I think becoming Catholic means that my parents failed me

trev56

New member
For background, I am 19 and I just moved back in with my parents for a while after dropping out of college.

We have never, not once, spoken of religion or God in my household. We would occasionally (Christmas, Easter) attend our local mega-church service, but beyond that there was no mention of Christ. As far as religion was taken up in my house, it was my mother who took the initiative to do so, and it seems to me that my father only really went along with it insomuch as he didn't want to have any conflict about it with his wife. My father was raised Catholic by his parents, but his mother died when he was a teenager, and he began to fall away from the Church. I think that my mother supportive of religion, and I don't even think that Catholicism would be excluded from that, but only insomuch as one is able to conjure up some hope from it, not in the sense it should affect one's way of living. Her mother was the most religious person in my extended family, and as far as I can tell, her death a few years ago has made my mother see the necessity of faith in God.

As far as I understand, all of my siblings are atheists, but again, it never really gets brought up in family conversation. If it were to be spoken of, I suppose that my father would take consolation in his children being atheists, and my mother would be sorrowful to find that out, but not say anything to the contrary.

I want to become Catholic but I feel like doing so would necessarily imply that my parents failed at raising me, and I don't know what to do about that. If I am to really say that living for Christ is the meaning of life, it seems dishonest, if not an outright lie, to say that they didn't fail me and my siblings in a real way by neglecting this responsibility that they have for their children. I don't think that I have the fortitude to make that kind of claim against my parents, especially not in my current situation where they are supporting me financially.
 
I really wouldn't worry about what becoming Catholic says about, or reflects upon, your family. Many families are non-religious or near enough so. That doesn't mean they're not good people, at least on the level of natural virtue. The only thing that matters, is that you wish to come into the one true Catholic Church. That trumps everything else. It doesn't require you to make any kind of "claim".

I was in much the same situation. My parents, while good and generous people, with natural virtue in abundance, did not possess the Faith themselves, and there was no way they could have raised me in it. You cannot give what you do not have. I found it entirely on my own. In a few years after I came into the Church, they did likewise. Would it have been better if they had been Catholics from the outset, and raised me in the Church? In one sense, yes. But that wasn't the way things were. A convert to the Faith has a special gift of having embraced the Faith on their own, and believing in it because they become convinced it is true, not because someone told them it was.
 
I want to become Catholic but I feel like doing so would necessarily imply that my parents failed at raising me, and I don't know what to do about that.
I do not understand how one relates to the other.

Did your parents specifically raise you against the faith?
 
You are called to faith for the sake of your soul; to know, love and serve God; to be at peace within a world at war.
I believe that you were created to seek and accept the light of Christ and to demonstrate that light to your family. It may feel to be an awesome responsibility, but God's grace will provide all that you need.
First: prayer and lots of it.
Then: patience and love.
The faith is attractive and your faith will attract others in your family. Not by words, which often fail, but by the joy radiating from your relationship with Christ.
Let nothing; no person, no thought, no other obstacle hinder a relationship with Christ.
 
Back
Top