Did you happen to read on from there?
Q. Why was it in your book?
A. It was in my book because as I’m sure you’ve also looked at, that statement was not in the first edition the book, it was not in the second edition, it was not in the fourth edition, it was not in the fifth edition. It was not —
Firstly, Miller claims “that statement was not in the first edition the book, it was not in the second edition, it was not in the fourth edition.” Miller is correct that the 1995 version is the third edition of that textbook. But he’s wrong to say it only appears in the third edition because the statement “
Evolution is random and undirected” (emphasis in original)
appears in all of the first four versions of this textbook! The 1991, 1993, 1995, and 1998 editions all state on page 658 that “Evolution is random and undirected” (emphasis in original), and they also all state on that same page, “evolution works without either plan or purpose.”
Miller’s account thus cannot be completely accurate. Miller told the Judge:
“When this was first pointed out to me, the third edition of this book was in print, I immediately went to Joe, I said Joe, I think this is a bad idea, I said I think this is a non-scientific statement, I think it will mislead students. Joe agreed. We immediately took it out of the book, and that’s why I emphasized that it did not appear in subsequent editions.”
The statement “evolution is random and undirected” does appear after the third edition; it is found in the fourth edition (1998). What really happened?
Secondly,
Miller claims that only one edition of his textbooks had problematic language, stating “this is the only edition of any of the books that we have published, and probably eleven different editions, that contains that statement”.
This is also a false statement. If Miller has indeed published eleven versions of his textbooks, as he says, then there are materialistic descriptions of evolution in six of them:
(1) “[E]volution works without either plan or purpose … Evolution is random and undirected.”
(Biology, by Kenneth R. Miller & Joseph S. Levine, pg. 658 (1st edition, Prentice Hall, 1991); emphasis in original)
(2)“[E]volution works without either plan or purpose … Evolution is random and undirected.”
(Biology, by Kenneth R. Miller & Joseph S. Levine, pg. 658 (2nd edition, Prentice Hall, 1993); emphasis in original)
(3)“[E]volution works without either plan or purpose … Evolution is random and undirected.”
(Biology, by Kenneth R. Miller & Joseph S. Levine, pg. 658 (3rd edition, Prentice Hall, 1995); emphasis in original)
(4)“[E]volution works without either plan or purpose … Evolution is random and undirected.”
(Biology, by Kenneth R. Miller & Joseph S. Levine, pg. 658 (4th edition, Prentice Hall, 1998); emphasis in original)
Additionally, Miller’s textbook, Biology: Discovering Life contains language which is even more anti-religious than that of his elephant textbook, Biology. Consider the 5th and 6th instances below:
(5) “
Darwin knew that accepting his theory required believing in philosophical materialism, the conviction that matter is the stuff of all existence and that all mental and spiritual phenomena are its by-products. Darwinian evolution was not only purposeless but also heartless–a process in which the rigors of nature ruthlessly eliminate the unfit. Suddenly, humanity was reduced to just one more species in a world that cared nothing for us. The great human mind was no more than a mass of evolving neurons. Worst of all, there was no divine plan to guide us.” (Biology: Discovering Life, by Joseph S. Levine & Kenneth R. Miller (1st edition, D.C. Heath and Co., 1992), pg. 152; emphasis in original)
(6) “Darwin knew that accepting his theory required believing in philosophical materialism, the conviction that matter is the stuff of all existence and that all mental and spiritual phenomena are its by-products. Darwinian evolution was not only purposeless but also heartless–a process in which the rigors of nature ruthlessly eliminate the unfit. Suddenly, humanity was reduced to just one more species in a world that cared nothing for us. The great human mind was no more than a mass of evolving neurons. Worst of all, there was no divine plan to guide us.”
(Biology: Discovering Life, by Joseph S. Levine & Kenneth R. Miller (2nd edition, D.C. Heath and Co., 1994), p. 161; emphasis in original)