Holocaust Denier Silenced

  • Thread starter Thread starter Soutane
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Soutane

Guest
Holocaust-Denying Bishop Silenced

Bishop Fellay Apologizes on Behalf of Pius X Society

MENZINGEN, Switzerland, JAN. 27, 2009 (Zenit.org).- Bishop Bernard Fellay, superior-general of the Society of St. Pius X, publicly apologized for statements regarding the Holocaust made by one of the society’s bishops, and reported that the prelate has been forbidden to speak further on the issue.

Bishop Richard Williamson, in an interview taped in November, but aired last Wednesday on Swedish television, claimed that historical evidence denies the gassing of Jews in Nazi concentration camps.

Days later Benedict XVI lifted the excommunication of Bishop Williamson, along with Bishop Fellay and two others, who were ordained bishops by Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre in 1988 without papal permission. The act was to be a step toward healing the division between the society and the Vatican that resulted from the ordinations.

“It is evident that a Catholic bishop cannot speak with ecclesial authority if it is not a question of faith and morals,” said Bishop Fellay. “Our fraternity does not claim any authority over other questions.”

“With great sadness we acknowledge the extent to which the violation of this mandate has damaged our mission,” he continued. “The statements of Bishop Williamson do not reflect in any way the position of our society.”

Bishop Fellay said that until further notice Bishop Williamson has been prohibited from speaking on these matters.

The superior-general asked “for the forgiveness of the Supreme Pontiff, and of all people of good will, for the dramatic consequences of this act,” which said were “not acceptable.”

 
MENZINGEN, Switzerland, JAN. 27, 2009 (Zenit.org).- Bishop Bernard Fellay, superior-general of the Society of St. Pius X, publicly apologized for statements regarding the Holocaust made by one of the society’s bishops, and reported that the prelate has been forbidden to speak further on the issue.
Excellent! 👍 Who could ask for anything more? This is a great solution to the problem.
 
Excellent! 👍 Who could ask for anything more? This is a great solution to the problem.
I agree - let him think what he thinks privately, but do not destroy this major step forward toward bringing the SSPX home by voicing his personal opinions publicly.

👍

~Liza
 
Has this bishop had a mental evaluation? I would question the sanity of someone who denies the horrors what went on in concentration camps.
 
Has this bishop had a mental evaluation? I would question the sanity of someone who denies the horrors what went on in concentration camps.
I’ve seen this guy interviewed at length and there’s nothing he says that doesn’t make sense or cause one to think more deeply and critically (and forensically) about the Stalags and what went on.

An issue for many of the “6 million” number is the sign at Auschwitz; it used to say 4 million Jews had perished there — now it says 1.5 million Jews died — but the 6 million as the number in popular history remained the same. Who wouldn’t fail math with that kind of thinking?
 
I’ve seen this guy interviewed at length and there’s nothing he says that doesn’t make sense or cause one to think more deeply and critically (and forensically) about the Stalags and what went on.

An issue for many of the “6 million” number is the sign at Auschwitz; it used to say 4 million Jews had perished there — now it says 1.5 million Jews died — but the 6 million as the number in popular history remained the same. Who wouldn’t fail math with that kind of thinking?
Ah yes-revisionist history.Wonder why?:rolleyes:
 
Ah yes-revisionist history.Wonder why?:rolleyes:
Ich gebe auf — I give up; why?’

Do tell.

Hey Robert: some guy called me a revisionist, and I think that was darned uncharitable. Whaddaya think? Banning??
 
Ich gebe auf — I give up; why?’

Do tell.

Hey Robert: some guy called me a revisionist, and I think that was darned uncharitable. Whaddaya think? Banning??
You ARE a revisionist.Anyone who denies the 6,000,000 figure is.Your ethnicity does not concern me but your inaccuracy does.And as I said,I DO wonder why?:rolleyes:
 
Suspended already after only 7 posts.My that didn’t take long.😃
 
Gee,could Abubd be the erstwhile,banned, Robertxxx,I wonder…nah,that would be deceitful.:rolleyes:
 
I’ve seen this guy interviewed at length and there’s nothing he says that doesn’t make sense or cause one to think more deeply and critically (and forensically) about the Stalags and what went on.

An issue for many of the “6 million” number is the sign at Auschwitz; it used to say 4 million Jews had perished there — now it says 1.5 million Jews died — but the 6 million as the number in popular history remained the same. Who wouldn’t fail math with that kind of thinking?
The inanity of the post beggars the imagination. As if Auschwitz was the only death camp. :hypno:

Should posts denying the Holocaust be banned on this forum? After all, it is illegal in France Germany and Austria to deny the holocaust.

As for Bishop Fellay’s response to Bishop Williamson’s outrageous comments I applaud them. However, I noticed that the news media, which was so quick to associate his remarks with the Holy Father who had just lifted his excommunication, has not covered this reprimand.
 
Has this bishop had a mental evaluation? I would question the sanity of someone who denies the horrors what went on in concentration camps.
Agree. This is an Orwellian situation where, once the clocks sound thirteen o’clock, they’ve completely untrustworthy.
 
Has this bishop had a mental evaluation? I would question the sanity of someone who denies the horrors what went on in concentration camps.
I was wondering the same thing.

I’d heard this in the news and came here to see what everyone thought about it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top