How am I supposed to find a Catholic girl I'm attracted to?

  • Thread starter Thread starter hamburglar
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

hamburglar

Guest
I’m extremely picky when it comes to women. I need to be attracted to her and she needs to be smart, fun, and a traditional/orthodox Catholic. Even at a Catholic college, this seems impossible to find.

I’ve only dated one girl, she fit the description perfectly. It ended badly, but I want to put it in the past. I then was attracted to another girl, but she ended up getting a boyfriend so that’s out the window. Now I come to find myself trying to find anyone I’m even remotely attracted to, and I can’t find anyone.

I’m not just looking for a relationship, it’s okay that I’m single right now. But it’s troubling that I can’t find anyone that I feel could possibly be my wife someday. How am I supposed to meet someone?
 
Hamburglar, I agree, it is hard to find a good Catholic woman these days. It really seems as if they are few and far between.

As far as meeting someone, I could say the usual of “God will put her in the right place at the right time,” but allow me to give you some more advice.

Have you ever tried praying for your future spouse? I always try to offer up intentions when I pray for her purity, chastity, for her to have a great love of the Lord, and for patience. I find that it is a good thing to do.

Have you ever tried online dating sites? Catholicmatch.com is always a good choice. It lets you look at women based on their acceptance of important church teachings such as the sanctity of life, contraception, premarital sex, etc. I am sure some others that come on here will also suggest avemariasingles.com, but I cannot speak to that site since I am not on it.

I think the last piece of advice I can give you is to stick to your guns. I see you saying that you are trying to find someone you’re even remotely attracted to. While attraction is important, if a deep spiritual (Catholic in this case) bond is what you are looking for. Look for that and stick to it. Don’t settle for anything less. In the meantime, I will keep you in your prayers! Have a great day!
 
I’m extremely picky when it comes to women. I need to be attracted to her and she needs to be smart, fun, and a traditional/orthodox Catholic. Even at a Catholic college, this seems impossible to find.

I’ve only dated one girl, she fit the description perfectly. It ended badly, but I want to put it in the past. I then was attracted to another girl, but she ended up getting a boyfriend so that’s out the window. Now I come to find myself trying to find anyone I’m even remotely attracted to, and I can’t find anyone.

I’m not just looking for a relationship, it’s okay that I’m single right now. But it’s troubling that I can’t find anyone that I feel could possibly be my wife someday. How am I supposed to meet someone?
True attraction happens when you are in love with somebody. Don’t worry about it up front. My wife, for example is the most attractive women in the world to me. I’m sure she wouldn’t meet all your standards at first glance (although I think she is objectively pretty too). The first several months that I knew her I did have a single thought on whether I was attracted to her or not. It wasn’t after we start to date that I became attracted to her. In fact 16 years since we first dated, I find her more attractive now than I did then. We have been through a lot and I love her in a deeper more mature way. In reality she is older a few lbs heavier etc. but that is not wear true attraction lies, it is 90+% between the ears.

My point friend is you may be much happier and successful if you allow friendships with good Catholic girls to happen and see how your feeling develop before dismissing them on some physical standard. Remember no woman is going to look the same 30 or 40 years down the road and neither will you.
 
My point friend is you may be much happier and successful if you allow friendships with good Catholic girls to happen and see how your feeling develop before dismissing them on some physical standard. Remember no woman is going to look the same 30 or 40 years down the road and neither will you.
Fully in agreement with the above statement. Also, try attending different parishes at different times. Once you ‘scope things out’ you may find that there are more folks your age at a certain parish. You can then try and talk with them and find out what they are active in in the Parish. One girl I know of started to help with the concession stands, with a friend, at the Parish basketball games. She realized that many of the younger men were volunteer coaches for the children. This allowed her to meet them. She was looking for a service and a way to meet and mingle with more young Catholics. This suited her on both levels! She found that both male and female parish members in their 20s were active with the sports ministry as coaches, helpers and such.
AnnGrace
 
Come to Alabama… 😃

How old are you, btw?

Guess what I mean … make a pilgrimage to EWTN and all that we have, you might met a young lady … there are lots in my parish and surrounding areas…
 
lol, this goes both ways. It’s hard to find a good-Catholic boy you’re interested in. Don’t just completely outcast a girl because she’s not “traditional/orthodox.” Perhaps you were placed into her life to help her find her faith again?
 
I will be 21 next month, and I am not willing to try online dating at this time.

I have considered non-Catholics and lapsed Catholics. I’m just honestly not attracted to anyone and can’t see myself dating anybody I know, other than my ex-girlfriend and the girl I was interested in but has a boyfriend.
 
You know, you’re awfully young (not meant derogatorily: I was once, too:D), and even though I well remember the “call of the hormones,” believe me, it’s better to give it a few more years of maturing and gaining financial stability before you tie that very terminal knot. Once you’ve crossed that threshold, you’ve passed into TroublesGaloreLand. Cherish your freedom and your options while you’re still single. The fact that you’re not finding anybody right now might well be a “sign” that the time is not right.😉

BTW, I completely agree with you about sticking to someone who solidly shares your faith: marriage (notice, it’s not spelled “merriage”:rolleyes:) is hard enough even with an optimal mate. You don’t want to add gratuitous sources of friction and disagreement. Nor is there any guarantee that you’ll “convert” someone (or cause them to revert); take it from my experience, it’s folly to date (and then possibly get emotionally attached to) someone who’s not on the same page with you. It makes it doubly as difficult to disengage and to heal afterwards.

In the meantime, dive into your passionate interests and goals (er, maybe not the most felicitous choice of words:blush:) to keep you content and your mind occupied, and work on gaining wisdom and insight.👍
 
I’m extremely picky when it comes to women. I need to be attracted to her and she needs to be smart, fun, and a traditional/orthodox Catholic. Even at a Catholic college, this seems impossible to find.

I’ve only dated one girl, she fit the description perfectly. It ended badly, but I want to put it in the past. I then was attracted to another girl, but she ended up getting a boyfriend so that’s out the window. Now I come to find myself trying to find anyone I’m even remotely attracted to, and I can’t find anyone.

I’m not just looking for a relationship, it’s okay that I’m single right now. But it’s troubling that I can’t find anyone that I feel could possibly be my wife someday. How am I supposed to meet someone?
You can’t find one because you are not ready, when you are ready God will provide, you can’t rush this kind of thing.

For now you need to concentrate on doing awesome in college and growing in your faith, you will need both those things in the future to prepare you to be a good husband and father.
 
I don’t have any interests, any hobbies, or really any friends. I am depressed and lonely. I was so happy when my ex-girlfriend and I were dating and we both thought we were going to get married. Then she broke up with me and everything became terrible: I flunked out of school, went to the mental hospital, lost friends, and basically sat around and cried all day. I still am like this and I want nothing more than to find the girl God desires for me, and eventually marry her and have a family.
 
I don’t have any interests, any hobbies, or really any friends. I am depressed and lonely. I was so happy when my ex-girlfriend and I were dating and we both thought we were going to get married. Then she broke up with me and everything became terrible: I flunked out of school, went to the mental hospital, lost friends, and basically sat around and cried all day. I still am like this and I want nothing more than to find the girl God desires for me, and eventually marry her and have a family.
Then you need to become a man worthy of such a girl, until you do God will not trust you with one.

You dated before you were ready that was your problem and the after effects of that mistake have left you unhappy.

However it is your choice not to have any hobbies or interests, all of that you can change if you want to. If you continue to look to others to make you happy you will never be happy, true happiness comes from living a virtuous life not from finding a fairytale princess to make all your problems go away, heck since I got married my problems have gone thorough the roof. If you can’t hack been single you certainly wont be able to hack been married.

Where you go from here is completely in your power.
 
I’m extremely picky when it comes to women. I need to be attracted to her and she needs to be smart, fun, and a traditional/orthodox Catholic. Even at a Catholic college, this seems impossible to find.

I’ve only dated one girl, she fit the description perfectly. It ended badly, but I want to put it in the past. I then was attracted to another girl, but she ended up getting a boyfriend so that’s out the window. Now I come to find myself trying to find anyone I’m even remotely attracted to, and I can’t find anyone.

I’m not just looking for a relationship, it’s okay that I’m single right now. But it’s troubling that I can’t find anyone that I feel could possibly be my wife someday. How am I supposed to meet someone?
Hamburglar, here’s a wild thought for you…

Have you ever considered that maybe your vocation is to the religious life? This problem you’re having could be God’s way of telling you that He has other plans for you.

Don’t let yourself be driven by hormones, either. (Very common for young men your age considering the constant sexual things in our society: TV, movies, magazines, newspapers, music, billboards, etc.) If God has other plans for you, and you decide to do your own thing instead, you’ll never be truly happy in this life.
 
I don’t have any interests, any hobbies, or really any friends. I am depressed and lonely. I was so happy when my ex-girlfriend and I were dating and we both thought we were going to get married. Then she broke up with me and everything became terrible: I flunked out of school, went to the mental hospital, lost friends, and basically sat around and cried all day. I still am like this and I want nothing more than to find the girl God desires for me, and eventually marry her and have a family.
I think you need to concentrate on getting your life in order, especially the depression. Please seek some professional help, get your life back on track, concentrate on being happy with your own life first. You can not worry about finding a girlfriend or being attracted to someone as long as you seem to be as unhappy as you describe.
 
I used to have a “list”, you know, “smart, sense of humour (or at least understands mine), worth ethic, pro-life, God fearing, good Catholic” then i realised, the world doesnt’ work like that.

I’ve met a guy who ticked all the boxes, but it turned out he was a bit of a coward when it came to being honest.

I met another chap who was a good Christian guy, and was keen on marrying me (he decided this after one coffee and one week of emails. >_< ’ ) But then his anti-catholicism showed.

Then I met another guy, a Catholic, educated, et al, again, all the boxes, bar one - he was a filthy pervert who after two coffee’s was demanding sex. Um, no.

The way I look at it now, is God has the right fella out there for me if I’m meant for this vocation, and knowing God’s sense of humour when it comes to me, its probably some guy who’s a non-Catholic christian with no sense of humour and drives a Ford.

But then with that said, I think a lot of Catholic guys need to own the situation, it ticks me off a bit when I hear some Catholic men go on about how women need to look one way or have this particular hair colour or be this particular bra size. Looks should be at the bottom of your list! I certainly wouldn’t date/court a man who was interested only in my appearance.

I met a “catholic” in a public place from an online dating site, and the first thing is, “I thought your [slang for mammary glands] would be bigger”. -_-’

I stopped actively looking after that gem.
 
When I was with my ex-girlfriend, things couldn’t have been better. My faith was as strong as it ever was, and we strengthened each others’ faiths. Going to Mass on Sunday was something very special we did together.

It’s hard for me to see myself so happy and strong in my faith when I was with someone and now seeing myself as sad, bored, and not trusting as much in God after the breakup. It also troubles me that I’m just not attracted to anyone else besides two girls I will likely never date. Sure I find girls attractive, but I honestly can’t see myself dating anyone else and that doesn’t seem to be normal thinking.
 
When I was with my ex-girlfriend, things couldn’t have been better. My faith was as strong as it ever was, and we strengthened each others’ faiths. Going to Mass on Sunday was something very special we did together.

It’s hard for me to see myself so happy and strong in my faith when I was with someone and now seeing myself as sad, bored, and not trusting as much in God after the breakup. It also troubles me that I’m just not attracted to anyone else besides two girls I will likely never date. Sure I find girls attractive, but I honestly can’t see myself dating anyone else and that doesn’t seem to be normal thinking.
Making girls the sole interest and goal of your life is not normal thinking I agree with you there, no wonder you are depressed, you are idolising creatures, creatures that have faults just like you, have you learned nothing from your break up? Are you going to keep on repeating the mistakes of the past? That is the definition of insanity.
 
I don’t have any interests, any hobbies, or really any friends. I am depressed and lonely. I was so happy when my ex-girlfriend and I were dating and we both thought we were going to get married. Then she broke up with me and everything became terrible: I flunked out of school, went to the mental hospital, lost friends, and basically sat around and cried all day. I still am like this and I want nothing more than to find the girl God desires for me, and eventually marry her and have a family.
This is why you can’t find a girl. You need to be satisfied and happy with who YOU are first before you can ever be satisfied and happy with who a woman is.

You are having a hard time accepting “real” women because you don’t accept yourself.

You HAVE to get help, medical and psychological, to get to a place where you are not depressed or lonely.

Think about it–what woman would want to spend time with a man who is depressed and sits around cries all day?!

I have a best friend who suffers from depression and schizophrenia. She lives in a group home, and I see her once a week for dinner. I’ve gotten to know quite a few of the other residents of the home, and I can say this about mental illness–those who have it are extremely self-centered. I can understand why–they suffer from an illness that is very hard to treat and manage, and so they have to think about themselves a lot.

But being self-centered is not a good way to be when you are involved with another person in a romantic relationship. Love between a man and a woman is all about giving of yourself to the other person, and if you don’t like yourself, you won’t be able to give yourself to anyone. All you can do is take from others. This is evidenced by the fact that in each of your posts, you talk about “not being attracted to any woman.” That’s nonsense, as several posters have tried to tell you. A romance has nothing to do with “being attracted to” anyone. What you are describing is a “crush” and that’s for kids and for women and men who love various movie stars and celebrities. (E.g., I “love” Robert Patrick! Sigh!) But it’s NOT the basis for a serious relationship. You’ll have to learn to forget about “being attracted to someone” unless you want your relationships with women to remain on a teenaged level.

I actually trained my girls to avoid romantic relationships with men who are mentally-ill. I’m sorry that sounds harsh, but in real life, on a daily basis, marriage is difficult enough without having to endure this very draining disability. A man is a supposed to support a woman and protect and take care of her, NOT the other way around. It’s one thing when one of the spouses develops a mental illness during the course of a marriage–that happens, and that is covered by our marriage vows. It happened to me when my husband was diagnosed with clinical depression (he’s on meds now and will be forever, and everything is fine). But for a woman to deliberately walk into a romantic relationships and marriage with a man who is mentally-ill–well, I would tell that woman to make darn sure she has a great deal of information about the illness and to learn exactly what she will be facing on a daily basis for the rest of her life, even if her husband is compliant with his treatments. Again, I apologize if this sounds harsh. I’m a realist.
 
I don’t have any interests, any hobbies, or really any friends. I am depressed and lonely. I was so happy when my ex-girlfriend and I were dating and we both thought we were going to get married. Then she broke up with me and everything became terrible: I flunked out of school, went to the mental hospital, lost friends, and basically sat around and cried all day. I still am like this and I want nothing more than to find the girl God desires for me, and eventually marry her and have a family.
Then you have to find interests and hobbies and make friends. What you are describing is looking for someone to fix you, to fill a void, to give you what you need to make you not lonely, not depressed and happy. That is not a relationship, and certainly no basis for marriage. That’s using someone to fill your needs (even if your not conscious of it).

Love is about giving, not taking. And right now you have much work to do before you are ready to give anything. Because you can’t give what you don’t have. You need to continue to work on your mental health with professionals and you need to force yourself to get involved in things. Not to mention -do you have a decent career that can support a family? These things don’t happen by wishing them or thinking you’ll just figure it out when the time comes. You have no hobbies, no interests, no friends and you have dropped out of school -what can offer a good, Catholic young woman?

Right now is your time to work on making yourself healthy and then you can start seeking out women.
 
I advice you to strongly consider enlisting in the military, it will teach you confidence and self reliance, two things you seem to desperately need and will also provide you with a huge number of new skills and interests as well as force you to make new friends.

youtube.com/watch?v=GlzdZqSVbJ4
 
hamburglar, there have been several very wise posts on here, but let me add a point or two from the opposite side of the aisle. I am a woman who feels called to be married. Now, Mr. Right hasn’t come along yet. I have a few–a very few–preconceived notions about him, and about the sort of person I want to be when I meet him.

Catholic? Almost certainly, as I’ve known exactly one interfaith marriage (in which the children were raised strictly Catholic) that has both worked out well and has produced solidly Catholic children…and the dad converted around ten years into the marriage. And by Catholic (can’t believe that I have to specify this), I do mean someone who’s in agreement with the Church vis-a-vis NFP, no artificial birth control, no premarital sex, etc, etc, etc. :rolleyes: Indeed, I want someone who is already very strong in his faith because part of the vocation of a husband and father, I believe, is to be something of a priest in his own home: he leads the family in worship and to God. On the other hand, I believe that a wife and mother needs to teach her children to have a spiritual life…so I try to prepare myself spiritually to do that. I pray every night to the Blessed Mother, spend time (if not so much time as I ought) in Adoration, and read books about the vocation of a wife and mother. (For anyone interested, I can’t recommend enough von Hildebrand’s “By Love Refined” and Genevieve Kineke’s “The Authentic Catholic Woman”.)

Mentally healthy? Well, we all have our quirks, no doubt about it. I’ve been through clinical depression before, and I certainly realize that it’s a nasty process. In my case, though, I believe it was due to circumstances rather than brain chemistry. (This certainly isn’t the case for everyone.) This is one area in which I found spiritual direction incredibly helpful. Again, this may not work for everyone, but my depression has poked its nose in the door all of one or two days of the last six months. I ascribe that to starting to have a prayer life. I still don’t pray and meditate as often as I should, but just having evening prayer and spending some time in Adoration has been INCREDIBLY helpful. Too, I’ve become more mature through this process, and so I think have become more fit for my vocation.

Finally, there is the question of finances. I’m not looking for a millionaire, nor even someone particularly wealthy. I am, however, looking to marry someone with a steady income that will be sufficient to have us live in a safe area, drive a reliable (not brand new, not a Porsche, just reliable) car or two, and not be worried from week to week about a paycheck. It isn’t responsible, to my way of thinking, to start a family if there isn’t a way of providing the basics for them…and in this Church, marriage generally does lead to a family. 😛 In my case, I keep my credit card balance low or non-existent, as I don’t want to enter a marriage and burden someone with debt.

I suppose that what I’m trying to say is threefold.

First, you need to get yourself spiritually in shape before you look to enter into the rather incredible-but-demanding relationship that is marriage. I STRONGLY suggest that you ask a priest for a little spiritual direction. Find a priest you think you’d be comfortable with and ask him to give you an hour or two. A good priest will REALLY help clarify what’s going on with you spiritually and emotionally, and will give you solid suggestions about both a prayer life and vocational discernment. Developing a close relationship with God before you do so with a woman will make the latter relationship infinitely better. Relying on Him is harder than leaning on someone you can physically see and talk to…but He’s infallible, always there, and only wants what’s best for you. If you’re supposed to be married, he’ll lead you to the right woman. You might consider praying for your future spouse now; even if you don’t know her yet, your prayers can do her nothing but good and are a beautiful gift for her. I say the Litany of the Blessed Virgin Mary every night for my future husband, asking Our Lady to guide him, watch over him, and give him peace. (I also add a caveat to the effect of “and if it turns out I’m not supposed to marry, use any graces associated with this Litany for whatever you think best, Mother.”)

Second, the mental health issues cannot help but improve when you develop a better and spiritual life. As someone earlier pointed out, marriage is tough enough without getting into it with mental health issues. I’m not saying this precludes you from getting married; it doesn’t. I will say that I would not be interested in seriously dating someone who had unresolved depression. (If he needed to be on antidepressants because the depression was chemical, I wouldn’t mind that. As I said, we all have our quirks. I mean untreated, unresolved depression.)

Finally, before you seek a spouse, make sure you’re in a position to start a family in a couple of years. If you’re in your last year or two of college, are spiritually and mentally fit, and know that upon graduation you could expect to have a steady job with sufficient income for a family, it sounds to me like an excellent time to look into finding a wife.

Mental and physical loneliness is hard, I know, and hormones are thoroughly unhelpful in this regard. I do have friends, though, and hobbies; comradeship and laughter, I’ve found, is another sign of God’s love. Keeping busy has also helped considerably lessen my depression, I think.

I suppose that this tome I’ve typed (assuming any of you are still reading!) leads up to this: try to, with God’s help, make yourself the man you would want the love of your life to spend her life with. True love is completely unselfish and wants only the best for the beloved, so make yourself into the best man that you can be.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top