How old is the earth?

  • Thread starter Thread starter denwiles
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually it is. Basic mistakes like that can undermine any claims to have mastered the material. Particularly when we are talking about getting the author wrong of one one of the most famous science books in the last 30 years.

–
Bill
its obviously a typo my friend, the other guy did the introduction. If I reference a quote from a saint but can’t remember his name, does that make his or her message any less important or meaningful? What if I get his name wrong?
 
its obviously a typo my friend, the other guy did the introduction. If I reference a quote from a saint but can’t remember his name, does that make his or her message any less important or meaningful? What if I get his name wrong?
It may not change the message, but what if someone doesn’t realize that you got the name wrong? If they look up the Saint you believed said something and they find the Saint never said it, they may disregard what you said believing you made the quote up.

It may seem like nitpicking, but frankly, things like that can go a long way to to selling your argument to your intended audience. Since I tend to follow Cosmology as a hobby, when someone tells me that A Brief History of Time was written by Karl Sagan, my first reaction is that this person isn’t familiar with the subject and probably hasn’t read the book, so why should I trust anything else?

–
Bill
 
It may seem like nitpicking, but frankly, things like that can go a long way to to selling your argument to your intended audience. Since I tend to follow Cosmology as a hobby, when someone tells me that A Brief History of Time was written by Karl Sagan, my first reaction is that this person isn’t familiar with the subject and probably hasn’t read the book, so why should I trust anything else?
Unless they were quoting from the introduction, which he did write. 😉
 
Who cares how old the earth is? What has that to do with your salvation and worship of the one true God? As far as I’m concerned it COULD have been made last Thursday!

PAX DOMINI

Shalom Aleichem
Well to me and you Salvation is the greatest importance, To truly know Jesus Christ is the main thing. It was really just a thought I had, and many people in the world are using this debate to try to prove against God. The Bible says to be prepared “study to show yourself an approved workman before God.” God Bless you and thank you for your comment
 
So do most creatures. In bacteria and most other single celled organisms that reproduce asexually, the exchange of genetic material is necessary to preserve the species.

In multi celled organisms, including members of the plant and animal kingdoms, the exchanges of genetic material occurs through sexual reproduction.

The point here is that by mixing up the genetic code of one organism with that of another, you can increase the chances of both organisms passing at least some of their genes onto the next generation (and so on).

Ultimately, all we are talking about here is the genetic variation part of evolution. Then comes the natural selection part; in the case of bacteria, those that have genes that make them somewhat resistant to antibiotics survive to pass on those genes to other bacteria making them also resistant.

With respect, I think you need to study the science a bit more carefully. If an object is traveling at the speed of light, it effectively becomes invisible to us as its redshift would be infinite (Essentially identical to an object crossing the event horizon of a black hole). In any case, none of this changes the fact, that we have good reason to believe that the Universe is hundreds of millions, if not billions of light years across (at least) and that to see as much of it as we do would require hundreds of millions or billions of years for the light to reach us.

There is a difference between the Church performing or encouraging research or engaging in a dialog with scientists and it trying dictate scientific facts based on what our faith or the Bible tells us. The Church can, does and should, work to ensure that we understand how scientific discoveries can fit into our faith and to ensure that scientific research is conducted in a moral way. If on the other hand it tries to dictate scientific results based on what it believes our faith or the Bible tells us, it risks its credibility. Almost 500 years after the fact, people still attack the Church because of Galileo.

–
Bill
Respectfully, have you read the Galilleo story? The Library of this site explains it well. Briefly, Galilleo was out of control. All the facts weren’t in, but he was running around saying, I’m right! I’m right!

Your comment about bacteria is odd. Mammallian sexual reproduction has nothing to do with bacterial defense against foreign substances like antibiotics.

Do you read any Catholic newspapers or magazines? I ask, respectfully, because there are too many here that are spreading false or distorted information.

All those people who keep telling me to question everything and keep an open mind have their own dogma.

Don’t believe the earth is old? Blasphemy!

Don’t believe in evolution? Blasphemy!

Got something good to say about Intelligent Design? Blasphemy!

Here’s a few words from the April 19, 2009 issue of Our Sunday Visitor.

“The truth of the matter is this. The Church cannot whole-heartedly affirm evolution because evolution as a science itself isn’t wholly firm.” The author is Benjamin Wiker who is also the author of Answering the New Atheism: Dismantling Dawkin’s Case Against God.

Referring to Intelligent Design, he writes: “These types of arguments have considerable merit, more than Catholics have been inclined to grant, precisely because they focus on quite particular trouble spots for a purely materialist, reductionist account of evolution.”

If you do a google search for red shift phenomena not related to distance, you’ll see what I’m talking about. Plus it’s not hard to find references to objects traveling at least .93 of the speed of light or faster.

Peace,
Ed
 
Scientists are not infallible, and they know it. That is why every scientific results comes with error bars on it. The age of the earth is 4.54 × 10[sup]9[/sup] years ± 1%. The “±” shows that scientists know that the figure is not exactly accurate, and that they are 95% confident that their error is within the stated limits. I suggest that you read Isaac Asimov’s essay The Relativity of Wrong to get an idea of how science deals with errors and how it works towards more accurate answers. All scientific answers have error bars, but the newer answers have smaller error bars than the older answers. By today the error bars on the age of the earth are small enough that there is no realistic possibility of the YEC interpretation of Genesis being correct. One of the old earth interpretations may still be correct.

Any reasonably trained geologist can tell the difference between annual varves (as in Lake Baikal) and non-annual flood. Have a look at this image. It is easy enough to see the difference between the non-annual layers from Lake Walensee on the left and the much more regular annual varves from Lake Zurich on the right. The picture came from Glenn Morton’s site: home.entouch.net/dmd/age.htm. Glenn is a Christian and a former Young Earth Creationist. We have checked that varves are annual by dating the layers from different lakes. Varves are annual and we have enough sequences of varves to show that the 10,000 year maximum age allowed under YEC assumptions is wrong. The same with ice layers, tree rings, astronomical data and many other ways of determining the age of the earth and of things on the earth. Insisting on a young earth is a good way to put off anyone with a scientific mind from accepting Christianity. To quote Saint Thomas Aquinas:In discussing questions of this kind two rules are to be observed, as Augustine teaches. The first is, to hold to the truth of Scripture without wavering. The second is that since Holy Scripture can be explained in a multiplicity of senses, one should adhere to a particular explanation only in such measure as to be ready to abandon it if it be proved with certainty to be false, lest Holy Scripture be exposed to the ridicule of unbelievers, and obstacles be placed to their believing.
Young Earth Creationism is an excellent example the kind of “obstacle” that Saint Thomas was talking about.

rossum
Why do you mention Thomas Aquinas? Here is a quote from an article that appeared in the April 19, 2009 issue of Our Sunday Visitor:

“The truth of the matter is this. The Church cannot whole-heartedly affirm evolution because evolution as a science itself isn’t wholly firm.” The author is Benjamin Wiker.

Peace,
Ed
 
Why do you mention Thomas Aquinas? Here is a quote from an article that appeared in the April 19, 2009 issue of Our Sunday Visitor:

“The truth of the matter is this. The Church cannot whole-heartedly affirm evolution because evolution as a science itself isn’t wholly firm.” The author is Benjamin Wiker.

Peace,
Ed
Evolution, creationism, science, religion, etc., etc., …this is all part of God’s plan. He lets us find out and know what He thinks we should know and can handle and then we go and argue among ourselves as to what “we have discovered” and as to what is right and what is wrong!

PAX DOMINI

Shalom Aleichem
 
Why do you mention Thomas Aquinas?
Because what he said was very sensible. I suggest that you read the Asimov essay that I referenced in my post. Yes science is provisional, but we do know that some things are established beyond reasonable doubt.

There are still some few people who insist on a flat earth. They are wrong, and will continue to be wrong, even if science discovers more detail about the exact shape of the earth. We know enough to know that the earth is certainly not flat but is much closer to a sphere, even though it is not exactly a sphere.

It is the same with the age of the earth. We do not have an exact age, but we do know enough to know that 6,000 years or 10,000 years is absurdly young.

Saint Thomas is making the point that if you insist that a flat earth is an essential part of Christianity then you will make it difficult for anyone with a little bit of knowledge to become Christian.
“The truth of the matter is this. The Church cannot whole-heartedly affirm evolution because evolution as a science itself isn’t wholly firm.” The author is Benjamin Wiker.
Science is indeed a work in progress, as is the develpment of Catholic doctrine. That is why the Church has Councils to re-examine and redefine doctrine. The idea of the Immaculate Conception has a long history, but was only recently elevated to the status of Church Dogma. The Catholic Church too is a work in progress, does that mean that we can believe anything we want because things might change in future? Of course not, and science is the same. There are areas where science is uncertain, but those areas of uncertainty are known and have known limits. Attempting to insist on something outside those limits will constitute one of the “obstacles” that Saint Thomas talks about.

rossum
 
I have heard conflicting reports about the age of the Earth. There are three diffrent point of views that I am aware of.
  1. Some say six literal days and that the Earth is 6,000 to 11,000 years old.
  2. A pre Adameic race- they say God wiped out a human race before Adam and created the world over again. Making the Earth Millions of years old.
  3. God worked with evolution and the days of creation were actually thousands of years apart.
    Could you shed some light on this question, please. God Bless
The bottom line is that is doesn’t matter. The evidence suggests a very old Earth. Whatever the Earth’s birth date, God made it and will remain on the throne for all eternity.
 
Because what he said was very sensible. I suggest that you read the Asimov essay that I referenced in my post. Yes science is provisional, but we do know that some things are established beyond reasonable doubt.

There are still some few people who insist on a flat earth. They are wrong, and will continue to be wrong, even if science discovers more detail about the exact shape of the earth. We know enough to know that the earth is certainly not flat but is much closer to a sphere, even though it is not exactly a sphere.

It is the same with the age of the earth. We do not have an exact age, but we do know enough to know that 6,000 years or 10,000 years is absurdly young.

Saint Thomas is making the point that if you insist that a flat earth is an essential part of Christianity then you will make it difficult for anyone with a little bit of knowledge to become Christian.

Science is indeed a work in progress, as is the develpment of Catholic doctrine. That is why the Church has Councils to re-examine and redefine doctrine. The idea of the Immaculate Conception has a long history, but was only recently elevated to the status of Church Dogma. The Catholic Church too is a work in progress, does that mean that we can believe anything we want because things might change in future? Of course not, and science is the same. There are areas where science is uncertain, but those areas of uncertainty are known and have known limits. Attempting to insist on something outside those limits will constitute one of the “obstacles” that Saint Thomas talks about.

rossum
God’s knowledge is above man’s knowledge. That needs to be understood. Thomas Aquinas was not just a sensible, but a saint. This dimension puts him and all Catholics in touch with our maker. Science is partly blind. It cannot see beyond certain limits. You seen to forget what the Church allows Catholics to believe regarding this subject.

From the April 19, 2009 issue of Our Sunday Visitor:

“Any view of evolution that assumes on principle that biological nature is entirely governed by chance and blind laws must be in error.”

Peace,
Ed
 
Why do you mention Thomas Aquinas? Here is a quote from an article that appeared in the April 19, 2009 issue of Our Sunday Visitor:

“The truth of the matter is this. The Church cannot whole-heartedly affirm evolution because evolution as a science itself isn’t wholly firm.” The author is Benjamin Wiker.

Peace,
Ed
Then you could say the same thing about gravity because it isn’t wholly firm.
 
What school taught you this?
I think nearly all colleges and universities teach that.
How do you test the theory of evolution?
If you mean provide evidence the best is the fossil record. The evidence from fossils is enormous.

If you mean predictability then again the fossil record can be examined from a historical perspective. A good example is the history of cetacean fossils.

Another test is in the lab. Bacterial cultures have been observed to evolve in response to environmental changes.

Gravity isn’t nearly as well understood because it’s a lot more complicated and no one really understands quantum theory, but we pretty much understand evolution.
 
I think nearly all colleges and universities teach that.
The ones that are accredited anyway.
If you mean provide evidence the best is the fossil record. The evidence from fossils is enormous.
If you mean predictability then again the fossil record can be examined from a historical perspective. A good example is the history of cetacean fossils.
Actually, our understanding of the genetics involved in evolution has progressed so far, that even without a single fossil it would still be one of the best supported theories in science.

I’m not saying the fossil record isn’t amazing evidence, because it really is. I’m just saying that it’s only half the story.
 
I can prove gravity whenever I want to. The Apollo 11 astronauts needed precise calculations to use the moon’s gravity to get them back home. This at a time when computers were toys compared to the laptops available today.

Peace,
Ed
 
I can prove gravity whenever I want to. The Apollo 11 astronauts needed precise calculations to use the moon’s gravity to get them back home. This at a time when computers were toys compared to the laptops available today.

Peace,
Ed
Really? What is it?
 
I think nearly all colleges and universities teach that.

If you mean provide evidence the best is the fossil record. The evidence from fossils is enormous.

If you mean predictability then again the fossil record can be examined from a historical perspective. A good example is the history of cetacean fossils.

Another test is in the lab. Bacterial cultures have been observed to evolve in response to environmental changes.

Gravity isn’t nearly as well understood because it’s a lot more complicated and no one really understands quantum theory, but we pretty much understand evolution.
adaptation is not evolution.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top