Help please:Quick comeback to unkind comments?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Kathryn_Ann
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

Kathryn_Ann

Guest
I have a serious heart condition. I have explained this to people who still continue to ask why I often look weak or tired.

I often do not look as I did when I was 21. It’s unlikely that I’ll have a facelift! What is the proper response to parishioners who come up after Mass at the coffee hour and inevitably sigh, look me up and down with arched eyebrows, shake their head and say:

1-“Ohhhhh, you still have those bags under your eyes? !”

2-“Are you cured yet?” (This just in: there is no “cure” for many heart conditions)
“You look* really* tired.”

3-“You look a lot better than you did LAST week You really looked terrible…”. (The same person says this to me EVERY single week.)

4-“I noticed you still have those bags under your eyes!”

5-“You* really *look older.”

I’m just trying to find some civil, quick comebacks to these unwelcome comments. I usually just try to explain that I’m doing my best…
 
I would hope that these comments are well intentioned, but just very poorly delivered. If that’s the case, could you say something like, “I appreciate that you’re concerned about my health. So, what did you think of Father’s homily?” This way you’d acknowledge their concern but also deliberately change the subject.
 
I would hope that these comments are well intentioned, but just very poorly delivered. If that’s the case, could you say something like, “I appreciate that you’re concerned about my health. So, what did you think of Father’s homily?” This way you’d acknowledge their concern but also deliberately change the subject.
That’s a wonderful idea, thank you:) I’ll definitely try that!:angel1:
 
Or you could try Judith Martin “Miss Manners” approach - the stare and raised eyebrow . . . :ehh:

Though silicasandra’s method is probably more charitable. 😉
 
How do you like . . .

“Since you so often express your concern to me, can I count on your continued prayers? I’m doing the best I can under the circumstance.”

To drive home the point more specifically, you could put more emphasis on “so often!”
 
I learned something in my own health problems. That is that people get awkward when they see their own mortality right in front of them. It is almost an act of charity to minister to them as they cope. If I’m right, you have had time to cope, they haven’t…take care. Samson
 
Or you could try Judith Martin “Miss Manners” approach - the stare and raised eyebrow . . . :ehh:

Though silicasandra’s method is probably more charitable. 😉
Love it!:clapping: I’ll practice that in the mirror, and if I’m not quite ready for that, I’ll try the other.
(We *do *want to be charitable.)
My daughter says I might try responding to the truly rude with either:

“And this is supposed to make me feel better?” * or
*
“I can’t believe you just said that!”
:ouch:

As a last resort, perhaps I could return the scrutinizing look and say "Oh, looks like we have the same problem! How do* you *deal with it?
 
I’m just trying to find some civil, quick comebacks to these unwelcome comments. I usually just try to explain that I’m doing my best…
Entirely ignore the comment, have a question ready. Respond to the comment with the completely unrelated question: “Are you going to the potluck on Friday?” “Have you seen that story about the six-headed canary?” If they say something else about your health or looks, say, “Oh! There’s Fred, I must speak to him, excuse me,” and walk away. If they say, “I take it this means you don’t want to talk about it?” smile and say, “I always like a potluck, people bring out their best recipes.”

Or, you can ignore the comment and say, “Hello, Frieda, how are you today?” This works fairly well because people would always rather talk about themselves than you. Of course, you can say, “Oh, do I look peaked? Well, you look lovely, I think the extra weight really suits you.” But - hmmmmmm. I suppose* someone *might think that uncharitable. :rolleyes: Oh well.

Your other option is to carry many copies of Miss Manners Guide to Excruciatingly Correct Behavior with you and start handing them out with the appropriate page marked and highlighted.

Or offer it up.

Peace be with you.
 
I I’m just trying to find some civil, quick comebacks to these unwelcome comments. I usually just try to explain that I’m doing my best…
" I promise not to make personal remarks about you if you extend me the same courtesy", then change the subject
 
I do not know your sense of humor, but “I” would come back with:

“Do I really resemble Mother Teresa? Thank you so much for that compliment!”

Maybe not.

What you are showing them is the purified face of suffering. It is beautiful to our suffering Lord.
 
This is the kind of situation where a little crude language might help!

To keep it clean you could tell them to “Go forth and multiply!”😊
 
Entirely ignore the comment, have a question ready. Respond to the comment with the completely unrelated question: “Are you going to the potluck on Friday?” “Have you seen that story about the six-headed canary?” If they say something else about your health or looks, say, “Oh! There’s Fred, I must speak to him, excuse me,” and walk away. If they say, “I take it this means you don’t want to talk about it?” smile and say, “I always like a potluck, people bring out their best recipes.”

Or, you can ignore the comment and say, “Hello, Frieda, how are you today?” This works fairly well because people would always rather talk about themselves than you. Of course, you can say, “Oh, do I look peaked? Well, you look lovely, I think the extra weight really suits you.” But - hmmmmmm. I suppose* someone *might think that uncharitable. :rolleyes: Oh well.

Your other option is to carry many copies of Miss Manners Guide to Excruciatingly Correct Behavior with you and start handing them out with the appropriate page marked and highlighted.

Or offer it up.

Peace be with you.
The title of that book just makes me giggle.
 
I do not know your sense of humor, but “I” would come back with:

“Do I really resemble Mother Teresa? Thank you so much for that compliment!”

Maybe not.

What you are showing them is the purified face of suffering. It is beautiful to our suffering Lord.
Yep. Remember going to a tool sale at the aromry in my 10th week of chemo. I looked like death walking, but so grateful to be there with my son. Nothing could rain on that. Samson.
 
How do you like . . .

“Since you so often express your concern to me, can I count on your continued prayers? I’m doing the best I can under the circumstance.”

To drive home the point more specifically, you could put more emphasis on “so often!”
A very charitable reply! (Especially with the emphasis on “so often!”) 🙂 Great idea.😉
 
I learned something in my own health problems. That is that people get awkward when they see their own mortality right in front of them. It is almost an act of charity to minister to them as they cope. If I’m right, you have had time to cope, they haven’t…take care. Samson
This is very true. It’s very humbling to realize one is not immortal! The comments people make range from the simply awkward all the way to downright catty. If replied to kindly, it might be a teachable moment for them as well!🙂
 
This is very true. It’s very humbling to realize one is not immortal! The comments people make range from the simply awkward all the way to downright catty. If replied to kindly, it might be a teachable moment for them as well!🙂
You take care. My son and wife have HCM of the heart, btw. Yes, a graceful and teachable moment. Samson
 
Entirely ignore the comment, have a question ready. Respond to the comment with the completely unrelated question: “Are you going to the potluck on Friday?” “Have you seen that story about the six-headed canary?” If they say something else about your health or looks, say, “Oh! There’s Fred, I must speak to him, excuse me,” and walk away. If they say, “I take it this means you don’t want to talk about it?” smile and say, “I always like a potluck, people bring out their best recipes.”

Or, you can ignore the comment and say, “Hello, Frieda, how are you today?” This works fairly well because people would always rather talk about themselves than you. Of course, you can say, “Oh, do I look peaked? Well, you look lovely, I think the extra weight really suits you.” But - hmmmmmm. I suppose* someone *might think that uncharitable. :rolleyes: Oh well.

Your other option is to carry many copies of Miss Manners Guide to Excruciatingly Correct Behavior with you and start handing them out with the appropriate page marked and highlighted.

Or offer it up.

Peace be with you.
Thank you so much!
I love your last two ideas. I will offer it up and also think about carrying the highlighted Miss Manners books around:) Since I have tried changing the conversation after these unbelievably insensitive comments (whether they were ill meant or not, they are hurtful) I think, again, this is a teachable moment. Who knows if they are saying the same kinds of things to other people as well? (I like your idea of saying “Oh, do I look peaked…you look lovely/the extra weight suits you!” ) Goodness, that is tempting, but of course, I must bite my tongue and persevere in charity. I’m thinking that I might very gently pull them aside, smile and say something like “You know dear, a more sensitive person would be hurt by that remark. I visit the sick in hospitals and one always wants to say something positive.” I wonder if that might work. Bless you for your thoughtful reply.
 
" I promise not to make personal remarks about you if you extend me the same courtesy", then change the subject
That’s excellent because it’s quick, to the point and truthful, while getting the message across! Thank you!👍
 
I do not know your sense of humor, but “I” would come back with:

“Do I really resemble Mother Teresa? Thank you so much for that compliment!”

Maybe not.

What you are showing them is the purified face of suffering. It is beautiful to our suffering Lord.
That’s a lovely idea, the purified face of suffering. I had not not of that and I should have, thank you!👍
 
This is the kind of situation where a little crude language might help!

To keep it clean you could tell them to “Go forth and multiply!”😊
It is tempting to explode and come back with something mean, but of course, I cannot!🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top