L
Lion_of_Narnia
Guest
Muhammed and Muslims after him claim that both the Jewish and Christian scriptures are “corrupted”–i.e. both Moses and Jesus taught a “pure Islam” which was distorted and changed beynd recognition
The burden of proof is squarly on Muslims–otherwise, “an assertion with no proof can be dismissed with no proof”
Claims of Hebrew scriptural corruption run right into the testimony the Dead Sea scrolls, whose scriptual texts are from circa 200 BC–which means the next oldest texts are from 1200 years later with the Masoretic text–the 99+% agreement between the DSS and the Masoretic refutes the Muslim claim right then and there
As for the Christian texts, the multiple geographic sources and “streams” of textual transmission absolutley prevented any possible “bottleneck” of central authority (i.e. The Church as we know her) re-writing the NT–VERY unlike the Uthman caliphate’s undeniable “lock” on koranic edition and transmission
The burden of proof is squarly on Muslims–otherwise, “an assertion with no proof can be dismissed with no proof”
Claims of Hebrew scriptural corruption run right into the testimony the Dead Sea scrolls, whose scriptual texts are from circa 200 BC–which means the next oldest texts are from 1200 years later with the Masoretic text–the 99+% agreement between the DSS and the Masoretic refutes the Muslim claim right then and there
As for the Christian texts, the multiple geographic sources and “streams” of textual transmission absolutley prevented any possible “bottleneck” of central authority (i.e. The Church as we know her) re-writing the NT–VERY unlike the Uthman caliphate’s undeniable “lock” on koranic edition and transmission