"I can pick someone who is only child almost immediately" can you?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Salonika
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Salonika

Guest
A friend at work made this comment recently – correctly identifying me as one.

When I asked how she knew she said some of the main clues were:

• getting upset over conflict
• seeing things from my point of view
• not sharing spontaneously
• being happy do things on my own
• not asking for help or assistance
• lack of small talk.

I think that most only children do share (to differing degrees) some characteristics. Do you? What do you think they are?

If you are an only child did you sometimes get the feeling that some people considered that some of these characteristics came from personal defect rather than our situation. (For example -you didn’t share because “only children are selfish” but from lack of having to do so at home.)

Did anyone else find it strange as a child that some people considered parents with one child to be strange and that they should have more when Jesus was an only child?
 
• getting upset over conflict
Seen a lot in adults, including those who would punish you for “hate speech”, i.e. any form of criticism of what they like, but they can criticise you all they want.
• seeing things from my point of view
On the logical level, people typically need some extensive schooling to avoid that, and on a more internal level, they need compassion that probably mostly comes from either compassionate parents or bad experience. At any rate, common in adults.
• not sharing spontaneously
Kids often share more spontaneously than adults. Kids are attached to their things, but they aren’t greedy. They would rather have the whole cake than a half because they like it, they would like whole attention instead of a half, and so on and so forth. But in the end, they don’t really have a greedy materialistic attitude that’s more specific of adults.
• being happy do things on my own
Intelligent people need solitude. Wise people probably also do. Not everyone is an extrovert. And some children need to involve someone else in everything they do. People are introverts, extroverts or somewhere in between. Children also.
• not asking for help or assistance
Typical trait of “tuff”, grumpy men. Also a typical trait of people who don’t want to bug others about their problems and prefer to spend 2 hours doing something instead of asking someone else to do it in half an hour. That’s not child-like. That’s simply not using commonly accepted calculations. Valuing self-reliance is a good thing. Humility and not wanting to bug others is a good thing as well.
• lack of small talk.
Small talk has some good sides to it and some bad ones, but it’s not a good in itself. Some people are up to the point, others aren’t really charmers. Excessive small talk is a bit like gossipping and that’s quite childish. So is “playing house” and making life into a theatre where people play adult.
 
Oh I’m not sure about this one- I know a man who is the eldest of 5 and he fits all of those categories!
 
I’m the youngest of 6 and I fit a lot of those characteristics. Especially preferring to work alone- which ironically I think is due to being from a LARGE family! Sure, some only children will fit them, and others may have traits like a middle/oldest/youngest, and vice versa. Birth order can ring true but I don’t think it determines a person’s behaviour.
 
Oh I’m not sure about this one- I know a man who is the eldest of 5 and he fits all of those categories!
I’m the oldest of 9, and I fit them.:hmmm:
Only children are often referred to as super-first borns by people into birth order dynamics.
I’m the youngest of 6 and I fit a lot of those characteristics. Especially preferring to work alone- which ironically I think is due to being from a LARGE family! Sure, some only children will fit them, and others may have traits like a middle/oldest/youngest, and vice versa. Birth order can ring true but I don’t think it determines a person’s behaviour.
See, you blow that theory out of the water.
Or do you? :hmmm:It supposedly depends on the difference in age between you and the sibling next oldest to you (and a bunch of other dynamics like the sex of each child or if a particular child has a disability or something).
 
A friend at work made this comment recently – correctly identifying me as one.

(…)

If you are an only child did you sometimes get the feeling that some people considered that some of these characteristics came from personal defect rather than our situation. (For example -you didn’t share because “only children are selfish” but from lack of having to do so at home.)

Did anyone else find it strange as a child that some people considered parents with one child to be strange and that they should have more when Jesus was an only child?
I was told several times by family friends that I was spoiled because I was an only child. Not just “spoiled” but “spoiled because”. Now it was the kids that told me that but I don’t think they formed this idea on their own so it must have been the parents. I kind of resented that. I wish I would have had the idea to ask for examples of my being spoiled or were they just repeating what they were told*. I suppose I have only child traits (I don’t know if I can be objective so I can’t really say) but I wasn’t spoiled.
  • I suspect this is what the parents told the kids when they said they wished they were an only child like me. I wish they didn’t throw me (and my mom) under the bus like that.
 
I don’t know about only children, but I can usually pick out oldest kids–very bossy!!! Also, usually very successful and responsible.

Not always, of course.

I’m a youngest, btw. 🙂
 
I was told several times by family friends that I was spoiled because I was an only child. … Not just “spoiled” but “spoiled because” . … . I kind of resented that… This got me as a child and still does when people say “so you must have been spoilt”…
Often I think the idea only children are “spoilt” is because there was only one of us and sometimes we got something new (like a bike) instead of a used one.

Also got/get annoyed with this comment as if I was to blame for getting these things. In Mum and Dad’s case they bought new for me for practical reasons like they knew the history of the bike (or that it had no history) and becasue they could afford it.

Sometimes also think that people thought we had a lot of toys etc as they compared what we had with one of the children in a larger family. As we grew older we got new ones as there weren’t any to be handed down from older children. Same for clothes.
 
A friend at work made this comment recently – correctly identifying me as one.

When I asked how she knew she said some of the main clues were:

• getting upset over conflict
• seeing things from my point of view
• not sharing spontaneously
• being happy do things on my own
• not asking for help or assistance
• lack of small talk.

I think that most only children do share (to differing degrees) some characteristics. Do you? What do you think they are?

If you are an only child did you sometimes get the feeling that some people considered that some of these characteristics came from personal defect rather than our situation. (For example -you didn’t share because “only children are selfish” but from lack of having to do so at home.)

Did anyone else find it strange as a child that some people considered parents with one child to be strange and that they should have more when Jesus was an only child?
I think the real question is why the person had to make such an ignorant comment in the first place.

Additionally, what in the world are you supposed to do about it - find a TARDIS and go back in time and put a gun to your parents’ heads and march them off to the bed to create a sibling for you?
 
I don’t know about only children, but I can usually pick out oldest kids–very bossy!!! Also, usually very successful and responsible.
I think many oldest children and only children share some of the same characteristics - except that we are less likely to be bossy. After all we didn’t have younger siblings to boss. Also only children are usually outnumbered by adults or were when I was growing up.

Maybe we also learnt to be more responsible becasue when there are a number of childlen some bad behaviour is likely to be missed by parents who can only be in one place at a time. Only children are more likely to be caught out. I learnt that when I spent time with cousins (seven in the family) and found I could get away with more than at home.

Also learnt through these cousins
  • that if you didn’t push in and get your food you only got the dregs
  • eat what you like first it won’t stay on your plate for you to eat at the end as it did at home
  • if you wait to speak when there is a gap you’ll never get to say anything
  • how can children move from being great friends to almost hating each other back to being great friends so quickly.
Do any of these resonate with other onlies or with children with siblings in their interaction with onlies?

By the way, I don’t think who and what we are determined by our place in our family - only that it provides a base and may explain why we find it harder to develop some characteristics than others. We are free to determine for ourselves whether we will be chained by that base or not.
 
I am an only child. (Parents wanted more children but my mother might have died had she had another so…not my fault!). I’ve heard a lot about this, especially since I took psychology and sociology this year. Teacher asked if anybody in the class was an only child and I had sense enough not to answer because a split second later her and everyone else goes on a rant about how spoiled and selfish only children are. Parents are selfish as well for not having more children, etc, etc.
Sort of pissed me off at first to be honest but I was more shocked at how angry everyone was about the issue more than anything. :confused:

I never take any of that spoiled stuff too seriously, My family is and always has been ,lets say, financially challenged and we live in a rich county for the schools. I don’t have new clothes, I drive a bada** car nearly as old as I am, and I don’t feel a need to buy new things if the old still are useful. Everyone around me is “spoiled”, including the students making all the comments in class! You know, drive BMW’s, wear top of the line clothes, have the newest in everything. The fact that they have siblings dosen’t enter into the equation from where I stand.
I was never “spoiled” but I had enough to eat. I learned to do more with less, not to waste money or anything else for that matter and to be as selfless as possible when dealing with others because I never know when I might need help.
True, I am an introvert but that may or may not be because I am an only child.

• getting upset over conflict
Well, I try to not start conflict but I don’t avoid it altogether 😃

• seeing things from my point of view
I happen to make an effort to view situations from other’s points of view

• not sharing spontaneously
I seriously doubt most adults share “spontaneously” but I am willing to give what I am able.

• being happy do things on my own
I am happy to do things on my own. No use bothering someone else is there?

• not asking for help or assistance
Again, why pester someone when I can do it myself? Seems selfish to bother someone else with your problems unnecessarily.

• lack of small talk.
I only speak when I have something of value to say. Small talk is a waste of time that benefits no one.

One thing I am curious about though, I am far more comfortable with adults, even old people, than any other teenagers. I am more mature than my friends because I was only around adults for most of my life, immaturity was not tolerated past a certain age. Not really into egging houses or making prank phone calls really. Anybody else turn out like that because of being an only child?

You know, a freak? 😃

Pax Vobiscum
 
Only children are often referred to as super-first borns by people into birth order dynamics.
See, you blow that theory out of the water.
Or do you? :hmmm:It supposedly depends on the difference in age between you and the sibling next oldest to you (and a bunch of other dynamics like the sex of each child or if a particular child has a disability or something).
I’m youngest of 5, all girls, two years between me and nearest sib, no disabilities. And fit that profile.

How does that gel with your theory?
 
I’m the oldest of 3. I definately fit the bossy older sibling category. I am married to an oldest, too. We joke that our oldest has a double dose from us. She is bossy to her siblings, but the 2nd gives as good as he gets. I think that has to do with them being 16 months apart and opposite genders.

Now for the onlies. I am sorry, but I have to agree that you can tell them apart a lot of the time. In college, 2 of my best friends were onlies. Now, granted, they were both onlies of onlies, and in one case onlies for 3 generations at least! This might have had the biggest effect since the mom’s had guilt tripping down to a science. :eek:

I used to tease my one that had the 3 gen thing, Beth, that she had to have more than one so that she wouldn’t continue the cycle, even if it meant she had to adopt. Well, I need not have worried. She is the proud mom of 3. She has had to call me about whether things were normal since she had no experience with siblings. It is all Greek to her. Thankfully, her dh is one of 5.

My funniest memory from college is with my friend, Christine. I lived half way to were she lived. She came home with me, and her parents came and got her. It cut their trip in half. Well, she had dinner with us before her parents got there. She was like a fish out of water. Afterwords, she asked me how we did it. I had not a clue what she meant. She didn’t know how we could have 5 different conversations going on at the same time. We would be talking about topic A, turn and say something about topic C, and then turn back and talk on A again. She couldn’t make heads or tails of it. I didn’t think anything of it because that is what I grew up with. 🤷

I don’t begrudge only children. I do get upset with the parents that give them anything that they want. But, I get upset with parents with 3 kids that do that. I know there were times that I wanted to be an only, but I would never change having siblings to share things with. I have to constantly remind my kids what a blessing it is to have siblings. With 4, the road is not smooth, but no one said that it would be.:rolleyes:
 
A friend at work made this comment recently – correctly identifying me as one.

When I asked how she knew she said some of the main clues were:

• getting upset over conflict
• seeing things from my point of view
• not sharing spontaneously
• being happy do things on my own
• not asking for help or assistance
• lack of small talk.

I think that most only children do share (to differing degrees) some characteristics. Do you? What do you think they are?

If you are an only child did you sometimes get the feeling that some people considered that some of these characteristics came from personal defect rather than our situation. (For example -you didn’t share because “only children are selfish” but from lack of having to do so at home.)

Did anyone else find it strange as a child that some people considered parents with one child to be strange and that they should have more when Jesus was an only child?
I recognise this a lot. I think as an only child, I’m less observant, I don’t notice what’s happening with other people, I really need to be told. Some people feel really uncomfortable telling me what they need me to do, but I really need that, otherwise I just won’t notice, I’m just too used to being in my own world.
 
A friend at work made this comment recently – correctly identifying me as one.

When I asked how she knew she said some of the main clues were:

• getting upset over conflict
• seeing things from my point of view
• not sharing spontaneously
• being happy do things on my own
• not asking for help or assistance
• lack of small talk.

I think that most only children do share (to differing degrees) some characteristics. Do you? What do you think they are?

If you are an only child did you sometimes get the feeling that some people considered that some of these characteristics came from personal defect rather than our situation. (For example -you didn’t share because “only children are selfish” but from lack of having to do so at home.)

Did anyone else find it strange as a child that some people considered parents with one child to be strange and that they should have more when Jesus was an only child?
It depends on how the child was raised. My neighbors have one son, and he is a nice, well-behaved child who says “please” and “thank you”. On the other hand, my uncle (who has six siblings) displays all of those characteristics. :rolleyes:

I hate it when people generalize about only children. The parents are responsible for making sure the child grows up to be a mature adult. As for being an adult… well, it’s up to you how you act.
 
I think that most only children do share (to differing degrees) some characteristics. Do you? What do you think they are?
Yes and No. While I believe that there may be a correlation of personality traits and characteristics with a person’s birth order or being an only child, I don’t think they are all the same.

I’m the oldest of three. My brother and I are 14 months apart and my sister and I are 5 years apart. Perhaps because I’m the oldest, there may be a similarities between the oldest and onlies, but I’ve found similar traits in others who were in a different birth order.

• getting upset over conflict
It’s natural for siblings to fight, but I hated it. I never liked myself after I would get into a fight with my siblings and I didn’t like raising my voice. I have always disliked fighting and will avoid it if I can. But I will engage in a conflict if it means speaking out to protect or defend someone else or myself who is being hurt (physically, mentally or by reputation) or unjustly treated or wrongly blamed. And I’ve gotten myself into trouble because of that, but all worth it. The funny part is that people who think they know me (especially those who have tried to treat me with a lack of respect as if I was just rug) are usually shocked when they see me do this. I tend to be quiet.

• seeing things from my point of view

I don’t think this falls under “onlies”. I believe it is deficiency in many people from all different backgrounds.

• not sharing spontaneously

Again, something I think can be seen in people of different backgrounds. I’ve seen that trait in youngest, middle and oldest children - not just only children. It all depends on how the parents raised the children.

• being happy do things on my own

Again, this trait does not just fall under only children. There are people in other categories who are like this. Often times they are in the minority of introverts. Unfortunately, because there are many more extroverts than introverts, this trait is often looked upon as something deficient in a person. It isn’t (and don’t let anyone else tell you that it is either. 🙂 )

As a true introvert, I am very happy to do things on my own. I remember being looked at as a weirdo because I was pleased to just sit in a tree to read a book or write a story as a kid instead of playing. Inner peace and quiet is still a very essential part for me. It gives me time to really think and ponder things in my own life or what’s happening to the world around me. In many ways, my “alone time” is sometimes the most spiritually and intellectually edifying, unless I’m with one or two people with whom I can trust and share my thoughts. (Like my husband, my Dad or a very good friend.)

• not asking for help or assistance

I don’t know, I think this depends on the person again. My grandmother was the youngest of six and she is extremely independent. It took a lot to get her to finally think it was ok to ask for help. (She’s 82) She didn’t ask for help because she didn’t want to be in the way of others. I’ve never been one to ask for help either since I was a little girl. I liked to learn how to do things on my own. I also didn’t ask for help because I didn’t want to bother people. I felt that I should be able to do it on my own and learn how to do it on my own without relying on others because I thought it would rude of me, especially if I knew they were busy. And when I was a kid, I used to want to be Laura Ingalls and Anne Shirley, so I thought I needed to learn how to be self-sufficient in order to survive should the world lose all its technology and such. hahahahaha!

• lack of small talk.

Why is that a negative thing? I think small talk is overrated and can be superficial. Sometimes it is needed and I had to learn how to do it, especially in my profession of meeting audience members after a recital and such. And as I’ve gotten older, I’ve been in so many large social situations (introverts do not like large social gatherings), if I didn’t learn how to do some small talk, I would have just been (as my husband put it) a bump on the log in the corner of the room. I’ve learned to just ask specific questions of other people and let them do the talking, then focus on something they said to get into a deeper conversation with them. If within a couple minutes of small talk I find that there will be no substantial, deep or even just a fun conversation, I politely find a way out of it. For the most part, though, in those large situations, I like to observe people (like an anthropologist, haha!) unless I find someone interesting to talk to.

What I have found sad with only children is that often times they are immediately branded as spoiled brats because they were only children. And whenever they might do something less than stellar, people will say, “That’s because he’s an only child.” I find that very unfair for you onlies. It’s the same as people saying that the youngest child in a family are always spoiled brats, too, or that the oldest child or the only boy or only girl in the family gets everything they want. I suppose in some instances it can be true to certain degrees, but I believe it is unfair when people are all lumped together like that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top