ID in public schools

  • Thread starter Thread starter edwest2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ummm no??? what gave you that idea? I asked for a site so I might read more and correct my misunderstanding. But thanks anyway, SoCalRC has cleared it up. I haven’t a clue how you could read my response that way. I never mentioned the words static. I have always been inclined to the open universe though I tend to follow what other astronomers claim to be the main theory.
you wrote:

wow, well I guess those 3 astronomers were just dead wrong in saying that. Thanks for the correction. Do you have a site? The Universe apparently is putting out badly flawed information. Funny that a couple of the scientists are people I’ve seen before on other shows. There is just no excuse for such bad work

I sensed a bit of sarcasm in your asking for a site.😉

Andre
 
I think we do a terrible disservice to our young people by teaching them doctrines that cannot be supported by even the most common scientific analysis … I don’t know as we need apologetics. . I am deeply dedicated to fight the fight against narrow minded relgious beliefs that lead to people deciding that they have to take stronger and stronger means to achieve what they deem essential—everyone living life as they deem appropriate.
I find it sort of interesting that in your reply to a comment that was entirely about the need to refute atheistic scientists like Richard Dawkins, you said nothing about atheism at all but just complain about “narrow minded religious beliefs”.

I say “sort of interesting” because it’s not really that interesting at all. I knew that none of the Darwinists here had any interest in trying to refute atheism. That is painfully clear after weeks of trying to read the replies from them.
 
[msg.168 ReggieM responding to MonFrere’s quote within msg. 159]Well, I think the atheist response is that since natural laws accidentally produced the entire universe, the planet earth, all life on it and human life as well – all without having any need for God’s direction, and also without showing any evidence at all that a God even exists – then to simply say that God created the Big Bang is to propose something that is just as akin to sci-fi.
MonFrere;3217448:
[msg.159]I think the atheists weakest arguments is their attempts to explain the Big Bang without a Creator. At this point they merely speculate and their scientific mind becomes to be more akin to sci-fi. The Big Bang created within it not only the universe but also the time-space continuum AND the laws of the natural world.
MonFrere
reggieM and MonFrere, you both have shown the reason why Intelligent Design is based on religion and why it isn’t science. The conclusion is obvious; ID isn’t in public schools nor will it ever be. The Intelligent Design movement has failed. So lets move onward and learn about SCIENCE.:):

Rev. Modern. Physics 79, 1331 (2007)
Nobel Lecture: From the Big Bang to the Nobel Prize and beyond by John C. Mather
Mail Code 665, Observational Cosmology Laboratory, NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, Maryland 20771, USA
(Published 2 November 2007)

NASA’s Cosmic Background Explorer satellite mission, the COBE, laid the foundations for modern cosmology by measuring the spectrum and anisotropy of the cosmic microwave background radiation and discovering the cosmic infrared background radiation. I describe the history of the COBE project, its scientific context, the people who built it, and the scientific results. The COBE observed the universe on the largest scales possible by mapping the cosmic microwave and infrared background radiation fields and determining their spectra. It produced conclusive evidence that the hot Big Bang theory of the early universe is correct, showed that the early universe was very uniform but not perfectly so, and that the total luminosity of post–Big Bang objects is twice as great as previously believed. The COBE concept was developed by a Mission Definition Study Team appointed by NASA in 1976, based on three competing proposals submitted in 1974. The COBE was built in-house by Goddard Space Flight Center, with a helium cryostat provided by Ball Aerospace, and was launched on a Delta rocket built by McDonnell Douglas. It is in a circular orbit 900 km above the Earth, in a plane inclined 99° to the equator and roughly perpendicular to the line to the Sun. It carried three instruments, a far infrared absolute spectrophotometer (FIRAS), a differential microwave radiometer with three channels (DMR), and a diffuse infrared background experiment (DIRBE). The helium cryostat cooled the FIRAS and DIRBE for 10 months until the helium was exhausted, but operations continued for a total of 4 years. Subsequent observations have confirmed the COBE results and led to measurements of the main cosmological parameters with a precision of a few percent.
scitation.aip.org/getabs/servlet/GetabsServlet?prog=normal&id=RMPHAT000079000004001331000001&idtype=cvips&gifs=Yes
http://scitation.aip.org/getabs/ser...00079000004001331000001&idtype=cvips&gifs=Yes

Here is John C. Mather’s Nobel Prize lecture and slides:
http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/physics/laureates/2006/mather_lecture.pdf
http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/physics/laureates/2006/mather-slides.pdf

NASA Scientist John C. Mather Wins 2006 Nobel Physics Prize
*Also, COBE discovered slight temperature variations of approximately 10 parts per million in this relatively uniform light. **These variations pointed to density differences which, through gravity ***over the course of billions of years, gave rise to the stars, galaxies and hierarchal structure we see today.
sev.prnewswire.com/aerospace-defense/20061003/DCTU04103102006-1.html
http://sev.prnewswire.com/aerospace-defense/20061003/DCTU04103102006-1.html
 
It isn’t a hypothesis if it is untestable and addresses no glaring deficiency in fitting alternate theories to available evidence. Meet the basic criteria for science, and it belongs in a science classroom. Don’t, and it belongs in religious studies.
Why would you say that it is untestable,SoCalRC? Also, I believe the hypothesis already exists.

livescience.com/strangenews/070816_gm_evolution.html

**“I think one of the greatest mysteries in biology at the moment is whether natural selection is the only process capable of generating organismal complexity,” said Massimo Pigliucci of the Department of Ecology and Evolution at Stony Brook University in New York, “or whether there are other properties of matter that also come into play. I suspect the latter will turn out to be true.” **

ww.surrey.ac.uk/qe/articles/The%20Guardian%20%20May2005.htm

Rather than having a single major function, most genes, like roads, probably play a small part in lots of tasks within the cell. By dissecting biology into its genetic atoms, reductionism failed to account for these multitasking genes. So the starting point for systems biologists isn’t the gene but rather a mathematical model of the entire cell. Instead of focusing on key control points, systems biologists look at the system properties of the entire network. In this new vision of biology, genes aren’t discrete nuggets of genetic information but more diffuse entities whose functional reality may be spread across hundreds of interacting DNA segments

72.14.205.104/search?q=cache:rN3x0CIqgT0J:www-binf.bio.uu.nl/BINF/seminar2005/3Caporale2003.pdf+directed+mutation&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=165&gl=ca&ie=UTF-8

**Most descriptions of evolution assume that all mutations are completely random with respect to their potential effects on survival. However, much like otherphenotypic variations that affect the survival of the descendants, intrinsic variations in the probability, type, and location of genetic change can feel the pressure of natural selection.survival. . . . . . . . . **

[

http://www.cababstractsplus.org/google/abstract.asp?AcNo=20053037028]()

Microsatellite mutation directed by an external stimulus

recombinomics.com/News/03210601/H5N1_Random_Mutations_Not.html

Commentary
.
H5N1 Random Mutations Are Not Random Or Recent Mutations


Recombinomics CommentaryMarch 21, 2006

As the number of bird flu sequences increase it becomes more apparent that the gentic drift of H5N1 is not due to random mutations, but is due to recombination. The widely held belief that the drifting is due to copying errors becomes less and less tenable as new sequences are made public.

users.tpg.com.au/users/jes999/gencog.htm

This paper shows how evolution tunes the content and frequency of genetic variation to enhance its evolvability. Genetic evolution is not random or entirely blind. Genetic systems are like nervous systems and brains—they have been structured and organised by evolution to enhance their ability to discover effective adaptations.

genetics.hannam.ac.kr/note/evolution.htm

Nine years ago John Cairns and his colleagues at the Harvard School of Public Health reported in the influential journal Nature sensational experiments “suggesting that cells may have mechanisms for choosing which mutations will occur” specifically, in ways that give those cells an advantage tn stressful conditions. This radical proposal collided head-on with the sacrosanct principle of genetics that mutations occur at a rate that is completely unrelated to whatever consequences they might have. Cairns’s suggestion thus consequence the ghost of Jean-Baptiste Lamarck, who argued in the 19th century that species evolve through the inheritance do " acquired" characteristics ¤Ñ ones that individuals develop in response to environmental challenges

jb.asm.org/cgi/content/full/182/11/2993

**This minireview will describe mechanisms of mutation that are not random and can accelerate the process of evolution in specific directions. The existence of such mechanisms has been predicted by mathematicians (6) who argue that, if every mutation were really random and had to be tested against the environment for selection or rejection, there would not have been enough time to evolve the extremely complex biochemical networks and regulatory mechanisms found in organisms today. Dobzhansky (21) expressed similar views by stating “The most serious objection to the modern theory of evolution is that since mutations occur by `chance’ and are undirected, it is difficult to see how mutation and selection can add up to the formation of such beautifully balanced organs as, for example, the human eye.” **

Would you claim these as bad science?

Andre
 
The conclusion is obvious; ID isn’t in public schools nor will it ever be. The Intelligent Design movement has failed. So lets move onward and learn about SCIENCE.
Well, I see the ID movement getting more successful every year. You could look at the debates that are taking place around college campuses for example. ID theorists are invited to debate evolutionists. As I’ve mentioned also, there are many new books on ID every year. ID is making a positive contribution to science and helping to expose the errors of Darwinism. So I wouldn’t say it has failed – it has really only just gotten started.
 
The Dover case was a nationwide disaster for ID, because it established that ID was a religion, and hence illegal to present in a public school science class. “A train wreck” admitted ID’er Phillip Johnson.

Of course the fact that prominent ID’ers like Behe and Denton went over to evolution didn’t help any. Nor did the release of the Wedge Document, in which ID’ers admitted that their “governing goal” was promotion of their religious ideas.

And, the ongoing failure of ID to do anything of use to science, after numerous promises about how “good it’s going to be” hurt them badly. Many scientists (myself included) were interested, but when it became clear that ID couldn’t do anything useful, they went away.

ID is primarily winning adherents from creationism. Which is why some creationists assail ID as a halfway house to evolution. In some cases, they are right.
 
Well, I think the atheist response is that since natural laws accidentally produced the entire universe, the planet earth, all life on it and human life as well – all without having any need for God’s direction, and also without showing any evidence at all that a God even exists – then to simply say that God created the Big Bang is to propose something that is just as akin to sci-fi.
IMO - I think the present crop of atheists are feeling pretty confident. And that confidence is giving them the rope that is going to hang them.

What I mean is that in terms of “the scientific method” all theories must be proven to be verifiable. I think your paragraph above is based on a non verifiable statements. I don’t think science can verify ANYTHING that occurred before the Big Bang. The statement “natural laws accidentally produced the entire universe” to me, cannot be verified. Philosophers, even skeptical ones, e.g. Hume, have extreme difficulty in accepting a non caused cause. He said, “I have never asserted so absurd a proposition as that anything might arise without cause.” There must be a cause for the universe to have come into existence.

I agree with a comment you made earlier that stated that philosophy needed to be considered as a tool of knowledge to help us in understanding “reality”. Science alone just doesn’t bring enough to the table.
Why does this leave a lot to be desired? Evolutionists commonly state that human consciousness is the product of material elements. Are you saying that it is not possible to accept that human consciousness arose through evolutionary means? If so, what evidence do you have to prove that?
I would use the same argument here. I don’t think human conscience is something that science can verify. It is something that is non material and therefore something that is beyond the scope of science.

more to come …

MonFrere
 
The following is a lengthy quote from D’Souza’s book explaining how conscience cannot be a completely materialistic phenomena.
In Crick’s view, the brain “sees,” “hears,” “believes,” guesses," and even makes “interpretations.” But as philosopher Peter Hacker and neuroscientist Max Bennett point out, it is a conceptual fallacy to attribute qualities to the brain that are possessed only by persons.
My brain isn’t conscious; I am conscious. My brain doesn’t perceive or hear things; I do. My brain isn’t thinking; I am thinking. Crick is guilty of something called the pathetic fallacy, which is the fallacy o ascribing human qualities to inanimate objects. Certainly we use our brains to perceive and reason, just as we use our hands and feet to play tennis. But it is just a crazy to say my hands and feet are playing tennis as it is to say my racket is playing tennis. By the same token it is wrong to portray the brain as perceiving, feeling, thinking, or even being aware of anything.
There is a deeper problem with extending the materialistic understanding of nature to human beings. For starters, we experience the outside world – the world described by the laws of physics and chemistry – very differently than we experience ourselves. This is a point emphasized by philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer. All other things we experience indirectly, for the outside, through the apparatus of our senses, but ourselves we experience directly, from the inside, without the involvement of our senses. Only about ourselves do we have this kind of “inside information.” which is the clearest, most fundamental knowledge we can have. Based on this privileged and unique access, we know that the external account of reality, however accurate it may be in describing raindrops and cheetahs, is not the full story when it comes to describing ourselves.
We are sure, for example, that we exist. David Hume said that we can’t really even know this: “When I enter most intimately into what I call myself, I always stumble on some particular perception or other, of heat or cold, light or shade, love or hate, pain or pleasure, I never can catch myself at any time without a perception and never can observe any thing but the perception.” Consequently, for Hume, the self is a fiction because it cannot be empirically located. But the remarkable thing is that we are conscious of our own existence prior to having any feelings and thoughts. Besides, our feelings and thoughts are experienced as “possessions” somehow distinct from the self, while the self is experienced directly. Schopenhauer writes that as we are the subjects of our own inquiry, the materialist mistake is that of “the subject that forgets to take account of itself.” Hume is observing sensations while ignoring the fact that he is the one who is doing the observing. He is allowing his indirect knowledge of external phenomena to trump his direct knowledge of the “I” that is having these experiences. We not only exist, but we are also conscious. This consciousness seems utterly basic; we cannot get “behind” it, and it is our entire mode of access to the world of experience. We seem to share consciousness with at least some other animals, but not with plants or nonliving things. Moreover, human consciousness seems to be of a different order than animal consciousness. For instance, consider the way we experience music. From the materialist point of view, music is nothing but vibrations that collide with eardrums and provoke neural reactions in the brain. But we experience music in an entirely different way. Even our most mundane thoughts and experiences seem inexplicable when described in terms of physical and chemical transactions alone. A doctor, for example, may know more about my cerebral cortex than I do, but of my inner thoughts he knows nothing, and he will never be able to see or weigh or touch them no matter how good his instruments.
I just cannot understand the possibility of our self consciousness being totally the result of materialism.

MonFrere
 
I just cannot understand the possibility of our self consciousness being totally the result of materialism.
Of course, I agree (and I take it much farther than that) but I wonder if your approach would apply to the “creation of life” itself. Since “life” is immaterial, would this immediately refute the evolutionary theories that claim that life emerged from non-living matter?

Or would you say that life is not immaterial and is thus a matter that science can study?
I don’t think science can verify ANYTHING that occurred before the Big Bang. The statement “natural laws accidentally produced the entire universe” to me, cannot be verified.
Well, I think it is “verified” in very much the same way that evolutionary theory is “verified”. Some ideas are proposed on what is observed and then a “plausible” evolutionary pathway is worked out. But simply observing fossils and stating that one emerged from the other is very similar to saying that one universe created another or that the big bang created the natural laws.
I agree with a comment you made earlier that stated that philosophy needed to be considered as a tool of knowledge to help us in understanding “reality”.
Yes, that is important. I would say that philosophy is essential to science and cannot be separated from it. Again, the concept of the “scientific method” is a philosophical proposition.
 
reggieM and MonFrere, you both have shown the reason why Intelligent Design is based on religion and why it isn’t science. The conclusion is obvious; ID isn’t in public schools nor will it ever be. The Intelligent Design movement has failed. So lets move onward and learn about SCIENCE.:):
WildLeafBlower,

Either I cannot write or you cannot read. My quibble is not with the Big Bang OR evolution. I thought my posting of the past couple days were very clear on those points. My quibble is with atheists who say God did not create the universe or who say that man is totally materialistic; a body without a soul.

On a personal level I have a problem with those who seem to put science on a pedastal ando look it as the Saviour of man. It’s been a wonderful tool for helping us understand our material world and has made the civilized world much more comfortable to live in. But in the realm of some scientists wanting to take over the work of the theologian or even God Himself – well, I say they need to confine themselves to areas where they’re useful.

MonFrere
 
In your dreams. 😃
No, there really are a number of new books on ID coming out each year. I would think that you would have to be dreaming to deny that. 🙂

There are also debates on Intelligent Design at prominent universities like this upcoming event:
Debate at Stanford
What: Atheism vs. Theism and the Scientific Evidence of Intelligent Design
Who: Christopher Hitchens (author, God is Not Great) vs. Jay Wesley Richards (author, The Privileged Planet)
When: SUNDAY January 27th - Doors open 2:45 PM – SHUT @ 3:30 PM – LIVE Broadcast on CCN Commences 3:55 PM
Where: Dinkelspiel Auditorium
How: Get FREE tickets w/ SUID at White Plaza 12-1 PM Tuesday-Friday or at the Ticket Office
 
Either I cannot write or you cannot read.
It’s interesting because you and I do not agree on evolution, but WildLeaf was not able to understand that.

I’ll also say that you’re the only evolution-defender I’ve seen thus far who really understands the threat of atheism and you’re taking it seriously enough to work on refuting it.

Perhaps that has lead Wildleafblower to think you are a creationist. :confused:

If so, that is very sad. Here on a Catholic discussion group, the mere effort to try to refute atheism is attacked as if that is something only a fundamentalist would do.
 
reggie << No, there really are a number of new books on ID coming out each year. I would think that you would have to be dreaming to deny that. >>

Oh sure, there are plenty of ID books published every year, just as there are plenty of books about the Lost City of Atlantis, psychics, UFOs, and various other pseudo-science. The question is who publishes these books? Are the ID books published by reputable university publishers? I can think of one from 2004: From Darwin to DNA co-edited by William Dembski and Michael Ruse, published by Cambridge Univ Press. I can’t think of any others. Behe’s new (2007) book was pretty much dead right when it came out.

reggie << There are also debates on Intelligent Design at prominent universities like this upcoming event >>

Well that’s interesting. But I wish the debate wasn’t between Hitchens (who is not a physicist or astronomer) and Richards (who is also not a physicist or astronomer). I wish it would be between Guillermo Gonzalez (astronomer ID proponent) vs. Vic Stenger (physicist ID opponent). Now that would be a more interesting debate. But still Hitchens is a prominent atheist spokesman, and Richards is co-author with Gonzalez of The Privileged Planet. For the record, I accept cosmological ID (or the Anthropic Principle) which has more going for it than biological ID.

Thanks for heads up about this debate. As for theistic evolutionists who defend against atheism, I probably have the largest William Lane Craig MP3 debate collection on my site, ones that were not online before. And he has debated Vic Stenger, it didn’t turn out so well for Vic. 😃

Phil P
 
As noted reggieM and MonFrere still can’t comprehend Science nor read or understand what they wrote that I replied to in my message 182. Yes, they are proponents of Intelligent Design. Can’t waste my time explaining it further to them. Moving on…
Oh sure, there are plenty of ID books published every year, just as there are plenty of books about the Lost City of Atlantis, psychics, UFOs, and various other pseudo-science. The question is who publishes these books? Are the ID books published by reputable university publishers? I can think of one from 2004: From Darwin to DNA co-edited by William Dembski and Michael Ruse, published by Cambridge Univ Press. I can’t think of any others. Behe’s new (2007) book was pretty much dead right when it came out.
Phil, the Intelligent Design movement is filled with New Age Enlightenment junkies into Intregal Studies. It’s not only books that ID has a hold of but magazines that support their patrons such as Ken Wilber (1)(Big fan of Behe and likes his pupils to read Behe’s books) and others in What Is Enlightenment? (magazine):

W ISSUE 39 / FEBRUARY–APRIL 2008
The Cosmos, the Psyche, and YOU
An evolutionary vision for spirituality and psychology in the 21st century
In one of WIE’s most eclectic issues yet, we trace the profound influence that the 20th-century luminaries Carl Jung and Pierre Teilhard de Chardin have had on the way we see ourselves and our world, and how their perspectives are shaping our collective destiny today. Plus, we take a closer look at the idea of the “divine feminine,” critique the artwork of Adi Da Samraj, explore the relationship between time and eternity, and speak with a bodybuilding legend on his pursuit of self mastery. Featuring Ken Wilber, Frank Zane, Helen LaKelly Hunt, Andrew Cohen, and more.
wie.org/j39/
wie.org/j39/

Obviously, people don’t have a lick of sense nor a grip on reality.😦
Get a life and don’t waste your time on junk.
  1. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ken_Wilber
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ken_Wilber
 
MonFrere writes:
On a personal level I have a problem with those who seem to put science on a pedastal ando look it as the Saviour of man. It’s been a wonderful tool for helping us understand our material world and has made the civilized world much more comfortable to live in. But in the realm of some scientists wanting to take over the work of the theologian or even God Himself – well, I say they need to confine themselves to areas where they’re useful.
In this, you and I are in complete agreement. Science is a very useful tool, but it has strict limitations in the way it works. For some reason, this is hard for creationists to understand.
 
It’s interesting because you and I do not agree on evolution, but WildLeaf was not able to understand that.

I’ll also say that you’re the only evolution-defender I’ve seen thus far who really understands the threat of atheism and you’re taking it seriously enough to work on refuting it.

Perhaps that has lead Wildleafblower to think you are a creationist. :confused:

If so, that is very sad. Here on a Catholic discussion group, the mere effort to try to refute atheism is attacked as if that is something only a fundamentalist would do.
It is also very sad that “fundamentalist” is understood only in a very negative light. Atheism is, right now, going through an attempted revival. It will be brief, since those who follow God will continue on.

God bless,
Ed
 
Fortunately, the Catholic Church is involved in science, and interprets it correctly for the faithful.
Yes they seem to Ed. Why are you still clinging to YEC and Creationism then? Why are there no creationists or YEC “scientists” on the PAS?
I don’t know why you identify creationism as a pressing problem. Pressing for who? I understand your job is to get everyone to just say yes to evolution, but creationism is a problem? “We believe in God, creator of heaven and earth.” That is what Catholics believe.
Ed
It is Ed because as we have told you multiple times, teaching kids lies causes them to become atheists in the end. They resent being told psuedo-science as truth. They get rebellious when they are given an opportunity to see the truth. We certainly do believe that God is creator, he just used evolution. You used to agree, yuou just wanted a God statement in textbooks, now you’ve decided to chuck it all and return to the comfort of fundamentalism again.
 
you wrote:

wow, well I guess those 3 astronomers were just dead wrong in saying that. Thanks for the correction. Do you have a site? The Universe apparently is putting out badly flawed information. Funny that a couple of the scientists are people I’ve seen before on other shows. There is just no excuse for such bad work

I sensed a bit of sarcasm in your asking for a site.😉

Andre
I’m aware some have the tendency to see it when its something they are disagreeing with. It reflected the constant concern I have as a lay person in attempting to know what I can accept on TV shows which attempt to teach me science. National Geographic has been caught in a rather bad thing with Judas, so I’m a bit wary. I thought I had heard it correctly and the science was poor. SoCal just explained that I had misunderstood what they said. I was partly right, partly wrong.

PS…I havent’ believed in a steady state theory in probably 30 years or more…lol…
 
I find it sort of interesting that in your reply to a comment that was entirely about the need to refute atheistic scientists like Richard Dawkins, you said nothing about atheism at all but just complain about “narrow minded religious beliefs”.
Did you want me to suggest we write books against atheism too? I figure that is done every time someone writes an “inspirational book”. I think you and Ed are fixated on atheists. They are quite a small part of the population, and most seem to be intelligent, hardworking,honest people. I disagree with them of course, but they are not evil people by and large. Most people would rather debate an atheist than a creationist for sure. Its a very big difference in logical argument.
I say “sort of interesting” because it’s not really that interesting at all. I knew that none of the Darwinists here had any interest in trying to refute atheism. That is painfully clear after weeks of trying to read the replies from them.
I didn’t know recognizing the worldwide acceptance of a scientific inquiry also required me to refute atheism. And ummmm, can you refute it? They certainly can do no better at refuting God, so I think we are in a standoff. I feel luckier being a believer, but then again, God will be the “decider” won’t he.?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top