You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
S
Sig
Guest
You’re fallible, and could be wrong about everything you believe regarding the Church.second tiring example, if HItler says 2+2=4 is he wrong…no
a person can’t be infallible but a statement can
and the statements I am saying that regard the CHurch, are indeed infallible
F
frankpetrucci83
Guest
Nope, sorry, for this specific thread, I am going to say for the sake of argument that I am infallible, sorry this argument didn’t turn out the way you wanted
S
Sig
Guest
But sir, you’re fallible, so all of what you said regarding infallible statements is fallible.no actually it says INFALLBILE…because the statements I have made regarding the Church have been infallible statements, so by YOUR DEFINITON, i would be infallible on that matter, read again
Being fallible you really have no way of knowing whether what you claim is infallible really is infallible.
That’s not to say you can’t, or don’t believe them completely, but you could be wrong about them.
S
Sig
Guest
The same is true of your fallible belief that Christ is your savior.maybe you should be agnostic, because according to your fallible reasoning, there is no way you can know for sure that CHrist is your saviour, since you are fallible
F
frankpetrucci83
Guest
you are constructing a strawman, as i have never claimed to be fallibleBut sir, you’re fallible, so all of what you said regarding infallible statements is fallible.
Being fallible you really have no way of knowing whether what you claim is infallible really is infallible.
That’s not to say you can’t, or don’t believe them completely, but you could be wrong about them.
S
Sig
Guest
You’ve already admitted to your fallibility, and I concur, everyone is fallible.Nope, sorry, for this specific thread, I am going to say for the sake of argument that I am infallible, sorry this argument didn’t turn out the way you wanted
F
frankpetrucci83
Guest
it’s an infallible belief, therefore your premise is wrongThe same is true of your fallible belief that Christ is your savior.
S
Sig
Guest
Sir, you have denied that you are infallible. Therefore, it is logical for me to conclude that you are fallible.you are constructing a strawman, as i have never claimed to be fallible
F
frankpetrucci83
Guest
no, actually I haven’tYou’ve already admitted to your fallibility, and I concur, everyone is fallible.
F
frankpetrucci83
Guest
once again, you need to reread, for the sake of this post, i am taking the position that I am infallbile, so good luck with thatSir, you have denied that you are infallible. Therefore, it is logical for me to conclude that you are fallible.
F
frankpetrucci83
Guest
**let’s review
- You claim everyone is fallible
- You are part of everyone, thereofre you are fallible
- I said i am infallible
- You fallibly say i am fallible
- Therefore i can be said to be infallbile and you are fallible
S
Sig
Guest
How is your belief an infallible belief when you, yourself, are fallible?it’s an infallible belief
S
Sig
Guest
Please prove that you are infallible…**let’s review
you lose, game over, troll**
- You claim everyone is fallible
- You are part of everyone, thereofre you are fallible
- I said i am infallible
- You fallibly say i am fallible
- Therefore i can be said to be infallbile and you are fallible
S
Sig
Guest
Please prove that you are infallible…once again, you need to reread, for the sake of this post, i am taking the position that I am infallbile, so good luck with that
S
Sig
Guest
Please prove that you are infallible…no, actually I haven’t
F
frankpetrucci83
Guest
my perfect proof would be fallibly interpreted by a fallible person such as yourself, therefore I can’t prove it, not because of any lacking on my part, but because of your inability to comprehendPlease prove that you are infallible…
as proved in scriptures “there is nothing which human malice cannot abuse since it abuses even God’s goodness”
therefore no matter how perfectly I prove something, your malice and error will be capable of twisting it
B
bmullins
Guest
I find this amusing. You can stay here and argue with yourself in circular logic. I am moving on now. I dust my feet off on you and say, “peace be with you.”I take it then that you are unable to produce the #s of the posts in which I said what you assert I said, is that right?
If you can’t produce them, just say you can’t, and we can move on.
S
Sig
Guest
That’s not very charitable of you.you lose, game over, troll
F
frankpetrucci83
Guest
Jesus called people far worse, and no one is more charitable then him, but of course someone as fallible as yourself can even twist God’s goodness
- Status
- Not open for further replies.