I am seriously starting to become Pro-Catholic, please help...need advice

  • Thread starter Thread starter ConflictedBoy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I can only second taking instruction, as I have done, and you become a catechumen, a part of the Church but one that cannot receive the sacraments yet. If you start now, you will get baptized around Easter 2011 as Catechism courses for catechumens last 1 or 2 years. After baptism a catechumen is official a Roman Catholic.
 
CB, this might help you too:

**The Works that Influenced me to return to the Catholic Church. **

Seek for answers, and when you find what seems to be an answer, question that too. Louis L’amour, The Walking Drum.

My return to the Catholic Church was not something that happened in an instant. The works mentioned here were read by me over a twenty year period. Here are a few golden nuggets I picked up on the way.

The Writings of the Early Church.
If one wishes to know about a period of history, what makes more sense? To ask someone who actually lived, worked, and experienced the events first-hand? Or to ask someone thousands of years and miles removed from the events who has his own prejudices? An honest historian will seek to hear the voices of those who lived the events. Here are a few:
A Dictionary of Early Christian Beliefs, edited by David W. Bercot.
The Teachings of the Church Fathers, edited by John R. Willis.
For those unwilling to sift through the volumes of writings by the Early Church Fathers, these two books give a comprehensive reference guide of how the Early Church thought in the first 300 years. The fundamentalist will avoid these books like a vampire does the sunrise.
The History of the Church by Eusebius.
This was a major shock to me while I was still in fundamentalism. Written in the 4th century, Eusebius gives an undeniably Catholic picture of the early church. It tears apart ‘Trail of Blood’ revisionist church history.
The City of God and Confessions by St. Augustine.
These works fascinated me with what is a clearly Catholic view of Christianity.

The Writings of the Medieval Church
The Imitation of Christ by Thomas a Kempis.
The Soul’s Journey into God, The Tree of Life, and The Life of St. Francis by St. Bonaventure.
The Little Flowers of St. Francis, unknown.
These works blew me out of the water. How could these men, in the “DARK AGES”, write what was so obviously born of the Holy Spirit? A Kempis especially moved me and brought me to my knees.

Modern Works.
Books:
Fundamentalism and Catholicism by Karl Keating.
The final nail in the coffin (for me) of fundamentalism. Keating writes with intelligence coupled with extensive background information that is a must read for any convert.
The Catechism of the Catholic Church.
Recommended for anyone who wishes to know what the Catholic Church believes.
Roots of the Reformation by Karl Adam.
In this short work, Adam gives the best analysis of the Reformation I have ever read.
Journeys Home by Marcus Grodi.
The journeys of Protestant clergy back to the Catholic Church.

There were many others, but these came immediately to mind.
 
And the funny thnig is, I have been Praying the Hail Mary now, followed by the Our Father and Glory Be, each night. I make the sign of the cross before i leave home,
BTW, no prayer to the Blessed Mother ever goes unanswered.
Welcome. 🙂
 
We have very similar situations, and I’m glad to hear from you. I’ll certainly keep reading your threads, and you can check out my own (very similar to yours) and maybe make some use of it… forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=309172
Who knows. Maybe we can get some advice off one another’s situation. I’ll keep you in my prayers.

P.S. Our only difference is that my mind is made up on what to do! Betcha can guess the answer.
 
Ok, here is the story. I have seriously, in the past few weeks or so, becoming interested to lean more and more about the Catholic Church, to see what its all about, its history, practices etc. Its, idk, I have become drawn to Catholicism in such a away that I cannot just ignore. The past two weeks I have been reading up about Catholic doctrine and history and its almost like some kind of addiction, I find myself more motivated to look up and examine facts about the “early church” and such, and its all so fascinating…Maybe its a phase? Maybe it’s the enlightening hand of God trying to show me what is right? I dont know. All I know is if God is trying to tell me something, I am listening

Just to start, I am Protestant, I was “raised” Protestant (thus far im still being “raised”)
That being said, I could admit that it used to be I didnt care much for Catholicism, I used to be this big supporter of Martin Luther and his “Justification by Faith”; when i first read of that in history class I looked him almost like a pseudo God (dont worry, we Protestants dont worship Luther i think most at our church dont even know who he is .little joke…very little).

Anyway. ummm I have been reading and study. a LOT all about the saints, about the Vatican II and why many catholics today are disenchanted by it, about liturgy, vestiments, and how the protestant churches (save for episcopalisn, tho they’re not exactly protestant)gave 2000 years of traditionaion up and for what? to stray from cathedrals and worship in football stadiums? Not to get political but they also support an unjust war, judge others, and they dont even like immigration, ive just, i have a lot of experience with these people, and they ALL regard guns as a birthright. And Im actually referring to more to evangelical christians rather than the mainline protestant church i go to which is not bad at all. but it still lacks when compared to more elaborate masses., having communion very sunday, etc.

The Point Is,all the reading I have done lately. all the new information I have on Catholicism, I am becoming more and more convinced that the Catholic Church is the church in which The Lord Jesus Christ established upon the rock of Peter — “You are Peter and Upon This Rock I will Build My Church, and the Gates of Hell will have no power over it.”

I have also been reading about Protestant history, and the more splits I see, about this, that and the other thing, the more I realise that we protestants worship and believe the way we do just because some man said so.

That being said, I have decided I want to be a Catholic. I am torn between Roman Catholicim and Anglicanism at the moment (thats a different story) but as of now, I no longer believe in Protestant theology or its liturgy lacking simplicity. The church that I a, currently a (baptised) member im of requires almost no preparation for being received into the church. And im guessing many of them dont evem know where their own denomination came from.

And the funny thnig is, I have been Praying the Hail Mary now, followed by the Our Father and Glory Be, each night. I make the sign of the cross before i leave home, Im not even Catholic, still dont know if i’ll ever be and yet doing that has brought more peace to me in prayer than I had known in while. I have become a Catholic-At-Heart. And I supposed that is the first step.

Now, what (if any) approach should I take from here? Go and talk about RCIA? Keep in mind im still a kid, not a LITTLE kid lol but a teen. My parents havent taken us to church in months now, and my mom’s family is strongly protestant and my dad’s parents are moderate, maybe nominal (i shouldnt say because i dont know them that well) catholics. My dad is anti-Catholic, not to the extend to where he thinks Catholics are unsaved, but he is not going to like it if i tell him. My grandfather is a Deacon of a Baptist church and has given me a lot of money so I could go on Baptist sponsored mission trips so I KNOW he won’t take it well. My Mother tho not a catholic is a little more catholic minded, she has pictures of the Virgin Mary in our house, (you would think we were catholics if you visited us) and the last supper painting with crucifix hanging from it and such.

And then I don’t want to tell my girlfriend because she is going to think that im trying to convert for her because she is catholic.

Please give me any and all good advice you can. Plus I know a few weeks of contemplation is a very short time. Any and all advice would be helpful…thank you

Sincerely

A Catholic-At-Heart
I agree the history of the “church” is interesting! But it doesn’t mean that its right! You should be studying your Bible instead!! Please take a minute and look up www.pro-gospel.org you will see many differences in what the Bible says contrary to what Catholics say and do. Also www.whateverycatholicshouldknow.com
 
I agree the history of the “church” is interesting! But it doesn’t mean that its right! You should be studying your Bible instead!! Please take a minute and look up www.pro-gospel.org you will see many differences in what the Bible says contrary to what Catholics say and do. Also www.whateverycatholicshouldknow.com
I don’t want to allow you to derail the thread, but I looked through both of your sites and I didn’t find “differences in what the Bible says contrary to what Catholics say and do.” All I found were a few men telling me that I should respect their authority on what the Bible says more than I should respect the Catholic Church’s authority on what the Bible says.

Thank you, but I’ll stick with trusting my Church.
 
Thank you, but I’ll stick with trusting my Church.
There’s an old saying that goes something like this: “Trust, but verify.”

One of the most beautiful things I have found about being Catholic is that unlike some non-Catholic faiths where they say “just read your Bible” or “we’re right-they’re wrong: end of story”, is that Catholics encourage others to investigate it for themselves. There is two thousand plus years of data to look at. There’s plenty of warts (i.e. poor behavior by Catholics) to be sure, but there is also so many instances of God-inspired men and women throughout the centuries who have unquestionably lived their faith.

God desires us to draw closer to Him. He wants us to know Him better each and every day of our lives. Trust God to lead you ConflictedBoy. He wants you to verify what the Truth is about Him. I have every confidence that He will lead you to that Truth. God Bless you on your journey. 🙂
 
Saint Augustine said hear the other side, so hear the other side! However, you need to realize that Protestants think entirely different from Catholics… Protestants may see something as being contrary to Scripture, since it is not in Scripture. Catholics also have tradition! Meanwhile, here are some Catholic links I found useful. If you are still uncomfortable with talking with your parents about this I think you’ll still be able to descretly read and listen to these. I tend to listen to the MP3s on my PsP, so there are plenty of ways!

Archbishop Sheen:

americancatholictruthsociety.com/articles/sheen.htm

Bible Christian Society MP3s:

biblechristiansociety.com/download

Catholic Ebooks:

freecatholicebooks.com/

The FULL Bible, including ‘Deutrocanonicals’:

vatican.va/archive/bible/index.htm

G.K. Chesterton and Hilare Belloc:

Chesterton: gutenberg.org/browse/authors/c#a80

Belloc: gutenberg.org/browse/authors/b#a2437

Virtual Rosary:

virtualrosary.org/
 
Wow, I’m so happy for you. And I’ll pray that you continue your journey to home. I would encourage you that you attend RCIA class or even a catholic bible study group. You don’t have to be catholic to attend to both. Honestly this is a touching story considering that you are young at heart just like I am. My boyfriend is presbyterian and well… I just wished he would have an open heart like yours. About a year ago I was considered one of those “lost catholics” who didnt know their own faith. My boyfriend began asking me question that I couldnt answered. So I attended RCIA class and Thank God I ended up there because now I love Catholicism like no other. It’s so beautiful and I truly believe our Jesus Christ established this church. i’m not sure if you heard of Scott Hahn he was ordained at a prebysterian church… (prebysterians split from protestantism…i believe, they are more on the Calvin side more than Luther.) Anyhow he was basically anti-catholic and well while he was out to TRY to prove catholics wrong, he ended up discovering that the Catholic church was the true church. You should read “Rome sweet Home” by Scott Hahn and also listen to some of his audios like “The healing power of confessions” by scott hahn (you can order it at saintjoe.com for only $3) Hopefully this helps. 😃
 
I don’t want to allow you to derail the thread, but I looked through both of your sites and I didn’t find “differences in what the Bible says contrary to what Catholics say and do.” All I found were a few men telling me that I should respect their authority on what the Bible says more than I should respect the Catholic Church’s authority on what the Bible says.

Thank you, but I’ll stick with trusting my Church.
The Bible is the inspired word of God, you can not argue with that. The Bible is our only source for truth.
 
The Bible is the inspired word of God, you can not argue with that. The Bible is our only source for truth.
“This is the disciple who testifies of these things, and wrote these things; and we know that his testimony is true. And there are also many other things that Jesus did, which if they were written one by one, I suppose that even the world itself could not contain the books that would be written” John 21:24-25

“Now I praise you, brethren, that you remember me in all things and keep the traditions just as I delivered them to you” 1 Corinthians 11:2

“Therefore, brethren, stand fast and hold the traditions which you were taught, whether by word or our epistle” 2 Thessalonians 2:15
 
“This is the disciple who testifies of these things, and wrote these things; and we know that his testimony is true. And there are also many other things that Jesus did, which if they were written one by one, I suppose that even the world itself could not contain the books that would be written” John 21:24-25

“Now I praise you, brethren, that you remember me in all things and keep the traditions just as I delivered them to you” 1 Corinthians 11:2

“Therefore, brethren, stand fast and hold the traditions which you were taught, whether by word or our epistle” 2 Thessalonians 2:15
Ahhh, yes all found in the BIBLE!
 
The Bible is the inspired word of God, you can not argue with that.
The bible is the collection of books collated by the Catholic Church in the 4th century, recording the scriptures accepted as inspired by the Catholic Church. Do your research.
The Bible is our only source for truth.
Wrong: There are three sources of Truth: Sacred Tradition, the Bible, and Magisterial Revelation.

Look at the book of Acts. Look carefully. Magisterial Revelation is the only reason circumcision isn’t mandatory, and neither is Kosher.

Acts clearly shows an organized hierarchical church. But the bible doesn’t say how it was organized. Nowhere does the institution of priests as separate from bishops get delineated in the bible, but it’s clear there is one; Paul writings show it.

And so do all the early church fathers.

Denial of the sacred tradition is denial of half the truth.
 
The bible is the collection of books collated by the Catholic Church in the 4th century, recording the scriptures accepted as inspired by the Catholic Church. Do your research.

Wrong: There are three sources of Truth: Sacred Tradition, the Bible, and Magisterial Revelation.

Look at the book of Acts. Look carefully. Magisterial Revelation is the only reason circumcision isn’t mandatory, and neither is Kosher.

Acts clearly shows an organized hierarchical church. But the bible doesn’t say how it was organized. Nowhere does the institution of priests as separate from bishops get delineated in the bible, but it’s clear there is one; Paul writings show it.

And so do all the early church fathers.

Denial of the sacred tradition is denial of half the truth.
Actually, I have done my research. My husband ran for his life from the Catholic church when Jesus opened his eyes up to the truth found only in the Holy Bible.
I do thank the catholic church for protecting the Bible, if it wasnt for them we wouldnt have it.
Also, kosher eating and circumcision is talked about before the book of Acts as practices that are no longer necessary. Jesus came to set us free from man made laws and needless tradition that will not get you any closer to heaven. Colossians 2:16-23 Galatians 4:9-12
 
Hi everyone =), I want to thank you all for your support and encouragement.

To make something clear (and this is not to sound defensive), I do feel that my contemplation of becoming a Catholic is for the right reasons, that being my increasing feeling that the Catholic church is the one church established by Jesus =), that I increasingly agree more with its theology, and that offers the Christian something that other denominations can’t. I also recall I think the Catechism teaches that those who view the church to be true are obligated to join it (i apologise if i am mis-stating this), but its more than that, if I in fact hold it to be true, it is something I WANT to do, to have that full relationship with God that we are all in need of.

I fully understand that this is a HUGE decision, and have every intention to take it day-today, and try to learn as much as I can and ask for the Lord’s guidance along the way. This is definately not something to just rush into. You all don’t know it but you have already helped me so much, thank you.
We will continue to pray for you.
 
The Bible is the inspired word of God, you can not argue with that. The Bible is our only source for truth.
Unfortunately, your second sentence is just as wrong as your first sentence is right.

Regardless, you didn’t answer my point. I looked through those sites you pointed us to and all I found were men telling me that their interpretation of the Bible was correct. If those men are your sources for the correct way to interpret the Bible then I have two options: I can choose to accept the interpretation that has been supported by you and a couple of men I don’t know for however long they’ve had webpages, or I can choose to accept the interpretation that has been supported by my Church for 2000 years.

Again: thank you but I’m good with what I’ve got.
 
Another problem that arises for someone who relies on the Bible alone… there are a thousand different ways to understand it. Without an authority to decide this, how are we to know which is correct? Certainly many Protestants claim that the Holy Spirit guides them… and people who have different opinions from them say the same. Either someone is wrong here, or, as one of the MP3s on the Bible Christian Society site said, the Holy Spirit is scizophranic! :rolleyes:
On the other hand it does make a great deal of sense that Christ would set up something to determine these things for us (The Church). How can we know that they are the correct ones, though? Well, for starters there’s lots of evidences. The Catholic Church is the oldest Church, from whence all others split off of from which (non Protestant rivisonist) history tells us.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top