

I’ve never walked out, but my stress dreams tend to be about attending Masses rife with liturgical abuse or sacrilege and throwing down the blasphemy flag. I don’t think I’d have the guts to be that vocal right in the middle, even if it was blatantly invalid (but I hope I would), to come to the defense of Christ’s holy Mass.
I believe the other poster was talking about music…which can be VERY subjective… Not about the concentration.
 
I have left directly after communion on one occasion for a reason that would probably take this thread way off topic, but i do leave super fast after the mass officially ends i wait till the priest exits the church and then i scadoodle, because of the choir, and this is at both churches i swap between due to if i miss the morning mass i can go to the evening mass at the other, any how the choir either plays something moronic , or will start doing guitar riffs n drum solos after the priest leaves, or the priest leaves and some uppity in the choir feels it necessary to address everyone remaining in the church and play happy birthday for that person. I call it moronic because I see the physical church as a place to be treated with reverance, not a place for loud music or antics, if someone wants to form some music group outside of mass, fine, go for it, keep out of the church so others can pray in peace and silence, and if the choir wants to play a special song for someone having a birthday, fine take it to the Church hall, or hey throw a party for that person some where and do it.

That and for some reason everyone at the contemporary mass at a church in town i go to, feels it necessary to give a round of applause to the choir after they finish.

And I mean they are not that great, it isnt like we have some New York orchestra that people pay 50 bucks a pop to listen to.

A simple thanks by the priest would be sufficent for me after mass and they do most all the time thank them.

Also I don’t understand with all the chatter in church before and after mass, I would say 95% of those that attend the churches i go to, feel it necessary to talk about the goings on of the week or day, or the elderly love to talk about who is in the hospital, what medications they are on, or their irritable bowel syndrome. Point being innappropriate conversations in church… it is as if nothing is special, sacred,or deserving of reverance until the mass actually starts, and it ends directly the moment priest ends mass and begins walking down the isle.

another horror story.

The priest in my church had to bring the Eucharist from the tabernacle to Adoration one Sunday, people were leaving, some were still in the church, talking, and the priest announces via the pulpit (WITH MICROPHONE) what he was about to do and to kneel in reverance ( paraphrasing).

some of us heard and did, others acted as if nothing was going on, or they were too busy flapping their traps to have heard the announcement.

I can only imagine how a priest sees his congregation when saying the mass.

And incase you might think i am full of it, consider this…

in comparision, i have been to the Wall South Memorial as a teenager serving in the Army, in Washington Dc, there is a sign that reads something to the sort of no food, cell phones, and to basically mind your manners.

and at that time of day that i was there, it felt like i was at some holy place, it was quiet, people were in awe, and no one was on a cell phone.

Now people in church answer their cell phones to tell someone on the other end they cant talk because they are in church, that is after they let their cell phone ring 7 times.
 
Yes. One time it was the middle of summer and it was so humid and hot, I was sweating and literally my shirt looked like as if I took a shower wearing that shirt. I left, it was already about the Offertory. Went home, took a real shower, then went for a later Mass in the evening when it was much cooler.
 
I have left…

…that is after they let their cell phone ring 7 times.
Great post; the whole lot of it!
It`s a good summing-up of the disgraceful behaviour in so many churches.

i like your choice of words: straight to the point! 👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top