Help me get past cannibalism

  • Thread starter Thread starter Odell
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I believe full heartily what the church teaches. I just want to better understand it.
there is a book out by John Salsa on the Eucharist and with Scriptures and explanation to back it up. i think it might be helpfull for you.

i have no problem in accept everything the Church teaches. none whatsoever. thanks be to God.

Grace of our Lord, the Christ be with you.
 
For the OP I apologize for joking on this topic.I will say that anyone who obtains salvation through Jesus is covered by the blood of the Lamb.There are those who are spoken of in the Bible as having their robes washed clean by the blood of the Lamb.
If taking communion is considered cannibalism in a spiritual sense then we who Love Christ will do this thing.We who love Christ are also covered by the blood.It’s all good:thumbsup:
 
For the OP I apologize for joking on this topic.I will say that anyone who obtains salvation through Jesus is covered by the blood of the Lamb.There are those who are spoken of in the Bible as having their robes washed clean by the blood of the Lamb.
If taking communion is considered cannibalism in a spiritual sense then we who Love Christ will do this thing.We who love Christ are also covered by the blood.It’s all good:thumbsup:
Thanks Louemma but to be technical I believe we meaning you and I are not covered but our sin washed by his blood he takes away the sin of the world he dosnt cover it. Thanks again
 
So Odell,
Where are you at on the issue? Has the thread been helpful?

VC
 
Thanks Louemma but to be technical I believe we meaning you and I are not covered but our sin washed by his blood he takes away the sin of the world he dosnt cover it. Thanks again
For one to be washed clean in the blood they gotta be covered by the blood:)
He does take away the sin by being washed and covered by the blood:shrug:Seems the same to me.
The reason I say this about the blood to begin with is,we have no problem getting washed in the blood and is this not the first step into the body of Christ?The eating of his flesh and the drinking of his blood is no different in the sense as saying we are washed in the blood.As far as flesh and blood goes.Of course we understand the significance of communion.But getting washed in the blood is symbolic and that’s why I even brought that up:)
 
I’m sorry Randy, it is still wine. It has great significance and represents the precious blood of the Savior but it is still wine. The council at Jerusalem in Acts 15:20 the Gentile christians are commanded to abstain from blood. This command is repeated in verse 29. Christians are not supposed to drink blood.
That request to abstain from blood-meats has nothing to do with Eucharist. Here is an article about it:

catholicculture.org/culture/library/view.cfm?recnum=723
 
To remind those who may be forgetting,Jewish law forbidding anyone to eat anything uncooked,meaning the blood in it,or drink blood.This was an abomination to God because the life is in the blood.Now in having said this,do you suppose God’s son would encourage a group of Jewish men to commit an act that was an abomination to his Father.The wine they drank was only wine,just like the bread they ate was only bread.Symbolic,I tell you:rolleyes:was all symbolic.Take baptism for example.We know that water in itself is incapable of washing away our sins.Yet we all do this thing as if water could because it is symbolic.
 
To remind those who may be forgetting,Jewish law forbidding anyone to eat anything uncooked,meaning the blood in it,or drink blood.This was an abomination to God because the life is in the blood.Now in having said this,do you suppose God’s son would encourage a group of Jewish men to commit an act that was an abomination to his Father.The wine they drank was only wine,just like the bread they ate was only bread.Symbolic,I tell you:rolleyes:was all symbolic.Take baptism for example.We know that water in itself is incapable of washing away our sins.Yet we all do this thing as if water could because it is symbolic.
would you say that this thing symbolic as you say, would make people sick and even kill them?
 
would you say that this thing symbolic as you say, would make people sick and even kill them?
Are you referring to the remark I made about catching a diease:D
That was said in the physcial sense of cannibalism.
 
Are you referring to the remark I made about catching a diease:D
That was said in the physcial sense of cannibalism.
No. that is not what i am referring to. Since you claim that you know what you are talking about, i will let you think about this for while.
 
No. that is not what i am referring to. Since you claim that you know what you are talking about, i will let you think about this for while.
If your referring to lost people taking communion and getting sick and dying,would this not be spiritual death?Unless you need to think on it a while;)
 
To remind those who may be forgetting,Jewish law forbidding anyone to eat anything uncooked,meaning the blood in it,or drink blood.This was an abomination to God because the life is in the blood.Now in having said this,do you suppose God’s son would encourage a group of Jewish men to commit an act that was an abomination to his Father.The wine they drank was only wine,just like the bread they ate was only bread.Symbolic,I tell you:rolleyes:was all symbolic.Take baptism for example.We know that water in itself is incapable of washing away our sins.Yet we all do this thing as if water could because it is symbolic.
We know this
The Torah prohibits consumption of blood. Lev. 7:26-27; Lev. 17:10-14. This is the only dietary law that has a reason specified in Torah: we do not eat blood because the life of the animal (literally, the soul of the animal) is contained in the blood. This applies only to the blood of birds and mammals, not to fish blood. Thus, it is necessary to remove all blood from the flesh of kosher animals.

This is why it was so hard for the Jews to accept Jesus teaching. They understood him literaly and walked away. Jesus did not tell them to stay I only mean symbolic. Remember every other time in the bible when ;Jesus was miss understood he explained himself. But no in John 6 he re iterates himself the second time he uses the word gnaw chew. He drives his message home. This is why it make since to me the blood as the Jews understood is the life force of the animal. We get this from the eucarist. Remember God is fully body blood and spirit. In order for God to fully abide in our body and spirit. We need to take him in fully body and spirit not just spirit as so many think.

Also catholics don’t believe the water in baptism is only symbolic.
And we don’t say we are covered as Martin Luther would say we are dung covered in snow. A catholic would say we are dung turned to snow.
 
He broke bread and drank wine.
The bread represented his body and the wine represented his blood.
If you say the disciples literally took a bite out of Jesus then okaaaay:eek:
I think you’re being deliberately obtuse if that’s your summary of the Last Supper.
 
To remind those who may be forgetting,Jewish law forbidding anyone to eat anything uncooked,meaning the blood in it,or drink blood.This was an abomination to God because the life is in the blood.Now in having said this,do you suppose God’s son would encourage a group of Jewish men to commit an act that was an abomination to his Father.The wine they drank was only wine,just like the bread they ate was only bread.Symbolic,I tell you:rolleyes:was all symbolic.Take baptism for example.We know that water in itself is incapable of washing away our sins.Yet we all do this thing as if water could because it is symbolic.
Are you Jewish or Christian? If you’re pointing out that Christian teaching is not the same as Jewish teaching, we know that.

BTW, isn’t gaining the life of God within us the whole point? 🤷

Speaking of things that were an abomination to Jews, here’s an interesting question. How many things are Christians allowed to do that would have brought the death penalty to a 1st century Jew? And why are we allowed to do them?
 
I’m sorry Randy, it is still wine. It has great significance and represents the precious blood of the Savior but it is still wine. The council at Jerusalem in Acts 15:20 the Gentile christians are commanded to abstain from blood. This command is repeated in verse 29. Christians are not supposed to drink blood.
Interesting perspective.
 
I tell you, I will not drink of this fruit of the vine from now on until that day when I drink it anew with you in my Father’s kingdom. (Matthew 26:29)

The fruit of vine is grapes; wine is made from grapes.
Right. Jesus did not drink of the cup that contained His Blood under the appearance or accidents of wine, the fruit of the vine.

There is no discrepancy here.
 
Are you Jewish or Christian? If you’re pointing out that Christian teaching is not the same as Jewish teaching, we know that.

BTW, isn’t gaining the life of God within us the whole point? 🤷

Speaking of things that were an abomination to Jews, here’s an interesting question. How many things are Christians allowed to do that would have brought the death penalty to a 1st century Jew? And why are we allowed to do them?
The Jewish God is the Christian God and what is an abomination to God is an abomination to God.He is the same yesterday,today and tomorrow.
The point to this whole thread is should we partake of the body of Christ?We should but anyone with common sense knows this was not drinking or eating the actual body of our Lord and savior.To make an argument over this is ridiculous and silly.We know full well what the last supper symbolizes and if one wants to speculate into this more then what is in the scriptures then go ahead.
I will say that God would have forbidden the drinking of blood.Whether I’m Jewish or Christian or both is no concern here,but do we not all have the same God:D
If the answer is yes,then you know the decispiles were not drinking Jesus’s blood and eating him.But keep putting thoughts into where there is no scripture and you will come up with foolish ideals.
 
The Jewish God is the Christian God and what is an abomination to God is an abomination to God.He is the same yesterday,today and tomorrow.
The point to this whole thread is should we partake of the body of Christ?We should but anyone with common sense knows this was not drinking or eating the actual body of our Lord and savior.To make an argument over this is ridiculous and silly.We know full well what the last supper symbolizes and if one wants to speculate into this more then what is in the scriptures then go ahead.
I will say that God would have forbidden the drinking of blood.Whether I’m Jewish or Christian or both is no concern here,but do we not all have the same God:D
If the answer is yes,then you know the decispiles were not drinking Jesus’s blood and eating him.But keep putting thoughts into where there is no scripture and you will come up with foolish ideals.
So I take it you don’t eat any meat with blood?

As what scripture says
John 6:35,41,48,51 - Jesus says four times “I AM the bread from heaven.” It is He, Himself, the eternal bread from heaven.

John 6:27,31,49 - there is a parallel between the manna in the desert which was physically consumed, and this “new” bread which must be consumed.

John 6:51-52- then Jesus says that the bread He is referring to is His flesh. The Jews take Him literally and immediately question such a teaching. How can this man give us His flesh to eat?

John 6:53 - 58 - Jesus does not correct their literal interpretation. Instead, Jesus eliminates any metaphorical interpretations by swearing an oath and being even more literal about eating His flesh. In fact, Jesus says four times we must eat His flesh and drink His blood. Catholics thus believe that Jesus makes present His body and blood in the sacrifice of the Mass. Protestants, if they are not going to become Catholic, can only argue that Jesus was somehow speaking symbolically.

John 6:23-53 - however, a symbolic interpretation is not plausible. Throughout these verses, the Greek text uses the word “phago” nine times. “Phago” literally means “to eat” or “physically consume.” Like the Protestants of our day, the disciples take issue with Jesus’ literal usage of “eat.” So Jesus does what?

John 6:54, 56, 57, 58 - He uses an even more literal verb, translated as “trogo,” which means to gnaw or chew or crunch. He increases the literalness and drives his message home. Jesus will literally give us His flesh and blood to eat. The word “trogo” is only used two other times in the New Testament (in Matt. 24:38 and John 13:18) and it always means to literally gnaw or chew meat. While “phago” might also have a spiritual application, “trogo” is never used metaphorically in Greek. So Protestants cannot find one verse in Scripture where “trogo” is used symbolically, and yet this must be their argument if they are going to deny the Catholic understanding of Jesus’ words. Moreover, the Jews already knew Jesus was speaking literally even before Jesus used the word “trogo” when they said “How can this man give us His flesh to eat?” (John 6:52).

John 6:55 - to clarify further, Jesus says “For My Flesh is food indeed, and My Blood is drink indeed.” This phrase can only be understood as being responsive to those who do not believe that Jesus’ flesh is food indeed, and His blood is drink indeed. Further, Jesus uses the word which is translated as “sarx.” “Sarx” means flesh (not “soma” which means body). See, for example, John 1:13,14; 3:6; 8:15; 17:2; Matt. 16:17; 19:5; 24:22; 26:41; Mark 10:8; 13:20; 14:38; and Luke 3:6; 24:39 which provides other examples in Scripture where “sarx” means flesh. It is always literal.

John 6:55 - further, the phrases “real” food and “real” drink use the word “alethes.” “Alethes” means “really” or “truly,” and would only be used if there were doubts concerning the reality of Jesus’ flesh and blood as being food and drink. Thus, Jesus is emphasizing the miracle of His body and blood being actual food and drink.

John 6:60 - as are many anti-Catholics today, Jesus’ disciples are scandalized by these words. They even ask, “Who can ‘listen’ to it (much less understand it)?” To the unillumined mind, it seems grotesque.

John 6:61-63 - Jesus acknowledges their disgust. Jesus’ use of the phrase “the spirit gives life” means the disciples need supernatural faith, not logic, to understand His words.
 
Right. Jesus did not drink of the cup that contained His Blood under the appearance or accidents of wine, the fruit of the vine.

There is no discrepancy here.
Under Asistotle’s substance theory anyone could declare that a 24 ounce Porterhouse has become a pound and a half of 24 karat gold. That doesn’t make it true.
:twocents:
 
So I take it you don’t eat any meat with blood?

As what scripture says
John 6:35,41,48,51 - Jesus says four times “I AM the bread from heaven.” It is He, Himself, the eternal bread from heaven.

John 6:27,31,49 - there is a parallel between the manna in the desert which was physically consumed, and this “new” bread which must be consumed.

John 6:51-52- then Jesus says that the bread He is referring to is His flesh. The Jews take Him literally and immediately question such a teaching. How can this man give us His flesh to eat?

John 6:53 - 58 - Jesus does not correct their literal interpretation. Instead, Jesus eliminates any metaphorical interpretations by swearing an oath and being even more literal about eating His flesh. In fact, Jesus says four times we must eat His flesh and drink His blood. Catholics thus believe that Jesus makes present His body and blood in the sacrifice of the Mass. Protestants, if they are not going to become Catholic, can only argue that Jesus was somehow speaking symbolically.

John 6:23-53 - however, a symbolic interpretation is not plausible. Throughout these verses, the Greek text uses the word “phago” nine times. “Phago” literally means “to eat” or “physically consume.” Like the Protestants of our day, the disciples take issue with Jesus’ literal usage of “eat.” So Jesus does what?

John 6:54, 56, 57, 58 - He uses an even more literal verb, translated as “trogo,” which means to gnaw or chew or crunch. He increases the literalness and drives his message home. Jesus will literally give us His flesh and blood to eat. The word “trogo” is only used two other times in the New Testament (in Matt. 24:38 and John 13:18) and it always means to literally gnaw or chew meat. While “phago” might also have a spiritual application, “trogo” is never used metaphorically in Greek. So Protestants cannot find one verse in Scripture where “trogo” is used symbolically, and yet this must be their argument if they are going to deny the Catholic understanding of Jesus’ words. Moreover, the Jews already knew Jesus was speaking literally even before Jesus used the word “trogo” when they said “How can this man give us His flesh to eat?” (John 6:52).

John 6:55 - to clarify further, Jesus says “For My Flesh is food indeed, and My Blood is drink indeed.” This phrase can only be understood as being responsive to those who do not believe that Jesus’ flesh is food indeed, and His blood is drink indeed. Further, Jesus uses the word which is translated as “sarx.” “Sarx” means flesh (not “soma” which means body). See, for example, John 1:13,14; 3:6; 8:15; 17:2; Matt. 16:17; 19:5; 24:22; 26:41; Mark 10:8; 13:20; 14:38; and Luke 3:6; 24:39 which provides other examples in Scripture where “sarx” means flesh. It is always literal.

John 6:55 - further, the phrases “real” food and “real” drink use the word “alethes.” “Alethes” means “really” or “truly,” and would only be used if there were doubts concerning the reality of Jesus’ flesh and blood as being food and drink. Thus, Jesus is emphasizing the miracle of His body and blood being actual food and drink.

John 6:60 - as are many anti-Catholics today, Jesus’ disciples are scandalized by these words. They even ask, “Who can ‘listen’ to it (much less understand it)?” To the unillumined mind, it seems grotesque.

John 6:61-63 - Jesus acknowledges their disgust. Jesus’ use of the phrase “the spirit gives life” means the disciples need supernatural faith, not logic, to understand His words.
Supernatural Faith friend:) is eating his flesh and drinking his blood and knowing we are partaking of the body of Christ.Common sense tells us this was spiritual and not physcial.
However I did not realize there were some who believed differently.I never thought that a Christian of any faith would endorse this as a worldly act and not a spiritual act.
Now to suggest that one don’t understand the meaning of communion because one knows it is a symbolic gesture much like the symbolic gesture of baptism.
I believe that this may be one topic that the Christian will have to disagree with the Catholics on.
My understanding of partaking of the body of Christ is in accordance to the word of God and I’m not debating my belief because I know what God’s word says on this.Now I can understand why the OP was worried about cannibalism:D
I will not debate this issue because I’m not sure exactly as to what I’m debating about.It is not completely clear as if you folks think this was symbolic or if the disciples really drank the blood of Jesus.But why not!As I pointed out in another post we who have salvation is washed in the blood.Is this also not symbolic?Or at one point was we dipped:p
I’m not arguing this topic until I research just what the Catholics do believe and practice on this.
For some reason I thought we all believe the same on the Lord’s supper:shrug:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top