How We Pale to Previous Generations

  • Thread starter Thread starter upant
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
U

upant

Guest
is he wrong?
Our ancestors were builders and pioneers and mostly fearless. We are regulators, auditors, bureaucrats, adjudicators, censors, critics, plaintiffs, defendants, social-media junkies, and thin-skinned scolds. A distant generation created; we mostly delay, idle, and gripe.
 
The answer to the author is an eye roll and an exasperated “Okay, Boomer”

And before anyone is triggered by that, that’s the right answer because the examples given are uncritical and hasty conclusions, non-sequiturs, and unsupported opinion that you might hear someone gripe about over their eggs at an early morning diner, without any real comparisons seriously evaluated.

Like… We haven’t been to the moon in 40 years, so naturally civilization is devolving? It couldn’t possibly be that we haven’t any need to go to the moon now that we’ve been there. And studied it up. And also blast rovers to Mars with some regularity Oh, and we don’t have a superpower foe to rub their noses in it. We’re a little beyond the moon in terms of our space exploration. The moon is the bunny hill, my dude. It’s also full of outright and easily provable lies. Diamond Valley Dam is huge. Diamond Valley Lake, its reservoir, is one of the largest in SoCal. And it was built in 1999. There are many more large dams that were built within the last 40 years. And at least three that have been in the planning phase for at least 15 years now. One slated to begin construction next year will be the fifth largest dam in the US when completed.

The author should’ve added “And these namby-pamby participation-ribbon wearers have done nothing in terms of candy technology. Our generation made the Mars Bar. The Baby Ruth. And the Raisinette! Would they even understand the satisfying pull of a Charleston Chew anymore?! I think NOT. Mr. Necco and his wafers didn’t go Over There just so this useless generation could drop the ball!”
 
Last edited:
Our forefathers helped to win World War II and defeat the Axis Powers in four years.
Which is approximately two years and four months less than it took the European Allies and almost as long as it took the Soviets following Germany’s fortuitously ill-judged decision to renege on the non-aggression pact! Which is not to diminish our important contribution to the Allied war effort, nor the personal heroism of those who served, but it’s disingenuous of Dr. Hanson, a distinguished military historian, to reduce the duration of the war to the (less than) four years that the United States was involved in fighting it.

Now, is Dr. Hanson speaking only about the United States or is he launching an assault against younger generations around the world? And from exactly what point in time does he date the declining standards? He suggested 40 years, so let’s stick with that. In the past 40 years, humankind has:
  • Pioneered laparoscopic surgery
  • Identified HIV/AIDS and developed antiretroviral drugs
  • Proved Fermat’s Last Theorum
  • Invented the internet
  • Achieved near ubiquitous use of GPS for non-military purposes
  • Near ubiquitous availability of cell phones and computers
  • Cloned a sheep
  • Mapped the human genome
  • Discovered the Higgs boson
  • Discovered water on Mars
  • Photographed a black hole
Also:
  • End of the Cold War, break-up of the Soviet Union, former eastern bloc states achieve independence and many join NATO and the EU
  • The British won the Falklands War in 10 weeks
  • Apartheid ended in South Africa and Nelson Mandela was elected the nation’s first black president
  • The Yugoslav Wars: effective involvement of the international community, seven independent states emerge from the conflict with almost universal international recognition, the perpetrators are brought to justice in an international tribunal.
  • Cessation of the Troubles in Northern Ireland
  • Charles Taylor became the first head of state since WW2 to be convicted of war crimes, crimes against humanity, and violation of international humanitarian law at an international tribunal and was jailed for 50 years
Female firsts:
  • 1979: Margaret Thatcher head of government of a G7/P5 country (UK)
  • 1979: Simone Veil president of EU parliament
  • 1980: Vigdís Finnbogadóttir elected head of state (Iceland)
  • 1981: Sandra Day O’Connor US Supreme Court justice
  • 1992: Stella Rimington director general of UK Security Service
  • 1992: Betty Boothroyd speaker of UK House of Commons
  • 1993: Janet Reno US Attorney General
  • 1994: Judith Rodin president of an Ivy League university (Pennsylvania)
  • 1997: Madeleine Albright US Secretary of State
  • 1997: Mary Robinson, former president of Ireland, UN high commissioner for human rights
  • 2006: Rosalyn Higgins president of the International Court of Justice
  • 2007: Nancy Pelosi speaker of the US House of Representatives
  • 2009: Catherine Ashton EU high representative for foreign affairs and security policy
  • 2011: Christine Lagarde managing director of the IMF
  • 2016: Hillary Clinton US presidential nominee
  • 2017: Cressida Dick commissioner of UK Metropolitan Police
  • 2017: Brenda Hale president of UK Supreme Court
 
I think the author is right, as he says, we built the great railroad West in 6 years, maybe that had some near slave labor doing it…but compare that to California pouring billions into building that light rail out there and now abandoning it. And that building the railroads, we are talking about the 1800s.

And JFK declared we would land a man on the moon. Oh, yes, water on Mars.

Now, what I’ve told people before, is we apparently had some racial strife in this country previously but the Great Society programs really haven’t done that much. An earlier generation in the 1800s fought the civil war, I think some of that is extremely noble that we don’t see everyday. A lot of volunteers in that war.

Talking about the internet is like calling radio and TV great inventions in the past. Yes, they are and so is the internet within limits. Lots of good on the web, lots of bad like film, radio and tv. But some of the net is a cesspool. Making available bad info on a wide-ranging basis.

And indeed, it is great that women have achieved these positions. Some of this though, I’d say are fruits from the past as well. Not like it was struck up in the 1980s. The push for equality.

Since 1973, abortion. I don’t consider that an advancement.

A challenge to our present day is this about the climate. I’ve got my own views certainly, I don’t think we should easily dismiss it.

I’ve got to say, not to push an idea on anyone, with free enterprise, capitalism, we don’t want to be greedy but it does look like socialism especially, largely flops. So, it’s not really talking, in part, of one era versus another. Nanny State Governments, they don’t look to be greatly successful. Socialism often, maybe not always, but often fails, see Venezuela.
 
Last edited:
I think where Dr. Hanson is correct is where he is talking about large infrastructure projects. The 19th and early 20th centuries saw extraordinary infrastructure projects undertaken all over the world and they were indeed often completed remarkably quickly.

For example, the Trans-Siberian Railway was constructed in just 15 years. Regulation, presumably, is a major reason why these kinds of projects now take so much longer than they used to. In the case of the TSR, for example, the foundations were too narrow, the ballast layer was too thin, the rails were too light and frequently warped, the crossties were too widely spaced and prone to splintering, and bridges that should have been built from metal were actually built from wood and sometimes just collapsed. It was the most dangerous railroad in the whole Russian Empire and trains had to travel at just 15 mph to avoid derailment. Reliance on convict and exile labor meant that much of the railroad was in fact deliberately sabotaged by the men who were supposed to be building it. It was also hugely unreliable with trains sometimes being delayed by several days at a time, often without food for those on board. By the time the TSR was completed, it accounted for 20 percent of Russia’s national debt.

As for Mars, don’t underestimate the challenge of taking an unmanned craft to Mars and making a successful landing. Earth to the moon is 238,900 miles. Earth to Mars is about 160,786,000 miles. The fact that humans have been able to land craft on the surface of Mars is absolutely amazing.

Of course, there’s bad stuff on the internet, but the invention of the internet has been an absolutely revolutionary scientific innovation. Its impact goes far beyond the impact of radio, TV, or film. The internet has allowed the almost instantaneous sharing of information virtually anywhere in the world. It has transformed almost every area of human activity. It’s changed how we engage in economic activity, how we fight wars, how our political system works, how we study, and how we communicate with people all over the world.

I do agree that those women were only building on the achievements of previous generations, but the truly extraordinary thing is how women holding positions of power has become completely normal. In the UK, for example, four out of their last six home secretaries have been women. In Finland, 12 out of the 19 ministers in their government are women, including the prime minister and deputy prime minister. Their government is a coalition of five parties, all of which are led by women. 47 percent of members of the Finnish parliament are women. Since 1789 only 56 women have served in the US Senate. The first was Rebecca Felton, who served for one day in 1922. Today, however, 25 US senators are women (increasing to 26 on 3 January next year). Crucially, between 1922 and 1992 the number of women in the senate fluctuated between zero, one, and two: there was no overall growth in numbers. Since 1992, however, the number of women in the senate has been steadily increasing. It’s reasonable to guess that within a generation women will make up 50 percent of the US Senate.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top