Hung Parliament in UK?

  • Thread starter Thread starter OraLabora
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It would appear the Labour Party has successfully rallied young people to vote.

If the exit poll is correct it will be interesting to see what will happen. The number 326 is used as the minimum to have a majority in the Commons but it’s likely to be lower because Sinn Fein MPs don’t take their seats because they would have to swear allegiance to the Queen. And the polls seem to show Northern Ireland will have the same distribution of seats so the number may be 324. If the exit poll is correct, 314 for the Tories and assuming Northern Ireland won’t give a different result, the two unionist NI parties (8 DUP, 2 UUP) will have quite a bit of influence on the Tories.
 
Well, well, well. A slap down for the politics of nastiness. Looks like the UK is a bit more concerned about domestic issues than Mrs May banked upon.
 
Gridlock isn’t that bad. No one will have an agenda to push through in theory.
 
You know what I think is a factor here? We’ve had dreadful terrorism and our response has been for everyone to focus on positivity and hopefulness. May ran a campaign of unpleasant smears and attacks and Corbyn ran one based on positive hope. You can argue it is pie in the sky, but it tapped into a mood of hopeful defiance, particularly among the young people I know.
 
I’m sad but actually not all that surprised. Corbyn and Labour had been surging in the polls. After Macron won I kind of wondered if this might happen though I have no idea if that had any influence or not - it is doubtful I guess. Perhaps even the Conservatives sensed the possibility of a defeat, but it was too late to do anything about it once the mood changed. Probably should not have called the general election. 😉 Shades of Cameron and the EU referendum. I hope they can pull Brexit out one way or another. Sounds like gridlock at this point, no side strong enough to govern. (I also wonder if a lot of the pro EU mentality is just anti-Trump sentiment mobilizing.)
 
Not my own words, but I think a fair assessment of the situation:

“Just like with Trump. When a government fails it’s population for so long, people make desperate choices. We’ve seen a massive wave of populism from frustrated people. If establishment politicians want to keep up, they need to change.”

Brexit, Trump, Macron and now Corbyn. In all cases a rejection of the political mainstream and a populist appeal to alienated voters who feel the system isn’t working, and for whom a fundamental change is promised without consideration for how it can be delivered.

I’d be suprised if half those voting for labour actually read Corbyn’s manifesto pledges or shared his hard-left attitude or were prepared to pay for his wish list policies (for one they would extend abortion to make it legal in northern Ireland!). And the impact of two terrorist attacks during the campaign can’t be ignored. Instead it wasn’t so much a vote for Corbyn, but a vote against the conservatives.

In consequence we now have no government at a moment of enormous danger for the country given the hostile brexit negotiations due to start in two weeks. No majority for any party was the worst possible outcome according to the analysts in the run up to today. There’ll probably be another election within 12 months because of this.
 
Not my own words, but I think a fair assessment of the situation:

Brexit, Trump, Macron and now Corbyn. In all cases a rejection of the political mainstream and a populist appeal to alienated voters who feel the system isn’t working, and for whom a fundamental change is promised without consideration for how it can be delivered.

I’d be suprised if half those voting for labour actually read Corbyn’s manifesto pledges or shared his hard-left attitude or were prepared to pay for his wish list policies (for one they would extend abortion to make it legal in northern Ireland!). And the impact of two terrorist attacks during the campaign can’t be ignored. Instead it wasn’t so much a vote for Corbyn, but a vote against the conservatives.

In consequence we now have no government at a moment of enormous danger for the country given the hostile brexit negotiations due to start in two weeks. No majority for any party was the worst possible outcome according to the analysts in the run up to today. There’ll probably be another election within 12 months because of this.
I agree it just seems like another protest vote. Kind of crazy when you think that at one point May was so far ahead in the polls she declined to debate Corbyn in order to avoid embarrassment. I will not be surprised if this just happens now over and over. No political party holds power for very long. No agenda is every really realized, stabilized. People vote based on current mood, anger - whichever side is angrier wins the election.
 
I agree it just seems like another protest vote. Kind of crazy when you think that at one point May was so far ahead in the polls she declined to debate Corbyn in order to avoid embarrassment. I will not be surprised if this just happens now over and over. No political party holds power for very long. No agenda is every really realized, stabilized. People vote based on current mood, anger - whichever side is angrier wins the election.
It’s almost as though the British people have decided to run across some railway tracks (brexit risk, for better or worse). But having gotten halfway across, are now content to stand indecisively listening to the sound of the oncoming train…

Thank God I’m Catholic. If I were still an atheist I’d have lost faith in my “secular gods” by now.
 
There’s a streak of stubbornness in the British character that means we don’t always do what is sensible.
 
There’s a streak of stubbornness in the British character that means we don’t always do what is sensible.
True, sadly. Our education system’s curriculum is apallingly devoid of philosophy and critical thinking.

It’s great for a materialistic consumer society which responds easily to advertising, prejudice and media bias, but is it any wonder we don’t know how to make decisions when we’re never taught to think critically?
 
It looks like Sinn Fein will win six seats so the Tories will need 323.
The forecast from the BBC for the Tories is 318 and the DUP has won 10 seats gaining one from the UUP and surprisingly one from the nationalist SDLP. Whoever will lead the Conservatives will have to answer to the DUP. I can’t see Labour or the Lib Dems will work with the Tories on anything.
 
It looks like Sinn Fein will win six seats so the Tories will need 323.
The forecast from the BBC for the Tories is 318 and the DUP has won 10 seats gaining one from the UUP and surprisingly one from the nationalist SDLP. Whoever will lead the Conservatives will have to answer to the DUP. I can’t see Labour or the Lib Dems will work with the Tories on anything.
And for labour to form any kind of government would need the SNP, who want to break up the UK, so a second independence referendum would be their price.

This result isn’t a win for anyone regardless of what Labour supporters may say on twitter. Nobody has won this election, everybody lost, includig the British people.
 
And for labour to form any kind of government would need the SNP, who want to break up the UK, so a second independence referendum would be their price.

This result isn’t a win for anyone regardless of what Labour supporters may say on twitter. Nobody has won this election, everybody lost, includig the British people.
And the fault for this self-inflicted mess lies entirely with Theresa May for calling an election she had absolutely no need to hold out of a naked desire to increase her majority, only to seemingly lose it.

We are heading off to Brussels to negotiate Brexit in a terribly weakened state of political chaos and without a mandate from the people on what kind of Brexit it should be now that May’s model has clearly been rejected.

This is the most embarrassing faux pas by a Prime Minister in British history. She has self-imploded before the eyes of the public and the world.

Can you even begin to imagine what they must be thinking in Brussels, Berlin and Paris? It’s just a huge national embarrassment.
 
And the fault for this self-inflicted mess lies entirely with Theresa May for calling an election she had absolutely no need to hold out of a naked desire to increase her majority, only to seemingly lose it.

We are heading off to Brussels to negotiate Brexit in a terribly weakened state of political chaos and without a mandate from the people on what kind of Brexit it should be now that May’s model has clearly been rejected.

This is the most embarrassing faux pas by a Prime Minister in British history. She has self-imploded before the eyes of the public and the world.

Can you even begin to imagine what they must be thinking in Brussels, Berlin and Paris? It’s just a huge national embarrassment.
I was going to say exactly the same thing. This message is completely of her own making.
 
Some significant updates:

bbc.co.uk/news/live/election-2017-40171454
**On the BBC Prof John Curtice, its elections expert, has just said that his analysts cannot see any circumstances now in which the Tories could win a majority.
He also said that academic literature shows that often calling a snap election can backfire. Voters suspect that the election is being called to pre-empt some bad news in the pipeline, he said.
John Curtice: Pretty clear there will be hung parliament
The exit poll might be one, two or three seats out, but it’s pretty clear there will be a hung parliament.
Maybe in the end this could be the most accurate exit poll yet.**
theguardian.com/politics/live/2017/jun/08/general-election-results-2017-uk-live-labour-tories-corbyn-may-election-results-live-news-line
**This, from David Davis earlier, is worth noting. Davis, the Brexit secretary, seemed to admit that the government could lose its mandate to take the UK out of the single market and the customs union.
Matthew Holehouse
(@mattholehouse)
Huge: David Davis concedes UK government may have lost mandate to exit customs union and single market (Sky, 2.30am). pic.twitter.com/9o9oxrvhf0**
 
Ack. Right royal dogs breakfast. I can’t recall the last time I saw something so astonishingly Ill judged.
 
bbc.co.uk/news/live/election-2017-40171454
**Can Theresa May stay as PM?
The conversations have started not just about whether the Tories will be able to form a government, but whether or not Theresa May can stay in her job.
There is no one prevailing mood inside the Tory party. As I write, Mrs May is holed up with her advisers inside Tory HQ. But a former minister Anna Soubry has called for her to “consider her position” - political code for calling for her to resign.
Another senior MP tells me ‘I can’t see how she can stay’. A minister texts to say the Tory party is ‘absolute monarchy, ruled by regicide and that’s the territory we are in’. One Tory source says it is ‘50:50’ that she will quit in the morning.
But others are urging caution, calling for reflection, a period of calm.
It’s clear the Tory party won’t allow her to stay on to fight another general election campaign in some years hence. But cooler heads may press on her to stay, not to walk away. This is the election none of the main parties predicted.
Just as David Cameron finished off his own career by gambling with the EU referendum he didn’t have to have, Theresa May has followed him by calling a national vote when it was not required, because of our relationship with the European Union, and ended her career in the same way.**
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top