How does a polyamorous relationship between four people work?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bubba_Switzler
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Bubba_Switzler

Guest
Charlie is talking excitedly about a first date she went on the night before.
Next to her on the sofa is her husband of six years, Tom. And on the other side of him is Sarah, who’s been in a relationship with Tom for the last five years. Sarah’s fiance, Chris, is in the kitchen making a cup of tea.
The two women are also in a full-blown relationship, while the two men are just good friends. Together, they make a polyamorous family and share a house in Sheffield.
“We’re planning to grow old together,” says Charlie.
bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-23726120

Who are we to judge?
 
Not quite sure what you are asking, but:

How does it work? Probably not as well nor as easy as you think it does.

Who are we to judge? In terms of judging people, we are no one, as only God judges souls.

Who are we to judge? In terms of actions, we are Catholics with a right formed conscience and clear teaching from God as to right and wrong.

Did I answer your question?
 
Do all four intend to marry each other?
I think the point of the article is to normalize polyamory in anticipation of polygamy. There have been others previously along the same lines. This is the first step juding from the experience of “homosexual marriage”.

Is it too soon for us to say “I told you so?”
 
I believe the unstated premise must first be proven,

that it does, in fact, “work”. 😉
 
I think the point of the article is to normalize polyamory in anticipation of polygamy. There have been others previously along the same lines. This is the first step juding from the experience of “homosexual marriage”.

Is it too soon for us to say “I told you so?”
NO question about it. It’s a logical conclusion.
 
Okay let me see if I’m reading this right. The two women are bisexual and sleeping together. In addition each of them are married to one guy while each is engaged or dating other men? In other words the women each have 3 relationships concurrently while at least their “shared husband” has at minimum two relationships. Talk about a mess. :juggle:

No way I could figure that can work. Heck I have a hard enough time making a relationship with one women work and I’ve been married to her for 19 years. I guess I never learned how to share enough as a preschooler because sharing or being shared just turns my stomach. That’s not a judgement so much as a violent visceral reaction. Bleck.
 
How does it work? It usually doesn’t. At some point, there is usually some drama and the poly “family” break up.

Who are we to judge? I don’t. None of my business. That’s between them and God.

Is this article and other like it being put out there, as someone mentioned, a step toward legalizing polygamy? I hope so. I support polygamy for those who hold it as traditional part of their religious belief system. Just as I don’t want anyone making a law saying I cannot freely practice facets of my faith, I don’t want to be part of restricting someone else from practicing their faith.

And, yeah, I agree with someone above me. I have a hard enough time making a two person marriage work. I shudder to think of the drama a 3rd or 4th person would add.
 
Yes. There are many more divorces now than before no fault.
While there are always individual exceptions, statistically the results of no-fault divorce have been devastating to children. Higher rates of violence, substance abuse, sexual abuse, physical abuse, emotional abuse, suicide, depression etc. etc. to children from single parent households.

Again, there are exceptions. My father was the finest man I have ever known, raised by a single mother during the depression. But in general, I wouldn’t say no-fault divorce is working overall.

I think the polyamorous relationship in going to be fraught with difficulties based on human nature. Particularly as they produce children and relationships break up.
 
I have Friends and family who are in “Poly” relationships. one couple is “married” and in a “open” relationship, that is open to both casual romances and the possibility of long term stable additions.
Another couple is recently engaged.

From a Christian perspective I would point out that such a “Marriage” is a sham. it fails to meet a basic prerequisite of marriage: To have and to hold, forsaking all others, till death do us part.

however many other faiths would disagree on that, and would permit polygamy.

I would propose that polygamy is significantly less different than a Christian view of Marriage, than the pretence of “Gay Marriage” - which is no marriage at all.

From a legal point of view, however, I would propose that either the State should clearly define Marriage, which needs to be defined in a way that recognises it’s importance as the foundation of family units which are the fundamental building block of society… or get out of the business of recognising personal relationships at all.

The perverse situation we have at the moment is that one loud special interest group has demanded the privilege of having everyone pretend that their romantic relationships are the same thing as traditional marriage (for which romance is not an actual requirement!!!), yet excluding any other special interest groups, and often denying that their change is likely to be the first in a long line of attempts to give recognition and privileges to all kinds of perversions and special groups.
 
I think the point of the article is to normalize polyamory in anticipation of polygamy. There have been others previously along the same lines. This is the first step juding from the experience of “homosexual marriage”.

Is it too soon for us to say “I told you so?”
We can say it, but if people’s ears are closed there is no one to hear it.

Polygamous “marriage” can be justified using the exact same arguments as “homosexual marriage” used.
 
Polyamorous relationship = Man, wife, and his 2 girlfriends. Happens all the time. The wife just doesn’t know about it.
 
The article tells us how well this works.
“It was a light bulb moment for me,” she says. 'I had been scared of commitment because I had never met anyone I felt I could fall completely and exclusively in love with. The idea of this not being a monogamous relationship allowed me to fall as deeply in love with Tom as I wanted to without fear that I would break his heart by falling in love with somebody else as well."
So, they can claim to be married, but not actually commit to a real marriage.

A sham.

I find it ironic these people claim that lying is their form of cheating on another when the entirety is a lie.
 
We can say it, but if people’s ears are closed there is no one to hear it.

Polygamous “marriage” can be justified using the exact same arguments as “homosexual marriage” used.
Yep. Of course, during the whole debate over homosexual marriage, those in favor always pooh-pooh any mention of polyamorous relationships. It’s not the same, they say. Marriage is between two people, they say. Hypocrites, I say.
 
Yep. Of course, during the whole debate over homosexual marriage, those in favor always pooh-pooh any mention of polyamorous relationships. It’s not the same, they say. Marriage is between two people, they say. Hypocrites, I say.
I’m not a supporter of same sex marriage, but I don’t think being gay necessarily means one is a supporter of polyamory .
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top