Hostess Maneuver Deprived Pension

  • Thread starter Thread starter didymus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

didymus

Guest
Wall Street Journal:
Hostess Maneuver Deprived Pension
Hostess Brands Inc. said it used wages that were supposed to help fund employee pensions for the company’s operations as it sank toward bankruptcy.
It isn’t clear how many of the Irving, Texas, company’s workers were affected by the move or how much money never wound up in their pension plans as promised.
After the company said in August 2011 that it would stop making pension contributions, the foregone wages weren’t put toward the pension. Nor were they restored.
The maker of Twinkies, Ho-Hos and Wonder Bread filed for bankruptcy protection in January and shut down last month following a strike by one of the unions representing Hostess workers. A judge is overseeing the sale of company assets.
Gregory Rayburn, Hostess’s chief executive officer, said in an interview it is “terrible” that employee wages earmarked for the pension were steered elsewhere by the company.
“I think it’s like a lot of things in this case,” he added. “It’s not a good situation to have.”
Mr. Rayburn became chief executive in March and learned about the issue shortly before the company shut down, he said. “Whatever the circumstances were, whatever those decisions were, I wasn’t there,” he said.
A spokeswoman for Hostess’s previous top executive, Brian Driscoll, declined to comment.
“Company operations” of course includes such items as executive salaries and bonuses.
 
This is an interesting forum to find such a topic. I happen to teach business finance at West Virginia University, and I will use Hostess as an example in my opening lectures this semester. Like it or not, capitalism is at the core of American society and at the core of capitalism is understanding that “the objective of every business is to make money for the owners of the business now and in the future.” What happened at Hostess has and will happen in every instance where we neglect the “now, AND IN THE FUTURE” portion of that objective.

My connection to this forum, is that what happened at Hostess and what is happening in the business world in general is indicative of our secular society and in far too many cases our spiritual lives. Our focus is on the here and now without regard to how our actions or lack thereof impact our own future, let alone the future of others.

There was a time when the question, “What is my purpose in life?” had an answer: “To know God, to love God and to serve God in this world so that I might spend eternity with Him in the next.” (Baltimore Cathechism Question ???)

If former executives at Hostess derailed funds from the retirement plan to their own coffers they need to be held accountable for their actions. I hate the thought of being held accountable before God just as much as the next sinner. I hope and trust that God’s mercy and justice far surpasses anything that we have been able to come up with. But as I ponder the ultimate outcome of a capitalistic society I cannot help but to see that its success or demise is closely tied to how our society lives out the Gospel. It is times like these that I wish I taught at a Catholic University. But God has placed me at the #1 party school in America for a reason. He has a wonderful sense of humor.
 
All I’ll say is that stealing the labor of workers is a sin that cries to heaven for vengeance.
 
In case some people run into Wall Street Journal’s paywall, here is another link to the same article
finance.yahoo.com/news/hostess-maneuver-deprived-pension-051400720.html

From a legal perspective, what the Hostess management did has a term: betrayal without remedy. What they did was unjust, but it wasn’t illegal because the funds didn’t come directly from the employees.
I am a huge proponent of capitalism, and I think that what 5000 striking workers did to the other 13000 was wrong. However, what hostess did SHOULD be illegal and those that authorized it should see jail time. The same applies to unfunded State pensions…Illinois, I’m looking at you.
 
Can you cite some Church teaching that says that the income tax is theft?
Nope. Does the Church need to define EVERYTHING?

Taking what rightfully belongs to someone under threat of violence IS the very definition of robbery, a form of theft.

Robbery n. the felonious taking of the property of another from his or her person or in his or her immediate presence, against his or her will, by violence or intimidation… dictionary.reference.com/browse/robbery

So, I guess when the state does it, its okay. Just like when a guy who works for the state and dresses in a fancy uniform shoots an unarmed citizen of another nation, it is called “collateral damage”, whereas you or I would be charged with murder.
 
After the company said in August 2011 that it would stop making pension contributions, the foregone wages weren’t put toward the pension. Nor were they restored.
This is while the workers were on strike, right?

If so, the company has no obligation to fund workers pensions while they’re striking against the company.

However, funds already in the pension fund prior to the strike, should still be protected by law.

Jim
 
Nope. Does the Church need to define EVERYTHING?
You would think the income tax would be significant enough for the Church to comment on.
Taking what rightfully belongs to someone under threat of violence IS the very definition of robbery, a form of theft.
Kind of like what the Roman empire did, but Jesus never saw fit to condemn Rome’s system of taxation.
 
From MATER ET MAGISTRA,
it would appear that an income tax would be perfectly moral.

Wages do seem to represent capacity to pay, so a tax on wages would be consistent with church teaching.
  1. In a system of taxation based on justice and equity it is fundamental that the burdens be proportioned to the capacity of the people contributing.
 
From MATER ET MAGISTRA,
it would appear that an income tax would be perfectly moral.

Wages do seem to represent capacity to pay, so a tax on wages would be consistent with church teaching.
MATER ET MAGISTRA must be balanced with other teachings by Popes such as the following from Leo XIII’s encyclical RERUM NOVARUM:
47…These three important benefits, however, can be reckoned on only provided that a man’s means be not drained and exhausted by excessive taxation. The right to possess private property is derived from nature, not from man; and the State has the right to control its use in the interests of the public good alone, but by no means to absorb it altogether. The State would therefore be unjust and cruel if under the name of taxation it were to deprive the private owner of more than is fair.
 
“Company operations” does include executive salary and compensation – but it also includes non-executive salary and compensation. When Hostess began not paying its promised amount into the pension funds, this was not hidden. It was a long standing issue, and also one of the complaints during the bakers’ strike.

The hard fact is the company was going down, as it has been going down for a long time now. This bankruptcy did not emerge out of the blue. The firm had been bleeding cash and also scrambling to find buyers for a long time. This is Hostess’ second bankruptcy in the past few years. What people do when faced with dire fiscal constraints is strive to keep various plates spinning in the air, on the hope that somehow it will all work out. Most times it doesn’t, sadly.

Shorting pension funds is a typical and early feature for entities in crisis. The federal government is doing it right now, and for less good reasons. It has reduced the Social Security payroll tax by 2% in the past few years, and it looks to continue doing this. The rationale is to provide stimulus today and worry about the future shortfall this creates later. Moreover, all the funds we have paid into Social Security our entire lives have been swapped out for intergovernmental securities (ie., IOU’s). That pension fund, the largest in the land, has been used as a slush fund in its entirety to finance various pet projects since the day it began. This is far worse than anything Hostess or such entities have done. In fact, what Social Security does is technically illegal. It’s called a “Ponzi Scheme”, and a private entity trying to pull this off would wind up in jail for racketeering, like Bernie Madoff.

I don’t think we have a single state or city government that has its pension fully funded. Every single one of them has done what the feds have done with Social Security, and used those pension funds to finance other activities. They’ve shorted paying into them here and there as their whim dictated, and done other various things to use that money today and worry about shortfalls tomorrow.

Shorting pension funds is sadly an American tradition. Both in private life but especially in public life. This is going to hurt us all.
 
MATER ET MAGISTRA must be balanced with other teachings by Popes such as the following from Leo XIII’s encyclical RERUM NOVARUM:
That is true, but that is not the issue at hand. The claim that was made was that an income tax is theft, which of course has no support in Church teaching.
 
You would think the income tax would be significant enough for the Church to comment on.

Kind of like what the Roman empire did, but Jesus never saw fit to condemn Rome’s system of taxation.
Other than point out that Tiberius made claim on the very coins used to pay the tax that he, Tiberius, was who Jesus was, in fact.

The coin that Jesus uses in the “render unto Caesar” speech contains the words “Tiberius Caesar Divi August Fili Augustus” or “Tiberius Caesar, Worshipful Son of the God, Augustus.”

Jesus may not be claiming that income tax is evil, but rather to stop worshipping the state, which aims to take the place of God. It is the same situation that we have today.
 
Jesus may not be claiming that income tax is evil, but rather to stop worshipping the state, which aims to take the place of God. It is the same situation that we have today.
One can be in favor of an income tax without worshiping the state. I am not even in favor of the income tax, but I cannot say that it is immoral. Because there is nothing in 2000 years of Church teaching that would suggest that.
 
“Company operations” does include executive salary and compensation – but it also includes non-executive salary and compensation. When Hostess began not paying its promised amount into the pension funds, this was not hidden. It was a long standing issue, and also one of the complaints during the bakers’ strike.

The hard fact is the company was going down, as it has been going down for a long time now. This bankruptcy did not emerge out of the blue. The firm had been bleeding cash and also scrambling to find buyers for a long time. This is Hostess’ second bankruptcy in the past few years. What people do when faced with dire fiscal constraints is strive to keep various plates spinning in the air, on the hope that somehow it will all work out. Most times it doesn’t, sadly.

Shorting pension funds is a typical and early feature for entities in crisis. The federal government is doing it right now, and for less good reasons. It has reduced the Social Security payroll tax by 2% in the past few years, and it looks to continue doing this. The rationale is to provide stimulus today and worry about the future shortfall this creates later. Moreover, all the funds we have paid into Social Security our entire lives have been swapped out for intergovernmental securities (ie., IOU’s). That pension fund, the largest in the land, has been used as a slush fund in its entirety to finance various pet projects since the day it began. This is far worse than anything Hostess or such entities have done. In fact, what Social Security does is technically illegal. It’s called a “Ponzi Scheme”, and a private entity trying to pull this off would wind up in jail for racketeering, like Bernie Madoff.

I don’t think we have a single state or city government that has its pension fully funded. Every single one of them has done what the feds have done with Social Security, and used those pension funds to finance other activities. They’ve shorted paying into them here and there as their whim dictated, and done other various things to use that money today and worry about shortfalls tomorrow.

Shorting pension funds is sadly an American tradition. Both in private life but especially in public life. This is going to hurt us all.
This makes me think that there is some fault to be found in promising something in the way of pensions that cannot be delivered. I am not at all certain that pensions, just as SS, were ever intended at their inception, to be the only income a person should depend on. Whatever happened to some semblance of self-reliance in that each of us is responsible to live our lives so as to help provide for our elder years. First place to start is to stop trying to “keep up with the Joneses” and having to have every new gadget that comes down the pike?
 
This makes me think that there is some fault to be found in promising something in the way of pensions that cannot be delivered. I am not at all certain that pensions, just as SS, were ever intended at their inception, to be the only income a person should depend on. Whatever happened to some semblance of self-reliance in that each of us is responsible to live our lives so as to help provide for our elder years. First place to start is to stop trying to “keep up with the Joneses” and having to have every new gadget that comes down the pike?
While a potential recipient of a pension does have to worry about credit risk, that is whether the entity making the obligation will pay off, there is no excuse for diverting money earmarked for pensions anyplace else. The entity making the promise has the moral obligation to do everything possible to deliver.
 
The coin that Jesus uses in the “render unto Caesar” speech contains the words “Tiberius Caesar Divi August Fili Augustus” or “Tiberius Caesar, Worshipful Son of the God, Augustus.”
Hmmm. Something seems lost or gained in the translation. I don’t know where the worship comes from.

The actual coin has TICAESARDIVI AUGFAUGUSTUS written on it, which stands for TI CAESAR DIVI AUG F AUGUSTUS, or spelled out with lower case as “Tiberius Caesar Divi Augusti Filius Augustus.”

Can maybe be better translated as “Augustus Tiberius Caesar the Son of the Divine Augustus.”

The US $1 bill has a reference to the Divine as well. “ANNUIT COEPTIS NOVUS ORDO SECLORUM” except the Divine is represented as an eyeball.
Just saying.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top