I am seriously starting to become Pro-Catholic, please help...need advice

  • Thread starter Thread starter ConflictedBoy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

ConflictedBoy

Guest
Ok, here is the story. I have seriously, in the past few weeks or so, becoming interested to lean more and more about the Catholic Church, to see what its all about, its history, practices etc. Its, idk, I have become drawn to Catholicism in such a away that I cannot just ignore. The past two weeks I have been reading up about Catholic doctrine and history and its almost like some kind of addiction, I find myself more motivated to look up and examine facts about the “early church” and such, and its all so fascinating…Maybe its a phase? Maybe it’s the enlightening hand of God trying to show me what is right? I dont know. All I know is if God is trying to tell me something, I am listening

Just to start, I am Protestant, I was “raised” Protestant (thus far im still being “raised”)
That being said, I could admit that it used to be I didnt care much for Catholicism, I used to be this big supporter of Martin Luther and his “Justification by Faith”; when i first read of that in history class I looked him almost like a pseudo God (dont worry, we Protestants dont worship Luther i think most at our church dont even know who he is .little joke…very little).

Anyway. ummm I have been reading and study. a LOT all about the saints, about the Vatican II and why many catholics today are disenchanted by it, about liturgy, vestiments, and how the protestant churches (save for episcopalisn, tho they’re not exactly protestant)gave 2000 years of traditionaion up and for what? to stray from cathedrals and worship in football stadiums? Not to get political but they also support an unjust war, judge others, and they dont even like immigration, ive just, i have a lot of experience with these people, and they ALL regard guns as a birthright. And Im actually referring to more to evangelical christians rather than the mainline protestant church i go to which is not bad at all. but it still lacks when compared to more elaborate masses., having communion very sunday, etc.

The Point Is,all the reading I have done lately. all the new information I have on Catholicism, I am becoming more and more convinced that the Catholic Church is the church in which The Lord Jesus Christ established upon the rock of Peter — “You are Peter and Upon This Rock I will Build My Church, and the Gates of Hell will have no power over it.”

I have also been reading about Protestant history, and the more splits I see, about this, that and the other thing, the more I realise that we protestants worship and believe the way we do just because some man said so.

That being said, I have decided I want to be a Catholic. I am torn between Roman Catholicim and Anglicanism at the moment (thats a different story) but as of now, I no longer believe in Protestant theology or its liturgy lacking simplicity. The church that I a, currently a (baptised) member im of requires almost no preparation for being received into the church. And im guessing many of them dont evem know where their own denomination came from.

And the funny thnig is, I have been Praying the Hail Mary now, followed by the Our Father and Glory Be, each night. I make the sign of the cross before i leave home, Im not even Catholic, still dont know if i’ll ever be and yet doing that has brought more peace to me in prayer than I had known in while. I have become a Catholic-At-Heart. And I supposed that is the first step.

Now, what (if any) approach should I take from here? Go and talk about RCIA? Keep in mind im still a kid, not a LITTLE kid lol but a teen. My parents havent taken us to church in months now, and my mom’s family is strongly protestant and my dad’s parents are moderate, maybe nominal (i shouldnt say because i dont know them that well) catholics. My dad is anti-Catholic, not to the extend to where he thinks Catholics are unsaved, but he is not going to like it if i tell him. My grandfather is a Deacon of a Baptist church and has given me a lot of money so I could go on Baptist sponsored mission trips so I KNOW he won’t take it well. My Mother tho not a catholic is a little more catholic minded, she has pictures of the Virgin Mary in our house, (you would think we were catholics if you visited us) and the last supper painting with crucifix hanging from it and such.

And then I don’t want to tell my girlfriend because she is going to think that im trying to convert for her because she is catholic.

Please give me any and all good advice you can. Plus I know a few weeks of contemplation is a very short time. Any and all advice would be helpful…thank you

Sincerely

A Catholic-At-Heart
 
Ok, here is the story. I have seriously, in the past few weeks or so, becoming interested to lean more and more about the Catholic Church, to see what its all about, its history, practices etc. Its, idk, I have become drawn to Catholicism in such a away that I cannot just ignore. The past two weeks I have been reading up about Catholic doctrine and history and its almost like some kind of addiction, I find myself more motivated to look up and examine facts about the “early church” and such, and its all so fascinating…Maybe its a phase? Maybe it’s the enlightening hand of God trying to show me what is right? I dont know. All I know is if God is trying to tell me something, I am listening

Just to start, I am Protestant, I was “raised” Protestant (thus far im still being “raised”)
That being said, I could admit that it used to be I didnt care much for Catholicism, I used to be this big supporter of Martin Luther and his “Justification by Faith”; when i first read of that in history class I looked him almost like a pseudo God (dont worry, we Protestants dont worship Luther i think most at our church dont even know who he is .little joke…very little).

Anyway. ummm I have been reading and study. a LOT all about the saints, about the Vatican II and why many catholics today are disenchanted by it, about liturgy, vestiments, and how the protestant churches (save for episcopalisn, tho they’re not exactly protestant)gave 2000 years of traditionaion up and for what? to stray from cathedrals and worship in football stadiums? Not to get political but they also support an unjust war, judge others, and they dont even like immigration, ive just, i have a lot of experience with these people, and they ALL regard guns as a birthright. And Im actually referring to more to evangelical christians rather than the mainline protestant church i go to which is not bad at all. but it still lacks when compared to more elaborate masses., having communion very sunday, etc.

The Point Is,all the reading I have done lately. all the new information I have on Catholicism, I am becoming more and more convinced that the Catholic Church is the church in which The Lord Jesus Christ established upon the rock of Peter — “You are Peter and Upon This Rock I will Build My Church, and the Gates of Hell will have no power over it.”

I have also been reading about Protestant history, and the more splits I see, about this, that and the other thing, the more I realise that we protestants worship and believe the way we do just because some man said so.

That being said, I have decided I want to be a Catholic. I am torn between Roman Catholicim and Anglicanism at the moment (thats a different story) but as of now, I no longer believe in Protestant theology or its liturgy lacking simplicity. The church that I a, currently a (baptised) member im of requires almost no preparation for being received into the church. And im guessing many of them dont evem know where their own denomination came from.

And the funny thnig is, I have been Praying the Hail Mary now, followed by the Our Father and Glory Be, each night. I make the sign of the cross before i leave home, Im not even Catholic, still dont know if i’ll ever be and yet doing that has brought more peace to me in prayer than I had known in while. I have become a Catholic-At-Heart. And I supposed that is the first step.

Now, what (if any) approach should I take from here? Go and talk about RCIA? Keep in mind im still a kid, not a LITTLE kid lol but a teen. My parents havent taken us to church in months now, and my mom’s family is strongly protestant and my dad’s parents are moderate, maybe nominal (i shouldnt say because i dont know them that well) catholics. My dad is anti-Catholic, not to the extend to where he thinks Catholics are unsaved, but he is not going to like it if i tell him. My grandfather is a Deacon of a Baptist church and has given me a lot of money so I could go on Baptist sponsored mission trips so I KNOW he won’t take it well. My Mother tho not a catholic is a little more catholic minded, she has pictures of the Virgin Mary in our house, (you would think we were catholics if you visited us) and the last supper painting with crucifix hanging from it and such.

And then I don’t want to tell my girlfriend because she is going to think that im trying to convert for her because she is catholic.

Please give me any and all good advice you can. Plus I know a few weeks of contemplation is a very short time. Any and all advice would be helpful…thank you

Sincerely

A Catholic-At-Heart
So, I won’t respond to everything you brought up, because I’m just going to plug a book I think you should pick up.

amazon.com/This-Faith-Complete-Explanation-Catholic/dp/0895556421/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1240136014&sr=8-1
This is the Faith, by Canon Francis Ripley.

It is a catechism, but it is a “readable” Catechism. It will tell you basically everything you need to know, and I think you would find it very useful.

It deals with higher-order Catholicism, but it doesn’t use unnecessarily big and fancy words, nor is it written for a child. I seriously can’t recommend it enough.

It also seems as though you’re praying the Rosary, kinda. Ask your girlfriend about it.

Also, how old are you, exactly? I think that will help future posters in this thread give you better advice.

As a side-note, I would encourage/recommend that you change the order of your prayers. 😉 I’d do “Our Father,” then the “Hail Mary,” and then the “Glory Be.” All the prayer books I’ve seen with those three prayers in succession have it that way (Honor God first, then His Mother, and then the Trinity, I think).

Also, try attending a Traditional Latin Mass. Or, talking with a priest who offers the TLM. If you need help finding one in your area/diocese, just PM me.
 
You seem to be doing a lot of things to try to learn about and understand the Church more. The things you mentioned are good things and I would encourage you to continue them, especially the prayers you recite. I would also suggest you try to attend the mass if at all possible. Just sit off to the side and watch what happens. Listen to the Holy Spirit and let God fill your heart with his peace. My prayers are with you on your journey.
 
Ok, here is the story. I have seriously, in the past few weeks or so, becoming interested to lean more and more about the Catholic Church, to see what its all about, its history, practices etc. Its, idk, I have become drawn to Catholicism in such a away that I cannot just ignore. The past two weeks I have been reading up about Catholic doctrine and history and its almost like some kind of addiction, I find myself more motivated to look up and examine facts about the “early church” and such, and its all so fascinating…Maybe its a phase? Maybe it’s the enlightening hand of God trying to show me what is right? I dont know. All I know is if God is trying to tell me something, I am listening

-snip-

And the funny thnig is, I have been Praying the Hail Mary now, followed by the Our Father and Glory Be, each night. I make the sign of the cross before i leave home, Im not even Catholic, still dont know if i’ll ever be and yet doing that has brought more peace to me in prayer than I had known in while. I have become a Catholic-At-Heart. And I supposed that is the first step.

Now, what (if any) approach should I take from here? Go and talk about RCIA? Keep in mind im still a kid, not a LITTLE kid lol but a teen. My parents havent taken us to church in months now, and my mom’s family is strongly protestant and my dad’s parents are moderate, maybe nominal (i shouldnt say because i dont know them that well) catholics. My dad is anti-Catholic, not to the extend to where he thinks Catholics are unsaved, but he is not going to like it if i tell him. My grandfather is a Deacon of a Baptist church and has given me a lot of money so I could go on Baptist sponsored mission trips so I KNOW he won’t take it well. My Mother tho not a catholic is a little more catholic minded, she has pictures of the Virgin Mary in our house, (you would think we were catholics if you visited us) and the last supper painting with crucifix hanging from it and such.

And then I don’t want to tell my girlfriend because she is going to think that im trying to convert for her because she is catholic.

Please give me any and all good advice you can. Plus I know a few weeks of contemplation is a very short time. Any and all advice would be helpful…thank you

Sincerely

A Catholic-At-Heart
Welcome! Your calling-home sounds very like my own, so many years ago! I, too was still at home, still a teen when the evangelical faith I had been so passionate about began to - not crumble, exactly, but leak - and what leaked in was the truth of the Catholic Church and all the glory that Jesus intended His Church to wear.

I would encourage you to keep praying (obviously), keep reading (I’ll suggest Alan Schreck’s *Catholic and Christian *and Mark Shea’s By What Authority, also pretty much anything by Scott Hahn. For now I would avoid setting up a confrontation at home - you don’t want to be put in a position of trying to defend a decision you haven’t fully made yet, or explaining all those doctrines that the anti-catholics always attack when you haven’t fully come to an understanding of them yourself. If you can attend Mass without causing an uproar, by all means do so - but if not, relax - the Mass will be there!

As to your girlfriend, you don’t indicate how serious that relationship is. If it’s casual and fun, I would think you could tell her about your interest and maybe get her involved in some of the reading (most young Catholics are sadly ignorant of their faith–you may well be evangelizing her!) If your relationship is more serious and you are talking about marriage already then I would begin the conversation by saying “I’m starting to think about becoming a Catholic, but I need you to know that this isn’t about you, it’s about Jesus - even if we broke up today I’d still be on this path” - or something to that effect, so she won’t jump to the conclusion you fear.

Your family’s response will depend a great deal on what they see in your life. If your faith shines through, they will have less to attack than if you just appear to be “playing Catholic.” If you can express to them that you’re not rejecting the faith they have raised you in but moving into a fuller, stronger experience of it, they may in time come to understand. Pray that in any conversation with them about the Church they will know that you are NOT rejecting them or suggesting that they are not Christians.

You’re taking the first steps of a wonderful journey!! Enjoy the views.
 
Welcome home. The Catholic Church was indeed founded by Jesus Christ and every Protestant denomination is an off-shoot. The term “protestant” refers to the protests of Luther and his followers. I’m sure the Good Shepherd wants his flock reunited. Half of the Anglican church has been talking to the Vatican about returning and I pray that happens soon. That off-shoot was founded by the British King Henry XIII so he could divorce his wife who wasn’t producing a son for him.

Here are some websites to check out if you haven’t already. Dr. Scott Hahn’s book, “Rome Sweet Home” may be of further inspiration.

www.wordonfire.org

www.chnetwork.org

www.wdtprs.com (actually a blog created by a convert like yourself who’s now a priest)

Of course this website is rich with information and I hope you find it useful on your journey.

oce.catholic.com/index.php?title=Protestantism

May God Bless You,
 
You are an intelligent, honest, and courageous young person.
I will keep you in my prayers. 🙂
 
It sounds like you’ve done a lot more research and reading than I have about becoming Catholic. I am very happy to hear that the more you learned, the more Pro-Catholic you became. Thank you for adding strength to my own beliefs.

I was not Catholic until 2005 after 8 months of RCIA classes. Prior to that I was working in Saudi Arabia. After being surrounded by Muslims for 3 years my faith in Christianity grew, yet I was still unsure about the correct path I should follow. I studied and visited many different denominations before deciding Catholic was the best path for me and my family. None of my Parents or Siblings are Catholic and many of them do not attend church, but I truly feel becoming Catholic was one of the best things I’ve ever done.👍
 
There are actually a lot of young converts to The Church. I was 18 when I started RCIA and Confirmed at 19. Here at Catholic Answers I met others about my age too who were converting in their teens.
 
Just wanted to chime in and say that Anglicanism is NOT Catholicism and in fact has quite a deal much in common with Protestant movements.

That said, it may be difficult to convert while still a teen under the care of your parents. You likely have a difficult road ahead, but certainly you will be willing to endure it. The best advice is to keep studying and try and talk things out with your parents. Last week, we had an entire family convert to Catholicism when a 17 year old (who had converted the year earlier) convinced his family to convert. So it IS possible.
 
I am a converted, too. I became a catholic while a student. The very recent martyrdom of ALL our catholic bishops opposing the installation of communism in my country (Romania), worked a lot to open my eyes to the only true religion of God. No human being is able to resist against ravaged atheist, the power to resist came from above us.

Now, if you are so young and in good health you can take your time before making the step you contemplate to make. It is important to be sure this is not a caprice, like becoming a fan of a pop artist. The main question you have to answer is the following one: the reason to become catholic is negative or positive ? In other wording, the motivation (the force pushling you to make this step) is something against your protestant status, or a positive one, fr exemple you feel our Lord is closer in the Catholic Church ? If there is a negative motivation, maybe is better (if in good health) to delay your decision.

Try this “oldie, but goldie” catechism:
cin.org/users/james/ebooks/master/baltimore/bindex.htm

Pray to our Holy Ghost and, if needed, ask the advice of a priest or of a brother advanced on the Way.

May God keep you in His hands !
 
I am a converted, too. I became a catholic while a student. The very recent martyrdom of ALL our catholic bishops opposing the installation of communism in my country (Romania), worked a lot to open my eyes to the only true religion of God. No human being is able to resist against ravaged atheist, the power to resist came from above us.

Now, if you are so young and in good health you can take your time before making the step you contemplate to make. It is important to be sure this is not a caprice, like becoming a fan of a pop artist. The main question you have to answer is the following one: the reason to become catholic is negative or positive ? In other wording, the motivation (the force pushling you to make this step) is something against your protestant status, or a positive one, fr exemple you feel our Lord is closer in the Catholic Church ? If there is a negative motivation, maybe is better (if in good health) to delay your decision.

Try this “oldie, but goldie” catechism:
cin.org/users/james/ebooks/master/baltimore/bindex.htm

Pray to our Holy Ghost and, if needed, ask the advice of a priest or of a brother advanced on the Way.

May God keep you in His hands !
This is an excellent point and I agree whole heartedly that a decision of this importance should be made for positive reasons and not negative ones. The decision to become Catholic (or to enter into any other relationship with God, to get married or embrace celibacy, for instance) should always be made for positive reasons and not because you are afraid or because you feel propelled into the decision or this is what is expected of you. God calls you out of love and your response should be made in the same way.
 
Hi everyone =), I want to thank you all for your support and encouragement.

To make something clear (and this is not to sound defensive), I do feel that my contemplation of becoming a Catholic is for the right reasons, that being my increasing feeling that the Catholic church is the one church established by Jesus =), that I increasingly agree more with its theology, and that offers the Christian something that other denominations can’t. I also recall I think the Catechism teaches that those who view the church to be true are obligated to join it (i apologise if i am mis-stating this), but its more than that, if I in fact hold it to be true, it is something I WANT to do, to have that full relationship with God that we are all in need of.

I fully understand that this is a HUGE decision, and have every intention to take it day-today, and try to learn as much as I can and ask for the Lord’s guidance along the way. This is definately not something to just rush into. You all don’t know it but you have already helped me so much, thank you.
 
I am not trying to sound like a nut, but one thing that is almost certainly going to happen is a fierce attack from Satan. Be aware that he has no intention of letting you make this journey peacefully. God bless and pray that the Lord keeps the sword of your guardian angel sharp.
 
Read Home Sweet Rome by Scott and Kimberly Hahn. That will get you on the right road.

Peace
 
Ok, here is the story. I have seriously, in the past few weeks or so, becoming interested to lean more and more about the Catholic Church, to see what its all about, its history, practices etc. Its, idk, I have become drawn to Catholicism in such a away that I cannot just ignore. The past two weeks I have been reading up about Catholic doctrine and history and its almost like some kind of addiction, I find myself more motivated to look up and examine facts about the “early church” and such, and its all so fascinating…Maybe its a phase? Maybe it’s the enlightening hand of God trying to show me what is right? I dont know. All I know is if God is trying to tell me something, I am listening

Just to start, I am Protestant, I was “raised” Protestant (thus far im still being “raised”)
That being said, I could admit that it used to be I didnt care much for Catholicism, I used to be this big supporter of Martin Luther and his “Justification by Faith”; when i first read of that in history class I looked him almost like a pseudo God (dont worry, we Protestants dont worship Luther i think most at our church dont even know who he is .little joke…very little).

Anyway. ummm I have been reading and study. a LOT all about the saints, about the Vatican II and why many catholics today are disenchanted by it, about liturgy, vestiments, and how the protestant churches (save for episcopalisn, tho they’re not exactly protestant)gave 2000 years of traditionaion up and for what? to stray from cathedrals and worship in football stadiums? Not to get political but they also support an unjust war, judge others, and they dont even like immigration, ive just, i have a lot of experience with these people, and they ALL regard guns as a birthright. And Im actually referring to more to evangelical christians rather than the mainline protestant church i go to which is not bad at all. but it still lacks when compared to more elaborate masses., having communion very sunday, etc.

The Point Is,all the reading I have done lately. all the new information I have on Catholicism, I am becoming more and more convinced that the Catholic Church is the church in which The Lord Jesus Christ established upon the rock of Peter — “You are Peter and Upon This Rock I will Build My Church, and the Gates of Hell will have no power over it.”

I have also been reading about Protestant history, and the more splits I see, about this, that and the other thing, the more I realise that we protestants worship and believe the way we do just because some man said so.

That being said, I have decided I want to be a Catholic. I am torn between Roman Catholicim and Anglicanism at the moment (thats a different story) but as of now, I no longer believe in Protestant theology or its liturgy lacking simplicity. The church that I a, currently a (baptised) member im of requires almost no preparation for being received into the church. And im guessing many of them dont evem know where their own denomination came from.

And the funny thnig is, I have been Praying the Hail Mary now, followed by the Our Father and Glory Be, each night. I make the sign of the cross before i leave home, Im not even Catholic, still dont know if i’ll ever be and yet doing that has brought more peace to me in prayer than I had known in while. I have become a Catholic-At-Heart. And I supposed that is the first step.

Now, what (if any) approach should I take from here? Go and talk about RCIA? Keep in mind im still a kid, not a LITTLE kid lol but a teen. My parents havent taken us to church in months now, and my mom’s family is strongly protestant and my dad’s parents are moderate, maybe nominal (i shouldnt say because i dont know them that well) catholics. My dad is anti-Catholic, not to the extend to where he thinks Catholics are unsaved, but he is not going to like it if i tell him. My grandfather is a Deacon of a Baptist church and has given me a lot of money so I could go on Baptist sponsored mission trips so I KNOW he won’t take it well. My Mother tho not a catholic is a little more catholic minded, she has pictures of the Virgin Mary in our house, (you would think we were catholics if you visited us) and the last supper painting with crucifix hanging from it and such.

And then I don’t want to tell my girlfriend because she is going to think that im trying to convert for her because she is catholic.

Please give me any and all good advice you can. Plus I know a few weeks of contemplation is a very short time. Any and all advice would be helpful…thank you

Sincerely

A Catholic-At-Heart
Learn everything you can about the faith, You will find out that it is for sure the Church started by Peter. Read up on the Pope, his teaching’s and you will understand why we are so contented in our faith. God Bless, and keep studying!
 
Read Home Sweet Rome by Scott and Kimberly Hahn. That will get you on the right road.

Peace
That is indeed a great start. I also recommend a book on the teachings of the Early Church Fathers.
 
Don’t tell her. Just start taking instructions, either privately with the priest or deacon, or in RCIA (often suboptimal due to mishandling by lay-ministers; if you were in Alaska, I’d send you to one of the parishes where RCIA is handled by the deacon…). Let her find out by seeing you attending mass on your own (it’s part of instruction, BTW, to attend).

If she asks, don’t deny it. But, unless you’re her fiancé, it’s really not her business… yet. Once she is, she’s obligated by canon law (the rules of the church) to try to convert you anyway.

Oh, and the current official catechism is online at:
vatican.va/archive/ccc/index.htm

The Baltimore Catechism is available from Project Guttenburg as electronic text for free. It has a few issues, but is generally solid “Traditionalist” Roman Rite Catholicism.
 
**You have nothing to lose by going to Mass, and everything to gain. You will KNOW what is right for you when you attend mass.

**I am not a cradle Catholic, and many of my family are very religious but not Catholic. A few years ago i felt a strong pull towards the Catholic church and went along ‘just to see’ what it was like and at that time I had no intention of doing anything other than finding out what happened there. It felt so, so right to be a part of the mass, and I was desperate to be a full part of the Catholic church. After speaking to the priest, who told me to think about what I wanted to do and why for a few weeks, I then went back to him and told him I was sure and my reasons, began classes and was received with open arms into the church. I LOVE BEING CATHOLIC!

Personal message me if you have any questions.
 
i was a fundamentalist and against the catholic church for 20 years. i then became catholic. keep studying history. keep studying the church fathers and their beliefs regarding the Eucharist. also do a good study on where the bible came from.
 
The Holy Spirit is calling you into the Catholic Church. You are on the right path. Your parents and family will come around eventually. Welcome!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top