I have entered into severe dryness, doubt, depression, and darkness

  • Thread starter Thread starter YosefYosep
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Y

YosefYosep

Guest
Since Easter my faith has been destroyed. I began to doubt everything and it happened so fast. I am a lover of philosophy and theology, but it seems as if I have been overcome by some emotional darkness, and now I feel as if my faith is on shaky grounds–as if it cannot be intellectually justified. I have, over the last few weeks, been trying to rebuild my faith. I have reassessed Aristotelian and Thomistic arguments for God’s existence, and I have gone through multiple books concerning the historicity of the Resurrection of Christ. Every time I think I can feel God’s presence (be it Adoration or in prayer) I rationalize it as something that is emotionally-contrived. Or every time I feel as if I have objectively looked at the premises and conclusion of an argument concerning, for instance, God’s existence, and find it convincing, I accuse myself of having bias. I am second-guessing everything, a mental voice is probing my faith, my beliefs, it’s exposing assumptions. I don’t know where this darkness is coming from–Satan, God, mental issues? It is making me exhausted and desperate. God save me.
 
That sounds deeply upsetting.

I haven’t experienced something identical but I have experienced something roughly similar in the past. Focusing on corporal works of mercy & tangible self-improvement was beneficial to me personally during that period.

You, Jesus, Mary, your angel, and your confessor will make a very good team to walk you through this period in your life.

Mother Mary, pray for your son and give him whatever arsenal he requires in order to persevere through his difficulty. Lord Jesus, have mercy on us and on the whole world. Amen.
 
That sounds deeply upsetting.

I haven’t experienced something identical but I have experienced something roughly similar in the past. Focusing on corporal works of mercy & tangible self-improvement was beneficial to me personally during that period.

You, Jesus, Mary, your angel, and your confessor will make a very good team to walk you through this period in your life.

Mother Mary, pray for your son and give him whatever arsenal he requires in order to persevere through his difficulty. Lord Jesus, have mercy on us and on the whole world. Amen.
Thank you for your suggestions. I also have an extreme lack of motivation for my faith now. I don’t know if this is important–but all of this began right after I seriously talked for almost two hours with a seminarian about me perhaps entering the priesthood. This has made me suspect that it could be a spiritual attack.

I no longer see the beauty of the Church, the sacredness of the sacraments, the holiness of saints. It’s as if someone has blinded me, made me unable to revel in the spiritual dimension of my faith. Because of this, I feel less motivated to pray, to love God.
 
It would be best to pray to the Holy Spirit for wisdom. As it says in the letter of James, the Holy Spirit gives wisdom to all who seek it.

I strongly suggest that you pray throughout the day. Have mercy on me, O Lord, a sinner.

I also suggest that you ease up on trying to find “the answer” in some book. Can God be reduced to some formula in a book? Those books may help you, but God is God, alone.

Pray for faith.

In “Jesus of Nazareth” Volume 1, Pope Benedict XVI discusses the temptations of Christ, which affect us, too. There is a chapter on the temptations of Christ. Satan tempts Jesus to misinterpret the Bible (God’s word), and, for that matter, to disregard the totality of Holy Scripture. As Benedict says, that is a temptation for people of all generations.
 
A crisis of faith, spiritual attack, or testing allowed by God. One thing I can wholeheartedly recommend, aside from the other suggestions here, is to obtain a copy of Divine Intimacy by Fr. Gabriel of St. Mary Magdalen, O.C.D.

It is a book of brief daily readings, reflections and prayers which follows the Church liturgical year. Fr. Gabriel was guided by the masters of Carmelite spirituality: Saint Teresa of Avila and Saint John of the Cross. It is aimed at the clergy and religious, but the laity most certainly can benefit greatly from it. It teaches the value even of darkness and dryness, so that you can easily envision the ultimate good that God will bring from your current situation. Highly recommended.

The Mystic Monks have the best deal on the web, and also great coffee, if you are so inclined.
 
I will keep you in my prayers. I recently went through a very hard bout of depression and spiritual drought.
 
What did you talk about during those two hours?
I imagine that’s the key as to why your thoughts and emotions are going through an upheaval…

.
I met with him to discuss the possibility of me entering into seminary–seeing how it has been a thought in the back of my mind for the past several years. To provide you with further details, we discussed the Eucharist, the saints, doubt, Thomas Aquinas, the Church Fathers, Jesuits, Ignatius of Loyola, and so on and so forth. I am also inclined to believe that I perhaps felt a tad discouraged after discussing all of this with him–as if I felt myself inadequate (both spiritually and intellectually) to join seminary or even, I regret to say, to be a Catholic.
 
Praying for you and praying for a renewal of your spiritual life.
 
Op please go back to that priest and explain this to him. Not here.
 
My friend, I am so sorry to hear of this. 😦 I will keep you in my prayers.

Try to remember that there are two sides vying for our souls: God and Satan. Only one of them works in feelings of despair, darkness, discouragement, and depression…

By deciding to even entertain the idea of the Priesthood, you have now become a much more visible target to the enemy in this battle; you have risen your head to peek above the trenches and climbed out with all the other brave men who decide to discern their proper vocational calling, be it the Priesthood or not.

Perhaps it is towards Priesthood, or perhaps towards married or single life. Do you trust in the Lord and press forward, trusting He will lead you where He needs you to go? Do you give your life over to Him? Or are you going to retreat like the enemy wants you to? Are you going to abandon He who holds your life in hands out of fear of the one who seeks to take your life away?

Now the bullets are whizzing and snapping by, and you are doubting why you left the trenches, why you were even in the trenches in the first place, and whether your participation in this battle is even necessary. What do you do now?

Trust in the Lord, trust in His will, and press on. Resist ever going backwards, but instead keep stepping forward to where He is leading. Feel lost? Don’t know where you are supposed to be going? Feel like you are in the wrong place? Then just stop, find cover and get out of range of what the enemy is throwing at you… drop to your knees, and lower your head… PRAY.

Reassess your situation and your surroundings. Where was the last place He told you to go? Have you gotten there yet? Is the reason why haven’t you heard anything from Him because you haven’t yet gone where He wanted you to go, where He called you to? Did the enemy onslaught drive you somewhere else or cause you to retreat? Can you not hear Him because you haven’t stopped the noise and the calling to Him long enough to listen for Him in the silence?

Trust in Him, trust in His will, and press on towards where He called you to go. Once you get there and when He has determined the time is right, you will then get your next move.

I highly suggest that you look into writings of the saints, like Dark Night of the Soul by St. John of the Cross.

In this hour of darkness, it is crucial to persevere in your faith, your prayer, and spiritual devotions. We must be vigilant in ensuring that our relationship with God is not just something we do because of the consolation, good feelings, and peace we feel from it.

The danger is that if we are doing them based on the joy or gratification they bring us, then there is a terrible risk of us abandoning our spiritual life when we don’t get the joy or gratification out of it that we expect.

This kind of perspective transforms our spiritual life from one of love for our Lord into one of “lust” because we are then only in it for what we get out of it: on fire and embracing it when we feel reassured, consoled, and at peace, and neglect it when we experience suffering, difficulties, and dryness or if we don’t get what we want out of our relationship with Him.

It is when we persevere through the “dark night” times, those times when prayer feels like an obligation rather than a joy, when the silence is painful, when the loneliness is crushing, and when the doubt is mounting, that we truly show our love and devotion to the Lord in an unconditional way; that we love Him and not just the feelings we get from Him.

It is then that we show that we are more than just fair weather followers who abandon His will whenever we don’t feel the consolation we crave in our spiritual life.

Go back to your seminarian friend and reengage with him, work with a spiritual director to navigate these feelings, and don’t give up! Look to the saints who have also suffered dark nights.

I will leave you with these quotes from St. Ignatius of Loyola and St. John of the Cross:
“After you have made a decision that is pleasing to God, the Devil may try to make you have second thoughts. Intensify your prayer time, meditation, and good deeds. For if Satan’s temptations merely cause you to increase your efforts to grow in holiness, He’ll have an incentive to leave you alone.” - St Ignatius of Loyola
“Never give up prayer. . . and should you find dryness and difficulty, persever in it for this very reason.
God often desires to see what love your soul has, and love is not tried by ease and satisfaction.” - St. John of the Cross
 
Lord, forgive me for not believing that your truth permeates every single layer of my life.
Fan my tiny smoldering little spark of faith into a burning and consuming fire that will bring you glory and drive out darkness.
But don’t ever let me think it is strong enough or that I have any hope of stoking it and keeping it alive apart from you.
I believe; Lord, help my unbelief!
 
YosefYosep, how have you been doing?
Better, I think. I have been praying this prayer every day. I might have experienced a moment of consolation the other night while reading a book on the philosophy of mind. I allude to that moment briefly here.
 
Happy to hear it. Hang in there and persevere and we will keep praying for you.
 
You may want to do a Google search using the keywords “depression stimulants” and take things from there.
 
This is classic dark night stuff. St. John of the Cross is the sure guide here. Also see if you can get a Carmelite to guide you through this territory.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top