I’m 20 she’s 42

  • Thread starter Thread starter thome600
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The post was edited. She previously said her FATHER had her mother at 45.
Then I’m sorry. I speak about 7 languages so I bend my mind around anything I come across.

BTW, met a Polish youngster touring Europe on peanut-butter, took him out for lunch, payed his commuter and gave him a pack of smokes…
 
Notice that I did not mention anything about the rightness or wrongness about a substantial age gap.

I just mentioned something about my own personal preference.

I prefer to grow old with someone who is from my generation. Nothing wrong with that either.
 
I’m always sensitive to these types of comments as one of my parents was in their 40’s and much older than my other parent. Yes there is a slight increase in some problems with older parents, but much of that depends on many many other factors including the general health of the parent who is older and other environmental factors.
My maternal grandfather was 21 years older than his wife. They had seven children together and were devout catholics all the way to the grave. They were cousins and had to get a dispentsation from the church to be able to marry. The marriage wasn’t accepted by much of the family and when they needed help, they were left alone. One of their children, that is, one of my aunts, has a severe genetically caused disorder caused possibly by that or possibly be their age. Neverthless, they loved this daughter the same as all the others and cared for her until they died. They had a tough life. They never had much money. My grandfather was a sailor and sometimes that meant he was away from the family for longer periods.

Despite being so much younger, my grandmother actually passed away before my grandfather. Before my birth even, so I never knew here. I remember my grandfather though.
 
Last edited:
You’re twenty, so you’ve probably never heard it, but years ago, there was a song called “Hey Nineteen”. It was about a middle aged guy who thought it would be fun to date a hot young college co-ed. As the song goes on, he realizes it was a mistake because they have absolutely nothing in common, and goes back to his friends his own age to commiserate.

I don’t think it’s wise for a variety of reasons and, no offense to you, but I’m wondering why she would think this is a good idea. Other than just being insecure about her age, I don’t know what she hopes to get out of a relationship with somebody who doesn’t have the same experiences (or, at twenty years old, any experiences, for that matter). I don’t see this ending well for either one of you.

And I’m not Catholic, but I have to wonder how you’d handle the fact that she’s almost reached the finish line, as far as child bearing goes. Seems like, as a Catholic, that would complicate your sex life some.

Sorry to be so blunt about it, but I’d rather hurt your feelings for a few minutes than have you make a mistake that will haunt you for years.

Incidentally, when he played for the Phillies, Jim Thome lived down the street from my sister and her husband.
 
Last edited:
There are so many young Catholic girls looking for young Catholic men. This relationship is not wrong on a legal standpoint but think of the implications of the future, if you were to commit to this woman.
 
What really is the threat to people here on a personal level that people are so concerned about. What am I missing?
Most people, including most Catholics, have a serious aversion to any relationship that’s “outside the box” of what they were taught to think of as a “normal” one.

The ex-boyfriend of mine whom I mentioned earlier in the thread could not fathom people having a baby in their late 30s or early 40s because that had not been his experience. He assumed that a 50-year-old parent of a 10-year-old would be unable to play with his or her children or keep up with them. My dad was 40 when I was born and he played with me all through my childhood. When I was 10 years old and Dad was 50, then unless it was snowing or raining out, we were out in the yard every night playing handball, badminton, or whiffle ball after Dad got home from work.

Those of us who have actually seen younger men marrying older women, in some cases having kids, staying married for decades (my friends in this situation have been married for about 35 years at this point) don’t see it as a bad or threatening thing. Others who’ve never seen it work have different opinions.

As I already mentioned up-thread in a post that got hidden, it’s best if people don’t try to crowd-source their relationship decisions. If I had based my relationship decisions on this forum, I would never have married my husband, because he wasn’t a Catholic and wouldn’t convert and everyone would have predicted the marriage was doomed. Fortunately, I don’t poll a group before I decide to do something. I am happier for it.
 
Last edited:
What really is the threat to people here on a personal level that people are so concerned about. What am I missing?
I do not think anyone was threatened by the relationship. The OP asked for two questions. One had to do with Church law, which everyone answered accurately. The other was more general as to people’s opinions on such a relationship. Folks answered. Some, myself included, thought it was a bad idea. That in no ways implies any of us feel personally threatened by it. I certainly don’t see why it should puzzle you.
 
I thought was in response to my formula examples. But that’s the point. Many of us do think there is something wrong, or at least not right, with the relationship. If my 20 year old child was dating a 42 year old, I wouldn’t be too happy about it. It is “icky”. Ickyness is not against the law, church or secular, but the law does not proscribe all vices.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for taking the time to show us your lack of manners. Always good when somebody tells you up front you should block them.

Sure. A wise person can learn anything from anybody. But it was my understanding that the OP wasn’t merely talking about learning something from somebody, but about entering into a serious romantic relationship with someone. Maybe you have a different understanding, but my response to him was based on his premise of entering into a possible serious relationship with someone.
 
Sorry but your exemple is not representative.
Some women had children very late, but for others their fertility would be erratic much more soon.
It cannot use to convince another person that having a child in their 40’s and even less in their 50’s will be possible.
If the percentage of women who had children late in their reproductive life had skyrocked in the recent decades, it is mostly thanks to artificial reproduction.
 
Sorry, I meant “not quite right”, my brain was ahead of my fingers I suppose.

Perhaps this is were we differ. Yes we are called to be married, but I think God rarely calls a individual to marry another particular individual. That sounds like a the definition of what a soul mate would be, which I generally think is a bad concept. There are exceptions, Mary and Joseph come to mind, but in general I don’t think so.
 
I don’t think anyone said it was morally wrong, just that in their personal opinion, such a huge age gap could be problematic in a number of ways. A 22-year age gap between romantic partners is bound to make some people uncomfortable, possibly even more so (dare I say it)when the woman is the older one. In this case, she is easily old enough to be his mother. The OP is free take or leave those opinions, but if he does end up pursuing a relationship with this lady, he might as well get used to the idea that many will look askance at it.
 
This man is 20, and this woman is 42, she’s old enough to be his mother, and he isn’t even old enough to buy a beer! Not even old enough to buy a beer! Let that sink in for a moment.

Is this woman a widow, divorcee, or never married? I seriously question her motives for dating you, as I fear they may not be the most pure.

There are serious maturity issues here as well. Your brain is still developing, the human brain doesn’t stop growing and developing until the age of 25. At your age difference I’d be quite protective if I were one of your parents.
 
Of course it’s not representative.

I never said it was.

If you looked at my other posts I said that one had a much greater chance of having children if one were younger.
 
And more, in the current society, in my opinion very few man of 20 years old are ready emotionnally to get married for life. And rarely work and had enough to support themselves and a family.

So, should they wait until some years that he matured enough? And get married at an age where the chances of having children were none or erratic?
Should they wait and then split because they are no longer compatible? And have suppress a lot of chances of this woman to find someone else?
Should they marry in a near future, with a man who cannot support his family, and the wife having to support financially his husband? And if they had children, she cannot rely on the financial support of her husband she she still had to work hard to support all the family? Some inverses values?

Of course they can have a great compatibility and chemistry. He can prefer to be with an older woman and her with a younger one. But the outcomes are so that in my opinion, it should be discouraged. It is not the most effective way to create a great catholic family.

I also think that the question asked by the OP seems naive.
 
Last edited:
At your age difference I’d be quite protective if I were one of your parents.
This. Of everyone who thinks it’s fine and dandy, they are adults after all, would you not strongly caution your 20 yo son or daughter against a relationship with a 42 yo? I will admit ahead of time, I will have a hard time believing you if you answer no.
 
All right, well a little bit of dating advice then. I and many others on here have some concerns about the nature of this relationship.

On your first date then I’d pay close attention to the way she’s dressed. If she’s wearing anything tight and form fitting, or a low cut top/dress or a short skirt/dress, with very high heels, a lot of makeup and very fancy hair, she probably doesn’t have the purest intentions towards you.

If she is more modestly and sensibly dressed for your date then that shows she has good intentions in my opinion. And by the way, my fiancée was the one who pointed out to me you should pay close attention to the way she’s dressed for your date. Women communicate with clothing, especially on dates.
 
Last edited:
If she is more modestly and sensibly dressed for your date then that shows she has good intentions in my opinion. And by the way, my fiancée was the one who pointed out to me you should pay close attention to the way she’s dressed for your date. Women communicate with clothing, especially on dates.
This is so true. I sometimes wish i had known this when I was younger. I payed far too little attention. I grew up in a sheltered and also poor environment and grew up thinking that I had this cheapish suit that I wore at job interviews, funerals and important social functions, and then I had casual stuff that I wore the rest of the time. When I went to Church, I checked my shirt didn’t have any stains or holes and that my shoes were sufficiently shiny. I must have looked a complete nerd on my first date as I wore a checkered shirt and a stripey tie. I never saw that girl again. That’s where my degree of dressing up or down stopped in those days. Many men function like that but many women don’t. I think especially young men don’t see the full scale of the subtelties in the way women present themselves.
 
Last edited:
I can’t help but notice you did not answer my question. Never the less, I will answer yours in detail. Yes, I would meet any person my kid brought home to meet. Having said that, it would make very little difference to me. I would strongly caution any 20 year old from dating/marrying a 42 year old up until the time they walked up the isle. In general, I have a strong concern for who my children end up with as a spouse, but I have always taken very little action towards that concern. It is none of my business. But if I thought a child was making a mistake, I would be very open about it. I would never treat them or a girlfriend/boyfriend badly. But I would let both know my feelings. Luckily, there has never been a situation where I have needed to so far. My kids who are married have selected pretty dang good spouses. I don’t get involved, but if I had to, I would. That involvement would be advice, respecting that they were adults and the ultimate decision was theirs. In this particular situation, I can imagine nothing that could occur which would convince me a prospective marriage with a 42 year old would be a good thing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top