Is the Pope American?
What a delightful display of arrogance. These congressmen are essentially accusing the pope of being un-American–that is, they are questioning his patriotism. Or they would be, anyway, if the pope were American. In fact, the pope is a leader of a foreign state, and they are demanding, as Americans, that he come to heel. What are they, a bunch of neocons?
Of course, what they are really doing is defying the pope’s authority, as leader of the Catholic Church, to make and enforce pronouncements about the obligations of a Catholic. In no way does this offend American pluralism. Pluralism allows for a variety of views on abortion and other subjects, and American politicians are free to follow or reject the teachings of their church, as they see fit.
What these congressmen–among them Rosa DeLauro of Connecticut, Patrick Kennedy of Rhode Island and Joe Baca of California–are saying is that at least
when it comes to abortion, they are liberals first and Catholics second. That probably reflects their constituents’ priorities, and it’s totally kosher from the standpoint of American political values. But it’s a bit much for them to demand the pope’s blessing.