How Sunlight Reflected Off a Building Can Melt Objects

  • Thread starter Thread starter didymus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

didymus

Guest
National Geographic:
How Sunlight Reflected Off a Building Can Melt Objects
The “Walkie Talkie Building,” a name Londoners have given a distinctively shaped skyscraper near Saint Paul’s Cathedral, has been in the news this week after reflected sunlight from its mirrored facade melted the side mirrors and panels on a Jaguar XJ parked on a nearby street.
So how on Earth does a skyscraper melt a car?
In a nutshell, it does so by using the same principles a Boy Scout might use to start a fire with a magnifying glass—by concentrating a beam of sunlight on a point.
But at 20 Fenchurch Street, London’s hottest new address, instead of a lens being used, it is the concave flank of a 37-story skyscraper covered with 355,000 square feet (33,000 square meters) of highly reflective south-facing glass. It is a coincidence of shapes and materials, say physicists, that is ideally suited to focusing a tremendous amount of solar energy on a small area and generating a lot of heat—enough to melt the plastic coatings on the side mirror of an expensive sports car, fry an egg, blister a bicycle seat, or burn a hole in a doormat, all of which are reported to have occurred in the hot spot beneath the Walkie Talkie.
From this side of the Atlantic:

Vegas Hotel Pool ‘Death Ray’ Burns Tourists

Same architect, what a coincidence!
I’m amazed such blunders occur esp. in these days of computer modelling. The energy of the Sun, the refelctivity & curvature of the glass for a proposed design are all knowns – so why don’t these problems show up until after completion?

PS – are architects required to carry malpractice insurance?
 
National Geographic:

From this side of the Atlantic:

Vegas Hotel Pool ‘Death Ray’ Burns Tourists

Same architect, what a coincidence!
I’m amazed such blunders occur esp. in these days of computer modelling. The energy of the Sun, the refelctivity & curvature of the glass for a proposed design are all knowns – so why don’t these problems show up until after completion?

PS – are architects required to carry malpractice insurance?
Computer modeling is great, but the computer will only answer the questions it is asked.
I doubt if the Architect thought to ask the computer questions about the potential effect of the reflected and concentrated light.

Peace
James
 
As kids we used to catch tissue paper on fire by focusing the sun rays through a magnifying glass. The architect of the building was very naive, and he or his firm should become liable for all damages and correcting the problem.
 
Computer modeling is great, but the computer will only answer the questions it is asked.
I doubt if the Architect thought to ask the computer questions about the potential effect of the reflected and concentrated light.

Peace
James
But doesn’t it stand to reason that the architect would have seen solar reflectors before, or even shaving mirrors? I’m possibly the least technically-adept person on earth, but even I know that a mirror or bunch of mirrors curved inward will concentrate sunlight. I knew that even when I was a kid playing with my father’s inward-curved shaving mirror.
 
But doesn’t it stand to reason that the architect would have seen solar reflectors before, or even shaving mirrors? I’m possibly the least technically-adept person on earth, but even I know that a mirror or bunch of mirrors curved inward will concentrate sunlight. I knew that even when I was a kid playing with my father’s inward-curved shaving mirror.
I agree…In my earlier reply I was mainly addressing the comment about computer modeling. In truth, computers, for all their capabilities, are quite stupid. They can only do what is specifically asked of them.

Now - as to the matter of should the architect have recognized the possibility of this problem, I would say that yes he should have -
Maybe he did and the numbers indicated that it would not be a problem…
Then again, maybe he didn’t think of it or maybe he just assumed it would not be a problem…
There are lot’s of possibilities.

But obviously there will need to be a fix and that is likely to be expensive.

Peace
James
 
Fascinating!

Coincidentally I watched an episode of *This Old House *last night and there was a case of a window on one side of a exterior walls at right angles reflecting the sun and melting the vinyl siding on the other side (perpendicular?). The case was solved by putting a screen in front of the glass to diffuse the reflected light.
 
If one watches the video on the las vagas link in the OP, it turns out that this is a problem that is not isolated to the concave design or to a large building…Standard High efficiency windows in homes are melting the vinyl siding on neighbor’s homes.
The problem seems to be fairly new…
So in defense of the designer in London…perhaps he DID check the calculations on the computer and maybe the numbers simply did not take into account this new information.

Peace
James
 
Yes, architects carry liability insurance. It’s one of their largest individual annual expenses (still less than payroll, but often higher than office space rent). Keep that in mind if/when you ever need to hire one and stagger at the enormity of their cost proposal. We engineers have the same problem.

Focus effects of light are NOT a traditional area of scrutiny in building design and permitting. And no architect I’ve ever met would have the faintest clue how to calculate the combined reflective effects of his structure. Probably cases like this will spur an new level of regulatory scrutiny and subconsultant cost for analysis before permits are issued.

As usual, it’s you and me that pay in the end.
 
Yes, architects carry liability insurance. It’s one of their largest individual annual expenses (still less than payroll, but often higher than office space rent). Keep that in mind if/when you ever need to hire one and stagger at the enormity of their cost proposal. We engineers have the same problem.

Focus effects of light are NOT a traditional area of scrutiny in building design and permitting. And no architect I’ve ever met would have the faintest clue how to calculate the combined reflective effects of his structure. Probably cases like this will spur an new level of regulatory scrutiny and subconsultant cost for analysis before permits are issued.

As usual, it’s you and me that pay in the end.
Thanks for these comments I did not know this.
As mentioned in my earlier post it appears that the more high efficiency window glazing is having some unintended consequences in just normal residential installation. As you say this will likely lead to some new rules and / modifications etc.

Peace
James
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top