How do we forgive Osama Bin Laden?

  • Thread starter Thread starter OneSheep
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well I was wrong about something in another thread so its possible I’m wrong again.
I would be interested to hear from others as to whether a person has to be alive to be forgiven or is it too late once they are dead.
Why not be able to forgive a person who has passed away? I think this is perfectly possible. I forgave Osama Bin Laden when he was alive, and I forgive him now that he is dead.
 
I would be interested to hear from others as to whether a person has to be alive to be forgiven or is it too late once they are dead.
A high school senior in my confirmation class asked today, “is the forgiveness for the person you are forgiving, or to make you feel better?” One of the parents in the room pointed out that the issue is to resolve your own anger and resentment, to make yourself right with God. Couldn’t have said it better myself.

I personally have found it valuable to not only forgive all the people who have ever hurt me, but also to forgive all those who harm people I care about, and “who I care about” includes the Jews caught up in the holocaust, and the Palestinians, both Christian and Muslim, suffering oppression, and many others. I am hopelessly drawn to empathy for underdogs. I forgive politicians on both sides of the aisle, they sure know how to push my buttons. I have also found it extremely valuable to forgive those acts I have committed and forgive parts of myself that I resent. So yes, it has been worthwhile to me to make the painstaking effort to forgive even dead people if I resent them in any way. One guiding factor for me in the process is to soul search for all things I condemn. If I condemn, then forgiveness is in order.

I found that it really is a process with an ending. We only have a finite number of things to forgive. To “clean it all up” is incredibly rewarding.

While I’m posting here, I’d like to say we had a wonderful time celebrating our wedding anniversary today, and I’d like to thank Alan, Robert, and Holly for your contributions and Thistle for making everybody think. Yesterday when I saw the Sunday readings from Sirach and Matthew, I could not help but tear up a little. It is time to forgive, and the people selecting the readings were undoubtedly guided by the Spirit to make the selection they did for September 11 this year. No small miracle in my book.

God bless all of you.
 
I am having a hard time with this one .How can I forgive this man,knowing all he wanted to do is kill as many americans as possible ?All he seemed to have is hate ???I am not the one whom his life will be judged by.
 
I am having a hard time with this one .How can I forgive this man,knowing all he wanted to do is kill as many americans as possible ?All he seemed to have is hate ???I am not the one whom his life will be judged by.
I think you may have answered your own question. You are not the one his life will be judged by. It is not a restriction, but a blessing that Jesus told us not to judge. There is no way to be wrong in your judgment if you don’t judge in the first place. And if you don’t judge in the first place, that’s even better … like forgiveness on steroids.

Yes, OBL did awful things, but look at Saul. Can we forgive him for the atrocities he’s committed? Bin Laden didn’t live long enough (sparing certain conspiracy theories) to repent. If Saul had died before Jesus appeared to him … such as in self defense by the people he tormented … then he would have not had a chance to repent, either.

We are so trained that we not only may, but should judge evildoers, that I think most of us look at Jesus as being kind of a spoilsport. But He really is giving us the key to freedom. If we judge another human being, then we open ourselves up to judgment along the same measure. That even applies to judging ourselves. How many of us want to be responsible for what happens to Bin Laden? Do we wish to tell God what to do? If not, then let’s bask in the glory of it Not Being Our Job, and go on to do our own good without getting our proverbial panties in wad over those we find troublesome.

Alan
 
I lost someone in the twin towers. I am trying to forgive Osama Bin Laden because Jesus asked me to. We are asked to forgive our enemies and pray for those who persecute us. If I hate him, then I am no better than him. There are times that I feel a flood of anger and hatred towards Bin Laden and the hijackers, but I try to give it to God and tell Him that I don’t want to feel this way because I want to live as a Christian. Forgiving Bin Laden doesn’t mean thinking that what he did was ok, it means that I hope that God will show him the same forgiveness I hope that God will show me. This is often very difficult but I must try.

God bless
 
i have nothing against osama, i dont even know the man! 🤷:shrug:plus if you are thinking about 9\11\01 it was the guys driving the planes that did that! how are you going to blame osama? wen we dont realy know what his role in this is? we know only what we are told, plus things are not always ehat they seem!:newidea:
 
I’m not quite sure where forgiveness fits in. Unless OBL has done something personally to you, what is there to forgive?
 
i have nothing against osama, i dont even know the man! 🤷:shrug:plus if you are thinking about 9\11\01 it was the guys driving the planes that did that! how are you going to blame osama? wen we dont realy know what his role in this is? we know only what we are told, plus things are not always ehat they seem!:newidea:
Because he confessed to do it…and his second in command testified in court their involvement…and the testimony of their involvemnet by his own…
abcnews.go.com/WNT/video/osama-bin-laden-911-confession-13506877
:rolleyes: wake up!
 
I lost someone in the twin towers. I am trying to forgive Osama Bin Laden because Jesus asked me to. We are asked to forgive our enemies and pray for those who persecute us. If I hate him, then I am no better than him. There are times that I feel a flood of anger and hatred towards Bin Laden and the hijackers, but I try to give it to God and tell Him that I don’t want to feel this way because I want to live as a Christian. Forgiving Bin Laden doesn’t mean thinking that what he did was ok, it means that I hope that God will show him the same forgiveness I hope that God will show me. This is often very difficult but I must try.

God bless
That is a very excellent outlook on it. I’m very sorry for the loss of your loved one, but like you say if we are to be Christian we are called to forgiveness of even our enemies. Not because they deserve forgiveness, but if we don’t know how to give it then we cannot experience being a true Christian.

Alan
 
Because he confessed to do it…and his second in command testified in court their involvement…and the testimony of their involvemnet by his own…
abcnews.go.com/WNT/video/osama-bin-laden-911-confession-13506877
:rolleyes: wake up!
Thank you for this. It’s creepy that these people think this way, plus it is not just some lone wolf but they have the power and backing of however millions of their followers they have. Once a radio show host read a letter from the mother of one of the hijackers. She was totally glowing with pride for her son, who would surely be amply rewarded by Allah. 😦

Alan
 
40.png
AlanFromWichita:
We don’t forgive others because they deserve it or to do them a favor; we forgive them because we must do it for our own spiritual growth, and to strive to accept the peace Jesus gave us.
This.
Remember that “forgive” does NOT mean saying :nope:“there, there, its OK”; it means that you refuse to “give forth” evil for evil. You let go &:sad_yes: leave him to God, Who is, after all, the Just Judge.
 
I’m not quite sure where forgiveness fits in. Unless OBL has done something personally to you, what is there to forgive?
I wonder about this too. I hope Bin Laden is in Hell. If someone like that can go to Heaven, then salvation is worthless, because then, all my striving to be a good person is in vain; I could go and kill everyone I have a grievance against and still go to Heaven (because I don’t know 6,000 people). Even life in prison will be short compared to an eternity in Heaven…

No, I’m not going to kill anyone, but does anyone else see the absurdity of Bin Laden going to Heaven?

Does this belief in divine justice count as the unforgiveness God won’t forgive me for?
 
I wonder about this too. I hope Bin Laden is in Hell. If someone like that can go to Heaven, then salvation is worthless, because then, all my striving to be a good person is in vain; I could go and kill everyone I have a grievance against and still go to Heaven (because I don’t know 6,000 people). Even life in prison will be short compared to an eternity in Heaven…

No, I’m not going to kill anyone, but does anyone else see the absurdity of Bin Laden going to Heaven?

Does this belief in divine justice count as the unforgiveness God won’t forgive me for?
I am going to quote Julia Mae from a different thread, because I love the way she put it. Here it is:

"Here’s my test: Imagine you have a button that will cause the object or your hatred immense pain as long as you press it. They will know you did it, but no one will ever catch you. Even God will give you a free pass.

On the day you know you would not use it, you’ll know you have forgiven."

I agree with her. If I still want to punish someone, (as opposed to stopping them from continuing to do harm, or perhaps using punishment as a deterrent) then I have not forgiven. So, if I still wanted someone to go to hell as we commonly know it, it would probably mean I haven’t finished working it all out and forgiving.

I have no doubts that God forgives us even if we don’t forgive someone else. HOWEVER (note the emphasis :)) until I forgave everyone, including characters like OBL, all of the bullies who ever picked on me, myself, etc. then I had plenty of doubt about whether I was forgiven or even loved by God. That is what Jesus is referring to when the master does not forgive 77 times, but only once (last Sunday’s Gospel). The torture is the doubt, the not knowing if God forgives us or not. (or probably not) If we do not forgive, we project a God that does not forgive. The question is, how do we forgive? That is the part that takes work.

Incidentally, when I saw the reading from Sirach and the Gospel on September 11 talking about forgiving our enemies, I teared up. No accident, just the Spirit.

Wherever OBL is, he is realizing now that he was not attacking the “great satan”; he attacked real people, just like himself, and all people are of great value. I have no doubt that the impact of that realization would be hell.
 
I lost someone in the twin towers. I am trying to forgive Osama Bin Laden because Jesus asked me to. We are asked to forgive our enemies and pray for those who persecute us. If I hate him, then I am no better than him. There are times that I feel a flood of anger and hatred towards Bin Laden and the hijackers, but I try to give it to God and tell Him that I don’t want to feel this way because I want to live as a Christian. Forgiving Bin Laden doesn’t mean thinking that what he did was ok, it means that I hope that God will show him the same forgiveness I hope that God will show me. This is often very difficult but I must try.

God bless
I appreciate your owning up to your hatred. To me, denial has such nasty consequences. When I deny that I hate, I still torment, but I don’t know why. The way I look at it now is “hey, God gave us the capacity to hate, go ahead.” Our capacity to hate is part of our innate self-protection mechanism, and it “works”. Well, it “worked” for our species when we didn’t have the ability to kill everyone on the planet. One hard part for me is realizing that I hate, and making the jump to knowing that, therefore, it is time to forgive. I have long given up on “not judging”. I judge automatically. The best I can do is realize I have judged, then start the forgiveness process I shared when I started this thread. A fellow Confirmation teacher I met a few weeks ago lost his 4 year old son to a drunk driver last year. He has forgiven the driver. I can’t imagine dealing with that kind of grief and desire for revenge.

One thing that has been somewhat helpful is to let myself go ahead and hate, to say that someone like OBL is evil incarnate, and let myself want to kill him. Then, I try to understand that OBL felt the same way towards his victims. But why? We ask. That is when it is time to investigate. And can we forgive our own capacity to hate?
I’m not quite sure where forgiveness fits in. Unless OBL has done something personally to you, what is there to forgive?
You always bring up such great points! To me, because you care about those that died in the towers, those people are part of you. We take “personally” what happens to our own children, because we care about them. I needed to forgive Hitler and his bunch because I cared about all those who were his victims. I needed to forgive Ariel Sharon because I cared about the well-being of the Palestinians and Lebanese he attacked.

My resentment is my resentment. I need to forgive the president of my country, after I have judged him a #@%, because the resulting peace within is great. Doesn’t stop me from doing what I can to stop him from ruining our country, though (in a peaceful way, of course).

Oops. I hope I didn’t start a rash of new stuff with those last paragraphs. This thread is still about how to forgive Osama.
 
This.
Remember that “forgive” does NOT mean saying :nope:“there, there, its OK”; it means that you refuse to “give forth” evil for evil. You let go &:sad_yes: leave him to God, Who is, after all, the Just Judge.
👍
I wonder about this too. I hope Bin Laden is in Hell. If someone like that can go to Heaven, then salvation is worthless, because then, all my striving to be a good person is in vain; I could go and kill everyone I have a grievance against and still go to Heaven (because I don’t know 6,000 people). Even life in prison will be short compared to an eternity in Heaven…

No, I’m not going to kill anyone, but does anyone else see the absurdity of Bin Laden going to Heaven?

Does this belief in divine justice count as the unforgiveness God won’t forgive me for?
Actually, all your striving to be a good person is in vain if you have not love, and if you cannot forgive then you do not have love.

Most of us have heard this scripture at countless weddings, even non-Catholic weddings in TV and movies, but only infrequently do I encounter anybody who actually seems to have internalized it. Or even believes it for that matter:

1 Cor 13
1 If I speak in human and angelic tongues but do not have love, I am a resounding gong or a clashing cymbal.
2 And if I have the gift of prophecy and comprehend all mysteries and all knowledge; if I have all faith so as to move mountains but do not have love, I am nothing.
3 If I give away everything I own, and if I hand my body over so that I may boast but do not have love, I gain nothing.
4 Love is patient, love is kind. It is not jealous, [love] is not pompous, it is not inflated,
5 it is not rude, it does not seek its own interests, it is not quick-tempered, it does not brood over injury,
6 it does not rejoice over wrongdoing but rejoices with the truth.
7 It bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things.
8 Love never fails. If there are prophecies, they will be brought to nothing; if tongues, they will cease; if knowledge, it will be brought to nothing.

Isn’t the bombing of the twin towers included in the set of all things?

Alan
 
My resentment is my resentment. I need to forgive the president of my country, after I have judged him a #@%, because the resulting peace within is great. Doesn’t stop me from doing what I can to stop him from ruining our country, though (in a peaceful way, of course).

Oops. I hope I didn’t start a rash of new stuff with those last paragraphs. This thread is still about how to forgive Osama.
You also make some great points. I think the Obama/Osama analogy is relevant because our president’s actions do directly affect many of us and our loved ones. 👍

Alan
 
Actually, all your striving to be a good person is in vain if you have not love, and if you cannot forgive then you do not have love.
If OBL had love, he would not have done what he did. So, by your logic, he must be in Hell. I hope this is so, not because I’m angry at him as much as because I hope there’s justice. What good does it do to believe in Hell if we believe there’s no one there but Satan? What you’re basically saying is that unless we hope Hell is empty (i.e. unless we hope God is a moral relativist), we’ll end up there ourselves. This smacks of the same kind of intolerance of intolerance that infests our culture, and frankly, it’s disgusting.

If God forgave OBL, He’ll forgive me for hoping OBL is in Hell. If not, then I’m right to hope OBL is in Hell.
 
If OBL had love, he would not have done what he did. So, by your logic, he must be in Hell. I hope this is so, not because I’m angry at him as much as because I hope there’s justice.
I didn’t intend to say that one without love goes to hell. While that may be true, it was not my intent to make that point. My point was that if you harbor anger and resentment and unforgiveness, that prevents you from having love – or at least interferes with its effects.

Is OBL in hell? I don’t know. Maybe God will tell me on judgment day, maybe not. Until then it is only speculation and frankly, it’s not for me to know.

As far as justice, what do we know about divine justice? OBL didn’t do anything St. Paul didn’t do while he was still Saul, and look where he is. It simply doesn’t pay to assume things, and to ask God for justice but then hope OBL is in hell or pray that he goes there, is to ask God to conform His justice to our own wishes. Why not sit back and enjoy the ride that is the wonderful life God gave us, and let Him do His job without our coaching or evaluation?
What good does it do to believe in Hell if we believe there’s no one there but Satan?
Since you asked, and since I don’t know the mind of God, I will have to settle for giving my personal opinion. Frankly, I don’t know what good it does to believe in hell, once a person is focused on the good things of life, and ultimately becomes “born again” like Jesus said we should. Once we are born of the spirit, we don’t have to worry about hell because we don’t need threats to actively seek to do the will of God. It might be useful to threaten baby Christians with hell, but once they move to the mature phase of their spiritual life, we can feed them solid food.

If you think I’m making all this “solid food” stuff up, try these on for size:

1 Cor 3
1 Brothers, I could not talk to you as spiritual people, but as fleshly people, as infants in Christ.
2 I fed you milk, not solid food, because you were unable to take it. Indeed, you are still not able, even now,
3 for you are still of the flesh. While there is jealousy and rivalry among you, are you not of the flesh, and behaving in an ordinary human way?

Hebrews 5
11 About this we have much to say, and it is difficult to explain, for you have become sluggish in hearing.
12 Although you should be teachers by this time, you need to have someone teach you again the basic elements of the utterances of God. You need milk, [and] not solid food.
13 Everyone who lives on milk lacks experience of the word of righteousness, for he is a child.
14 But solid food is for the mature, for those whose faculties are trained by practice to discern good and evil.
What you’re basically saying is that unless we hope Hell is empty (i.e. unless we hope God is a moral relativist), we’ll end up there ourselves. This smacks of the same kind of intolerance of intolerance that infests our culture, and frankly, it’s disgusting.
That makes no sense to me, so if you got that from what I said than a clarification is in order. :o

As far as hoping hell is empty as being equivalent to God being a moral relativist, then again I’m not in the business of second-guessing God’s decisions about another human being’s salvation. It would be like saying, “God, I know you are a Good God, and if you don’t punish and torment my wayward brother for the rest of eternity then I know you’re a phony.” Sorry but that doesn’t wash.
If God forgave OBL, He’ll forgive me for hoping OBL is in Hell. If not, then I’m right to hope OBL is in Hell.
I can agree with this sentiment entirely. I don’t know objectively if He WILL forgive you and me, but we can certainly HOPE He does, and I believe He can and will. But if He can create the universe, I suspect it is within His power to forgive even OBL. 😉

Looking at it another way, if I’m wrong and misleading others then I hope God can forgive me for I know not what I do. If God can forgive me for that, then He can probably forgive OBL on the same basis, “Father forgive them for they know not what they do.”

Why is that such a big deal? Because of this:

Mark 9:42
Whoever causes one of these little ones who believe [in me] to sin, it would be better for him if a great millstone were put around his neck and he were thrown into the sea.

When I go around writing these things and casting out my own personal opinions mixed with Gospel truth, I always keep this in mind. :sad_yes:

So yes, if I’m lying to you and you believe me, I’m in deep doo-doo. So I have reason to be careful, and I’m always ready to hear honest protests and contrary opinions. 👍

You come across as being a very nice person, my friend. But on the issue of judging or forgiving OBL, I invite you to try looking at it as a privilege, if not an obligation, to stand back and let God handle His business without trying to guess the outcome, and feel the freedom and peace that comes in doing so. Let Him do His job, and we can then see more clearly to do our own. Taste and see the goodness of the Lord. :getholy:

Alan
 
I guess all that makes sense. I can forgive most people, but there are a few in my life whom I would like to see burn for eternity. I know I’m supposed to feel differently, but I can’t.

As for Hell in general, I hope some crimes are punishable by eternal damnation. If not, everyone goes to Heaven, and doesn’t that make salvation meaningless?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top