ID in public schools

  • Thread starter Thread starter edwest2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Why would teaching ID, which is not science, be worse than teaching evolution, which is bad science?
 
Tell you what… let’s leave the term intelligent design aside. Would you be in agreement to simply let schools teach Darwin’s theory of evolution as such with the inclusion of having **some **hypotheses arising identifying the nature of mutations as being non-random in essence, and let the implication as to what this means, left to the
students?
It isn’t a hypothesis if it is untestable and addresses no glaring deficiency in fitting alternate theories to available evidence. Meet the basic criteria for science, and it belongs in a science classroom. Don’t, and it belongs in religious studies.
 
You have a very sympathetic ear with me, MonFrere, although I don’t think most of the Darwinists here really care that much about refuting Dawkins’ work. They don’t seem to care much about the problem of atheism either.
I don’t worry about atheism nearly as much as I worry about the activities of many self described theists. Look at the lay provided voter’s guide for ‘serious’ Catholics. It took the Vatican’s list of non negotiable moral principles and pared it down, dropping anything even remotely related to social justice.

So, we have a form of Catholicism that not only is comfortable in ignoring the Magesterium, but has decided that the Gospels (from the Greek for ‘Good News’, as in Good News for the Poor) is obsolete as well.

Add in supposedly serious politicians on the national stage with ties to religious reconstructionism making noises about reshaping the Constitution, and I get very nervous indeed. Something about their holding the belief that Catholicism isn’t a valid form of Christianity makes me skeptical about life in a theocracy of their making…
 
Dawkins’ view is that natural laws working on matter of the universe are responsible for the formation of the earth and life on earth and of human life and all there is to it.

As he sees it, there is no need for God to exist since everything that exists came about through accidental, blind processes.

How do you refute that?
First, I would recommend Dinesh D’ Souza’s book that was specifically written as a response to Harris, Dawkins, Dawkins et. al. and their recent books attacking theism, especially Christianity. The title is What’s So Great About Christianity.

amazon.com/Whats-So-Great-About-Christianity/dp/1596985178/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1200887199&sr=8-1

I think the atheists weakest arguments is their attempts to explain the Big Bang without a Creator. At this point they merely speculate and their scientific mind becomes to be more akin to sci-fi. The Big Bang created within it not only the universe but also the time-space continuum AND the laws of the natural world.

I also think their explanation of human consciousness, as being pretty much a result of the multiplicity of neurons synapses, leaves a lot to be desired. The addition of arguments from philosophers on this point is a great boon to this book.

I may go in more detail later - I just popped in before going to bed here in EST. But, I do recommend D’ Souza’s book. I’m learning a lot from reading it. He brings in a whole host of the atheists complaints regarding Christianity and does a fine job of deflating their anti-God positions.

MonFrere
 
Personally, I view the comparison you made as something much different.

For me, atheism is far, far worse than mistaken political policies that some Catholics may hold.

It’s a different topic also, but something like a pro-abortion political stance is so completely immoral that one cannot trade that off with a candidate who perhaps has more humane policies in helping the poor (and what those policies are and how they are more humane than others is very far from being certain in Catholic moral or doctrinal terms).

In any case – that’s very much off-topic here, but I’ll just say that my view of atheism; the damage it causes to individuals and society, the almost complete extinguishing of any spark of grace or light of God, and the almost-certain eternal consequences of that position – all of that is an enormous moral and spiritual problem. I agreed with MonFrere that atheism is growing in influence, especially with young people.

I also think that the Darwinists here will generally agree with you that atheism is not a primary concern for them (if a concern at all).
 
However, his inference were philosophical, not scientific, for there was no way he could experiment on them.
Hmm… he pointed out that a clepshydra could only work if air were made of miniscule particles. Observation and evidence ar powerful parts of the scientific method.

He also performed experiments with herbs , plants and stones, and eventually acquired a reputation for a deep knowledge of natural phenomena. Though his lifestyle was reclusive, his talents and intelligence helped him became a man of authority and honour in Abdera.
bbc.co.uk/dna/h2g2/A3936026

Barbarian observes:
Properly speaking, there are no philosophical hypotheses. Science is a methodology which is inductive and procedes from evidence.
However, some scientific inductions are, in my opinion, philosophical in essence since they are not directly verifyable,
Then they aren’t science at all. A hypothesis must above all, be testable.
such as … Democritus’ atom.
The atom was quite testable for democritus. He showed that air, for example, was made of small particles. \

Barbarian observes:
No. He conducted experiments, and examined the results to make his conclusions. His use of a clepshydra to show that air must be made of something, and his explanation of the nature of conic sections led him to believe that atoms must exist.
Would you have a link which I could maybe read up on this?
Maybe so. Let me see… nothing much on the net. A brief mention of his experiments.

Barbarian observes:
I don’t see how. What he did was what scientists still do. He even mocked other philosophers for trying to explain the material world with philosophic speculations. He said that people always want to explain nature by inventing new gods.
Well, he actually proposed the soul to be made up of a specific form of atoms.
He was a philosopher, as well as a scientist. Remember, he was a pioneer in the scientific method, not the man who put the finishing touches on it.

Barbarian observes:
We don’t. In series of experiments, it was shown that antibiotic resistance (for example) appears even when antibiotics are not present. But such things only come to dominate the population where selection is operating for it.
But would’nt this be an example of genetic drift?
Not usually. In the absence of antibiotics, antibiotic-resistant organisms are usually at a disadvantage. At very least, there’s no selective pressure to continue the mutation in the population, and so it normally disappears. The point is that mutations are not in response to need. They appear randomly.
If so, random mutation is not the explanation as I understand it.
“Genetic drift” only counts if the allele frequency changes randomly. And in some respect or another, this is always happening. But that would not account for the random nature of favorable mutations. As you see, they happen whether or not there is a need for them. Indeed, they are only favorable, if useful.
Also, would you have a site where observations were made where bacteria deficient in their ability to utilise the milk sugar lactose, acquired lactose-eating mutations when lactose was not available within their environment?
The classic test of that hypothesis was done with antibiotic resistance. This is the famous Luria/Delbruck experiment, in which they showed that mutations were not driven by selection.
mai.liu.se/~tikos/kurser/TAMS23/delbru.pdf

They just appear randomly, and if they happen to be useful, then they tend to spread in the population.

Barbarian on ID:
Being a religious doctrine, it can’t be taught in public school science classes, but it could be taught in a class on religion.
I don’t refer to id (as opposed to ID) as a form of intelligent design in terms of a god of the gap theory, but a process which exists having a purpose and direction.
That’s the first problem. We can’t find anything like that in nature. Of course, IDers say that they know God is doing it. But that’s not science.
natural selection is said to be the “directional element” (something I’m having problems with), it certainly cannot be said to be purposeful in nature.
No more than a hurricane is purposeful. It just happens as the result of natural forces.
Tell you what… let’s leave the term intelligent design aside. Would you be in agreement to simply let schools teach Darwin’s theory of evolution as such with the inclusion of having some hypotheses arising identifying the nature of mutations as being non-random in essence, and let the implication as to what this means, left to the students?
Some years ago, there was some indication in a study that there might be non-random mutations. But it didn’t pan out.
 
First, I would recommend Dinesh D’ Souza’s book that was specifically written as a response to Harris, Dawkins, Dawkins et. al. and their recent books attacking theism, especially Christianity. The title is What’s So Great About Christianity.
Ok, thanks for that recommendation. I watched D’Souza in a televised debate with an atheist and I thought he did a good job.
I think the atheists weakest arguments is their attempts to explain the Big Bang without a Creator. At this point they merely speculate and their scientific mind becomes to be more akin to sci-fi. The Big Bang created within it not only the universe but also the time-space continuum AND the laws of the natural world.
Well, I think the atheist response is that since natural laws accidentally produced the entire universe, the planet earth, all life on it and human life as well – all without having any need for God’s direction, and also without showing any evidence at all that a God even exists – then to simply say that God created the Big Bang is to propose something that is just as akin to sci-fi.
This would be a God who exhibits no evidence of existence on earth – and no sign in creation. Additionally, the “natural laws” he supposedly created are imperfect and use random, accidental patterns to create mutations which are useless (and die off) and all sorts of by-products of evolution. In other words, what evidence is there that God created laws?
I also think their explanation of human consciousness, as being pretty much a result of the multiplicity of neurons synapses, leaves a lot to be desired.
Why does this leave a lot to be desired? Evolutionists commonly state that human consciousness is the product of material elements. Are you saying that it is not possible to accept that human consciousness arose through evolutionary means? If so, what evidence do you have to prove that?
He brings in a whole host of the atheists complaints regarding Christianity and does a fine job of deflating their anti-God positions.
I will look for that and try to read it as soon as possible. I liked D’Souza’s presentation on tv but I felt he gave far too much ground to evolution. As above, it sounds like a God of the gaps approach – in other words, evolution did everything except for possibly one thing that we haven’t figured out yet. Also, God created the Big Bang but we have no evidence for that except to wonder where the natural laws came from. We can’t see any evidence (supposedly) of God’s creation within the laws themselves.
 
Why would teaching ID, which is not science, be worse than teaching evolution, which is bad science?
Excellent question. Although I do believe that ID is founded in science – and as Cardinal Schonborn says, the evidence for design in nature is “overwhelming”. So I think it is science to recognize God’s design in nature. Philosophy is an important part of science – otherwise, we wouldn’t even be able to define what science is.
 
Although I do believe that ID is founded in science
That’s a testable belief. From the guys who invented ID:

Governing Goals
To defeat scientific materialism and its destructive moral, cultural and political legacies.
To replace materialistic explanations with the theistic understanding that nature and hurnan beings are created by God.


So it’s a religion. Not scientific in the least.
and as Cardinal Schonborn says, the evidence for design in nature is “overwhelming”. So I think it is science to recognize God’s design in nature.
So far, everytime someone thinks he’s found “design”, we find a naturalistic reason for it. That’s how God does most things in this world. Why not just let Him be God and let it be?
 
Inferior graduates who cannot compete in high tech fields in a global economy.
Mysteriously, for the entire history of the United States, brilliant scientists went to Sunday schools and were taught that God created everything. This did not hinder them. In fact, because they believed the universe was created by a rational, intelligent being, they expected to find order in it. Samuel Morse, the inventor of the telegraph, sent this first message: “What hath God wrought?”

Those who wish to kick God out of public life should recognize the fact that God was and still is, very much a part of it, including science. Your statement is not provable.

God bless,
Ed
 
That’s a testable belief. From the guys who invented ID:

Governing Goals
To defeat scientific materialism and its destructive moral, cultural and political legacies.
To replace materialistic explanations with the theistic understanding that nature and hurnan beings are created by God.


So it’s a religion. Not scientific in the least.

So far, everytime someone thinks he’s found “design”, we find a naturalistic reason for it. That’s how God does most things in this world. Why not just let Him be God and let it be?
Your mention of God appears to be window dressing and unimportant. Your primary concern seems to be the Discovery Institute and the Wedge Document. This is not charades. The truth of the matter is not sleight of hand and misdirection - pointing to the “evil” creators of the Wedge Document - but about the truth. The Discovery Institute does not have a monopoly on Intelligent Design.

You mention God but it appears your only goal is to get everyone to “just say yes to evolution.”

God bless,
Ed
 
Your statement is not provable.
Actually, it is, we can look at many metrics and compare the results. Remember, much of the industrialized world is secular, or otherwise not deist.

Seen the makeup of the graduate students of our best scientific institutions lately?

Don’t get me started on the anti-Catholic propoganda we used to bombard every school aged child with. Suffice to say, who is stopping future generations from Sunday school? Did God and faith get weaker? Why does it suddenly need to be in science class?
 
(Barbarian points out that IDers have declared that the promotion of their religious ideas is the “governing goal” of ID)
Your mention of God appears to be window dressing and unimportant.
IDers say it is their guiding purpose. It is, by their own declaration, the most important thing to them.
Your primary concern seems to be the Discovery Institute and the Wedge Document.
They invented ID; they should know.
This is not charades. The truth of the matter is not sleight of hand and misdirection - pointing to the “evil” creators of the Wedge Document
Why do you assume that those who are looking to advance their religion (different as it is from our own) are “evil?”
The Discovery Institute does not have a monopoly on Intelligent Design.
They invented it. And so, they remain the authority on what it is. You could do what creationists do with evolution; modify it to suit yourself, and then pretend that it’s the real thing. But no one with any sense would be fooled.
You mention God but it appears your only goal is to get everyone to “just say yes to evolution.”
The real issue is that creationism is a way to drive people away from God. That is the most pressing problem.
 
Mysteriously, for the entire history of the United States, brilliant scientists went to Sunday schools and were taught that God created everything. This did not hinder them.
Of course. God is in no way antithetical to science in general or evolution in particular.
Those who wish to kick God out of public life
God will always be in public life. It’s government that is prohibited from meddling in our religious beliefs. The same Founders who so bluntly prohibited governmental interference in religion, stated that a free nation needed God. They even went so far as to assert that the law had no business promoting or controlling religion.
should recognize the fact that God was and still is, very much a part of it, including science.
Science is too weak a method to consider God. And as the Pope said, science shouldn’t get involved in theology. Fortunately, scientists are not limited to science.
 
Fortunately, the Catholic Church is involved in science, and interprets it correctly for the faithful.

I don’t know why you identify creationism as a pressing problem. Pressing for who? I understand your job is to get everyone to just say yes to evolution, but creationism is a problem? “We believe in God, creator of heaven and earth.” That is what Catholics believe.

God bless,
Ed
 
I agree with your point that Christians need to be educating their people.

BUT I also feel that there needs to be an answer to these current best sellers written by atheists. The God Delusion - God Is NOT Great. These books cry out for a Christian response. If we don’t respond it seems as if their arguments are beyond dispute and we are admitting defeat. Atheists needs to see the weakness of their “religion” just as much, perhaps even more, than non-Catholics. They are spiritually MORE needy that Protestants!! I’ve had some conversations with young people who are testing the waters of atheism. Most of them have been disillusioned because of the death of a loved one and cannot reconcile this with a loving God. From everything I see, with materialistic western society going to its logical end, atheism is very much on the ascendancy. Catholic Christians need to be equipped for this apologetic work because these people really are in great spiritual need.

MonFrere
I think you are right. More needs be written undoubtedly on the subject that evolution is no threat to God and the two are a complementary whole. I have not the degree in science required to do a credible job however. I think we do a terrible disservice to our young people by teaching them doctrines that cannot be supported by even the most common scientific analysis. The truth is not incompatible as I said.

I don’t know as we need apologetics. That gets you off on the wrong foot immediately because it says by definition, I’m here to make the best case for the Church. The best work would be by Catholic or believing scientists who can painstakingly go through the evidence and show that the findings of science are not incompatible with God or with Church teachings.

When you lie to kids and tell them evolution is bunk, they buy it until they leave home…In the wider world of ideas they soon see that the position is insupportable and end up becoming atheists. This is the direct fault I lay claim on those who fundamentally taught them lies in the first place.

I am deeply dedicated to fight the fight against narrow minded relgious beliefs that lead to people deciding that they have to take stronger and stronger means to achieve what they deem essential—everyone living life as they deem appropriate. Al Qaida does this, and historically fundamentalist christians have done so,on many occassions. It is dangerous and so against God. They universally distort God into some revenge seeking absolute monarch.
 
I think you are referring to the episode on dark matter and dark energy. I think it is a matter of context and presentation. I actually know some of the folks being interviewed and I think that your impression is just a missunderstanding on extent, emphasis, and implication (ex. sometimes the naration is a little over dramatic).

As noted, Einstein did not like that his own theory predicted that the universe would either be expanding or contracting, so he created a force with properties opposite of gravity and used it to predict a static universe. However, then we realized that some celestial bodies were actually other galaxies and, by all apparent measure, are moving away from us.

So, it was filed away as a blunder. However, now it appears that expansion is not slowing, but accelerating. So it appears evident that something other than gravity is involved. If it is a force, it has somewhat opposite properties from gravity. An idea along the same general lines of what Einstein called his greatest blunder. But Einstein’s proposed cosmological constant does not fit the actual data. That is, as a theory, it does not seem match what we know about ‘dark energy’. So, in scientific terms, ‘dark energy’ and ‘cosmological constant’ are two different things.

But it still is an excellent show - and I’m not just saying that because my oldest daughter has had a non speaking cameo appearance!
Thanks for clearing it up for me. I thought I had got it all wrong, now it appears I only got it part wrong…lol…We’ve certainly enjoyed them a lot. Not as good as PBS usually does with similar stuff, but sometimes History, discovery channel, and NG get it right. then of course we are faced with NG’s rather poor mangling of the gospel of Judas…lol…
 
So, you’re saying that the universe is static…???

Do you have a site which claims this?

Unfortunately the site you gave me couldn’t upload all the way…I’ll try later, or you could just copy/paste the reference of those three astronomers.

Andre
Ummm no??? what gave you that idea? I asked for a site so I might read more and correct my misunderstanding. But thanks anyway, SoCalRC has cleared it up. I haven’t a clue how you could read my response that way. I never mentioned the words static. I have always been inclined to the open universe though I tend to follow what other astronomers claim to be the main theory.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top