Hawking posits false conflict

  • Thread starter Thread starter Soutane
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Science rejects such religious notions because they are, by their very nature, irrational and untestable and therefore impossible to verify.
First, you don’t know that.

Second, you don’t know whether there is life of any kind at the far edges of the universe, any more than you know for a scientific fact that there are no angels. But I take it you concede the possibility that there is life at the far edge of the universe, theoretically, though no one is ever likely to verify it scientifically. Right?
 
No. The word “amount” has no numerical connotations in and of itself.
Well, let’s see how you expressed your “infinites”.

"It makes life on Earth unimportant because there is likely an infinite amount of life in the universe.

There are an infinite number of reasons to believe otherwise.

there is likely an infinite amount of life in the universe."

For there to be an infinite amount of life in the universe, there has to be an infinite number of living beings. Correct? Or are you saying you think life is some kind of universal unity encompassing all living things notwithstanding their perception that they are individuals separate from other life?

“Infinite number” of reasons.

Now, please explain yourself when it comes to “infinite amounts” of life and “infinite number” of reasons.

And, in the process, please explain how, if there is an “infinite amount” of life, their existence is consistent with the existence of inanimate objects that are not living. (i.e., why the living beings, being “infinite” do not crowd out the nonliving things.)
 
First, you don’t know that.
I don’t? Have you developed a test for omnipotence, immortality, omniscience, etc.? I don’t know any scientific way of testing for the alleged existence of beings which are convieniently absent from empirical reality.
Second, you don’t know whether there is life of any kind at the far edges of the universe, any more than you know for a scientific fact that there are no angels.
Angels are not scientific concepts.
But I take it you concede the possibility that there is life at the far edge of the universe, theoretically, though no one is ever likely to verify it scientifically. Right?
Based on what we know of the universe, it is a scientific possibility.
For there to be an infinite amount of life in the universe, there has to be an infinite number of living beings. Correct? Or are you saying you think life is some kind of universal unity encompassing all living things notwithstanding their perception that they are individuals separate from other life?
I’d say that the answer is probably both.
And, in the process, please explain how, if there is an “infinite amount” of life, their existence is consistent with the existence of inanimate objects that are not living. (i.e., why the living beings, being “infinite” do not crowd out the nonliving things.)
Inanimate objects are also infinite.
 
I don’t? Have you developed a test for omnipotence, immortality, omniscience, etc.? I don’t know any scientific way of testing for the alleged existence of beings which are convieniently absent from empirical reality. ** Of course not. No more than anyone has developed a scientific test to see what’s in the core of a black hole. But I do see that you believe living beings are infinite, and perhaps you’ll explain that. **

Angels are not scientific concepts. ** Because you say they aren’t? How do you know there are no incorporeal beings? **

Based on what we know of the universe, it is a scientific possibility. ** Please explain to me, then, how anything that’s billions of light years away and cannot be seen at all, can be evaluated for life. A multi-trillion year trip in a space ship perhaps? **

I’d say that the answer is probably both. **Please explain this. I am really interested in your explanation of both things:
  1. How there can be an infinite number of individual lives.
  2. How there can be an infinite single all-encompassing life. (without it being God, of course. :)**
Inanimate objects are also infinite. **So, the pencil at my desk is infinite in mass, and my coffee cup is too, but there is (or appears to be) space between them and they both rest on my desk without either of them gobbling up the other or the desk. Please explain how this is. **
 
I’m no scientist, but to my understanding true science does not affirm what it cannot verify. Consequently, the assumption that there IS other life out in the universe is,when accepted, done so on faith alone.

But as soon as you all find ET, old buddy, let me know.

I have read where some scientific folk, at least, believe there are creatures out in the universe that must surely be far, far more advanced than us. Possibly they are so advanced we could no more understand or perhaps even perceive them than a sea slug that has spent its life under 2000 feet of water could understand or perceive us.

But as soon as one hazards to apply a term like “angels” to such posited creatures, the atheist or agnostic science person sulls up and rejects the whole notion because of its association with religion.

Parenthetically, it should be noted that religion does not preclude the existence of other life out in the universe. Christianity, in fact, affirms that there is. (Using, of course, such unacceptable terms as “angels”, “saints”, etc) Of course, since the physicists are now talking about things like “membranes” and “11 dimensions” and such, the “universe” has taken on a very different aspect from the old “gas balls and rocks” notion. But, of course, other “dimensions” are required to be resolutely secular in their nature, aren’t they? 🙂
Beautifully put.I continue to be astounded at the blind dogma of materialists.
 
Of course not. No more than anyone has developed a scientific test to see what’s in the core of a black hole.
The difference being that you’re comparing empirical phenomenon with philosophical speculation.
Because you say they aren’t?
See my last post.
How do you know there are no incorporeal beings?
I pointed out that incorporeal beings are not a scientific concept; I didn’t say that they certainly don’t exist. I think one of the problems with the article and with this thread is that people seem to misunderstand what Stephen Hawking is saying. He is not saying that God does not exist. In fact, he is an agnostic who simply opposes organized religion.
Please explain to me, then, how anything that’s billions of light years away and cannot be seen at all, can be evaluated for life. A multi-trillion year trip in a space ship perhaps??
With current technology such a journey might take as long but it is possible.
I’d say that the answer is probably both. Please explain this. I am really interested in your explanation of both things:
  1. How there can be an infinite number of individual lives.
  2. How there can be an infinite single all-encompassing life. (without it being God, of course.
  1. Because there is an infinite number of stellar bodies in the universe
  2. I think I misunderstood what you were saying here. I thought you were reffering to something else.
So, the pencil at my desk is infinite in mass, and my coffee cup is too, but there is (or appears to be) space between them and they both rest on my desk without either of them gobbling up the other or the desk. Please explain how this is.
You misunderstood what I said. I said that there are an infinite number of inanimate objects in the universe. You’re presenting a false dilemna; as inaminate objects and life don’t have to exist in the same physical space. For example, there are mountains on Earth but you don’t exist with mountains in the same physical space.
 
It was my understanding that no one currently knows if the universe is infinite.

God bless,
Ut
 
It was my understanding that no one currently knows if the universe is infinite.
WMAP has confirmed that the universe is flat and suggests the existence of the cosmological constant (in this case dark matter) therefore infinite.
 
WMAP has confirmed that the universe is flat and suggests the existence of the cosmological constant (in this case dark matter) therefore infinite.
Nope.
map.gsfc.nasa.gov/

In fact, it would be pretty difficult to conclude the following from WMAP…
The CMB became the “premier baryometer” of the universe with WMAP’s precision determination that ordinary atoms (also called baryons) make up only 4.6% of the universe (to within 0.1%)
…
WMAP’s complete census of the universe finds that dark matter (not made up of atoms) make up 23.3% (to within 1.3%)
…if the universe is infinite.

Also, it seems to support the Big Bang theory…again, an “infinite” universe came from the expansion of a finite entity?
 
I don’t? Have you developed a test for omnipotence, immortality, omniscience, etc.? I don’t know any scientific way of testing for the alleged existence of beings which are convieniently absent from empirical reality. ** Neither have you developed a test to determine what’s in the center of a black hole. Nor is science ever likely to do it. But science believes in them nevertheless. **

Angels are not scientific concepts. ** If someone like Hawking posited the likelihood of sentient beings of pure energy existing somewhere or other, you would likely buy into it. It’s the religious terminology you can’t stand.**

Based on what we know of the universe, it is a scientific possibility. ** About as remote (perhaps more so) than finding a way of detecting the presence of beings of pure energy of a sort that doesn’t register on any device man has invented or can invent. **

I’d say that the answer is probably both. Please explain. Sounds more philosophical or religious than scientific to me.

Inanimate objects are also infinite. I have asked you previously to explain why either living or non-living things can be infinite. You keep saying it, but you never explain or demonstrate why we should believe it. Never have I heard or read any reputable scientist say this. In fact, Einstein’s theory of general relativity seems to preclude it as to any being having mass. It’s your belief, so explain it.
 
Nope.

A finite number of stellar bodies are expanding infinitely. There is no data showing an infinite amount of stellar bodies, as you posited earlier. You are making a false conclusion based on the data. Again, if it validates the Big Bang theory (or a form thereof), then it leads to the logical understanding that a finite mass split into a finite number of objects…even if they are expanding infinitely. Of course, it also follows that there are not an infinite number of living beings (from a scientific standpoint…i.e. not counting angels), since there are a finite number of stellar bodies.

Anyway, you are still a chick in an egg…WMAP is just one of our limited senses. It won’t detect any parallel universes, different dimensions, etc. It is limited to a single universe, as far as we know. Of course if it disappears into a black hole, we won’t know where it went.
 
Nope.

A finite number of stellar bodies are expanding infinitely. There is no data showing an infinite amount of stellar bodies, as you posited earlier. You are making a false conclusion based on the data. Again, if it validates the Big Bang theory (or a form thereof), then it leads to the logical understanding that a finite mass split into a finite number of objects…even if they are expanding infinitely. Of course, it also follows that there are not an infinite number of living beings (from a scientific standpoint…i.e. not counting angels), since there are a finite number of stellar bodies.

Anyway, you are still a chick in an egg…WMAP is just one of our limited senses. It won’t detect any parallel universes, different dimensions, etc. It is limited to a single universe, as far as we know. Of course if it disappears into a black hole, we won’t know where it went.
I think the L’Empereur believes “ever-expanding” and “infinite” are the same thing. :rolleyes:
 
Your attempt at a counterargument fails as there is not an infinite amount of life on Earth. The extinction of a single species could be catestrophic to life on Earth but the destruction of all life on Earth would be irrelevant on a cosmological scale. Life on Earth is not an important feauture of the cosmos in the grand scheme of things.
Your faith, hope, belief that life exists on other planets is merely a theory. Show me the proof that life exists on other planets. Your faith, hope, belief that life exists on other planets has never been scientifically proven. How can any sane person have your leap-of-faith belief system???
 
Science rejects such religious notions because they are, by their very nature, irrational and untestable and therefore impossible to verify.
Like a non-fifth-dimensional beginning of time and space, or actual infinity??? Oh, the hypocrisy.
 
Man is located in the center of the biggest distances and the smallest.
 
WMAP has confirmed that the universe is flat and suggests the existence of the cosmological constant (in this case dark matter) therefore infinite.
NASA link: map.gsfc.nasa.gov/universe/uni_age.html: important parts in red

“How does WMAP data enable us to determine the age of the universe is 13.7 billion years, with an uncertainty of 1%? The key to this is that by knowing the composition of matter and energy density in the universe, we can use Einstein’s General Relativity to compute how fast the universe has been expanding in the past. With that information, we can turn the clock back and determine when the universe had “zero” size, according to Einstein. The time between then and now is the age of the universe. There is one caveat to keep in mind that affects the certainty of the age determination: we assume that the universe is flat, which is well supported by WMAP and other data. If we relax this assumption within the allowed range, the uncertainty increases to a bit over 2%. However, theorists have long known that a nearly-flat universe is very difficult to produce, whereas inflation naturally predicts a flat universe.”

So, is it Flat? Or, Nearly Flat? Are those highly specific terms?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top