I am curious about "witches"

  • Thread starter Thread starter ateista
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Do you guys and gals believe in “witches”? After all you believe in demons… What about witches? Are they just a piece of folklore? 🤷
What do you burn besides witches? MORE WITCHES! 😃

Demons are real, that’s why we believe in them. We don’t just believe in things for the sake of belief or bring stuff out of other religions and add them to Christianity. Our faith is founded on truth and reason, not on our own personal beliefs and other faiths.

Witches are those who use occultic powers - i.e., demons, since demons are the ones who give them the power to do such things; however, demons aren’t jusr forces or energies: they are creatures of God, who rebelled against God and now fight against Him and those who keep His Commandments - to do extraordinary feats, such as see into the future, know secrets, lift things into the air. Witches are not occultists in general but just one category out of many: Psychics and palm readers, spirit mediums, soothsayers, etc.
 
wickens are new age nonsense. they probably have realized there is a spiritual emptiness in their lives, but are on the wrong track.

their standard of behavior, articulated in the clever use of nonstandard english, is the rule of rede, “an’ it harm none, do as ye will.”

two minutes of thought will show this completely ethically bankrupt, i.e., there are no implicit affirmative obligations to feed the hungry, clothe the naked, nurse the sick, etc. life as an average wicken is just a joy ride where every day is a renaissance faire.
 
Oh don’t give me this. Both Protestants and Catholics killed witches in roughly equal proportions–it varied from region to region but not obviously from confession to confession. You are confusing “Catholic persecutions” in general with the Inquisition in particular. You ought to know better.

It’s also nonsense to say that the numbers surpass the “alleged inquisitional executions by orders of magnitude.” The numbers you give surpass the proven executions of the Spanish Inquisition by a figure of about 10 to 1, I believe (assuming your numbers for the Protestant witch-burnings are correct, which is a dubious assumption given your other flawed claims). Add in all the Inquisitions–all the church courts using Roman law from the 13th century on–and I’m sure that if the numbers you give are greater, it’s not by “orders of magnitude.” And of course the “alleged inquisitional executions” run into the millions. The allegations are silly, but you did use the word “alleged.”

You can defend your Church quite well without distorting the truth. You should try this tactic sometime. It would avoid getting you into fights with people like me, who are not trying to discredit Catholicism but do care a little about history.

Edwin
Ahh Edwin, so good of you to drop in here. Didn’t know you were loitering in here or I would have put up facts and figures for you ahead of time. You are simply misinformed about how many died in Catholic inquisitions vs. Protestant civil executions. At the risk of derailing the thread I’ll give my facts in a moment.

I will say that I perhaps expressed myself wrongly by using the word “alleged”. But I think you know what I meant. When I say “allegedly” it is from the Catholic perspective of suffering the popular Protestant revisionist history that has perma-worked its way into all the western high school level school books - even to this day this tripe is still taught in High School and you seem to hold to the tradition.

These histories as you should know still claim Catholic inquisitions were much more terrible than the much graver atrocities committed under the rule of protestant secular rule where . Of course its all anti-Catholic hysteria and protestant polemics that is now a fixture in our American and Western mythology (ever since the Reformation got control of the printing presses to revise history). If we believed all the hysteria, myth and legend still taught in the west then the Catholic Inquisitions would be “allegedly” responsible for slaughtering more people than ever lived in Europe at any time prior to the 1600s. Hyperbole and revisionist history is now a tradition here in the west.

It is only recent historical scholarship that has come out of JPIIs opening of the Vatican archives to historians that we see that very few people were executed in the various Catholic inquisitions. In fact most people preferred and chose the fairness and mercy and light sentences of the Catholic Inquisitional courts over hard and barbaric civil rule - especially the latter protestant government dominated civil rule.

So permit me to drop the word “alleged” and say that “as a matter of fact” Protestant countries, in particular Lutheran Germany murdered many orders of magnitude more woman for witchcraft and for other crimes than ALL the Catholic inquisitions combined in every other country ever did.
Recent investigations into the Inquisition:
In 2000 Pope John Paul II called for an “Inquisition Symposium” and opened the Vatican to 30 external historians. Their findings called into question certain long-held beliefs. It emerged that more women accused of witchcraft died in the Protestant countries than under the Inquisition. For example, the Inquisition burned 59 women in Spain, 36 in Italy and four in Portugal, while in Europe civil justice put to trial close to 100,000 women and burned 50,000 of them. Some 26,000 condemned witches died in Germany.
More here: Inquisition
Again I don’t want to hijack the thread - but if you see roughly 100 Catholic executions as “equal” to 50,000 woman burned at the stake under Protestant rule (a ratio of 1:500 !!) then I think you need to go back to school for a routine lube, oil and recalibration my friend. 😉

James
 
Sorry,

You were not clear that you meant “witches killed by the Inquisition”–you said “all Inquisitional executions.”

And I repeat: why are you focusing on the Inquisition? Catholic governments executed lots of witches without the Inquisition being involved.

Edwin
 
I am still asking if you believe in the “witches” of the Middle Ages, the women who were thought to be practitioners of “dark forces”… do you believe that they exist?

No, I don’t believe they ever did exist. That gives the devil too much power.
And that was, in fact the dominant opinion within the Church for most of the Middle Ages. Why it changed is a very interesting question which I don’t think has yet been answered. But it went along with a lot of other things–what Jean Delumeau has called an era dominated by a sense of sin and fear. It is no accident that the Reformation happened at the same time. It was born in a very troubled and violent period of Christian history.

Edwin
 
And that was, in fact the dominant opinion within the Church for most of the Middle Ages. Why it changed is a very interesting question which I don’t think has yet been answered. But it went along with a lot of other things–what Jean Delumeau has called an era dominated by a sense of sin and fear. It is no accident that the Reformation happened at the same time. It was born in a very troubled and violent period of Christian history.

Edwin
What is most ironic is that ever since the reformation we arrive at the current age of so called “secular enlightenment” where the moral pendulum has swung to the extreme opposite pole. That is, humanity to a large degree has use secular ideals to pacify its prior fears of sin and evil with the moral absurdity that there is no such thing as sin and therefor nothing to fear. But in fact demons are very real and the entire planet is currently in an intense spiritual warfare.

Given that humanity has delivered its mass consent to moral relativism I believe that it’s now inevitable that humanity will swing back to rediscover the ancient reasons for having fear of sin and evil and will encounter more raw fear and violence than it has ever before seen in history.

James
 
Witches, witchcraft, the occult, etc are all to vague and inflammatory.

I would say we definitively believe in the devil and his angels. Further, I see no reason why they could not have influence in this world and why that influence couldn’t involve a human accomplice. This of course within God’s permissible bounds (see the Book of Job, writings of St. Paul, etc)
 
Witches, witchcraft, the occult, etc are all to vague and inflammatory.

I would say we definitively believe in the devil and his angels. Further, I see no reason why they could not have influence in this world and why that influence couldn’t involve a human accomplice. This of course within God’s permissible bounds (see the Book of Job, writings of St. Paul, etc)
I agree in concept. Anyone in a state of mortal sin (I suspect that is probably more than 85% of the planet at any given hour of the day) is essentially a living agent of Satan irrespective if we call them witches, pagans, heathens, pawns, thralls etc. That is, a person in a state of mortal sin who remains unresponsive to the call to repentance through universal grace is essentially passively working for Satan either by example or deed or directly by active and deliberate efforts to undermine God’s people and Church.

James
 
Obviously there are many interpretations of this word. I am still asking if you believe in the “witches” of the Middle Ages, the women who were thought to be practitioners of “dark forces”… do you believe that they exist?
There are women who are practitioners of the dark arts . Some are very powerful in their craft, some just wish the tart who stole her husband will grown moles. Do they cackle, fly on brooms and dress in black with conical hats with wide brims? No, but I wouldn’t underestimate them either.
 
Obviously there are many interpretations of this word. I am still asking if you believe in the “witches” of the Middle Ages, the women who were thought to be practitioners of “dark forces”… do you believe that they exist?
I certainly believe in witchcraft and the occult. They are spoken of in the Bible. Saul and his sons consulted a witch in order to speak to the prophet Samuel after he died. For this, god punished Saul. He and his son died in battle the next day, just as the ghost of Samuel warned.

As strngth mentioned, there clearly are witches. I think asking whether I believe witches exist is a little like asking whether astronauts exist. Of course they do, but most of us do not knowingly run into one every day.
 
Are there people who meddle with preternatural stuff that is very bad for them? Definitely. Do some of those people try to make contact with evil spirits, and perhaps succeed? Probably. Is there or has there ever been a large, organized community of people who worship Satan? Probably not. Accounts pointing to such a community always seem unreliable and stereotyped, and often look as if they were manufactured for sensationalistic reasons. Even if there is, it isn’t something Christians should freak out about. We believe that Satan has already been defeated on the Cross and can only harm us if we let him.

Edwin
That probably depends on what you call a “large organized community” In Chicago and its surrounding suburbs there are lots of forest preserves. My friend Vince is a cop in one of the southwest suburbs and he has told me that frequently they find evidence of satanic rituals and sacrifice in the forest preserve on his patrol route.
 
I agree in concept. Anyone in a state of mortal sin (I suspect that is probably more than 85% of the planet at any given hour of the day) is essentially a living agent of Satan irrespective if we call them witches, pagans, heathens, pawns, thralls etc. That is, a person in a state of mortal sin who remains unresponsive to the call to repentance through universal grace is essentially passively working for Satan either by example or deed or directly by active and deliberate efforts to undermine God’s people and Church.

James
Wow, that is one serious assertion!

Did you forget the Muslims, Hindus, Buddhists, Protestants (all belonging to your “etc.”) or was that just an unintentional omission? And yes, I included the Protestants, too, since they are not part of the “Church”, which is usually reserved for the “one true Church”… namely the Catholic Church.

We all are the “passive” followers of Satan? Sheesh. 😉

No wonder that Satan is “winning” the battle! With so many followers it is not a surprise.
 
wickens are new age nonsense. they probably have realized there is a spiritual emptiness in their lives, but are on the wrong track.

their standard of behavior, articulated in the clever use of nonstandard english, is the rule of rede, “an’ it harm none, do as ye will.”

two minutes of thought will show this completely ethically bankrupt, i.e., there are no implicit affirmative obligations to feed the hungry, clothe the naked, nurse the sick, etc. life as an average wicken is just a joy ride where every day is a renaissance faire.
First off it is spelled Wiccan.

Second there is more to Neo-Pagan morality than “Harm None.” One of the largest American Pagan organizations the ADF for example requires it’s groves to do community service including a major project during the Fall, Winter, Spring and Summer (Ian if your reading this please correct me if I am wrong this is what I know of it).

Pagans often do great charity work. Just they rarely do the “LOOK AT US LOOK AT US! WE ARE DOING CHARITY!” attitude that so many Christians and Catholics do. Such as how many Christian books claim (falsely) that the Christianity gave us Hospitals.

Fun fact: Early Christian hospitals were more along the lines of a Modern Hospice a place to go to die. It was Buddhism, Paganism and Islam that really kick started modern medical practices with Christianity acting as a sort of gathering places for information on this an bring it together.
 
First off it is spelled Wiccan.

Second there is more to Neo-Pagan morality than “Harm None.” One of the largest American Pagan organizations the ADF for example requires it’s groves to do community service including a major project during the Fall, Winter, Spring and Summer (Ian if your reading this please correct me if I am wrong this is what I know of it).

Pagans often do great charity work. Just they rarely do the “LOOK AT US LOOK AT US! WE ARE DOING CHARITY!” attitude that so many Christians and Catholics do. Such as how many Christian books claim (falsely) that the Christianity gave us Hospitals.

Fun fact: Early Christian hospitals were more along the lines of a Modern Hospice a place to go to die. It was Buddhism, Paganism and Islam that really kick started modern medical practices with Christianity acting as a sort of gathering places for information on this an bring it together.
Athiests do a lot of charity work too, but the Church teaches that even doing good things is sin if they are not done for the love of God .
 
Athiests do a lot of charity work too, but the Church teaches that even doing good things is sin if they are not done for the love of God .
You made me very curious. Where does the Church teach that? And is it a mortal sin or a venial sin?
 
Athiests do a lot of charity work too, but the Church teaches that even doing good things is sin if they are not done for the love of God .
Where do you find this taught by the Church? I thought this was one of the differences between Catholicism and traditional Protestantism.

Failure to love God is, of course, sinful. But that’s a bit different from saying that the good work is itself a sin.

Edwin
 
You made me very curious. Where does the Church teach that? And is it a mortal sin or a venial sin?
I have heard this many times and I THINK I read it in the Catechism, but I can’t provide you a specific reference.
 
I have heard this many times and I THINK I read it in the Catechism, but I can’t provide you a specific reference.
I think I know what you’re trying to get at though. Good works without love are an empty act, whether you are Christian, Buddhist, or atheist. I think what we’re getting tripped up on here is the concept of good works outside the Church as necessarily equal to good works without love of God.

Sure, it seems more likely that an atheist’s “reasons” for good works will not be equivalent to a Christian’s, or a Wiccans, but you can make all the statistical deductions you want, and only God knows the heart and intent, even more so than the persons themselves.

Not everyone has the gift of the Church’s Truth; a person could be loving God without knowing that it is God he is loving.
 
Failure to love God is, of course, sinful.
I heard that on these boards. I even started a thread on the subject. The Catholic posters unanimously asserted that NOT loving God is a sin, moreover a mortal sin.

What they failed to explain is, HOW could I love God, whose very existence I do not believe? And if I DID believe in God’s existence, I would have a very low opinion about him - based upon my experience in the world.

In what manner is it just to demand the “love” for God, if there is no actual (and factual) evidence that he exists? Maybe someone can explain this to me…
 
I heard that on these boards. I even started a thread on the subject. The Catholic posters unanimously asserted that NOT loving God is a sin, moreover a mortal sin.

What they failed to explain is, HOW could I love God, whose very existence I do not believe? And if I DID believe in God’s existence, I would have a very low opinion about him - based upon my experience in the world.

In what manner is it just to demand the “love” for God, if there is no actual (and factual) evidence that he exists? Maybe someone can explain this to me…
I’m not going to try and prove God’s existence to you, since you’ve proved quite resistant to any such attempts. But I will say that according to Church teaching one can love God by seeking to follow his will as written in every human heart. This assumes, of course, that the person’s rejection of the concept of God is not a rejection of God himself. How often this condition is met is something only God knows.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top