How do i justify this as a catholic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ChristIsLord
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
In the very same chapter where that commandment is given, God commands statues of cherubim to be made and placed on the ark of the covenant, which was highly venerated. God also commanded a bronze serpent to be made and to look upon it to be saved from the snakes (unfortunately, much later, the people actually did begin to worship that bronze serpent as a god and so it was rightly destroyed).
so of your two examples out of thousands of years of biblical history, you have one being destroyed because the people fell into idol worship and the other was to be made only under direct comand from god for the ark, and you turn this into making any graven image of people, jesus, angels, bowing before them, lighting candles, praying to them, kissing them etc… that’s a leap i am not ready to take, it’s quite a chasm you jumped over.
 
so of your two examples out of thousands of years of biblical history, you have one being destroyed because the people fell into idol worship and the other was to be made only under direct comand from god for the ark, and you turn this into making any graven image of people, jesus, angels, bowing before them, lighting candles, praying to them, kissing them etc… that’s a leap i am not ready to take, it’s quite a chasm you jumped over.
You have not, then, understood the depth and force of the Incarnation. In the Incarnation of God as the Man Jesus, the Living Image of God became visible. Representations of Him and His deeds (including His Mother and all who are His handiwork of Grace) and His Mysteries, therefore, are not only allowed but desirable. The Church is only imitating what God Himself has done in giving for our salvation, the True Icon of Himself. It is the Incarnation of God that is the key factor in determining if sacred images may be used.

Thus the reason we Catholics truly have honor for things we can see and feel, etc., has to do with the Incarnation in that Catholicism understands and appreciates the reality of the Incarnation, whereas Protestantism merely pays it lip service without truly appreciating what it means for God to have become Man; as St. Paul says of Christ: “He is the visible image of the invisible God; and so in seeing Him we are caught up in love for the God we cannot see.”

This situation (the Incarnation) changes everything. It shows that the New Covenant in Christ is different from God’s Covenant with Israel. In the Christian Covenant, we have Emmanuel (“God-with-us”), and, therefore, not only Christ’s Incarnation reflects the glory of the Father, but also the Church - the extension of Christ’s Incarnation (i.e., the Body of Christ) - reflects God’s glory. Thus Mary and the other Saints who reflect Christ, thereby reflect the Father’s glory. And so, images of Christ and the Saints are at the service of this incarnational glory of God; and the law against “graven images” is turned against itself in Christ.

Under the Old Law the Israelites were not to make graven images because no earthly creation could reflect the glory of God. Yet, after the Incarnation, this is possible, but only in Christ and in His Saints - those who are part of His Body.

So, the key to understanding Catholic iconography is to appreciate the reality of Christ’s Incarnation. In rejecting the legitimacy of icons and other religious images, the Protestant world comes very close to rejecting the Incarnation Itself. Indeed, Christ became FLESH in order to save FLESH (us). If everything is merely spiritual, why did Jesus need to come in the flesh at all?? This must be addressed and recognized.

This, posted some years back on another forum, very well addresses your concern:
The Old Testament prohibitions (which are quite strict) against the creation of images, are similar to Israelitic rules pertaining to “kashrut” (koser; meaning, “that which is fit”) in general; they are pedagogical.
The Israelites were a people mired with pagan influences, dwelling in a carnal and darkened world. According to the Great Prophet of the Old Covenant, Moses the God-seer, the Israelites were an extremely stubborn people, and even in his own lifetime they rebelled against him and God (Deuteronomy 31:27). Thus the Law they received, was harsh, to ensure they’d stay on the right path (and very often even this was not enough.)
They were given dietary laws which were strictly enforced, so that they couldn’t even sit at the table of a pagan, let alone fraternize with him. They were absolutely forbidden to marry foreign wives (a great sin which King Solomon was punished for) for this reason (save those women would convert, as did happen a few times in the Old Testament; one of our Lord’s ancestors, Ruth, was in fact a covert to the Old Covenant). These laws were needed in their regard, to keep them from the abominations of the pagans.
This included the fetishistic idolatry of pagans, and their carnal notions about spiritual things. The pagans envisioned divinity as being something degraded and human; their “gods” subject to the worst forms of human pettiness, and moral debauchery. The common belief of the people, envisioned “gods” who copulated, had spats, ate, drank, killed each other, etc.
This is very foreign to any true idea about the Divinity. Thus, there were strict prohibitions (enforced with varying degrees of severity in Jewish history) against making images, or showing them veneration, to avoid the danger of making a mockery of God, and the fetishism of the pagans.
Given that the Israelites were a people who, despite the theophanic fire burning atop Mt.Sinai, and the great miracles they’d witnessed, still worshipped the idol of the golden calf, shows such severity was needed. (Exodus chapter 32) So outrageous was their conduct, that God was prepared (according to Exodus 32) to annihilate the Israelites, and let Moses start over again somewhere else (but Moses supplicated on their behalf, so a lesser punishment was allowed.). . .
continued. . .
 
Despite all of this, we do see that in the Old Testament, even under the Old Covenant, there were sacred images (greek “icon”). The Ark of the Covenant which God gave specific instructions on how to construct, was itself a “type”, and the statues of the Cherubim on the top were certainly representations (indeed, representations of something which is in fact spiritual, and by it’s nature incorporeal). The vestments worn by the Aaronic Priests had illustrations of vegation on them, and we know that the Temple of Solomon (which God consecrated to Himself) had representations of Cherubim all over the place, a representation of Paradise in the inner area, and two gigantic gold leafed statues of Cherubim in the inner sactuary, between which the Ark of the Covenant was placed.
It can be said, and very correctly, that the entire ritual and Temple worship mandated by the Old Covenant was “iconographic”, both in it’s representations of Angels, and of spiritual ideals like God’s Throne, Heaven, the Heavenly Altar, etc. This is not only not condemned by God in the Old Testament, but was constructed according to His will.
For believers in God, who are rightly initiated into the New Covenant (made not upon Mt.Sinai, but Mt.Zion, where the house was located that the Last Supper occured in…surrounded not by twelve stone pillars as Moses was, but the twelve Apostles), this iconographical principle (representing in type heavenly things, and mysteries of the Kingdom) is still in force.
Are not the promises and gifts given to the Church greater than that seen in Israel of old? Were they not pointing to the reality of redemption, where as we are familiars with it? While they could only live in hope of the Christ, has He not already come to us? Where as the Israelites could only point to Heavenly things, are we not partakers in them?
Speaking of the righteous men and women who lived before the coming of Christ, St.Paul states, “All these died according to faith, not having received the promises but beholding them afar off and saluting them and confessing that they are pilgrims and strangers on the earth.”(Hebrews 11:13)
And making a contrast between these persons and the Church, St.Paul adds:

“And all these, being approved by the testimony of faith, received not the promise: God providing some better thing for us, that they should not be perfected without us.”
(Hebrews 11:39-40)
According to Hebrews 12:1, these Saints of the Old Testament (who now, being rescued in death by the power of the Ressurection, have inherited the promise), and for us (by default) all of those who have successfully run the course before us in the New Covenant, exist as a “cloud of witnesses” that “surrounds us”.
This Holy Mystery, lies at the heart of the true Church, and is the reality it participates in, this reality being most clearly shown where and when She gathers to celebrate the Eucharist (which was established on Mt.Zion):

"For you are not come to a mountain that might be touched and a burning fire and a whirlwind and darkness and storm, And the sound of a trumpet and the voice of words, which they that had excused themselves, that the word might not be spoken to them. For they did not endure that which was said: and if so much as a beast shall touch the mount, it shall be stoned. And so terrible was that which was seen, Moses said: I am frighted, and tremble.But you are come to mount Sion and to the city of the living God, the heavenly Jerusalem, and to the company of many thousands of angels, And to the church of the firstborn who are written in the heavens, and to God the judge of all, and to the spirits of the just made perfect, 24 And to Jesus the mediator of the new testament, and to the sprinkling of blood which speaketh better than that of Abel. (Hebrews 12:18-24)
The above shows the direct communion which the Church Militant (the Church in this world) has with the Church Triumphant (the Heavenly Church); a union which is made manifest when the Mass is celebrated (the Priest acting in the person of Christ the Offerer, the Bread and Wine separately consecrated as His Body and Blood, the sacrifice for our sins).
The above also shows, just how superior the life of the Church is, over the Synagogue; how more fruitful the New Covenant is, over the Old (which it in fact came to fulfill and bring to completion; the Old by it’s very symbols and nature, points to the New). Whereas the Old Covenant was characterized by severity, and fear, the New Covenant is characterized by fellowship with God as His very sons, being baptized into the eternally begotten Son.
Therefore, just as God hallowed Solomon’s Temple, is it not right to believe that God hallows the Temples which the Church has erected, for the purpose of giving them a place to gather and celebrate the Holy Mass? And just as this Temple had rightful Icons, reprenting Heavenly beings and mysteries, would it not make sense that the Angels and Saints are also represented in our Houses of Prayer? Indeed, are not such representations only giving symbolic form, to that which is in fact very real and very much present?
As the Apostle teaches, after speaking of our communion with Heaven: “We have an altar whereof they have no power to eat who serve the tabernacle.” (Hebrews 13:10)
 
so because jesus was incarnate as a man (of which we really have no idea what he looked like he certainly wasn’t the blond haired blue eyed european he’s displayed as). that means that making graven images is now o.k.? again that’s quite a leap.

i’ll leave it as agree to disagree, i’ve tried to justify the praying before statues and lighting candles and i just can’t.
 
so because jesus was incarnate as a man (of which we really have no idea what he looked like he certainly wasn’t the blond haired blue eyed european he’s displayed as). that means that making graven images is now o.k.? again that’s quite a leap.

i’ll leave it as agree to disagree, i’ve tried to justify the praying before statues and lighting candles and i just can’t.
If it troubles you then don’t pray before statues or candles and just sing happy birthday with your eyes closed if somone decorates your b-day cake with candles. You can also remove your Christian cross from your bumper sticker (along with any “This car will be pilot-less after the rapture” ones you might also have) and your neck chain and just relax - no one is going to begrudge you that.

And you can forget about the legends of the image of Jesus’ face that was put on St. Veronica’s cloth when she wiped The Lord’s face on the road to Calvary since its not essential to your salvation.

But tell me truthfully, would you not kiss a relic of the One True Cross if it was proven beyond all doubt to be authentic? 😉

James
 
so because jesus was incarnate as a man (of which we really have no idea what he looked like he certainly wasn’t the blond haired blue eyed european he’s displayed as). that means that making graven images is now o.k.? again that’s quite a leap.

i’ll leave it as agree to disagree, i’ve tried to justify the praying before statues and lighting candles and i just can’t.
Are you a Catholic?
 
*“I am the Lord your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of slavery; you shall have no other gods before me. **You shall not make for yourself an idol, whether in the form of anything that is in heaven above, or that is on the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth. You shall not bow down to them or ***worship them; for I the LORD your God am a jealous God, punishing children for the iniquity of parents, to the third and fourth generation of those who reject me, but showing steadfast love to the thousandth generation of those who love me and keep my commandments.”

it says pretty clearly don’t make them, don’t bow down to them, and don’t worship them. it seems like a clear commandment, yet in the catholic church i see people, bowing down to them, lighting candles before them, rubbing them, praying before them. i just don’t know how to justify it. how does god go from forbiding making graven images for thousands of years to allowing rampant graven images adorning his church and having people bowing before them?

i’ve read the catholic answers apologetic on this and it doesn’t seem convincing to me. god only authorized the cherubim to be placed on the mercy seat which wasn’t in the public eye, and the serpent staff was later destroyed because some were falling into idolatory.

i don’t understand how graven images are no good, to then perfectly fine. if god’s commandments are unchanging and god is unchanging the graven images don’t make sense to someone like me.
Because the invisible God became Man and dwelled among us. God became visible, so now it is acceptable to have images of God (Jesus), whereas before, it was not.

Also, when people bow down or kneel down and pray, they are praying to God in heaven; not to the images or to the statues themselves. The images or statues are just focal points, in the same way that when you pray with the Bible, the words on the page are a focal point - you aren’t actually praying to the ink and paper. Nobody thinks the images they are using can hear or see, or that they are actually Mary, or St. Therese, or whomever.

Back in the Old Testament times, the pagans actually believed that their images had souls of their own - that you could talk to the image. The only thing analogous that we have today, is kids talking to their dolls and teddy bears - except that the kids really know that it’s just pretend. The ancient pagans actually thought that those objects, themselves, could hear them and answer them. They were not meant to be representing something else or someone else. This isn’t something that we can really relate to, in modern times. It would be very unlikely for someone to actually pray to a statue - they are actually praying to God, whom the statue represents.
 
for anyone who has been to mexico or south america we can see that idol worship has grabbed hold of that church almost through and through. many mexicans believe in the cult of santa meurta, many mexicans will outright claim mary is their god. and the statues have taken on full fledged idol worship. THIS is why god commanded them not to be even made in the first place and certainly not to bow down to them.

and to the person saying the graven images aren’t “venerated” they certainly are according to the catechism and the code of canon law:

"2132 The Christian veneration of images is not contrary to the first commandment which proscribes idols. Indeed, “the honor rendered to an image passes to its prototype,” and “whoever venerates an image venerates the person portrayed in it.” 70 The honor paid to sacred images is a “respectful veneration,” not the adoration due to God alone: "

as for stating my translation is “fishy” well that is untrue too, there is nothing fishy about it. graven images means carved images, that’s the meaning of the word so a photo of your family would not fall into that. anyway i don’t set up photos of my family and burn incense or candles and bow befeore them.
Oh great, it’s so nice to know that when someone burns incense in front of a PICTURE of Buddha or one of the Hindu deities and bows down to it in LATRIA/WORSHIP (as opposed to prayer - you do know, do you not, that I pray to you every single time I ask you to do something for me?) that they’re not doing anything wrong - it’s only if it’s a STATUE. :yup: 🤷
 
Because the invisible God became Man and dwelled among us. God became visible, so now it is acceptable to have images of God (Jesus), whereas before, it was not.
again that’s a leap to make there, there’s absolutely nothing in the bible stating it is now o.k. to make graven images at will, bow before them and pray.
Also, when people bow down or kneel down and pray, they are praying to God in heaven; not to the images or to the statues themselves. The images or statues are just focal points, in the same way that when you pray with the Bible, the words on the page are a focal point - you aren’t actually praying to the ink and paper. Nobody thinks the images they are using can hear or see, or that they are actually Mary, or St. Therese, or whomever.

Back in the Old Testament times, the pagans actually believed that their images had souls of their own - that you could talk to the image. The only thing analogous that we have today, is kids talking to their dolls and teddy bears - except that the kids really know that it’s just pretend. The ancient pagans actually thought that those objects, themselves, could hear them and answer them. They were not meant to be representing something else or someone else. This isn’t something that we can really relate to, in modern times. It would be very unlikely for someone to actually pray to a statue - they are actually praying to God, whom the statue represents.
that isn’t the jewish understanding of the commandment, it doesn’t say don’t make graven images that you believe have souls of their own and you can talk to. it says don’t make graven images period, don’t bow down to them or worship them.
 
Oh great, it’s so nice to know that when someone burns incense in front of a PICTURE of Buddha or one of the Hindu deities and bows down to it in LATRIA/WORSHIP (as opposed to prayer - you do know, do you not, that I pray to you every single time I ask you to do something for me?) that they’re not doing anything wrong - it’s only if it’s a STATUE. :yup: 🤷
well worship is for god alone clearly, so anyone worshiping a photo or anything other than god alone would be guilty too, let’s not split hairs here and twist the discussion.
 
that isn’t the jewish understanding of the commandment, it doesn’t say don’t make graven images that you believe have souls of their own and you can talk to. it says don’t make graven images period, don’t bow down to them or worship them.
And? By the Jewish understanding of the nature of God He cannot possibly be a Trinity. They were wrong on that point and they are possibly wrong on this one. 🤷

If their understanding of the nature of God itself is so different from yours, then why would you accept without questioning their interpretation of this commandment?
 
so because jesus was incarnate as a man (of which we really have no idea what he looked like he certainly wasn’t the blond haired blue eyed european he’s displayed as). that means that making graven images is now o.k.? again that’s quite a leap.

i’ll leave it as agree to disagree, i’ve tried to justify the praying before statues and lighting candles and i just can’t.
You know, here is what is interesting to me. Jesus left no writing, and did not command anyone to write anything, yet you believe in the Bible, right? You accept that the Church can create the Bible without any explicit command to do so from God, and that it is a good and holy thing to have and to use.

But, Jesus left us not one but two images of Himself - Veronica’s veil, and the Shroud of Turin - but you have trouble with images in the Church.

How does this come about? 🤷
 
well ***worship is for god alone ***clearly, so anyone worshiping a photo or anything other than god alone would be guilty too, let’s not split hairs here and twist the discussion.
Exactly - worship is for God alone! ANYTHING that we do for or to a person or a thing that we do NOT consider to be GOD and don’t call GOD, by its very definition canNOT possibly be worship!
 
You know, here is what is interesting to me. Jesus left no writing, and did not command anyone to write anything, yet you believe in the Bible, right? You accept that the Church can create the Bible without any explicit command to do so from God, and that it is a good and holy thing to have and to use.

But, Jesus left us not one but two images of Himself - Veronica’s veil, and the Shroud of Turin - but you have trouble with images in the Church.

How does this come about? 🤷
i give zero credibility to “veronica’s veil” or the shorud of turin, absolutely zero. they are stories, middle age frauds. simple as that.

you have to look at it from the other end, here’s god himself commanding do not make graven images or anything in heaven, on earth, or in the sea, do not bow down to them, or worship them. then as a catholic is sit there and bow down and pray before graven images of jesus, mary, the saints etc… you have to understand why a man like me would have a difficult time understanding why.

and as someone who has seen the idolatory these statues and bowing before them firsthand in churches in mexico and south america where idolatory is rampant. it makes me wonder what they’re adding to the faith when they seem to directly go against god’s commandment.
 
Exactly - worship is for God alone! ANYTHING that we do for or to a person or a thing that we do NOT consider to be GOD and don’t call GOD, by its very definition canNOT possibly be worship!
you need to get off the worship thing, because i clearly said that it’s a three part commandment, don’t make them, don’t bow to them OR worship them. doing two of the three is still idolatory, and “venerating” the images is dangerously close to providing them with worship or setting them up as idols.
 
you need to get off the worship thing, because i clearly said that it’s a three part commandment, don’t make them, don’t bow to them OR worship them. doing two of the three is still idolatory, and “venerating” the images is dangerously close to providing them with worship or setting them up as idols.
But if it’s a three part commandment then you got this idea of ‘TWO out of three’ out of thin air. Obviously it’s not just one out of three - we see people bowing and making images all the time in the NT. And it could just as correctly be translated, doubtless, as ‘don’t make them OR bow to them OR worship them’.

So why two of the criteria constituting a breach of the commandment as opposed to all three? That distinction comes out of your own head and nowhere else.
 
But if it’s a three part commandment then you got this idea of ‘TWO out of three’ out of thin air. Obviously it’s not just one out of three - we see people bowing and making images all the time in the NT. And it could just as correctly be translated, doubtless, as ‘don’t make them OR bow to them OR worship them’.

So why two of the criteria constituting a breach of the commandment as opposed to all three? That distinction comes out of your own head and nowhere else.
the word or is what dictates the meaning, had it be “and” it could possible be understood that all three criteria have to be met, however the word “or” makes it understood that simply making them is idolatory, bowing down to them is idolatory, or worshiping them is of course idolatory too.

and/or arguments in a simple search engine follow this premise. i can’t think of anywhere in the nt where people are creating graven images and bowing before them and giving burnt offerings and praying.
 
the word or is what dictates the meaning, had it be “and” it could possible be understood that all three criteria have to be met, however the word “or” makes it understood that simply making them is idolatory, bowing down to them is idolatory, or worshiping them is of course idolatory too.

and/or arguments in a simple search engine follow this premise. i can’t think of anywhere in the nt where people are creating graven images and bowing before them and giving burnt offerings and praying.
SIMPLY MAKING THEM IS IDOLATRY according to the commandment (your own words)!? You must be joking! So the makers of the statues of Lincoln and Jefferson in their respective memorials in Washington, or the many statues of the great and good that are all over our major cities, are ALL idolators by your logic, since they made graven images.

Michelangelo, Rodin, all the great sculptors. All idolators. The makers of the cherubim on the Ark, idolators. Don’t make me laugh.

I can’t think of anywhere in the NT where anyone is using cars or computers either - so by your logic it must be wrong to do so, since they didn’t. And I notice you didn’t respond to my
 
the word or is what dictates the meaning, had it be “and” it could possible be understood that all three criteria have to be met, however the word “or” makes it understood that simply making them is idolatory, bowing down to them is idolatory, or worshiping them is of course idolatory too.

and/or arguments in a simple search engine follow this premise. i can’t think of anywhere in the nt where people are creating graven images and bowing before them and giving burnt offerings and praying.
If it is a sin only to make images, then God sinned by creating us in His image, right? 🤷

And God required Solomon to sin when He required Solomon to make images of the cherubim, and He commanded Moses to sin, when He told him to make a bronze snake and display it on a pole.

I have also never heard of a Catholic giving burnt offerings to a statue, anyway - where on earth are you getting this from? (Candles are not “burnt offerings” - they are timing devices. The idea is that you are supposed to stay there and pray until the candle burns out. If you have to leave early, other people can come and pray for you, until your candle burns out. Some people piously believe that their guardian angels finish their prayers for them. But the candle is not intended as an “offering.”)

But if a candle is a “burnt offering” then to whom or to what are you offering, when your electricity goes out and you use emergency candles? 🤷
 
SIMPLY MAKING THEM IS IDOLATRY according to the commandment (your own words)!? You must be joking! So the makers of the statues of Lincoln and Jefferson in their respective memorials in Washington, or the many statues of the great and good that are all over our major cities, are ALL idolators by your logic, since they made graven images.
Michelangelo, Rodin, all the great sculptors. All idolators. The makers of the cherubim on the Ark, idolators. Don’t make me laugh.
LilyM had my thoughts exactly, but there is even more. Why not just burn all of your family photos? Throw out every piece of memorabilia, crush every replica and model building, car, or train! Let’s just erase our memory of the Saints and Angels who sacrificed everything to be holy examples for us as Catholics Today.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top