How to respond to and honor my mother?

  • Thread starter Thread starter turkeysandwich
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

turkeysandwich

Guest
I work outside the home one to two days a week, during which time my mother, who lives down the street from us, cares for my four children, ages 8 and under, in our home. She is a wonderful, energetic, disciplined caregiver who truly enjoys being with her grandkids and my children adore her- for the most part we also have a good relationship.

However…

My family and I live in a very small home. We purchased it as a “fixer-upper” several years ago because it was what we could afford on one income (we homeschool and are committed to my staying home most days). My husband, who is very handy, has done a tremendous amount of work himself (on evenings and weekends) on the house in order to make it safe and structurally sound for us to live in : replaced all the plumbing and electricity, replaced all the windows, re-shingled the roof, put new cabinets and appliances in the kitchen, to name a few. In addition, of course, he also takes care of the regular home maintenance issues that arise. We have not hired someone to do this work for us because we cannot afford it.

Because we’ve done all this work ourselves, and because my husband has a physically demanding 50-hour a week job, we haven’t put much effort into the cosmetic appearance of our house. For instance, my husband remodeled the kitchen cabinets but hasn’t finished painting all of the walls yet. We replaced the windows but haven’t put the curtains and curtain rods back up. There are stains on some of the walls from some previous water damage. We don’t have any pictures on the walls. It seems like we’re so happy to get the majority of the work done that neither one of us cares about the details at the end that would go toward making the house really look pretty. This drives my mom CRAZY. She sees this all as jobs unfinished and criticizes my husband (to me, never to his face) for being unmotivated and lazy for not finishing a job once he’s started it. She believes we don’t have enough “pride” in our living arrangements and should take more care to make it look nice, or at least finished. She has even said that she finds our house embarrassing.

While I agree that it would be nice to have a more finished looking house, and while I recognize that maybe most people wouldn’t enjoy living in our crazy house, it doesn’t bother me as it is. I am happy with it, I am proud of the work my husband has done, and I usually don’t notice these things until she points them out to me. Her statement about our house being “embarrassing” was particularly hurtful. I am starting to question whether she is right-- is my home a dump? Should I be too embarrassed to invite colleagues or the priest over for dinner? How can I evaluate this and how should I respond to my mother, whom I know means well and whom I want to honor?
 
Just express what you feel about the subject without being critical about her or her actions.Basically the part where you feel hurt and that your husband deserves better.

You may not be able to change her opinion, but at least you let her know what you feel. If she fails to respect your feelings, then it is her fault, not yours. You and your husband can move on.

A house is a house, it’s the people that live in it that count. Of course, we should make it somewhat presentable, but not demand it to be like a vain hotel or designer room.
 
“Mom, the subject of our house remodeling is now closed. It will not be discussed in this house ever again. It is hurtful to me when you criticize my hard-working husband and our home. Therefore, we will not discuss it any more. If you are not comfortable in this house just the way it is, then the kids can visit at yours. Please respect me and my home enough to keep your opinions to yourself in the future.”

Then, enforce it. If she brings it up-- tell her, “remember, mom, our home is offlimits for discussion.”
 
I don’t know anything about a “fixer-up” home. But it sounds like you and your husband are both working very hard to provide for your children and give them what you can. In what spare time (which as a HS’er is rare) you have been working on the house. Don’t worry about your mom.

I would tell her “If you would like to help me finish getting things in order, then I welcome your help. If not, then it will have to wait until I have time”
 
In general I would say it’s none of her business what your home looks like. If something were unsanitary or unsafe for your children, that would be different, but that doesn’t seem to be the case here.

But in the interests of keeping the peace, especially since she spends “one or two days a week” in your home, doing you the favor of free child-care, can you point out to her exactly what you just told us: how buying a fixer-upper allows you to stay home with your children for the most part (I hope she’d agree that’s worth making sacrifices for), how much work has already been finished, how your homeschooling and your husband’s demanding job limit your time and energy for “cosmetic” home-improvement projects, how you can’t afford to hire someone for other jobs (I hope she’d agree that living within your means is a worthy goal), etc.

As a concession to her, could you paint and hang curtains (a privacy, light control and warmth issue, I myself don’t care about hanging pictures) in the “public” rooms of the home, where she presumably spends most of her time with the kids when she’s caring for them? Or at least can you tell her you and your husband’s plan for when you will “get around to” finishing the rooms? Maybe there are other more-urgent projects, higher up on the priority list than cosmetically finishing the rooms. Maybe if you listed those projects for her, she’d see where your priorities lie, and (hopefully) agree with them. For example, replacing plumbing and electricity is a sanitary, safety issue which I hope everyone would agree takes priority over cosmetics, and indeed you and your husband took care of that already.

If these reasonable attempts to accommodate her still do not satisfy her, by all means, just come right out and tell her “cosmetics” aren’t as important to you as they are to her, you’re doing the best you can, and her comments hurt you. Declare the subject off-limits in the future, and if it does come up again, just say, “I’m not willing to discuss that anymore. You’re hurting me. Please respect my wishes.” Say exactly the same thing over and over like a broken record until she changes the subject.
 
My mil is a Mrs. Stewart wanna-be.
I don’t even like Mrs. Stewart. All those silly knickknacks and stuff just look likemore junk for me to spend money and time on. No thanks, I’d rather be … doing just about anything else. Read a book, take a walk - anything.


**That said, my house is always clean. Not perfect, we do live here, but it isn’t run down. Every once in a while, about once a month or two, we have to set aside a day to do all the piddly stuff that accumulates. You can get a LOT done in one day set aside for just maintence of the house. Broken coat hooks, sew up a little tear in a curtain, patch a hole from a tonka truck gone wild off the stair rail, fix a cabinet hinge, fix some lattice that looks a bit wobbly in the garden, repair a screen door… you know the little stuff that happens when people use their home for more than sleep.😉 **

My mil once commented on our old house. She made a few comments. The yard needs mowed? Do we just leave the hose in the yard? What do I use to clean? There’s no bleach?? It would only take a bit of effort to hang some things and maybe paint the house?

Now keep in mind my house wouldn’t win any awards, but it wasn’t condemnable either. The yard wasn’t a golf course, but it was no where near code violations or anything.

**I listened very nicely and then said honestly and cheerfully, “That sounds great! If it’s really bothering you that much, then plese feel free to pitch in on any project that strikes your fancy. We are gone from the home during these times, so just let yourself in and the kids won’t even be in your way.”😃 **

You are at a stage where your priorities are elsewhere. If you are bothered, then do something.

Are you proud of your home and comfortable in it? If not, then by all means change that. But there’s no point making it to where you mother is happy in it if everyone who actually lives there is miserable in the process.
 
But in the interests of keeping the peace, especially since she spends “one or two days a week” in your home, doing you the favor of free child-care,
I guess this is what I feel guilty about- she spends so much time here (she offered, and I know she is doing it freely) that I do want her to feel “at home”.

I have told her in the past that her comments are hurtful. She will lay off the issue for long stretches at a time, during which I think she’s OK with the status of our house or at least not thinking about it all the time. Then suddenly (it seems sudden to me) something will tip her off and she will explode (she is a temperamental Irishwoman!) about it again and I’ll realize that it’s been bugging her all along. Or she will make comments to her friends about how sorry she feels for us that our house is so terribly small, and how the kids are tripping over their own feet all the time. I guess, honestly, I feel that she is being patronizing and somewhat materialistic about the whole thing. Should I just ignore her complaints after telling her the subject is closed?
 
Tell your Mama that you all are having a painting party (oh so popular with my parents and their fixer-uppers. Yes, plural). We invite people to bring themselves and a brush/roller. We usually have spaghetti to feed them, and we paint. In some cases, window dressings have gone up as well.
One party even ended in a bonfire.
 
Explain things to your mother exactly how you explained them here, tell her that you plan on getting all these things finished and that you are really not unhappy with it right now because you know that it is going to get finished, better to take your time and get it done right the first time than to do it fast and have to re do it over right away.
 
If, after carefully explaining all this to her, I would say

“Mom, thank you so much. I know you only mean to help and want only what is best for my family. I know you would NEVER deliberately hurt my feelings. Trust me, if there is anything Hubby and I are aware of its how much we need to get done around here. However, for right now, we are doing the best we can with what we have and knowing that you are holding us up in prayer is something for which we are really grateful. Now, how 'bout those Yankees?”
 
You know, my very independent 80 yo mom has lived with us for over 10 yrs…no, I’m not an only child, I have 4 siblings. Based on that experience, I have 3 suggestions:
  1. Speak the truth in love: Mom, I appreciate your help but it hurts my feelings when you say these things & talk about us to others etc.
  2. Don’t be drawn in by “I don’t mean any harm/I’m only concerned for you all/ I only etc etc etc”. Simply keep repeating #1 calmly, kindly & assertively…probably about once every 2-3 months initially.
    #3. Remind yourself that your first duty is always to your spouse & your children. If you keep backing up, it’ll simply lead to more confusion in your fam & and a bigger eventual blow up.
 
I’d ask for her help. Let her know that with schooling, work, daily chores you don’t have time to finish. Ask if she would be willing to hang curtains, grab a paint roller or organize a finishing party.
 
“Mom, the subject of our house remodeling is now closed. It will not be discussed in this house ever again. It is hurtful to me when you criticize my hard-working husband and our home. Therefore, we will not discuss it any more. If you are not comfortable in this house just the way it is, then the kids can visit at yours. Please respect me and my home enough to keep your opinions to yourself in the future.”

Then, enforce it. If she brings it up-- tell her, “remember, mom, our home is offlimits for discussion.”
Above is written the best answer. I have found that overly nice solutions usually don’t work. Be calm but firm.

My stepfather used to drive me nuts. Everytime my knowledgable 18 year old self would offer some helpful insight, he would shrug his shoulders and calmly say, “Ah well, life sucks doesn’t it?” And then ignore me! After a while I learned to keep my opinion to myself:rolleyes:
 
I’m not sure how you should respond to your mother (my mother lives with me, so ‘how to respond’ is always an ongoing issue for me, and I have very few answers), but I think you should both be very proud of yourselves … in my opinion, it shows that you have your priorities straight that you’re concentrating on having a nice, safe, snug home rather than a showpiece. Bravo!

DEFINITELY invite people over! You have nothing to be ashamed of; if you ever felt the need to offer an explanation, you could just be honest - that the work on the house is still in progress. I’m impressed with all you’ve done, and I’ve only heard part of it!

Bravo to you! 👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top