I asked for an opinion. Here is what was said

  • Thread starter Thread starter khmsct99
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

khmsct99

Guest
I asked what, the a. Father’s opinion is on Catholicism. He didn’t get mad, which was shocking. But he is not an expert at it either. He told me what someone told him about the Catholic Church because the person was raised up in Catholicism but he converted and became Baptist. What was told to me yesterday was:
  1. Priests are allowed to get drunk. Apparently a priest was selling drinks. If the person wanted to drink more than one drink the priest had 8 or 9 in a case. So instead of just buying several at a time, the customer could get a whole case of alcohol, sold by the priest. He then said a priest and the members could get drunk in the middle of church service.
  2. They honor Mary more than they do Jesus.
  3. They are still stuck in the Old Testament. (Confession instead of just praying)
  4. This one was odd, I don’t know where he heard this from: They don’t believe in praying. Instead they have to have a priest to give God the prayers. The individual can’t pray because they don’t believe in it.
  5. Catholic priests organized the Protestant Bible?
These are the only 5 things I remember him saying about it. I didn’t know what to say. I didn’t want it to seem like I knew too much about the faith, because I don’t want to disobey and talk about my views, while still living in there house.
 
  1. Priests are allowed to get drunk. Apparently a priest was selling drinks. If the person wanted to drink more than one drink the priest had 8 or 9 in a case. So instead of just buying several at a time, the customer could get a whole case of alcohol, sold by the priest. He then said a priest and the members could get drunk in the middle of church service.
This doesn’t make any sense at all. The priest was selling booze?
  1. They honor Mary more than they do Jesus.
Simply false.
  1. They are still stuck in the Old Testament. (Confession instead of just praying)
I’m not a Bible scholar, but Confession comes from the New Testament. Jesus told the apostles, “What sins you forgive are forgiven…”
  1. This one was odd, I don’t know where he heard this from: They don’t believe in praying. Instead they have to have a priest to give God the prayers. The individual can’t pray because they don’t believe in it.
Simply false. Priests leads the congregation in prayer, just as a Protestant Minister leads his congregation in prayer.
  1. Catholic priests organized the Protestant Bible?
🤷
 
I’d definitely talk to some more people. There is so much misinformation, it is difficult to know where to begin.

Can a priest drink? The short answer is “yes”. But our perspective on the matter is what is most important to consider, I believe. I find it refreshing, as a Catholic, that the church understands and accepts that we are ALL sinners.

On the issue of Mary, as a Catholic, I have a tendency to turn the point right around. My question to those that question a devotion to Mary, why they choose to ignore her? Are we “more” devoted to the Holy Mother-I’d say that we are not “more” devoted. But there is certainly a love and respect for all she has done to do God’s will. She humbly served our Lord, and her humility is an example to all of us…or should be, at least. She helps us to more completely love and understand her Son-she points us to Him, never herself.

To your third point, are there SOME Catholics too concerned about one or two books of the Bible more than the others? The answer, I’m sure, is again, “yes.” But isn’t that true of any member of any faith? The same could be said about many individuals. We must look beyond individuals, though, to find the right answer. I’d ask you to look at the liturgy. During Mass, throughout the year, there is usually a reading from both the Old and New Testament, followed by the Gospel. During the weeks of Easter, there are only readings from the New Testament. So, there is a measurable, quantifiable way to dispute this particular information you’ve been given. If you are curious and wish to explore this point further, I’d direct you to look at a Missal and look at the readings for each Mass. (they can also be found on line if you don’t have a Missal at your disposal).

Fourth point, as a Catholic I can answer for myself. I pray often. Every morning I make an offering to Jesus. I pray any special intentions I may have at that given moment. Every evening, I pray special intentions and examine my conscience. Again, you can look at a local parish for guidance here also. Many parishes have prayer groups, just like many Protestant churches do.

I don’t feel qualified to answer your fifth point. I am unaware of where that would even come from. So I will use the space to make a point about something else you brought up…confession. I didn’t understand it before my conversion. I didn’t want to receive the sacrament of reconciliation before my conversion, if I’m being honest. Confession is a beautiful part of the faith, now that I’m a part of it. It allows me to feel completely forgiven for my specific sins. It also helps me avoid occasions of near sin and sin itself by being aware of my sinful nature, thanks to the sacrament. I went from not wanting to be a part of reconciliation, to now seeing it as one of the true joys of the Catholic faith.

Hope this lengthy post helps you in your journey. May God Bless!
 
  1. Priests are allowed to get drunk. Apparently a priest was selling drinks. If the person wanted to drink more than one drink the priest had 8 or 9 in a case. So instead of just buying several at a time, the customer could get a whole case of alcohol, sold by the priest. He then said a priest and the members could get drunk in the middle of church service.
No Catholic is ever allowed to get drunk really, the Catechism certainly looks down on it, and that would apply to priests especially since they should be looked up to as examples (though they are still human of course.)
The virtue of temperance disposes us to avoid every kind of excess: the abuse of food, alcohol, tobacco, or medicine.
Or more clearly from the Baltimore Catechism:
Q. 305. What kind of a sin is drunkenness?
A. Drunkenness is a sin of gluttony by which a person deprives himself of the use of his reason by the excessive taking of intoxicating drink.
Q. 306. Is drunkenness always a mortal sin?
A. Deliberate drunkenness is always a mortal sin if the person be completely deprived of the use of reason by it, but drunkenness that is not intended or desired may be excused from mortal sin.
Q. 307. What are the chief effects of habitual drunkenness?
A. Habitual drunkenness injures the body, weakens the mind, leads its victim into many vices and exposes him to the danger of dying in a state of mortal sin.
At any rate the idea of anyone, especially the priest, getting drunk at Mass (if that’s what you meant) is a bit far-fetched. People don’t eat or drink at Mass except for during Communion.
 
I asked what, the a. Father’s opinion is on Catholicism. He didn’t get mad, which was shocking. But he is not an expert at it either. He told me what someone told him about the Catholic Church because the person was raised up in Catholicism but he converted and became Baptist. What was told to me yesterday was:
  1. Priests are allowed to get drunk. Apparently a priest was selling drinks. If the person wanted to drink more than one drink the priest had 8 or 9 in a case. So instead of just buying several at a time, the customer could get a whole case of alcohol, sold by the priest. He then said a priest and the members could get drunk in the middle of church service.
  2. They honor Mary more than they do Jesus.
  3. They are still stuck in the Old Testament. (Confession instead of just praying)
  4. This one was odd, I don’t know where he heard this from: They don’t believe in praying. Instead they have to have a priest to give God the prayers. The individual can’t pray because they don’t believe in it.
  5. Catholic priests organized the Protestant Bible?
These are the only 5 things I remember him saying about it. I didn’t know what to say. I didn’t want it to seem like I knew too much about the faith, because I don’t want to disobey and talk about my views, while still living in there house.
I think you were wise not to have said anything at the time. You asked for his opinion and he gave it…case closed.

Now - that being said, you can certainly go back and say - "You know when you mentioned…[fill in the blank]…about Catholicism? I looked into it and found out that…[fill in the blank].
In this way you are not being disrespectful. You are simply continuing the dialogue.

Peace
James
 
I really would not know how to approach the subject though. Last night was just silence until I mentioned it. I am worried because the guy who was Catholic told him these statements. Therefore, he would believe that guy more than me since “I’m young, therefore, dumb and have no knowledge.” Is what some say.

I will keep looking into this.
 
I really would not know how to approach the subject though. Last night was just silence until I mentioned it. I am worried because the guy who was Catholic told him these statements. Therefore, he would believe that guy more than me since “I’m young, therefore, dumb and have no knowledge.” Is what some say.
Well then just let it go for now…
I will keep looking into this.
Good for you.

Peace
James
 
I really would not know how to approach the subject though. Last night was just silence until I mentioned it. I am worried because the guy who was Catholic told him these statements. Therefore, he would believe that guy more than me since “I’m young, therefore, dumb and have no knowledge.” Is what some say.

I will keep looking into this.
The man who gave him this information may have been a baptized Catholic; however, he was one who was poorly catechized.

I would tell your father that the information he was given was incorrect. I would then hand him a copy of the Catechism of the Catholic Church, tell him, “This is what Catholics believe” and then let him read it for himself.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top