If we trust in God

  • Thread starter Thread starter Michael96
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Michael96

Guest
A genuine question as this has been troubling me lately…

If we trust in God’s love and mercy for unborn (aborted) children, then why is it dreadful to abort a baby? Why does *this *life trump the *eternal *life? Why expose those babies to a potentially corrupting life if we trust in God’s mercy for them now? Or do we not trust in God’s mercy towards them?
 
A genuine question as this has been troubling me lately…

If we trust in God’s love and mercy for unborn (aborted) children, then why is it dreadful to abort a baby? Why does *this *life trump the *eternal *life? Why expose those babies to a potentially corrupting life if we trust in God’s mercy for them now? Or do we not trust in God’s mercy towards them?
Because then WE attempt to be God .WE decide what is best for God’s creation.It would be the same thing as killing people who emerged from the confessional in a state of grace.WE DON"T HAVE THE RIGHT TO ACT IN GOD’S STEAD.Your arguement sounds like something the Enemy would come up with.We cannot perform an evil to perform a good.
 
Your arguement sounds like something the Enemy would come up with.
I was hoping for something more than an *ad hominem * response; it is genuinely a sincere question from a sincere (Catholic) Christian.
 
I was hoping for something more than an *ad hominem * response; it is genuinely a sincere question from a sincere (Catholic) Christian.
Of course we trust in God’s mercy for the unborn, as we trust in His mercy for everyone.

That doesn’t give us any right to take anyone’s life. Bar the very rare exceptions such as legitimate self-defence, just war, voluntary martyrdom in defence of the faith and so on.

The commandment not to kill doesn’t lend itself to any exceptions for unborn life.
 
Well, one reason is “Thou shalt not kill.” That’s a commandment, not a suggestion. We’re supposed to obey, even if we don’t understand, although this one, IMO, is pretty easy to understand.

Life is a gift from God, it’s not up to us to end it. We are denying a huge gift to a totally innocent child, who deserves that gift as much as we do.
 
A genuine question as this has been troubling me lately…

If we trust in God’s love and mercy for unborn (aborted) children, then why is it dreadful to abort a baby? Why does *this *life trump the *eternal *life? Why expose those babies to a potentially corrupting life if we trust in God’s mercy for them now? Or do we not trust in God’s mercy towards them?
I’m not a Catholic, so keep that in mind when I try to answer your question. As a disclaimer, I do not believe in Heaven or God, but I’m going to assume them true temporarily in order to try to relate an answer to you.

I think it is wrong to abort a baby in the same way it is wrong to murder someone. Yes, maybe that person will go to Heaven and live a life free from suffering, but this end does not justify the means. The person, just like this baby, has the gift of free will, and a right to his or her own life. You can’t just take away that right because you believe that they’ll go to a better place.

You trust that God has infinite mercy upon the innocent, but that is not enough justify the act of killing. I hope that makes sense. You cannot know this baby’s future. Perhaps this baby is the person who will go on to cure disease or end hunger. Think about the harm you would be doing in that case.
 
A genuine question as this has been troubling me lately…

If we trust in God’s love and mercy for unborn (aborted) children, then why is it dreadful to abort a baby? Why does *this *life trump the *eternal *life? Why expose those babies to a potentially corrupting life if we trust in God’s mercy for them now? Or do we not trust in God’s mercy towards them?
The commandment about not murdering has been mentioned.

The idea - “That which you have done for the least of my brothers so have you done unto me,” comes to mind.

The root cause of murder is anger. If we are willing to deny life to another human then deep inside our souls are stained with anger. We are putting a selfish desire for worldly pleasure and freedom from responsibility ahead of another’s life.

It is an interesting question. If I may, what prompted the question?
 
I was hoping for something more than an *ad hominem * response; it is genuinely a sincere question from a sincere (Catholic) Christian.
My response WAS NOT ad hominum.IT DOES sound like something the Enemy would come up with to confuse.I am NOT suggesting that it in fact equates you with Satan.Read the whole post.Your question was indeed sincere as was my response.
 
A genuine question as this has been troubling me lately…

If we trust in God’s love and mercy for unborn (aborted) children, then why is it dreadful to abort a baby? Why does *this *life trump the *eternal *life? Why expose those babies to a potentially corrupting life if we trust in God’s mercy for them now? Or do we not trust in God’s mercy towards them?
Michael,

You’re not taking into consideration the mortal sin of murder which the abortionist and anyone else who participates commits.

Also, if we accept this idea of abortion being a merciful good, why not have someone stand outside the confessional with a gun and shoot those coming out who are in a state of grace to prevent them from ever sinning again and send them straight to heaven?
 
A genuine question as this has been troubling me lately…

If we trust in God’s love and mercy for unborn (aborted) children, then why is it dreadful to abort a baby? Why does *this *life trump the *eternal *life? Why expose those babies to a potentially corrupting life if we trust in God’s mercy for them now? Or do we not trust in God’s mercy towards them?
Suppose you see me walk out of a confessional. You know that since I just received sacramental confession, I will go to heaven if I die right this second. Does that entitle you to pull out a gun and blow my head off?
 
Also, if we accept this idea of abortion being a merciful good, why not have someone stand outside the confessional with a gun and shoot those coming out who are in a state of grace to prevent them from ever sinning again and send them straight to heaven?
Ha ha! Well, great minds think alike! I posted virtually the same thing after reading the OP without even having seen your post. Sorry for the unintentionaly plagiarism!
 
Ha ha! Well, great minds think alike! I posted virtually the same thing after reading the OP without even having seen your post. Sorry for the unintentionaly plagiarism!
I laughed when I saw you posted the same thing at the same time, too. Go figure! 😃 No apologies necessary
 
It is an interesting question. If I may, what prompted the question?
I think it was the combination of all of debate abortion and also a recent funeral that I attended where the atmosphere was one very much of hope and faith in the future of a commited Catholic. In my mind I have been contrasting the positive view of death I observed at the funeral and the negative view of death that runs through the abortion debate.

Now I will add that of course I don’t think we should take life (I don’t condone abortion for a second); but it seems that perhaps that it is *ourselves *who in most danger from taking an innocent life; and that we have every reason to hope that the innocent go straight to paradise.

I guess the abortion issue just brings our attitude to death into sharpest focus.

Thank you all for your responses; the thread than seems to link them for me is chosing to be part of God’s plan and fully co-operating with it.
 
it seems that perhaps that it is *ourselves *who in most danger from taking an innocent life;
This is very good. Simple. True. The innocent life is in no eternal peril, despite the earthly risk of suffering and death. The murderer’s life, though, is now in eternal peril as well as temporal.
and that we have every reason to hope that the innocent go straight to paradise.
Yes. We have an infinitely good and loving God and can entrust the souls of those murdered for the sake of convenience to his mercy. 👍
 
A genuine question as this has been troubling me lately…

If we trust in God’s love and mercy for unborn (aborted) children, then why is it dreadful to abort a baby? Why does *this *life trump the *eternal *life? Why expose those babies to a potentially corrupting life if we trust in God’s mercy for them now? Or do we not trust in God’s mercy towards them?
Killing is against the 5th Commandment. We are not to judge when someone is better off dead. That’s a dangerous thing (i.e. the “slippery slope”).
 
A genuine question as this has been troubling me lately…

If we trust in God’s love and mercy for unborn (aborted) children, then why is it dreadful to abort a baby? Why does *this *life trump the *eternal *life? Why expose those babies to a potentially corrupting life if we trust in God’s mercy for them now? Or do we not trust in God’s mercy towards them?
Yes, this “argument” is making the rounds, possibly due to the past American presidential election which featured some novel spins on getting Catholics to support abortion.

Follow this line to its logical conclusion—wouldn’t it be better if there were no people in the world at all? Imagine that—no evil. No sin. No people. The saved would be in heaven, the damned in hell and that would be that.

There are fast and slow roads to that depopulated wilderness.

The slow road would be to abort every unborn child and contracept the rest.

But what to do about those who simply insist upon bearing children? Shall they be allowed to confound the plan to exterminate evil?

That of course sets you on the fast road. You can see where it goes. We have been here before, btw—Google “eugenics”. It is no wonder that so many abortion agencies began during this movement, founded by its leading lights.

It’s the same old story when you stop and think: Man elevating himself over God.

Every child conceived is God’s will. Abortion is nothing more than the willful destruction of God’s will for that child. Those who claim that the unborn are not children falter on the shoals of logic—the whole point of abortion is to avoid being responsible for a child that will undoubtedly result from an unterminated pregnancy.

Trust in God means that we trust that He would not conceive children for the purpose of tossing them aside. Every generation has been convinced at some point that theirs will be the last. Thankfully, none have decided to make it so, or at least they haven’t succeeded.

You should ask why that is.

Additionally, what is your response to this question:

“Is abortion the will of God?”
 
I think it was the combination of all of debate abortion and also a recent funeral that I attended where the atmosphere was one very much of hope and faith in the future of a commited Catholic. In my mind I have been contrasting the positive view of death I observed at the funeral and the negative view of death that runs through the abortion debate.

Now I will add that of course I don’t think we should take life (I don’t condone abortion for a second); but it seems that perhaps that it is *ourselves *who in most danger from taking an innocent life; and that we have every reason to hope that the innocent go straight to paradise.

I guess the abortion issue just brings our attitude to death into sharpest focus.

Thank you all for your responses; the thread than seems to link them for me is chosing to be part of God’s plan and fully co-operating with it.
This is not a cartoonish response, but it does involve a cartoon. It depicts a despairing man staring at the sky and demanding of our Lord, "Where are the people who will cure cancer? Where are the people who will solve the poverty equation? Where are the people who will improve health care? Where are the people who will cure the incurable diseases?

The response from Heaven: “You aborted them!”

Simple, but profound. Please reflect on that, as your premise has a hint of relativism in it.

Christ’s peace.
 
Additionally, what is your response to this question:

“Is abortion the will of God?”
I believe abortion is not the will of God. I have no arguement with that; I’m only struggling with our general attitude to death.
 
Please reflect on that, as your premise has a hint of relativism in it.

Christ’s peace.
Indeed - I will freely admit my thoughts can often tend towards relativism (and some subjectivism) which I tend to think reflect the real messy choices we have to make in life. I’m not saying I’m right; just saying where my thoughts often lead me.
 
I believe abortion is not the will of God. I have no arguement with that; I’m only struggling with our general attitude to death.
In what way? Our stance is generally pro-life, generally life is a great good and a blessing from God that we are to cherish and protect at every stage. Generally death is only to be at the time God chooses for each of us.

Generally we are against anything that goes against this principle of cherishing life (or at least pro God’s plan for it) - artificial contraception, abortion, euthanasia, murder, unjust war, embryonic stem-cell research, cloning, suicide, refusal of basic medical treatment.

That there are a few exceptions - placing faith above life by choosing voluntary martyrdom for God’s sake (as Christ Himself did), legitimate self-defence, just war, refusing extreme and unusual medical treatments - doesn’t negate the rule.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top