How would we enforce new abortion laws?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JimG
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Strongly disagree, where does it say specifically that killing is wrong? Everywhere in the bible.
Okay, what I’m saying here is this:

We are the ones who decided that abortion = murder. We are the ones who interpreted scripture. Just because you decided based upon scripture does not mean that you are inherently correct about your inference.
 
Assuming that abortion is outlawed throughout the U.S. and effective enforcement is put in place across the country, the process will impact mostly poor people. Rich and middle class people seeking an abortion will simply hop a flight to Canada. Thus, for a great many Americans the question really is, will Canada enforce U.S. abortion laws? Will Canada welcome abortion tourists, or will it resist being sucked in to the controversy?
 
Okay, what I’m saying here is this:

We are the ones who decided that abortion = murder. We are the ones who interpreted scripture. Just because you decided based upon scripture does not mean that you are inherently correct about your inference.
God decided abortion is murder. Who decided killing people with guns is murder? It doesn’t say in the bible. But we know it’s murder.
 
Show me the word “abortion” in the Bible. Because verses that do not explicitly mention something will be interpreted differently by every single denomination and thus hold no weight in this argument. None of them mention abortion. None of them. They say not to murder, and humans are the ones who have made the abortion connection based on other scriptural verses.

Not once is abortion mentioned, as I said.
You’re refusing to see clear Biblical evidence in front of you because you don’t want to be wrong.

Bible clearly mentions that babies are a person with a plan from God from the time they are in the womb.

Bible clearly mentions that killing is wrong.

Abortion ends the life of a baby in the womb.

Not too hard to connect the dots.
 
You’re refusing to see clear Biblical evidence in front of you because you don’t want to be wrong.

Bible clearly mentions that babies are a person with a plan from God from the time they are in the womb.

Bible clearly mentions that killing is wrong.

Abortion ends the life of a baby in the womb.

Not too hard to connect the dots.
Not. Once. Is. Abortion. Mentioned.

What am I wrong about in the statement that not once is abortion mentioned in the Bible?

We’re not discussing whether your interpretation is correct or not. I am telling you:

Not. Once. Is. Abortion. Mentioned.
 
Not. Once. Is. Abortion. Mentioned.

What am I wrong about in the statement that not once is abortion mentioned in the Bible?

We’re not discussing whether your interpretation is correct or not. I am telling you:

Not. Once. Is. Abortion. Mentioned.
Not once are guns mentioned.
 
God decided abortion is murder. Who decided killing people with guns is murder? It doesn’t say in the bible. But we know it’s murder.
Guns are a weapon that did not exist at the time of biblical writing. Abortion is a procedure that did exist at the time of biblical writing.
 
You’re refusing to see clear Biblical evidence in front of you because you don’t want to be wrong.

Bible clearly mentions that babies are a person with a plan from God from the time they are in the womb.

Bible clearly mentions that killing is wrong.

Abortion ends the life of a baby in the womb.

Not too hard to connect the dots.
Yet Yahweh can kill babies in the bible and no one bats an eye. What exactly did they do to deserve death. If we really want to dig into it why exactly would Yahweh cause miscarriages/spontaneous abortions? Why would a baby be born with cancer just to die in a few weeks or months causing more heartache for families?
 
Not. Once. Is. Abortion. Mentioned.

What am I wrong about in the statement that not once is abortion mentioned in the Bible?

We’re not discussing whether your interpretation is correct or not. I am telling you:

Not. Once. Is. Abortion. Mentioned.
You are wrong in that “thou shall not kill” is very specifically mentioned. It also very specifically mentions that we are people from the time we are the womb. Therefore, while abortion is not mentioned by name, it’s clearly covered. There is nothing to interpret.
 
Yet Yahweh can kill babies in the bible and no one bats an eye. What exactly did they do to deserve death. If we really want to dig into it why exactly would Yahweh cause miscarriages/spontaneous abortions? Why would a baby be born with cancer just to die in a few weeks or months causing more heartache for families?
Why does anyone die at all? It’s not for man to decide, but God.
 
You are wrong in that “thou shall not kill” is very specifically mentioned. It also very specifically mentions that we are people from the time we are the womb. Therefore, while abortion is not mentioned by name, it’s clearly covered. There is nothing to interpret.
Oh boy, you’re just… Not getting this.

If there is nothing to interpret, I don’t think every single denomination would have so many different views on the matter.

Go ahead and keep making your argument against abortion over and over in each post you direct towards me, but I’m just going to continue saying that I am not discussing the validity of your argument, I’m discussing the fact that your interpretation is not gospel.
 
Oh boy, you’re just… Not getting this.

If there is nothing to interpret, I don’t think every single denomination would have so many different views on the matter.

Go ahead and keep making your argument against abortion over and over in each post you direct towards me, but I’m just going to continue saying that I am not discussing the validity of your argument, I’m discussing the fact that your interpretation is not gospel.
You my friend, are the one who’s “not getting it”.
 
I’m assuming that you believe in the Trinity. Guess what. The Trinity is not mentioned in the bible.

Is yours?
I have not mentioned my “interpretation” on this thread so I don’t see the relevancy of my interpretation when even the interpretations being expressed on here are irrelevant to my point.
 
I have not mentioned my “interpretation” on this thread so I don’t see the relevancy of my interpretation when even the interpretations being expressed on here are irrelevant to my point.
Please reread that post. I decided that it was lacking charity, my apologies for that, and rewrote it heavily. My point with interpretation is that we need an interpreter for scripture. As a Catholic, the Church is that interpreter.

I don’t think that it is much of a stretch to apply the law for born human beings to unborn human beings.
 
Please reread that post. I decided that it was lacking charity, my apologies for that, and rewrote it heavily. My point with interpretation is that we need an interpreter for scripture. As a Catholic, the Church is that interpreter.

I don’t think that it is much of a stretch to apply the law for born human beings to unborn human beings.
I agree that an interpreter is needed, but I have not yet fully come to the conclusion on whether or not the Catholic Church is that interpreter or not. As you can see, I am not Catholic, though I am researching heavily.
 
I agree that an interpreter is needed, but I have not yet fully come to the conclusion on whether or not the Catholic Church is that interpreter or not. As you can see, I am not Catholic, though I am researching heavily.
Abortion is evil, and the catholic church is the interpreter.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top