There is a basis for my denial. I would not believe that the sky is green just because somebody claimed it was. I do not believe these things to be true because I believe them to be unfounded, leading the simple minded into error and distracting myself from the glory of my Lord. I do not believe that Mary was conceived without sin and I choose to disbelieve. As much as others choose to believe I choose to believe not.
Dear Janet,
These things are not unfounded. The Catholic Church takes great care in examing the writings of the Church Fathers and Church Doctors, before declaring any dogma of the Church.
Our Blessed Mother Mary herself revealed to St Bernadette Soubirous at Lourdes in 1858 that she is the Immaculate Conception;
*Thursday, March 25, 1858. Bernadette joyfully rejoined the lady in the grotto. It had been 3 weeks since she saw Aquero and had not known whether she would ever appear again. This time she was determined to obtain the lady’s name, so that she could finally tell the priest. Bernadette was characteristically stubborn, and she repeated four times the question she had practiced so often, “Would you be so kind as to tell me who you are?” The answer finally came: “I am the Immaculate Conception.”
“I went every day for a fortnight, and each day I asked her who she was–and this petition always made her smile. After the fortnight I asked her three times consecutively. She always smiled. At last I tried for the fourth time. She stopped smiling. With her arms down, she raised her eyes to heaven and then, folding her hands over her breast she said, ‘I am the Immaculate Conception.’ Then I went back to M. le Curé to tell him that she had said she was the Immaculate Conception, and he asked was I absolutely certain. I said yes, and so as not to forget the words, I had repeated them all the way home.”
Bernadette planted a candle between two rocks as a gift, a sign of her prayer and the revelation, and then ran home. Running all the way, she repeated these strange words over and over so that she would not forget them. Of course the words were spoken in her native Bigourdan dialect and were completely unfamiliar, “que soy era Immaculada Councepciou.”
Fr. Peyramale said that a woman cannot have a name like that. “You are mistaken. Do you know what that means?” The priest was shaken, and unable to talk to Bernadette. He quickly sent her away, and she left without the privilege of understanding the meaning of the title. She was only told later that afternoon that the Blessed Mother carried that title.
"She could never have invented this … " wrote Fr. Peyramale to the bishop that evening.
The Church declared that Mary was the “Immaculate Conception” only four years earlier in 1854. The title would certainly have been unknown to Bernadette since it was not broadly discussed in the liturgy, and Bernadette still could not read or write. She was only then learning her catechism to prepare for first Holy Communion, a task undertaken typically by children six or seven years her junior. It was her poor health and her family’s poverty that had hindered her education. *
