How to receive?

  • Thread starter Thread starter wonderingCatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
… other times it can be someone trying to draw attention to themselves.
That seems to be a popular opinion when someone chooses to do something to show reverence or honor or love to Our Lord that not all our doing. It is rarely true.
As I also said, standing to receive can show more of a fraternal attitude. Rather than approaching the king in Communion, I am approaching my brother, Christ.
Though Christ is more than our brother, He is Our King and while we may not be kneeling now here on Earth, someday we will all bend our knees before Him.
Both are allowed, reverence is internal, your preference is not “more reverent” or “more humble” than another, and that’s that.
You’re right both are allowed at present and it has been made very difficult for us to kneel when receiving since there are no altar rails with kneelers any longer to help us get up and down. Hopefully someday all parishes will have altar rails that will give everyone the ability to get up and down so they can kneel before Our Lord.

As far as both standing and kneeling before Christ being equal, I charitably disagree. It has come to be what many Catholics believe but standing generally means equal or on the same level. That is not quite where we are with Christ, though as I said above kneeling today is a difficult thing to do without something to kneel on.

God bless.
 
How is it that in 1962 (or 1862, or 1462), it was forbidden to receive standing, and to receive in the hand? Then just 5-10 years later it was basically forbidden to receive kneeling, and seen as unusual to receive on the tongue?
Can you imagine someone in 1962, (or 1862 etc.), saying “you know, it’s taking too long to distribute communion. Could we have some laypeople help out so it doesn’t take so long?” Can you imagine what a priest, or bishop, or pope would have said?
 
Last edited:
And they fell down before the throne upon their faces
On their faces, = prostrate, no knees, no sitting, prostrate. In this translation.
That hardly means that we should be standing even when sleeping.
Are you against praying at all in a kneeling position
Are you attacking the person rather then the comment?
Can we not at least agree that we should be as free to receive kneeling as those standing? No one should be feeling judged… whether its simply in the OP’s mind or not.
If this were the case CAF would experience no controversy over threads about how to receive Communion.
The Op was asking a question, had it resolved, yet the debate continues.
 
Last edited:
Well, except that Christ is coming to us in an extremely special way in the Eucharist and we are receiving Him into our very beings, receiving graces and mercy when we receive and to be receiving Him worthily. Not anywhere near the same thing as God being everywhere.
God everywhere is pretty special. We still receive graces and mercies, Confession being one example where we do.

This is why some very holy people of the past lived their lives accordingly.
 
So, where is the article about receiving on the tongue being a novelty?

Do you reject the council?

Straight talk, please.
 
Our priest brought this up at Mass this morning. I attend an OF Mass, but he asked one of his Latin rite cohorts what his parish is doing in the wake of our bishop’s recent orders to administer Eucharist only in the hand. In the true spirit of our faith, the EF priest said that if the bishop requires hand-only, then he obeys. This healthy attitude comes in the midst of numerous angry calls that our diocese is receiving about this latest missive.
One diocese here simply allowed Communion in the hand (OF). Nobody is forced to do it. By general rules of EF no one can receive in the Hand. That’s like forcing people to kneel when communing at OF or even worse… its practically violation of rubrics promulgated by Holy See based on call from one ordinary. Bishops have no such authority as to decide form of communion in the EF.
 
So the bishop dictates everything? What if you get a disobedient bishop?
 
I just didn’t know I’ve never strayed from the teachings.
 
Kneeling before someone has always been a sign of humility.
In the Eastern Churches, kneeling is a sign of penance.
While standing does not show humility and at times can be a sign of pride or lack of humility:
It is true that standing does not necessarily show humility, but when properly understood, it shows something else.

Neither position is inherently better, although one or the other might speak to an individual’s spirituality more profoundly.

Here is the explanation from St. Basil the Great (a doctor of the Church) as to why standing is the preferred position for Christian prayer, particularly on Sundays.

“We stand up when praying on the first of the week, though not all of us know the reason. For it is not only that it serves to remind us that when we have risen from the dead together with Christ we ought to seek the things above, in the day of resurrection of the grace given us, by standing at prayer, but that it also seems to serve in a way as a picture of the expected age. Wherefore, being also the starting point of days, though not the first with Moses, yet it has been called the first. For it says: ‘The evening and the morning were the first day’ (Gen. 1:5), on the ground that it returns again and again. The eighth, therefore, is also the first, especially as respects that really first and true eighth day, which the Psalmist too has mentioned in some of the superscriptions of his psalms, serving to exhibit the state which is to succeed this period of time, the unceasing day, the day without a night that follows, the day without successor, the never-ending and unaging age. Of necessity, therefore, the Church teaches her children to fulfill their obligations to pray therein while standing up, in order by constantly reminding them of the deathless life to prevent them from neglecting the provisions for the journey thither. And every Pentecost is a reminder of the expected resurrection in the age to come. For that one first day, being multiplied seven times over, constitutes the seven weeks of the holy Pentecost. For by starting from the first day of the week, one arrives on the same day… The laws of the Church have taught us to prefer the upright posture at prayer, thus transporting our mind, so to speak, as a result of a vivid and clear suggestions, from the present age to the things come in the future. And during each kneeling and standing up again we are in fact showing by our actions that is was through sin that we fell to earth, and that through the kindness of the One Who created us we have been called back to Heaven…” (Canon XCI of St. Basil the Great). The three well-known kneeling prayers of Pentecost composed by this great Father of the Church are thus not read at third hour, when the Holy Spirit descended upon the Apostles, nor at Liturgy on Pentecost, but at vespers, which is already part of the following day, after the Entrance.
 
I forgot to mention another reason was the particle issue. I couldn’t bring myself to use my hand anymore when I knew there was microscopic particles on my hand. To another poster I don’t agree with Eucharistic ministers either. I think there should be multiple priests to administer the host at communion.
 
Where are these “multiple priests” suppose to come from?

Also, if they are microscopic, how would you know that they were there?
 
Yes, and we do pray for more priests.

But that doesn’t make them appear fully ordained and ready to serve.

So, what do you do in the meantime? In other words, what do we do today?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top