If I'm Baptized, Shouldn't I Have The Right To Communion Too?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Protestant_Me
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

Protestant_Me

Guest
Why is it wrong for a Protestant to take Communion in a Catholic Church? We all belive in God and the wonderful things his Son did for humanity. I understand that it is the blood and body of Christ that is given in that piece of leavened bread and sip of wine. Why am I not worthy? Please help me understand.
Thank You, God Bless.
Protestant Me.
 
Why is it wrong for a Protestant to take Communion in a Catholic Church? We all belive in God and the wonderful things his Son did for humanity. I understand that it is the blood and body of Christ that is given in that piece of leavened bread and sip of wine. Why am I not worthy? Please help me understand.
Thank You, God Bless.
Protestant Me.
This article from the main part of the website should prove helpful.
catholic.com/tracts/who-can-receive-communion
Other Christians and Communion
The guidelines for receiving Communion, which are issued by the U.S. bishops and published in many missalettes, explain, "We welcome our fellow Christians to this celebration of the Eucharist as our brothers and sisters. We pray that our common baptism and the action of the Holy Spirit in this Eucharist will draw us closer to one another and begin to dispel the sad divisions which separate us. We pray that these will lessen and finally disappear, in keeping with Christ’s prayer for us ‘that they may all be one’ (John 17:21).
"Because Catholics believe that the celebration of the Eucharist is a sign of the reality of the oneness of faith, life, and worship, members of those churches with whom we are not yet fully united are ordinarily not admitted to Communion. Eucharistic sharing in exceptional circumstances by other Christians requires permission according to the directives of the diocesan bishop and the provisions of canon law. . . . "
**Scripture is clear that partaking of the Eucharist is among the highest signs of Christian unity: “Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread” (1 Cor. 10:17). For this reason, it is normally impossible for non-Catholic Christians to receive Holy Communion, for to do so would be to proclaim a unity to exist that, regrettably, does not.
Another reason that many non-Catholics may not ordinarily receive Communion is for their own protection, since many reject the doctrine of the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist. Scripture warns that it is very dangerous for one not believing in the Real Presence to receive Communion: “For any one who eats and drinks without discerning the body eats and drinks judgment upon himself. That is why many of you are weak and ill, and some have died” (1 Cor. 11:29–30).**
 
Why is it wrong for a Protestant to take Communion in a Catholic Church? We all believe in God and the wonderful things his Son did for humanity. I understand that it is the blood and body of Christ that is given in that piece of leavened bread and sip of wine. Why am I not worthy? Please help me understand.
Thank You, God Bless.
Protestant Me.
The Holy Eucharist , the Body , Blood , Soul and Divinity of our Saviour the Lord Jesus Christ is the very center of a Catholic Christians life and worship, so unless you are in complete union with what the Apostolic Church teaches , you must join us in communion with the full truth of Christ’s revelation handed down to Church from the beginning through his Apostles.
I welcome you to these forums and I do hope you continue visit with us and learn from us what we believe, God Bless and Peace to you, Carlan:)
 
The thing is, none of us are worthy, and NO ONE has a right. Us Catholics do not take the Eucharist lightly; stating that you have a right to consume the Body and Blood of Christ speaks to your lack of understanding of the act itself. It’s a serious act that requires full knowledge of what is occurring. Unless you’re in communion with the Catholic church, it’s safe to assume that you have not acquired the appropriate instruction. Of course, this is a generalization, but partaking of the Eucharist is immensely serious, so much importance is given to proper catechesis beforehand.
 
Because the act of taking communion means several things, one of which is that you are in “communion” with the Catholic Church and her teachings. Protestants do not believe in all the tenets of the Catholic Faith; first of which is the real presence. If you find that you do believe in these things, then maybe you should look into conversion. I did, and it was the best thing that ever happened to me. Also, you must be in a state of grace to receive communion. I’m not saying that you aren’t, but it is very important for us. If we aren’t, we have to go to confession & be absolved before receiving communion. The eucharist is the source & summit of the church; we take it very seriously. And as for you asking, “why am I not worthy?” None of us are worthy. But is a precious gift Christ gave us; to remind us of his sacrifice. None of us has a right to it. I sincerely urge you to look into the Catholic faith. EWTN is a great place to start.
 
Why is it wrong for a Protestant to take Communion in a Catholic Church? We all belive in God and the wonderful things his Son did for humanity. I understand that it is the blood and body of Christ that is given in that piece of leavened bread and sip of wine. Why am I not worthy? Please help me understand.
Thank You, God Bless.
Protestant Me.
Here is the kicker. **There is absolutely no bread or wine in the Eucharist ** :eek:- the bread and wine are wholly transformed (transubstantiated) into the Body and Blood of Jesus.

Receiving the Host and Cup during communion is an act of worship. If there were objectively bread or wine remaining in the Eucharist, we Catholics would be guilty of idolatry - worshiping bread!

While this may sound like just a play of words, what it really comes down to is accepting the Catholic Church’s unique authority. If you do truly understand that the Eucharist is wholly the Body and Blood of Christ, then you should also understand that the Catholic Church is truly the Bride of Christ, and seek membership in the Church. Proper understanding of the nature of the sacrament and the nature of the church is the key to reception of Communion.

There are a few complicated exceptions, but in general it is the case that “worthiness” to receive the Eucharist means accepting one must also be received into the Catholic Church. It is a sign of humility and obedience to the our Lord’s desire that “they all be one”.
 
I had a conversation on this a couple of weeks ago, and did a little Biblical homework then. At the time, I found 2 readings that I find apply strongly. First you have 1 Corinthians 11:23-29 saying
For I received from the Lord what I also handed on to you,k that the Lord Jesus, on the night he was handed over, took bread, and, after he had given thanks, broke it and said, “This is my body that is for you. Do this in remembrance of me.” In the same way also the cup, after supper, saying, “This cup is the new covenant in my blood. Do this, as often as you drink it, in remembrance of me.”l For as often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you proclaim the death of the Lord until he comes.
Therefore whoever eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord unworthily will have to answer for the body and blood of the Lord. A person should examine himself, and so eat the bread and drink the cup. For anyone who eats and drinks without discerning the body, eats and drinks judgment* on himself.
That reading, in a nutshell, says that one must not take Communion lightly. Then I found 1 John 5:16-17, and this one says
If anyone sees his brother sinning, if the sin is not deadly, he should pray to God and he will give him life. This is only for those whose sin is not deadly. There is such a thing as deadly sin, about which I do not say that you should pray. All wrongdoing is sin, but there is sin that is not deadly.
This reading is about protecting all wrongdoing, even if it isn’t yours. As John, chapter 6 says, Jesus is present in the bread and wine. That is why in a Catholic Church, a non-Catholic should not be able to just walk in, not believing in the divine presence of Jesus in the Eucharist, and sin.

I hope that helped.
 
Nobody has a “right” to Sacraments.
Come to think of it, I forgot that part of the argument. And that is why every time, before we are about to recieve the Eucharist, we say “Lord, I am not worthy to recieve you, only say the words and I shall be healed.” (I know the wording will change a little very soon) That is a reference to Matthew 8:8, where the centurion said a similar thing when he wanted Jesus to heal his daughter.
 
Why is it wrong for a Protestant to take Communion in a Catholic Church? We all belive in God and the wonderful things his Son did for humanity. I understand that it is the blood and body of Christ that is given in that piece of leavened bread and sip of wine. Why am I not worthy? Please help me understand.
Thank You, God Bless.
Protestant Me.
Nobody has a “right” to Sacraments.
And as a Sacrament it is under the Church’s control not the person’s, people who falsely partake commit sacrilege and receive no grace as it is an invalid action
 
It isn’t limited to understanding or catechesis or agreement with the Church though. There is a real difference in theology following from our metaphysical beliefs. Protestant theology sees our nature having differing levels of depravity, depending on the particular theological tradition, which must be covered by the Merits of Jesus, whereas in Catholic theology “grace perfects nature” and the Infinite Merits of Jesus are applied to our perfection through cooperation with God’s Grace as our participation in the very Life of God, in us and through us.

The Sacraments of the Church, which the Eucharist is the summit, is the normative way God has ordained us to receive this grace. Sin is a failing to cooperate with this grace and mortal sin separates us from this Life of God begun at baptism, which confession is required for reconciliation with Him through the Church, which Jesus founded. The priest in confession, authorized to work in the place of Jesus and Jesus working through him, restores the connection between the sinner and God through the Church. The cooperation between us, the Church, and God’s Grace in the Sacraments is a reality of the highest order. When one knows this, they will prepare themselves, discerning the “body of the Lord”, not being “guilty” and bringing “judgment to himself”, 1 Cor. 11: 27-29. It is in confirmation that one begins the cooperation with God’s Grace to be able to discern, for without God, we can do nothing.
 
Why is it wrong for a Protestant to take Communion in a Catholic Church? We all belive in God and the wonderful things his Son did for humanity. I understand that it is the blood and body of Christ that is given in that piece of leavened bread and sip of wine. Why am I not worthy? Please help me understand.
Thank You, God Bless.
Protestant Me.
This is one of those things where people believe the Church is being mean. The reality is that the Catholic Church is more liberal on this issue than the early Church. In the very early Church an unconfirmed Christian could not even be present during the second half of the Mass which is called the liturgy of the Eucharist (Early Christians called it the Mass/Liturgy of the Faithful). They would actually have to leave. Additionally, in the early days, absolution was not receive immediately after confessing one’s mortal sins. Back then you had to do your penance (which could take a very long time to complete) before receiving absolution. Even a confirmed/initiated Christian that had not received absolution could not be present for the liturgy of the Eucharist. Ironically, in his 95 Thesis, Martin Luther criticized the Church for granting absolution before penance.

So if you feel insulted in the modern Church… how would you have felt in the early Church?
 
Why is it wrong for a Protestant to take Communion in a Catholic Church? We all belive in God and the wonderful things his Son did for humanity. I understand that it is the blood and body of Christ that is given in that piece of leavened bread and sip of wine. Why am I not worthy? Please help me understand.
Thank You, God Bless.
Protestant Me.
Welcome, Protestant!. (1) Because Our Lord Said that One who Receives His “Body/Blood” Unworthily will “Die” (1 Cor 11: 27-29); We Understand Grave sin Against Christ. (2) All Non-Catholics and Convert Students had to Leave the Catacombs or site of the First Centuries “Mass”, During The Most Sacred Moments In the Church: CONSECRATION of Bread/Wine Into REAL PRESENCE Christ. (3) It’s Not Bread/Wine anymore; It Is the Real Presence Christ. That’s why Not Many Go for Communion: Have to be Worthy, as Christ wants, Since His Time. (4) The Church teaches Only Christ Consecrates the Bread/Winr, Through the Priest; Same as The Apostles Taught, practised. (5) You can check things out In RCIA, Now Starting Every Catholic Parish, as In the Catacombs, to Qualify as Catholic. No Obligation, to Just Learn the Ideal Living Full Christ we have done almost 2,000 years. Live in Jesus, Brother. [SIGN] :bible1: Please see God’s Full Word we Live, on the Eucharist: promised - Jn 6:35-71l; Insrtituted: Mk 14:22 ff, Lk 22:17 ff, Mt 26:26 ff; Participation in Christ’s Body and Blood: 1 Cor 10:16; Numerous More Bible and Early Church Fathers quotes, on Real Presence, Not Symbolism. [/SIGN]
 
This is one of those things where people believe the Church is being mean. The reality is that the Catholic Church is more liberal on this issue than the early Church. In the very early Church an unconfirmed Christian could not even be present during the second half of the Mass which is called the liturgy of the Eucharist (Early Christians called it the Mass/Liturgy of the Faithful). They would actually have to leave. Additionally, in the early days, absolution was not receive immediately after confessing one’s mortal sins. Back then you had to do your penance (which could take a very long time to complete) before receiving absolution. Even a confirmed/initiated Christian that had not received absolution could not be present for the liturgy of the Eucharist. Ironically, in his 95 Thesis, Martin Luther criticized the Church for granting absolution before penance.

So if you feel insulted in the modern Church… how would you have felt in the early Church?
👍👍
 
Why is it wrong for a Protestant to take Communion in a Catholic Church? We all belive in God and the wonderful things his Son did for humanity. I understand that it is the blood and body of Christ that is given in that piece of leavened bread and sip of wine. Why am I not worthy? Please help me understand.
Thank You, God Bless.
Protestant Me.
There is much that is being said here. First you admit to being Protestant posting on Catholic Answers. You are concerned enough to ask a question as to the propriety of communion in a Catholic Church. Many Protestants as you know believe that the Catholic Church is not a Christian Church and your consideration is a consideration of other than that. To say that you understand that the body and blood of Christ is given in bread and wine is a far cry from the Protestant that states it is only symbol. The fact that you ask if you are worthy suggests humility and I honor that. To ask for understanding, offering gratitude and blessing suggests that there may be more to your journey than is offered here. I suggest you continue to search and ask and find your way to the wedding supper of the lamb.👍
 
Come to think of it, I forgot that part of the argument. And that is why every time, before we are about to recieve the Eucharist, we say “Lord, I am not worthy to recieve you, only say the words and I shall be healed.” (I know the wording will change a little very soon) That is a reference to Matthew 8:8, where the centurion said a similar thing when he wanted Jesus to heal his daughter.
“Lord I am not worthy to receive you under my roof but only say the word and my soul shall be healed.”

I am already reading and trying to learn the new responses. I am so happy we are getting a real translation.
 
This is one of those things where people believe the Church is being mean. The reality is that the Catholic Church is more liberal on this issue than the early Church. In the very early Church an unconfirmed Christian could not even be present during the second half of the Mass which is called the liturgy of the Eucharist (Early Christians called it the Mass/Liturgy of the Faithful). They would actually have to leave. Additionally, in the early days, absolution was not receive immediately after confessing one’s mortal sins. Back then you had to do your penance (which could take a very long time to complete) before receiving absolution. Even a confirmed/initiated Christian that had not received absolution could not be present for the liturgy of the Eucharist. Ironically, in his 95 Thesis, Martin Luther criticized the Church for granting absolution before penance.

So if you feel insulted in the modern Church… how would you have felt in the early Church?
Even today as a catechumen you will leave Mass early.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top