How do so many people get into shaky relationships?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DigitalFish_20
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

DigitalFish_20

Guest
Everyday, I constantly hear about relationships and marriages that fall apart in very bad ways. From watching the news, reading other forums, or even overhearing everyday conversations, this topic always seems to come up. I find it disheartening as it I’ve noticed that some people have begun to consider it normal. In my life, I know a very good acquaintance of mine that just got divorced for the second time and is already contemplating a third marriage which I’m sure will not turn out well. Whenever I make an inquiry, all I get is a casual remark of “oh it just did not work out.” :confused:

What puzzles me, from a personal point of view, is why and how do people get into these relationships that fall apart so often? Is there some reoccurring theme?
Is out of fear that there won’t be some other?
Is it simply blindness or ignorance to obvious faults?
Is it lack of patience, a desire to rebel, or something else?
Do people just wake up after a few years and feel that this isn’t working?

My apologies if it may seem a bit rude to ask such things, but I’m already well on my way towards an electrical engineering degree and soon it will be the time in my life where I’ll be searching for some special person in my life; however, the news I hear is always so worrying. Does anyone have any insights on this matter that I can take advice from?
 
A lot of the time, we can blame our emotions. The rational part of our mind is suppressed, and, as you say, among other ideas, we can suffer from “blindness or [AND] ignorance to obvious faults”.On both sides!
I can speak from experience - it happened very early last year. Thanks be to God it didnt involve marriage, but i was stupid enough to think that marriage was a very strong possibility. Firmly believed that i could be the proverbial knight in shining armour for this already married, divorced, annulled woman. Felt sorry for her because shed been through a hell of a lot: ruled by the heart only, and not by the head.
**Totally blind! **

Still havent fully recovered......therell probably always be a scar.
 
A lot of the time, we can blame our emotions. The rational part of our mind is suppressed, and, as you say, among other ideas, we can suffer from “blindness or [AND] ignorance to obvious faults”.On both sides!
I can speak from experience - it happened very early last year. Thanks be to God it didnt involve marriage, but i was stupid enough to think that marriage was a very strong possibility. Firmly believed that i could be the proverbial knight in shining armour for this already married, divorced, annulled woman. Felt sorry for her because shed been through a hell of a lot: **ruled by the heart only, and not by the head.****Totally blind! **

Still havent fully recovered......therell probably always be a scar.
To quote one Mr. Willy Wonka:
“Indeed, where is fancy bread? In the heart? Or in the head?” 😛
 
Relationships fall apart (and bad ones get started) for the same reason that all sin exists in the world - human pride and weakness. If God isn’t the center of your life then you’re in trouble. You don’t need to be discouraged though. Two practicing Catholics have a much lower chance of divorce than the average population. That’s why it’s so important to marry someone with the same values.
 
I got into bad or shaky relationships - friendship or otherwise, because I did not like myself. I felt I didn’t deserve to have anyone good etc.

I suppose it can be the same for many people. It might be the idea of the person, part of the attraction is that it is not a safe and predictable relationship. Or it might be that the oerson doesn’t think much of themselves.
 
It’s having sex before you get married. Most of the time, that’s why people form a bond before they truly get to know the other person and discern if that person would make a good spouse. Everyone trashes their treasure which is meant for their spouse, then they get disillusioned when the person’s real traits come out, but the bond was made through sex not agape love.
 
A lot of the time, we can blame our emotions. The rational part of our mind is suppressed, and, as you say, among other ideas, we can suffer from “blindness or [AND] ignorance to obvious faults”.On both sides!
I can speak from experience - it happened very early last year. Thanks be to God it didnt involve marriage, but i was stupid enough to think that marriage was a very strong possibility. Firmly believed that i could be the proverbial knight in shining armour for this already married, divorced, annulled woman. Felt sorry for her because shed been through a hell of a lot: ruled by the heart only, and not by the head.
**Totally blind! **

Still havent fully recovered......therell probably always be a scar.
Read, “10 Stupid Things Men Do to Mess Up Their Lives.”

Stupid Stuff Men Do

Dr. Laura always says, “When you rescue a damsel in distress, you end up with a distressed damsel.”

😉
 
My apologies if it may seem a bit rude to ask such things, but I’m already well on my way towards an electrical engineering degree and soon it will be the time in my life where I’ll be searching for some special person in my life; however, the news I hear is always so worrying. Does anyone have any insights on this matter that I can take advice from?
Well, the problem is that nobody is perfect. No matter who you enter into a relationship with, that person is going to have imperfections. The trick is to recognize beforehand what kind of imperfections you can stand and what you can’t. Unfortunately, some (or all?) people can only figure this out through trial and error. That’s one reason why breakups happen.

Note that this reply addresses unmarried relationships that break up, rather than divorces. One would hope that before getting married, both people have figured out that they can live with the other’s imperfections.
 
Dr. Laura always says, “When you rescue a damsel in distress, you end up with a distressed damsel.”
I know a kindergarten teacher, a nice, sweet, very flawed gentleman, who in the past five or six years has attempted to date-cum-rescue:
  • an aging stripper with a methamphetamine addiction;
  • a former swimsuit model with an addiction to prescription painkillers, who lives in a trailer that’s not hooked up to utilities of any kind and is sitting in her parents’ pit fruit orchard, where it’s regularly sprayed with insecticides and weed killers that give her migraines. But instead of re-locating, she decided to sue her parents;
  • a woman whose ex-husband is in prison for trying to kill her and who continues to question if she did the right thing by testifying against him;
  • a business-to-business sales women who talks to pencils;
  • a one-woman dog rescue group who doesn’t re-home nearly enough of her animals and lives with a couple dozen of her finds; and the coupe de grace
  • a woman who receives advice from her microwave.
The more damaged and unstable a woman, the harder he falls. And he can’t seem to let go until she either gets physically dangerous or she brings law enforcement into their relationship.

Luna
 
It’s having sex before you get married. Most of the time, that’s why people form a bond before they truly get to know the other person and discern if that person would make a good spouse. Everyone trashes their treasure which is meant for their spouse, then they get disillusioned when the person’s real traits come out, but the bond was made through sex not agape love.
This, people not centering their lives on God, sexual revolution, feminism’s effect on couples creating an attitude of competition and an exhausting gender role reversal which makes both unhappy; contraceptive mentality, fear / no trust, media’s appalling example, and marriage not seen as the goal/ something good. Everyone just drifting in half formed relationships, not asking God’s wil, not sure of the purpose of dating, undermining each other and, wondering what happened…
 
It’s having sex before you get married. Most of the time, that’s why people form a bond before they truly get to know the other person and discern if that person would make a good spouse. Everyone trashes their treasure which is meant for their spouse, then they get disillusioned when the person’s real traits come out, but the bond was made through sex not agape love.
You hit the nail on the head. This is so true.
 
Thanks for the replies everyone. Some interesting points were made–especially about getting involved with the wrong woman (weak, flaky, damaged, needy, desperate, stupid, untrustworthy, immature, etc.) and then thinking that your love will save/transform her.

Sounds like individuals need to have a strong grasp over their own lives first before they can even begin to start thinking about intimate relationships.
 
DigitalFish,

I know I got into my relationship for Love, as for my wife I think it was for the security of having someone there to support her emotionally.

But I know for my own marriage it fell apart due to one major factor – dishonesty.

There were several lies prior to us getting married that I did not discover until years later. There were several other deceptions during our marriage; this last one deception which is ending my marriage was a 1.5 year long affair where she left the church to pursue someone else. Where she was telling the other guy that she loved him and wanted him to leave his wife for her and she would leave me for him. We were even in counseling with her explaining that it was me that did not seem interested in saving our marriage.

So the biggest thing I think that destroys marriage is: dishonesty.

Winter
 
I think a lot of people get into shaky relationships because it is the “norm” in the United States during the dating phase for people to try to attract the person they are dating by “hiding” who they really are and trying to pretend to be someone that they are not.

Both the man and the woman will do everything possible to appear beautiful/handsome, intelligent, fascinating, athletic, free of personality flaws, etc.

Here are a few examples.

If a person normally has a bad habit of swearing, they will make a huge effort not to swear during dates. If a naughty word pops out, sometimes they will actually lie and "say, “Oh, I’m so sorry, I never say stuff like that!”

And the other person in the dating relationship actually believes that.

Same with any bad habits or addictions. Most people who binge eat in secret do NOT binge eat when they are out on a date. Most people who have a drinking problem make tremendous efforts to curb their drinking, or if they do drink irresponsibly, they make excuse and say, “I don’t know what came over me–I never drink like that.”

Again, the other person actually believes that!

People who are involved in serious sin certainly don’t commit their sin when they are out on dates. E.g., a man who is into perversion, or is abusive, goes to a lot of trouble to hide these “sins” and instead, presents himself as a kind, polite man who treats women and children with respect.

And the woman believes it.

Or a woman who is a mean-spirited gossip, or who nurses a lot of jealousy or resentment, will act sweet and loving on a date, and take care not to speak badly of anyone so that she will appear kind.

And the man believes it.

And of course there is the physical camouflage. We all know that women take a lot of extra care with makeup, hair, dress, etc. when they are dating, and they do everything they can, even skipping food all day, to look really good on their dates. But men do the same thing–they primp, too, and suck in their stomachs and go outside to pass gas!

And each person in the relationship wants so much to believe that their date always looks this good and never looks puffy or sweaty or smells bad or makes rude noises!

The problem comes when the facade starts to crumble, which it often doesn’t do until the couple is seriously involved with each other, or even married. The camouflage begins to erode, and the person starts acting like their true self. They stop wearing the makeup and the nice outfits. They openly practice whatever bad habits they have been suppressing and/or keeping secret; e.g., binge eating, unhealthy drinking, etc. And worst of all, they stop trying to hide their sins, and commit them openly.

And the other person wonders what the heck happened! They thought that the person they were dating was free of bad habits, and was kind and loving and respectful. They thought the other person’s stomach really IS flat!

How often have you heard someone say that it seems that they are now dating or married to a whole different person! Well, that’s exactly true. The person they were dating wasn’t real, but just a facade hiding the real person.

IMO, the answer to this is a long dating relationship. My husband and I dated for six years before we got married, and my daughter and her husband dated for seven years.

Someone can hide who they are for a few months, or even for a full year, but it’s really really hard to keep up a pretense, or always wear the “good makeup” and outfits, or never commit a sin, for six or seven years!

Now I’m not saying that everyone should date for several years! But I think that a couple should take their time while dating, and that they should try very hard to be “real” with each other. The best way to do this is to do “real” activities; e.g., going to church, fixing meals together instead of going out, getting involved in volunteer work (especially volunteer work that involves working with children, so that you can see how you each deal with kids), doing actual physical labor together that makes you sweat (e.g., yardwork, or planting a garden, or taking care of pets or livestock), spending a lot of time with each other’s families, etc.

These are the kinds of things that married people do! Married people don’t often go on ski weekends, or go to romantic restaurants and stare at each other. Married people do a lot of “work” together, and fix broken things, and figure out ways to have fun when the paycheck is gone. These kinds of activities make it easier to be your real self instead of trying to dress up like a movie star and act charming, intelligent, and witty! Try doing all that while you’re installing a new toilet!
 
Everyday, I constantly hear about relationships and marriages that fall apart in very bad ways. From watching the news, reading other forums, or even overhearing everyday conversations, this topic always seems to come up. I find it disheartening as it I’ve noticed that some people have begun to consider it normal. In my life, I know a very good acquaintance of mine that just got divorced for the second time and is already contemplating a third marriage which I’m sure will not turn out well. Whenever I make an inquiry, all I get is a casual remark of “oh it just did not work out.” :confused:

What puzzles me, from a personal point of view, is why and how do people get into these relationships that fall apart so often? Is there some reoccurring theme?
Is out of fear that there won’t be some other?
Is it simply blindness or ignorance to obvious faults?
Is it lack of patience, a desire to rebel, or something else?
Do people just wake up after a few years and feel that this isn’t working?

My apologies if it may seem a bit rude to ask such things, but I’m already well on my way towards an electrical engineering degree and soon it will be the time in my life where I’ll be searching for some special person in my life; however, the news I hear is always so worrying. Does anyone have any insights on this matter that I can take advice from?
Premarital sex and overreliance on emotions to the exclusion of reason.

Some people have come to expect that they will always be “in love” and they rely on feelings to decide whether to start or continue a relationship. They are never able to get past that stage to the real love phase of a relationship, and it’s quite often because the real love phase is impossible for very rational reasons which were obscured by emotions in the first place.
 
People get into poor relationships as a result of rushing without thinking, or self-esteem problems that make them think they don’t deserve or can’t find anybody better. Some others fall for some kind of Stockholm syndrom analogue by which they become attached to those that treat them badly. Yet others feel the compulsion to change or redeem somebody.
Sex before marriage…Full Stop.
Premarital sex? Bah. I don’t know what people see in it. Starcraft is so much cooler.
 
Dating: sex
Marriages: Failing to grasp that you only get one shot at it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top