Holder seeks limits on mandatory minimum sentencing

  • Thread starter Thread starter oldcelt
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

oldcelt

Guest
usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2013/08/12/holder-mandatory-minimum-sentence-elderly-inmates/2640247/
WASHINGTON — Attorney General Eric Holder will call Monday for major changes in the federal criminal justice system, including doing away with some mandatory minimum sentencing policies that have condemned scores of non-violent offenders to long prison terms and driven up the costs of incarceration.
In a speech before the American Bar Association, Holder will also push for early release of seniors and ill inmates who no longer pose a danger to society, yet require expensive special care.
"The bottom line is that, while the aggressive enforcement of federal criminal statutes remains necessary, we cannot simply prosecute or incarcerate our way to becoming a safer nation,’’ Holder will say, according to excerpts of his prepared remarks. "We must never stop being tough on crime. But we must also be smarter on crime.’’
Long overdue IMO.

John
 
I agree!! The drug minimums are out of control. They also seem to target minorities and low income people. Mandatory minimums for crack cocaine are twice as high as those for regular cocaine. Is it a coincidence that the majority of coke users are white, and the majority of crack users are black?
Crack cocaine is more addictive, more damaging, and causes greater social problems than powder cocaine. These factors rather than race play into severity of sentencing. The more crack dealers off the street, the better in terms of having a safer and more vibrant black community.
 
I agree!! The drug minimums are out of control. They also seem to target minorities and low income people. Mandatory minimums for crack cocaine are twice as high as those for regular cocaine. Is it a coincidence that the majority of coke users are white, and the majority of crack users are black?
I agree.
But it was Congress who passed these crazy sentencing laws and Holder’s oath is to see that the laws are enforced. He is advocating sidestepping the law by leaving the amount of drugs in question off of indictments (to avoid triggering minimums).
If an Atty Gen can decline to enforce one law, why not others?

Politicians on both sides, in Congress and state legislatures need to loo at mandatory minimums, three strikes, &c.
 
I agree.
But it was Congress who passed these crazy sentencing laws and Holder’s oath is to see that the laws are enforced. He is advocating sidestepping the law by leaving the amount of drugs in question off of indictments (to avoid triggering minimums).
If an Atty Gen can decline to enforce one law, why not others?

Politicians on both sides, in Congress and state legislatures need to loo at mandatory minimums, three strikes, &c.
Exactly. This adminstration is picking and choosing which laws they want to enforce. This is a constitutional crisis.

This adminstration has failed to enforce immigration laws and in fact has fought states like Arizona from enforcing them.

They are now saying they will not enforce the Obamacare employer mandate (which requires employers to provide health insurance), while still requiring that all people have health insurance.

Now they are picking which drug laws to enforce.

I agree with the principal that too many people are being put in prison for minor drug offenses, but the laws need to be changed properly, we can’t have “policy” defining which laws to enforce.

Obama took an oath to uphold and defend the constitution. In the constitution, laws are passed with approvals from by congress and the president. Not the president alone.
 
I agree.
But it was Congress who passed these crazy sentencing laws and Holder’s oath is to see that the laws are enforced. He is advocating sidestepping the law by leaving the amount of drugs in question off of indictments (to avoid triggering minimums).
If an Atty Gen can decline to enforce one law, why not others?

Politicians on both sides, in Congress and state legislatures need to loo at mandatory minimums, three strikes, &c.
He’s already doing that in several cases.

The issue is that many times the drug possession charge is just one of several charges that puts a person in jail - usually there are theft, assault or crimes against the public included with the drug charge. Instead of putting them in jail the victims foot the bill for letting these people roam committing more crimes.
 
Good move, I imagine he must have a plan of rehabilitation, education?

“We are on an unsustainable path here,” Justice Inspector General Michael Horowitz said.

Holder’s proposals largely track the inspector general’s findings.

"We need to ensure that incarceration is used to punish, deter and rehabilitate – not merely to convict, warehouse and forget,’’ the attorney general’s draft remarks state.

"Clearly, these strategies can work. They’ve attracted overwhelming, bipartisan support in red states’ as well as blue states. And it’s past time for others to take notice.’’

The unsustainable path is a symptom of the problem which by large is an on-going social political problem.
 
Exactly. This adminstration is picking and choosing which laws they want to enforce. This is a constitutional crisis.

This adminstration has failed to enforce immigration laws and in fact has fought states like Arizona from enforcing them.

They are now saying they will not enforce the Obamacare employer mandate (which requires employers to provide health insurance), while still requiring that all people have health insurance.

Now they are picking which drug laws to enforce.

I agree with the principal that too many people are being put in prison for minor drug offenses, but the laws need to be changed properly, we can’t have “policy” defining which laws to enforce.

Obama took an oath to uphold and defend the constitution. In the constitution, laws are passed with approvals from by congress and the president. Not the president alone.
This practice is not unique to the Obama administration…

lifemanagement.com/nsa17.4.1232/

oas.org/juridico/mla/en/usa/en_usa-int-desc-guide.html
  1. Code:
        Declining Prosecution
One of the most significant aspects of the American legal system is the wide discretion that American prosecutors have in criminal matters. For example, a federal prosecutor may decline to prosecute an offense because he or she finds it not significant enough to merit prosecution in federal court. For instance, the quantity of drugs involved or the loss to a victim may be relatively small. The investigating agents may then present their evidence to a state prosecutor (assuming the offense is one that may be prosecuted in state court), where, again, the state prosecutor has discretion to prosecute the offense or to decline prosecution. Similarly, the federal prosecutor may decline prosecution of a minor offense if he or she considers that there is an acceptable alternative to prosecution, such as an agreement by the defendant to compensate the victim of the offense.

Defendants charged with minor, non-violent crimes may be eligible for pre-trial diversion into a program that usually includes making restitution to the victim. If the defendant completes the program successfully, he or she will not be prosecuted and may avoid a criminal record.

Another instance in which a prosecutor may decline to bring charges or ask the grand jury to return an indictment is where, although there is enough evidence to obtain a persons arrest, (that is, probable cause), the prosecutor knows that enough additional evidence to convict the person at trial will be unavailable. In such circumstances, the prosecutor is not obligated to seek an arrest warrant. In fact, if a prosecutor did bring charges or obtain a grand jury indictment and have a defendant arrested under those circumstances, this could be viewed as an abuse of the prosecutor’s discretion.
 
In 2009 Obama stopped using the term, war on drugs. And then, as now, and as other times the surface issues were admitted. Which again seems to be the case since the revolving door syndrome came to light with the Trayvon Martin media frenzy. Add to this the state by state overcrowding which as in California also hit the media, forced to release prisoners by Federal mandate, due to unconstitutional living conditions. And this overcrowding varies. Needless to say mandatory sentencing isn’t helping. That is unless the goal is build more prisons and fill them.

But the solutions are also known, and they through rehab and education will take time, a generation of so. But this can’t be done while government heath care is overworked and riddled with issues, and by large doomed to failure.

The drug issue coming into the country is also a known. Most argue our Government would chose to ignore it. And then, they prosecute the small poverty stricken uneducated abandoned etc…statistically in generates income. You would think this people were predestined the way we rush them off to the revolving door syndrome. And all isn’t to say bad choices and behavior is acceptable, but damn. Then from what I have seen, those that do come out of that are confronted with employment plus a felony record.

Wow, how did we become the world leader in incarceration. The drugs, and the booze are leading candidates to blame. Not really hard to see we refuse to give this up. 🤷 Work in progress.

Yes, now and again they catch a big fish, but those wouldn’t apply to the above anyway.
 
How odd. While Holder is doing this, Rahm Emanuel is pressing the Illinois legislature to INCREASE minimum sentences for gun-related crimes and to make people actually serve their sentences.
 
Didn’t you know… him and holder are above the constitution. Its sickening.
Exactly. This adminstration is picking and choosing which laws they want to enforce. This is a constitutional crisis.

This adminstration has failed to enforce immigration laws and in fact has fought states like Arizona from enforcing them.

They are now saying they will not enforce the Obamacare employer mandate (which requires employers to provide health insurance), while still requiring that all people have health insurance.

Now they are picking which drug laws to enforce.

I agree with the principal that too many people are being put in prison for minor drug offenses, but the laws need to be changed properly, we can’t have “policy” defining which laws to enforce.

Obama took an oath to uphold and defend the constitution. In the constitution, laws are passed with approvals from by congress and the president. Not the president alone.
 
This practice is not unique to the Obama administration…

lifemanagement.com/nsa17.4.1232/

oas.org/juridico/mla/en/usa/en_usa-int-desc-guide.html
  1. Code:
        Declining Prosecution
One of the most significant aspects of the American legal system is the wide discretion that American prosecutors have in criminal matters. For example, a federal prosecutor may decline to prosecute an offense because he or she finds it not significant enough to merit prosecution in federal court. For instance, the quantity of drugs involved or the loss to a victim may be relatively small. The investigating agents may then present their evidence to a state prosecutor (assuming the offense is one that may be prosecuted in state court), where, again, the state prosecutor has discretion to prosecute the offense or to decline prosecution. Similarly, the federal prosecutor may decline prosecution of a minor offense if he or she considers that there is an acceptable alternative to prosecution, such as an agreement by the defendant to compensate the victim of the offense.

Defendants charged with minor, non-violent crimes may be eligible for pre-trial diversion into a program that usually includes making restitution to the victim. If the defendant completes the program successfully, he or she will not be prosecuted and may avoid a criminal record.

Another instance in which a prosecutor may decline to bring charges or ask the grand jury to return an indictment is where, although there is enough evidence to obtain a persons arrest, (that is, probable cause), the prosecutor knows that enough additional evidence to convict the person at trial will be unavailable. In such circumstances, the prosecutor is not obligated to seek an arrest warrant. In fact, if a prosecutor did bring charges or obtain a grand jury indictment and have a defendant arrested under those circumstances, this could be viewed as an abuse of the prosecutor’s discretion.
I remember a little thing called a “Signing Statement.” Essentially meant that the President was signing the legislation, but had no intention of following the law. Wish I could remember who that was.
 
I remember a little thing called a “Signing Statement.” Essentially meant that the President was signing the legislation, but had no intention of following the law. Wish I could remember who that was.
It’s actually within their power though. Bush did it, Clinton did it, Obama has done it. It’s not the preferred course, but if they believe a law is unconstitutional, then they have an obligation to not enforce/defend in my opinion.
 
It’s actually within their power though. Bush did it, Clinton did it, Obama has done it. It’s not the preferred course, but if they believe a law is unconstitutional, then they have an obligation to not enforce/defend in my opinion.
Bush was notorious for it.
 
How odd. While Holder is doing this, Rahm Emanuel is pressing the Illinois legislature to INCREASE minimum sentences for gun-related crimes and to make people actually serve their sentences.
Guns are evil, drugs are a-okay. :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top