ID in public schools

  • Thread starter Thread starter edwest2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Q. Sir, in your 1995 edition of Biology, I believe it’s the Elephant Book?

A (Kenneth Miller). That’s correct. It’s generally known by that name.

Q. Did it not state in that book, “It is important to keep this concept in mind. Evolution is random and undirected, and the part “evolution is random and undirected” was in bold print?

…]

A.(Kenneth Miller) … So yes, sir, it does say that.

(Transcript of Testimony of Kenneth Miller, Day 2 of Kitzmiller Trial (Sept. 27, 2005), pgs. 4-8.)
Nice quote mine. Did you happen to read on from there?

Peace

Tim
 
More nonsense. The life you see around you, we are told, just happened to end up this way. A different mutation here or there in the past, and even humans might have ended up looking differently.

No, this is an abdication of human reason. We are told by the Church that through natural reason alone we can see that living things were made, but, the secular world tells us otherwise. There was a roll of the dice (actually, many rolls) and because our genes kept giving us bigger and bigger brains, here we are. Nothing supernatural about it. God would disagree.

Ed
Ed you refuse to quote anyone, so we don’t know what nonsense you are invoking now. I’m sad to see that you have regressed from believing in some form of evolution guided by God to your present postion of just calling it nonsense for want of any argument. 😦
 
There are two types of evolution being discussed:

A) Naturalistic textbook evolution as taught in public schools. Everything happened on its own, naturally. A mutation here, a selection there, and poof, all life you see around you. A great deal of luck is assumed. Had not a few lucky mutations occurred, we could still be swinging in the trees with our ancient ape forebears. But chance and selection brought us to self-awareness. Yeah, right.

B) God guided evolution. A process where God through His divine providence, infallibly acts to see His will accomplished. But that is rejected by the purely scientific. Since it can’t be proven scientifically, then no one has any reason to believe that.

So, there are two camps. The pure scientists who see no evidence of divine intervention. And the Catholics, some of whom look at the theory of evolution and wonder: “The textbooks say all life came to be by this purely naturalistic process. Is that possible? Could mutation and selection be the only answer?” That’s all the textbook will give you. That is not theistic. And no need to repeat that “science” makes no claim. People do take the science and compare it to what they think and know. For Catholics, real, actual supernatural events happened and are still happening. Today, two miracles are needed before sainthood is granted. For Catholics, that is just as real as anything that is printed in a textbook.

And yes, the theory of evolution is worth questioning since it clearly states that everything got here by itself.

God bless,
Ed
 
A) Naturalistic textbook evolution as taught in public schools.
How does that differ from naturalistic physics, or naturalistic geology, or naturalistic chemistry? Naturalistic is good; God said so. Nature is the way He does most things in this world, after all.
Everything happened on its own, naturally. A mutation here, a selection there, and poof, all life you see around you. A great deal of luck is assumed. Had not a few lucky mutations occurred, we could still be swinging in the trees with our ancient ape forebears.
You don’t think God can use contingency to His purposes? If not, you have departed from the Church’s teachings.
But chance and selection brought us to self-awareness. Yeah, right.
So Pope Benedict says. Are you sure you’re a Catholic?
God guided evolution. A process where God through His divine providence, infallibly acts to see His will accomplished. But that is rejected by the purely scientific.
Nope. It’s just that science can’t tell one way or another. It can only see the results. But of course, God can do it that way.
Since it can’t be proven scientifically, no one has any reason to believe that.
You’ve departed from Catholic doctrine again. Science can’t find God, but scientists can. They can’t use science to do it, but there’s nothing wrong with being unscientific for many things.
So, there are two camps.
  1. Catholics who acknowledge, as Pope Benedict has, that common descent is virtually certain.
  2. Fundamentalists and their followers who deny evolution.
And yes, the theory of evolution is worth questioning since it clearly states that everything got here by itself.
All science is worth questioning; it should be and is questioned constantly. It’s how we get progress. But, as you know, evolutionary theory doesn’t say everything got here by itself. In fact, Charles Darwin attributed the origin of life to God in “The Origin of Species.”

A lot of things you hate about evolution don’t even exist, Ed.
 
Did you happen to read on from there?
Q. Why was it in your book?

A. It was in my book because as I’m sure you’ve also looked at, that statement was not in the first edition the book, it was not in the second edition, it was not in the fourth edition, it was not in the fifth edition. It was not —

Firstly, Miller claims “that statement was not in the first edition the book, it was not in the second edition, it was not in the fourth edition.” Miller is correct that the 1995 version is the third edition of that textbook. But he’s wrong to say it only appears in the third edition because the statement “Evolution is random and undirected” (emphasis in original) appears in all of the first four versions of this textbook! The 1991, 1993, 1995, and 1998 editions all state on page 658 that “Evolution is random and undirected” (emphasis in original), and they also all state on that same page, “evolution works without either plan or purpose.”

Miller’s account thus cannot be completely accurate. Miller told the Judge:

“When this was first pointed out to me, the third edition of this book was in print, I immediately went to Joe, I said Joe, I think this is a bad idea, I said I think this is a non-scientific statement, I think it will mislead students. Joe agreed. We immediately took it out of the book, and that’s why I emphasized that it did not appear in subsequent editions.”

The statement “evolution is random and undirected” does appear after the third edition; it is found in the fourth edition (1998). What really happened?

Secondly, Miller claims that only one edition of his textbooks had problematic language, stating “this is the only edition of any of the books that we have published, and probably eleven different editions, that contains that statement”. This is also a false statement. If Miller has indeed published eleven versions of his textbooks, as he says, then there are materialistic descriptions of evolution in six of them:

(1) “[E]volution works without either plan or purpose … Evolution is random and undirected.”
(Biology, by Kenneth R. Miller & Joseph S. Levine, pg. 658 (1st edition, Prentice Hall, 1991); emphasis in original)
(2)“[E]volution works without either plan or purpose … Evolution is random and undirected.”
(Biology, by Kenneth R. Miller & Joseph S. Levine, pg. 658 (2nd edition, Prentice Hall, 1993); emphasis in original)

(3)“[E]volution works without either plan or purpose … Evolution is random and undirected.”
(Biology, by Kenneth R. Miller & Joseph S. Levine, pg. 658 (3rd edition, Prentice Hall, 1995); emphasis in original)

(4)“[E]volution works without either plan or purpose … Evolution is random and undirected.”
(Biology, by Kenneth R. Miller & Joseph S. Levine, pg. 658 (4th edition, Prentice Hall, 1998); emphasis in original)

Additionally, Miller’s textbook, Biology: Discovering Life contains language which is even more anti-religious than that of his elephant textbook, Biology. Consider the 5th and 6th instances below:

(5) “Darwin knew that accepting his theory required believing in philosophical materialism, the conviction that matter is the stuff of all existence and that all mental and spiritual phenomena are its by-products. Darwinian evolution was not only purposeless but also heartless–a process in which the rigors of nature ruthlessly eliminate the unfit. Suddenly, humanity was reduced to just one more species in a world that cared nothing for us. The great human mind was no more than a mass of evolving neurons. Worst of all, there was no divine plan to guide us.” (Biology: Discovering Life, by Joseph S. Levine & Kenneth R. Miller (1st edition, D.C. Heath and Co., 1992), pg. 152; emphasis in original)
(6) “Darwin knew that accepting his theory required believing in philosophical materialism, the conviction that matter is the stuff of all existence and that all mental and spiritual phenomena are its by-products. Darwinian evolution was not only purposeless but also heartless–a process in which the rigors of nature ruthlessly eliminate the unfit. Suddenly, humanity was reduced to just one more species in a world that cared nothing for us. The great human mind was no more than a mass of evolving neurons. Worst of all, there was no divine plan to guide us.”
(Biology: Discovering Life, by Joseph S. Levine & Kenneth R. Miller (2nd edition, D.C. Heath and Co., 1994), p. 161; emphasis in original)
 
I don’t think ID should be taught in schools because really, we don’t know how things are done.

I would wish to oppose the default position though in many schools which seems to be ‘scientific materialism’.

Perhaps a different non science course can be taught about the limits of science and the evidence which seems to refute ‘scientific materialism’.

The problem is though that it is more of a philosophy / religious subject matter with no ‘obvious’ immediate commercial benefit, which i think a lot of schooling is directed at.

In the commercial world, the idea that all there is, is matter and common laws is all you need for subjects like engineering and chemistry etc.

It’s only when you progress in science to the quantum level, or the probabilities of life and the probability of our physical laws that the idea of ‘scientific materialism’ breaks down.

I do think there are huge commercial possibilities with such subjects as quantum physics but it’s likely to be only a few who will be involved in this area and thus the mass of people at high school or even tertiary studies receive a science education that is almost entirely compatible with the ‘scientific materialist’ philosophy.

As such many ideas, such as undirected evolution are what seems to ‘make sense’ to a lot of students simply because their science will not have advanced past the ‘scientific materialist’ level IMHO.

I would wish a seperate syllabus talking about the assumptions of science, its limitations, its origin and some of the outstanding questions from a philosophical basis. These questions would refer to the probabilities of things happening just in nature and the quantum realities of ‘the observer effect’ and the ‘uncertaincy principle’ to name but two. I would also highlight the break down of the ‘cause and effect’ principle at the quantum (basic) level.

Perhaps then you could introduce current theories to address these issues such as String Theory (10 dimensional nature), Parrallel Universes and Many Worlds (or universes) theory.

Of course then you could also introduce the theory that to me makes the most sense - God, or call it Conscious Creation or whatever you want to be politically correct.

I’d favour calling it what it is though - God.
I agree with you in many ways; When science crosses over into metaphysical realms, such as Quantum worlds, or the Singularity being the cause for the origin of the universe, the mentioning of at least identifying these concept as being “out the bounderies of science” and that such philosophical hypotheses are on equal ground with religious concepts is important, in my opinion. Such would simply unite science and philosophy, something that used to exist side by side. One cannot exist without the other, in my opinion. Just take the origin of the universe. It either started with some metaphysical concept (Singularity) or existed for eternity (another metaphysical concept).I believe the same could be implied for abiogenesis. This term, like the Singularity, might also be part of a metaphysical
reality, never to be scientifically observed.

Andre
 
Such would simply unite science and philosophy, something that used to exist side by side. One cannot exist without the other, in my opinion.
Agreed. It’s as simple as the many people here who claim: “that’s not science”, or “science doesn’t do that” or “science can’t talk about God” or “science is only …”

Those are all philosophical statements.
 
I would certainly be interested in anyone who has a way of using science to study the supernatural.

Does anyone have an example of such a research paper that actually does it?

Science is too weak a method to do that. It would be a wonderful thing if someone could do that, and demonstrate the fact of God or anything supernatural, in a scientific way.

So far, no one knows how to do that.
 
Hi Barbarian,

from a scientific viewpoint, if we start with the theory of God and look for scientific proof we have to admit to some basic assumptions.

The first is that because our science is based on the material world (things we can measure with material instruements) we are making the assumption that God is material, that is, of the universe, which is incompatible with the Christian philosophy of the universe being His creation out of nothing.

The second is that He is constricted to act in repeatable and uniform ways. This limits His free will and abilities in this universe and basically makes Him subserviant to it. Again against Christian teaching.

Basically if we go down the scientific route we are putting God in a materialistic box and saying - tou HAVE to act like this.
 
I think though what we can do is challenge the materialistic view and show that it is incompatible with explaining the full workings of the universe and show why and then hypothesise on what the most logical conclusion is to how it does work.

I think this is where science is today frankly even if it is not widely acknowledged. As Andre says, the limitations of the materialistic science look to have been reached and now science is reaching over into the metaphysical to look for answers.
Basically it is a defacto surrender of the widely held past principles that everything can be explained in terms of materialistic inter-actions in this universe.

When you look at where scientists today are looking for the deep answers to reality it is beyond our universe, as defined by our 4 dimensions and thus past our observable, experimental and verified science. As such, past dismissiveness about God because He can’t be proved look very hypocritical.

The ideas today are about String theory - a 10 dimensional space (to get around the problem materialists have with non cause and effect at the quantum level), together with a Parallel universe theory where our universe is copied trillions and trillions of time a
nano second (to get around the materialists problems that our conscious observation seems to effect and create our reality) and the Many Universe Theory (to get around the problem materialists have with the fact that the inter relationships betweein our basic laws and constants need to be so finely balanced for our universe to be so stable and move from chaos to order).

You will notice that all of these ‘materialistic’ theories acknowledge the exisitance of other realms. In fact you could say that scientific materialism today has been forced to postulate that there our origin and existance come from a realm beyond our observable senses and underpins and interacts with our reality constantly. This has moved very close to the Christian position so that now we are really disagreeing about what is the nature of this other realm. A materialist would expect to find, if he could look there, a natural mechanical process, although the irony is that because there is no way (that we know of) to scientifically verify something in another realm, science, unfortunately is rendered useless.

One or two generations ago, an attraction of atheism was that we didn’t have to resort to other realms to explain existance and origin, it was thought we could explain it through science using the ‘cause and effect’ principle That attraction now looks to be misplaced.

All materialistic scientists have retreated to looking at other realms for their underlying meaning even if it has not been acknowledged that way.

The best we can do, from a scientic point of view is understand the science that has forced them to retreat to such a position. The answer comes from different discciplines but the study of quantum mechanics (how things work at the basic minute level) has been responsible for most of the ‘challenges’ to scientific materialism.

I would look at the ‘observer effect’, the Bell Theorem of Inequality, and the ‘uncertainty principle’ to start. Experiments such as the delayed choice double slit experiment and zeno effect experiments, proofs of Bells theorem and the EPR experimental outcomes are good pointers.

I think because we can’t put God in a materialistic box, the best we can do is point to the scientific invalidation (in my view) of the scientific materialist philosophy and ask what else makes the most sense from what we can observe.

That is usually enough to jolt people out of the misconception that science underpins scientific materialism, if you can explain it well. Of course it will not convinve everyone.

You can look at the following link although i don’t support everything on the page.

paddingtonuca.org.au/pc/index.html

The frame videos and written transcripts on quantum mechanics are very interesting although there is a lot of background basic knowledge presented before getting to the interesting conclusions (starting half way through with video 4).

Also you can look at the links to my posting on page 3 on the following link starting with post 22 then post 21 if you want.

sluggerotoole.com/index.php/weblog/comments/i-am-attacking-gods-all-gods-anything-and-everything-supernatural/P50/

Then there is the whole notion of how finely tuned the universe is from a perspective of the physical laws and their constants and there are many sites that explore this.

All the best.
 
I would certainly be interested in anyone who has a way of using science to study the supernatural.

Does anyone have an example of such a research paper that actually does it?

Science is too weak a method to do that. It would be a wonderful thing if someone could do that, and demonstrate the fact of God or anything supernatural, in a scientific way.

So far, no one knows how to do that.
A google search reveals that the CIA was involved in studying, scientifically of course, any and all paranormal/psychic abilities that might help it in its mission:

biomindsuperpowers.com/Pages/CIA-InitiatedRV.html

Or the Division of Perceptual Studies at the University of Virginia, here:

healthsystem.virginia.edu/internet/personalitystudies/case_types.cfm#CORT

God bless,
Ed
 
That is usually enough to jolt people out of the misconception that science underpins scientific materialism, if you can explain it well. Of course it will not convinve everyone.

You can look at the following link although i don’t support everything on the page.

paddingtonuca.org.au/pc/index.html

The frame videos and written transcripts on quantum mechanics are very interesting although there is a lot of background basic knowledge presented before getting to the interesting conclusions (starting half way through with video 4).

Also you can look at the links to my posting on page 3 on the following link starting with post 22 then post 21 if you want.

sluggerotoole.com/index.php/weblog/comments/i-am-attacking-gods-all-gods-anything-and-everything-supernatural/P50/

Then there is the whole notion of how finely tuned the universe is from a perspective of the physical laws and their constants and there are many sites that explore this.

All the best.
abucs - it seems like you may have posted the wrong first link above. Does that link go where you want it to?

And your posting at the slugger… site also contains some broken links (FYI).

As an aside - I’d like to again recommend the books (to all posters):

The Science Before Science - Rizzi.
A Meaningful World - Wiker & Ritt

These books also cover many of the topics mentioned in abucs’ post above.
 
There are two types of evolution being discussed:

A) Naturalistic textbook evolution as taught in public schools. Everything happened on its own, naturally. A mutation here, a selection there, and poof, all life you see around you. A great deal of luck is assumed. Had not a few lucky mutations occurred, we could still be swinging in the trees with our ancient ape forebears. But chance and selection brought us to self-awareness. Yeah, right.

B) God guided evolution. A process where God through His divine providence, infallibly acts to see His will accomplished. But that is rejected by the purely scientific. Since it can’t be proven scientifically, then no one has any reason to believe that.
That is your mistake Ed. And you make it over and over. It’s the SAME science in both…The second adds the theological basis for 1. It does NOT change the science.
So, there are two camps. The pure scientists who see no evidence of divine intervention. And the Catholics, some of whom look at the theory of evolution and wonder: “The textbooks say all life came to be by this purely naturalistic process. Is that possible? Could mutation and selection be the only answer?” That’s all the textbook will give you. That is not theistic. And no need to repeat that “science” makes no claim. People do take the science and compare it to what they think and know. For Catholics, real, actual supernatural events happened and are still happening. Today, two miracles are needed before sainthood is granted. For Catholics, that is just as real as anything that is printed in a textbook.
We really have been through this enough times now that I know ou know this is not true. Scientists aren’t looking at the ISSUE of divine intervention, so naturally they aren’t talking about it. YOUR OWN POPE said they shouldnt.Show us any textbook that says that all life arose from “purely” natural processes. Of course its not theistic…its SCIENCE. You continue to claim that people aren’t smart enough to get it, so you propose what? just throwing out the entire thing? You claim not to want to teach God in the science lab so what do you want? Miracles ED do not have a thing to do with this. You just get so agitated that you just start listing all your grumblings about the world.
 
Miracles happen today. You appear to not want to accept this.

God bless,
Ed
 
(Barbarian asks for any scientific findings that show science can investigate the supernatural)
A google search reveals that the CIA was involved in studying, scientifically of course, any and all paranormal/psychic abilities that might help it in its mission:
But these are naturalistic claims, not about magic. And all the information I can find shows that the CIA (which investigated this largely because of reports that the Soviets were doing it) found no evidence any of it even existed.
 
Hi Barbarian,
from a scientific viewpoint, if we start with the theory of God and look for scientific proof we have to admit to some basic assumptions.
You can’t start with a theory, if you want to do science. “Theory” is as high as you go in science. You start with a physical phenomenon, make a hypothesis about what it might be, and then test that hypothesis.
The first is that because our science is based on the material world (things we can measure with material instruements) we are making the assumption that God is material,
What you mean “we”, Kemo Sabe? Scientists assume that God, if He exists, is not physical and we therefore can’t investigate Him scientifically.
The second is that He is constricted to act in repeatable and uniform ways. This limits His free will and abilities in this universe and basically makes Him subserviant to it.
This would be true, if we could learn about God through science. But we can’t. For reasons you make clear.
Basically if we go down the scientific route we are putting God in a materialistic box and saying - tou HAVE to act like this.
It’s why the Pope pointed out that science has no business getting into such things. You may have noticed that the scientists on this board get weary pointing out that fact.
 
Hi The Barbarian,

obviously i realized when i wrote about being scientific that the theory is supposed to come last. But in reality i would argue that this is not really so. The best way to design experimental setups for the big questions is, in practise, to have a personal theory first that can be tested and then think about how to test it.

Of course this ‘theory’ is not one that is published in the formal sense of the word.

Using the colloquial usage of the word ‘theory’, then when referring to God and then trying to be scientific (using the royal ‘we’) in looking for that God, then i’m pointing out the obvious - that ‘we’ are assuming ‘we’ can put God in a materialistic box which is, as you point out, contradictory.

Hence i’m saying we can’t do that.
 
obviously i realized when i wrote about being scientific that the theory is supposed to come last. But in reality i would argue that this is not really so.
I can’t think of an example like that right now.
The best way to design experimental setups for the big questions is, in practise, to have a personal theory first that can be tested and then think about how to test it.
Ah, you’re thinking of “hypothesis.” Theories only become theories after there is evidence for them.
Of course this ‘theory’ is not one that is published in the formal sense of the word.
Right. If you want to talk science, you’re thinking of “hypothesis.”
Using the colloquial usage of the word ‘theory’, then when referring to God and then trying to be scientific (using the royal ‘we’) in looking for that God, then i’m pointing out the obvious - that ‘we’ are assuming ‘we’ can put God in a materialistic box which is, as you point out, contradictory.
Hence i’m saying we can’t do that.
Ah. So you’re right about that.
 
Miracles happen today. You appear to not want to accept that.

Ed
See Ed, you simply do not read carefully. I did not say i did not believe in miracles, or did I say that they don’t occur today. What I said, is that miracles have nothing to do with this discussion. Miracles have nothing to do with ID or evolution. Your injecting them is wrong…

Ed do you not know how to use the quote thingie? No problem. I didn’t know either until someone showed me…

When you want to break up someone’s quote into parts, just put a
in front and a
behind the section you wish to segregate. Your responding to posts in a vacuum where we often don’t know who you are replying to or what particular complete statement, makes it very hard to answer, and may also be responsible for people piling on, since you usually address no one in particular but start out usually sounding like you are responding to something.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top