How do YOU know that God exists?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bohm_Bawerk
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Please don’t just say “faith” :o. There is a reason behind everything. Why do you personally believe that God, or a god, exists?

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
youtube.com/watch?v=qP2rLgrBtTI Fr. Robert Barron on “Why do we believe in God?”

He talks mainly of the Argument of desire, Argument from intelligibility and Argument of Contingency
 
Eugen, do you just go around planting these questions here and there like land mines?..anyway - be that as it may.

You must realize that to an overwhelming amount of people, proof of God’s existence is a non-issue.

Despite the troubles and pitfalls in my life, I have never been tempted to believe that God doesn’t exist. It’s rediculous.

If you were once a catholic and now you’re an atheist then you wouldn’t understand that I see God’s existence in everything I see and in everyone I meet. Even in you.

You can’t prove that God doesn’t exist and no one that believes in God would give you a second to try.
Yet I could sing the praises of God’s existence in the things He’s created but it would be inconsequential to you.

How sad.
That is great that the Lord has blessed you with great faith! However, it is not fair to say that just because someone, even someone very pious, questions the existence of God they are not good Christians. Blessed Teresa of Calcutta struggled with many doubts - including the existence of God. The Lord gave her these challenges so that she could offer them up for the salvation of souls. One cannot help it if they struggle with doubts, but they still pursue a relationship with God. It makes it even more beautiful because it shows the commitment the person has to the Lord.
God bless.
 
I prove the existence of God everytime when an angry Atheist bug me about the bads that had been done by the Church in the past. I ask him back: “What is your moral authority to say what we did were bad. In fact how do you know they are bad at all?”
 
Please don’t just say “faith” :o. There is a reason behind everything. Why do you personally believe that God, or a god, exists?

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
I don’t believe that cells can just group-up on their own to the extent that a human being is just the result of random cell combinations… Were just too complex…

There must be a designer.
 
I know God exists because of three main miracles in my life. I am not going to go into detail just try to make this short because otherwise it would be like 3 pages long to try to explain.
  1. I was dicerning the religious life and became very confused about my vocation. I was terribly afraid of making the wrong decision. I felt pulled towards marriage but also towards the consecrated life. I decided to pray a novena to Saint Therese of lisieux for her intercession a nine day novena for a rose if I was suppose to be married and there was a man out there who would lead me closer to God. I recieved a rose from my best friend the day after Saint Therese feast day. That is the person I am married to now, and believe me when he gave me the rose, I did not believe he was the one I was meant to be with, I for over two years after that only viewed him as a friend. It was entirely God that brought us together.
  2. was a very complicated twin pregnancy where I was told there was “No hope” and expect things to go from bad to worse, and that my twins wouldn’t survive. I prayed the divine mercy chaplet everyday and asked for Saint Gerards intercession and and my twins were born alive and healthy despite what the medical doctors believed.
  3. I had a VBAC (vaginal birth after ceserean) about a year and a half after the birth of my twins. I was told to expect a 20-24 hour labor for a first time vaginal birth and to expecting pushing would be at least 3 hours. This is the NORM for almost all women. I had a home birth with no epidural and prayed for Saint Gerards intercession once again asking him to pray that i may be spared the excessive pains of childbearing. I was in labor for only 6 hours and pushed for only 45 minutes!
There are many other instances of miracles in my life, but these are the biggest. Some of the others are things like being preserved from danger in my youth when I abused drugs/alcohol.

A friend of mine who had been away from the church for many years asked me if she could attend mass with me. I of course said yes. Before mass we went to the mall. She wanted to show me this perfume she liked so much called “coco” by Chanel. A few hours later we went to mass, the priest after reading the gospel began talking about his mother who had passed away and she use to always wear a perfume called “coco chanel” and the smell reminded him of her whenever he smelled it at the mall. My friend and myself faces quickly turned to each other in disbelief of the coincidence. I told her make no mistake that was entirely for you, God is letting you know, he is thankful you are here. 👍
 
Hello My (name removed by moderator)ut is this. Yes the complexity argument. I have an agnostic working for us right now. I don’t mind talking to athiests nor skeptics as I am firm in my faith. My hobby is well one of them is restoring old city buses. I work on them and the engines and air systems. So on so forth. You look at the engine how complex it is and how it runs the cylinder liners the pistons the crankshaft fuel pump injectors and there are hundreds of parts and the whole unit was engineered and put into production and fruitition. Then that is all done, Then we walk over to the transmission with it’s hundreds of parts now the frame the airbrakes suspension that is air. so on so forth. then the gauges the numbers on the guages. Oh forgot the electrical system I mean systems. 110 v 12V and the 24 Volt. system. what else oh tires and I can go on, but no athiest I ever met would agree that that bus could just come up from ooze and just exist. But what about a 747 400 airliner MUCH more complex of a machine. Even more so the athiest will agree that it had to be engineered and manufactured to exist. The next is a cruise ship even MORE complex and then the human body ever so more complex yet atheists will drop off and think that the human body was just by accident. The point is that the world has revolved around the sun for 5 billion years in perfect timing and the tilt of the axis is perfect for seasons and the sun is amazing and beautifully mastered in construction… Our laws in science is all God’s . It is a perhaps a very scarey thing to accept and to look at as God is so awesome he scares me half to death. That same God that same mastermind that made the sun that will burn up the earth like a fly on a bug zapper LOVES us so much he is so intimate that he is IN us that he wants to have us EAT him rip his flesh and eat him as he told his followers (Eucharist) that he humbled himself to be born a human die for us and save us, My God you are so AWESOME!!! that I can’t wrap my arms around you as to how humble you are to save us yet at the same time you made the universe. My friend you have the truth you were Catholic the Catholic church is also the biggest beacon telling me all this is true. Look toward the Holy Catholic Church as your rock and beacon to see that all is true and that he is the real lord and King!!! and that all this is true. Trust that you are not by accident or came from monkeys!!! you came from God and is reserved for God and God alone. Love him and WANT!!! him want him to hold you to be with him for ever. That makes me have hope and I DESIRE HIM!!! God I want you and I want you now!!!
 
Please don’t just say “faith” :o. There is a reason behind everything. Why do you personally believe that God, or a god, exists?

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
the simplest answer is that I know Him 🙂 thinking that He doesn’t exist is just like thinking that my best friend, or my family, doesn’t exist. It didn’t always feel obvious like that - I struggled with doubt because I used to be an agnostic - but I believe now. Also there is much evidence out there for God (creation, our own desire for God, miracles, etc).

I find it difficult to read about someone like St Padre Pio and not believe in God 🙂
padrepiodevotions.org/

God bless
 
This is how I know that God exists.

I was about 10 and it was a Sunday morning and we were getting ready for mass. My 19 year old brother had a single statue of Jesus on his dresser surrounded by beer bottles, beer mugs, etc. On this one Sunday morning, the light shined through a crack in his curtains right on the statue of Jesus and nothing else. This was Easter Sunday morning.

For a long time, I kept my radio on scan. It would just go from one station to another and I would stop it when I heard a song I liked. Well one day while I was driving and after I had just resisted a particular temptation to sin, I said out loud, “God I hope you are happy” Right then, on the radio (keep in mind, it was on scan) the line from the Chicago song (Make me Smile), “I’m so happy, when you’re near me”

It had been years since I had been to the sacrament of reconcilliation. I was very nervous and worried and anxious about it. I was dreading going to reconcilliation. Right as the person before me was leaving, the choir started singing “Be not afraid”

I chose not to take these a mere coincidences. I am willing to bet, if you open your mind and look for them similar things will appear in your life.
wow that is awesome 🙂

I have some similar stories too…

I was praying the St Therese novena and I did not yet believe that the Saints could pray for us. I was just trying it out. I got up in the morning, knelt by my prayer table and said the novena… then I looked up and saw a whole vase of roses on the table! I did not see it before. My mom put them there but just because she “felt like it” 🙂

later on, I was praying the novena in the car and finished just as I got to the dentist office for a check up. I went into the office, sat down, and right beside me was a Kleenex box with roses drawn on it, and it said “la petite rose”. Well St Therese was called the “little flower”, and she was French, and she is associated with roses… and “la petite rose” means “a little rose” in French 🙂

yet another time, 🙂 I was at church and saying this novena, and RIGHT when I finished, a little girl walked right in front of me, and she was wearing a long dress with a huge rose print on it.

One morning I woke up and I was very upset about something… then I turned around and saw the sun shining right on my Divine Mercy image on the wall. It wasn’t shining in anything else, or on the wall. (it was coming through the space between the wall and the curtain on another side of the room)

After Christmas eve Mass, my mom and I were in the car and we were going through the different radio stations looking for Christmas music… however they were all playing secular music. I said, that is so sad that no one is playing Christmas music on Christmas eve. Right then, I came across Celine Dion’s “O Holy Night”… and RIGHT at that moment, both my mom and I smelled incense VERY strongly in the car… just for a few moments… in front of us. And I kind of felt smoke there too I think. The interesting thing is that during the Mass, we were sitting way at the back and the incense didn’t really reach us… and there was definitely none in the car… and we had already been driving for a while and far from the church and none of the windows were open 🙂
 
I refuse to believe that everything mankind is and was is nothing more than mere accident. To insist on such a view will only give the psychopathic a reason to bring humanity to extinction and the universe to oblivion.
 
I refuse to believe that everything mankind is and was is nothing more than mere accident. To insist on such a view will only give the psychopathic a reason to bring humanity to extinction and the universe to oblivion.
It’s intriguing that that you are theist. I have read some of your posts and they are very interesting…but they have this sort of “nihilistic” tone to it. Guess theists come in different types, don’t they 😉 ?

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
It’s intriguing that that you are theist. I have read some of your posts and they are very interesting…but they have this sort of “nihilistic” tone to it. Guess theists come in different types, don’t they 😉 ?

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
Nihilistic? I can’t say really. 😛 All I simply believe is that some things have more meaning to them than others. Looking at humanity with its different cultures, religions, and how we all cope with the ups and downs of Life, makes the atheist fantasy of mankind having no purpose for existence seem as ludicrous as the religious ideas that they mock. It trivializes moral triumph and renders human misery meaningless.

You can say I am also arguing from the Complexity Argument but instead of science, I look to humanity and human nature for my examples. It just doesn’t make sense to say that all this diversity in mankind can be reduced to a mere accident.

In fact, I find the ‘accident’ argument perpetuated by the likes of Dawkins just downright cowardly. It’s nothing more than a nice big cop out because atheists like him are afraid of the implications that finding meaning in existence entails.
 
That is great that the Lord has blessed you with great faith! However, it is not fair to say that just because someone, even someone very pious, questions the existence of God they are not good Christians. Blessed Teresa of Calcutta struggled with many doubts - including the existence of God. The Lord gave her these challenges so that she could offer them up for the salvation of souls. One cannot help it if they struggle with doubts, but they still pursue a relationship with God. It makes it even more beautiful because it shows the commitment the person has to the Lord.
God bless.
I don’t know where you got “goodness and non-goodness” from my thread. However, I’m having a peaceful morning and I want to keep it that way.

Thank you.
 
Please don’t just say “faith” :o. There is a reason behind everything. Why do you personally believe that God, or a god, exists?

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
Personal experience.

I became a Christian in late 1982, although I’d had Sunday School training as a kid, but drifted away from the (Presbyterian) church, and became atheist by the time I was about 15.

But about a year later at Christmas 1983, I was at a Scripture Union “Beach Mission” at a place called Forest Glen Caravan Park, just south of Nambour in Queensland. Actually it wasn’t at the beach, but a few kilometres inland from the Sunshine Coast.

I wasn’t feeling very convinced of my new found faith at the time. I’d just gone through a divorce, finance was not the best, I’d been chewed out by the boss at work not long before going on the “mission”, struggling with self acceptance and suffering depression (which had been the case for some years).

Now it was the custom for the mission leaders to have a Bible study at about 3pm each afternoon under the marquis (large tent). I remember sitting there, feeling pretty cynical, and out of my depth as the whole thing was completely new to me, and thinking “How do you know this is all true, and that it isn’t just some psychological prop?”

In that frame of mind I was sitting there, a bit dozy as it was quite warm and humid (summer in the sub-tropics), when the team leader read from the Bible, from Kings or Samuel (I forget which) when he said the eaact words, “A man after my own heart…”

He was talking about David of course. But precisely as he said the words, I copped my first “double whammy”. Something like a breath coursed through me in waves from head to foot, very strong and pronounced, and I woke up from my reverie with a jolt. Anyone looking at me would have seen my eyes go wide open.

I remember looking around and seeing what the others were making of this, but they weren’t taking the slightest bit of notice, for the simple reason it hadn’t happened to them.
Personally I was so startled that I nearly fell off the chair.

I spoke later to my pastor, and his opinion was that God was encouraging me. He said God knew I’d been through a tough time and needed encouragement. But that spiritual event also cemented my realisation that it wasn’t a “psychological prop”, and that there was a real spiritual world out there. No matter how negative things get (and they have done at times), I simply cannot go back to my old world view that God doesn’t exist. I’d only be kidding myself.

I had two more “double whammies” over the next year or two, both times used to highlight the words the pastor was speaking (one time referring to St. Paul, the other referring to CS Lewis), and it hasn’t happened since. But I’ve had so many other experiences since then, including some that were very obviously demonic eg. a heavy grip on my throat and the bed shaking, during the daytime too on a couple of occasions, so it soon became obvious that the devil also existed.

I also remember driving down to the church and taking liberties with a “pally” attitude to God. Suddenly this feeling of intense anger seemed to settle down on me, and I literally felt as though I was going to disintegrate. I had to pull over into a side street, until the sense of anger abated. I had been intending to go to the gym we had under the church, but I was too shaken to continue and turned around and went back home.

So it hasn’t all been beer and skittles.

My Catholic psychiatrist, when I discussed the Glen Retreat experience wtih him, said, "Oh, you mean a ‘double whammy’?’ It’s really his term, and he said that because he’s experienced it too. Something about running or walking around an oval at the time. I don’t know the full context in his case. It’s handy when you’ve got a psychiatrist who can relate to the spiritual as well as to the psychological.

Now I’ve often written my father appeared the night he died, and that was nearly 5 years before the Forest Glen experience, in January 1979. But I was an atheist when he died, and I did my best to ignore and forget the incident. Hence when I was at Forest Glen, I didn’t rake into account the dead giveaway (if you’ll pardon the term) when my newly deceased father appeared in my room the night he died.

How do I know God exists? Personal experience.

We’re all going to have a “personal experience” of God one day. The trouble is a great many people aren’t prepared for it. The day they die, they’re going to face something it never even entered their heads to conceive.
 
My primary reason is the argument from morality. Aquinas’s arguments are also good. I don’t find the argument from complexity very impressive though, so I try to stay away from it in a logical sense – but it can be convincing on an emotional level, and that’s valuable as well.

the atheistic argument of the problem of evil in the world actually does more to provide evidence for God’s existence than for his non-existence, and of all the atheist arguments it is probably the best one, but is still unconvincing.
 
My primary reason is the argument from morality. Aquinas’s arguments are also good. I don’t find the argument from complexity very impressive though, so I try to stay away from it in a logical sense – but it can be convincing on an emotional level, and that’s valuable as well.

the atheistic argument of the problem of evil in the world actually does more to provide evidence for God’s existence than for his non-existence, and of all the atheist arguments it is probably the best one, but is still unconvincing.
Would that be Kant’s argument from morality…about the “summum bonum”?

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
Would that be Kant’s argument from morality…about the “summum bonum”?

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
I’m unfamiliar with this particular argument of Kant’s; I was thinking more along the lines of “right and wrong exist”, thus morality. It’s in ways similar to arguments 4 and 5 of Aquinas’s.
 
The Designer Argument is another word for the Teleological Argument…that life seems so complex and ordered that it would be impossible for it to have happened spontaneously. I will *never *insult someone who posts on my thread respectfully!

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
🙂
 
Nice personal experience stories everybody. 👍

I always second guess those, lol. I have a hard time believing them. So instead when I’m down, I start reading science books. It’s hard to believe there’s not a God than. 🙂
 
I have several reasons for believing in God, but they’ve been said already in this thread and I’ll try to be more original.

When I’m struggling with doubt, I think of myself on my proverbial deathbed. If I’m an atheist and atheism is correct, I would utterly cease to exist- my consciousness and whole being would be doomed to oblivion. If I’m an atheist and Catholicism is correct, then I would be suffering in hell forever.

If I’m Catholic and atheism is correct, I will have lived a good, fulfilling life and be subjected to the same fate as the atheist. If I’m Catholic and Catholicism is correct, well you know how it goes…

This is basically Pascal’s wager argument, of course. If any religion is true, Catholicism is it, and if atheism is true, then what’s in it for me? A life of self-indulgence and “freedom”? As Jesus said, “What does it profit a man to gain the whole world and forfeit his life?” The Christian life is more fulfilling and satisfying than anything the world can offer. I won’t be on my deathbed regretting believing in Jesus!
 
I don’t have any intellectual arguments, and I’ve never read any more than a few things from Aquinas. I’m rather “earthy”. To me, it is just plain illogical that something could come from nothing. It is not possible for nothing to generate something. There has to be a source.

Now as to why I am a Catholic Christian–well that is a whole other story. But it begins with the above. And when doubts occur, as they sometimes do, I refer myself to the original premise, and that resolves the doubts. It’s rather simple, I know, but it doesn’t have to be any more complex than that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top