A
Anna_Scott
Guest
Vatican II a disaster. . . . .LUMEN GENTIUM came out of Vatican II. Progress Gurney?. . . .And Vatican II was quite a disaster. Whatever intentions were there at the time materialized into a mess.
Anna
Vatican II a disaster. . . . .LUMEN GENTIUM came out of Vatican II. Progress Gurney?. . . .And Vatican II was quite a disaster. Whatever intentions were there at the time materialized into a mess.
not progress, more like heresyVatican II a disaster. . . . .LUMEN GENTIUM came out of Vatican II. Progress Gurney?
Anna
May God send us more such heresy, and save us from those who think their own prejudices are orthodoxy.not progress, more like heresy
None of these have ever said that Muslims worship a false god, as far as I know. This has been debated over and over. Mickey produced a passage from St. John of Damascusābut this passage does not say that Muslims worship a false god. It says that Islam is a heresy, which is quite different.More like loyalty the church and the catholic faith, you should consider partaking in it and stop letting liberal winds keep you from sound doctrine. Many Popes, saints, councils, and catechisms have denounced Islam. Where they wrong too? Should we chuck our history and the gospel of Christ for the sake correct of being politically correct?
Vatican II a disaster. . . . .LUMEN GENTIUM came out of Vatican II. Progress Gurney?
Anna
Califman831,not progress, more like heresy
But the plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator. In the first place amongst these there are the Mohammedans
We can only be saved in the name of Christ, not is some false gospel being spread by an Antichrist name mo-hammed.
Califman831,
My comment to Gurney was actually an āinsideā joke between two friends about ***his ***progress in returning to Catholicism. Weāve both had long discussions, on the forums, about the requirements of LUMEN GENTIUM in regards to Papal infallibility. LUMEN GENTIUM came out of Vatican II, and I was just āribbingā Gurney a bit; because seeing Vatican II as a ādisasterā is one way of dealing with the demands of LUMEN GENTIUM to submit religious mind and will to the Roman Pontiff, even when he is not speaking Ex Cathedra.
So, I wasnāt commenting on āprogressā in terms of Vatican II. Andāeven though I was ribbing Gurney a bit; as his friend, I am very happy he has returned to the Catholic Church and found some peace in his own journey.
Anna
I am 46 and still listen. Though not as loud now. How is your head banging? The youth group did it fairly poorly. I showed them how to do it properlyā¦though my hair is very shortā¦left over from the Marines and thin. My mojo increased greatly as I head banged.Ah, Mark you take me back to my youth group days. Those were some great times. By the way Red is a pretty good band too. Iām 30 and still listen to that kind of stuff. I always have said I will be suffering from Alzheimers in a nursing home with that stuff blaring out of my room.
Conservative more evangelical minded Anglicans would seem to fit right in, but then the more Catholic aspects of our faith would really cause some good conversations. I beat some people wondered what a priest was doing there. I think its cool that you went in your clericals. Thats too funny.
Let us not forget Ozzie and no not the guy with Harriet!But what Father Mark isnāt telling you is how much he was a fan of Iron Maiden, Judas Priest, and metal! He needs to tell the story about driving with a priest and the metal came on in the car. That is a classic!![]()
Gurney,Hi Anna,
Of course I know youāre joking. Weāve been friends long enough!! And youāve come to know me like an open book. Of course LG (not the cellphone company!) still troubles me indeed. And another adept poster here made comments about CCC841 being horrible doctrine and I heartily concur on that as well. Iām living in contradiction and right now just trying my best to make sense of it all.
The one appealing thing for sure about Anglicanism for me was this----I could feel that ALL three of the major apostolic succession churches (Orthodoxy, Catholicism, Anglicanism) are flawed and I wasnāt a heretic with them. I have always felt that they each maintain defects and not one of them is perfect in doctrine or theology. But if you ask a Catholic, heāll tell you theyāre infallible, ask the Orthodox and theyāll tell you theyāre infallible and the Catholics are schismatics and lost souls, but ask the Anglicans and they admit theyāre imperfect. Sometimes I found that appealingāa refreshing honesty. They seemed to be just earnestly trying to discern the Truth and admitting that they donāt have all the finer points hammered out but the fundamentals they have indeed. I liked that.
My wife is not happy as a Catholic. Despite being born and raised one in the Philippines, she finds the Church flawed, the education and homilies and didactic side banal and empty, doesnāt see a heck of a lot of value in confession like I do, and sheās not into the sacramentals much either. Since going back to the CC she has been lackluster with motivation but while Anglican she was motivated, excited, into it. My parents the same thing. My mom and dad were really jazzed up about Mass on weekends with St. Paulās Anglican. St. Maryās now? They donāt even go to Mass three times a month. They hit it here and there. Motivation low as all getout.
And I feel a little caught in between. My kids were really excited about St. Paulās too. We loved the rector and people and the worship was great. It had its shortcomings and banality at times too but overall I enjoyed it.
I could easily go there the rest of my days but honestly extra ecclesiam non sallus scares the bejeaminies out of me. Outside the Catholic Church no salvationā¦I get shivers.
When my grandma died the day after Christmas, we had to watch a woman steadily die and drift away. It made me think, almost obsessively, what will become of her? Deathā¦deathā¦wowā¦death over and over. And I think my fear of hell and the fundamentals of just wondering if I turned my back on Christās real true Church kicked in?
Intellectually at this point I can defend MUCH of Catholicism but intellectually honest-wise I cannot defend several areas that I personally donāt like or agree with in my coreālumen gentium, ccc841, NFP, indulgences (still hate 'em), infallibility (my reading of the Fathers and history precludes this but Matt 16:18 does make sense), co-redemptrix language, and the sex scandals and how they were dealt with bothers me tremendouslyā¦so at this point, Iām just trying to be faithful on an almost emotional level.
Intellectually I cannot be fully on board either Catholicism or Orthodoxy I think. And Iām tired of ping-ponginā my family. We need some stability.
If God came to me tonight and said ābe an Anglican!ā Iād be so happy!LOL because I genuinely enjoyed it.
So yes, Anna, you know me all too well my sisterā¦![]()
Let us not forget Ozzie and no not the guy with Harriet!
I am not allowed to pick the station or Cd in the car anymore!
And yes the priest is still in therapy!![]()
Gurney,
Youāve got to be one of the most open and honest people on the forums. You speak of your struggles openly, and it takes courage to do that.
The idea of yielding to the Magisterium certainly has merit and many times I think it would be a welcome relief.
I was just talking to my sister recently about the irony of my feelings about Anglicanism. I love being able to openly disagree in a discussion or study at Churchāand we are allowed to disagree, even with a Priest. Ironically, it is that very freedom to disagree that has opened the door to the abandonment of much of Christian orthodoxy. Kind of a ācatch 22.ā IOW: I like it when I can disagree; but I donāt like it when others disagree with what I believe to be orthodoxy. Makes me a hypocrite right out of the gate.
Anglicanismās Three-Legged Stool is supposed to be āScripture, Tradition, Reason.ā But now it seems more like āScripture held hostage by private interpretation,ā āTradition redefined to suit human desire,ā and āReason that doesnāt seem so reasonable.ā At least thatās the way it feels on an emotional level.
?), the race is on, and no one is slowing down, except maybe the ABofC.
I donāt know. . . .Itās all giving me a headache. :blackeye: And thatās not because Iām a dumb blond.
Anna
Well I might be behind things a bit. I understand from the Catholic perspective that is true and donāt fault you for pointing that out. However, other non Catholic groups do not have some of the issues that are found in Anglicanism, and then it is debatable how big of an issue these issues are.the Anglican Communion was wrong from its very beginnings, a house built on sand will get washed away in the tide, while the Catholic Church build soundly on the rock of of our Lord Jesus Christ will weather the storms of manās vain inclinations.
Well here at CAF the Orthodox seem to be given more of a pass because in the eyes of the RCC, they maintain Apostolic succession, the Anglicans do not. However, both groups are schismatic and represent direct breaks from the Catholic church, in the Catholic view of things. I have heard Catholics speak of the Catholic and Orthodox churches like two lungs, but this is very close to the idea of branch theory from the Anglican Church, just leaving the Anglicans out of the mix.Very refreshing to hear someone in here call the Orthodox schismatics and consider them defective as the Pope has declared they are. Many folks in here feel they are somehow āanotherā Catholic Church and they give them a free pass.
I donāt agree with the Orthodox views on the papacy nor do I agree with their views on the Atonement/Original Sin and I generally feel they are in schism.
And Vatican II was quite a disaster. Whatever intentions were there at the time materialized into a mess.
Most church groups headbang poorly, and the moshing is more laughable. Sigh. Iām very rusty, I havenāt been to a good show in a couple of years now.I am 46 and still listen. Though not as loud now. How is your head banging? The youth group did it fairly poorly. I showed them how to do it properlyā¦though my hair is very shortā¦left over from the Marines and thin. My mojo increased greatly as I head banged.
And yes my neck does hurt today!![]()
Oh I got some looks and one rabid fundie tried to save me!It was not pretty. I use to be a rabid fundie for about 5 minutes. As rabid fundie was going on about so much silliness, I turned to the group and saidā¦this is what happens when you cut yourself off from the true vine. We then prayed for him, right there at the entrance. I then asked St Michael the ArchAngel to protect us from the wiles of the devil. When I was done, the kids made a sign of the Cross and people just stared. I gave a big grin and said āsee working already. Letās go have some fun.ā
![]()
Sounds like you handled it well. I bet their āCatholic alertā alarms were going off as soon as they saw you. Even my family needs more understanding that Roman/Latin Rite Catholics, Anglicans and Lutherans all wear clericals. Its almost like they think its more Biblical to more ministers to dress like business executives or something.Yea, I can be confrontational when needed. I try to use humor if possible.
Please forgive me for posting like four posts, but I have to say I find your honesty refreshing. I concur with some of your points, highlighted. āOutside the Church there is not salvationā scares me too, frankly. I can relate somewhat to how your grandmothers death impacted you. That certainly makes it hit home. I appreciate you so much.Hi Anna,
Of course I know youāre joking. Weāve been friends long enough!! And youāve come to know me like an open book. Of course LG (not the cellphone company!) still troubles me indeed. And another adept poster here made comments about CCC841 being horrible doctrine and I heartily concur on that as well. Iām living in contradiction and right now just trying my best to make sense of it all.
The one appealing thing for sure about Anglicanism for me was this----I could feel that ALL three of the major apostolic succession churches (Orthodoxy, Catholicism, Anglicanism) are flawed and I wasnāt a heretic with them. I have always felt that they each maintain defects and not one of them is perfect in doctrine or theology. But if you ask a Catholic, heāll tell you theyāre infallible, ask the Orthodox and theyāll tell you theyāre infallible and the Catholics are schismatics and lost souls, but ask the Anglicans and they admit theyāre imperfect. Sometimes I found that appealingāa refreshing honesty. They seemed to be just earnestly trying to discern the Truth and admitting that they donāt have all the finer points hammered out but the fundamentals they have indeed. I liked that.
My wife is not happy as a Catholic. Despite being born and raised one in the Philippines, she finds the Church flawed, the education and homilies and didactic side banal and empty, doesnāt see a heck of a lot of value in confession like I do, and sheās not into the sacramentals much either. Since going back to the CC she has been lackluster with motivation but while Anglican she was motivated, excited, into it. My parents the same thing. My mom and dad were really jazzed up about Mass on weekends with St. Paulās Anglican. St. Maryās now? They donāt even go to Mass three times a month. They hit it here and there. Motivation low as all getout.
And I feel a little caught in between. My kids were really excited about St. Paulās too. We loved the rector and people and the worship was great. It had its shortcomings and banality at times too but overall I enjoyed it.
I could easily go there the rest of my days but honestly extra ecclesiam non sallus scares the bejeaminies out of me. Outside the Catholic Church no salvationā¦I get shivers.
When my grandma died the day after Christmas, we had to watch a woman steadily die and drift away. It made me think, almost obsessively, what will become of her? Deathā¦deathā¦wowā¦death over and over. And I think my fear of hell and the fundamentals of just wondering if I turned my back on Christās real true Church kicked in?
Intellectually at this point I can defend MUCH of Catholicism but intellectually honest-wise I cannot defend several areas that I personally donāt like or agree with in my coreālumen gentium, ccc841, NFP, indulgences (still hate 'em), infallibility (my reading of the Fathers and history precludes this but Matt 16:18 does make sense), co-redemptrix language, and the sex scandals and how they were dealt with bothers me tremendouslyā¦so at this point, Iām just trying to be faithful on an almost emotional level.
Intellectually I cannot be fully on board either Catholicism or Orthodoxy I think. And Iām tired of ping-ponginā my family. We need some stability.
If God came to me tonight and said ābe an Anglican!ā Iād be so happy!LOL because I genuinely enjoyed it.
So yes, Anna, you know me all too well my sisterā¦![]()
Please forgive me for posting like four posts, but I have to say I find your honesty refreshing. I concur with some of your points, highlighted. āOutside the Church there is not salvationā scares me too, frankly. I can relate somewhat to how your grandmothers death impacted you. That certainly makes it hit home. I appreciate you so much.
*A. Knocking is a way to show respect for their space.Test question she had today:
What is the best way to establish a helping relationship with a client?
a) knock on the door before entering their room
b) hold the patientās hand
c) call them by their first name
d) being assertive
Which would you choose?
*A. Knocking is a way to show respect for their space.
NOT:
B. Do not touch a patient without her permission.
C. Many, especially the elderly and those of other cultures, do not appreciate being called by their first name.
D. Assertive? Thatās not a great way to start a client relationship.*
So, did I give the correct answer?