There’s no way to tell where you need to look because even going to church does not guarantee you will meet someone. You need to try something though. Unfortunately, without a car how will you get around to meet women? How will you take a girl on a date? Seems to me that your best bet would be finding a girl through friends who know people. Do you have friends who are practicing Catholics?
Nobody is really a fan of internet dating but if that is your only option, it’s your only option. It took me almost 5 years before I became a item with my girlfriend who I met from Catholicmatch. So, internet dating can work. The thing is you need money to pay to use a site and then more money to take a girl on a date. And you will be rejected 90% of the time if not more so you need the stomach to handle that. Only “bad boys” get away with being broke, unemployed and no car in the dating world. So, although it may take a long time, I think you need to focus more on becoming financially stable. I know it’s hard, believe me, I use to have to save money from three weeks of pay to be able to take a girl on a date. I was so lonely and frustrated with never meeting girls at church or any other ministry I became involved with but sometimes it takes a lot of time. All you can do is work on yourself while you are single and make a attempt to date instead of waiting around for something to happen. But, having a car and money helps a lot.
Also, you need to go to Mass. Traditional Catholic who does not go to Mass every week? Come on, man. Not to be harsh but come on. And you want a traditional Catholic girl? That’s like a 400 pound man wanting a fitness model. Think about it.