Illegal Immigrants Released Pre-Sequestration

  • Thread starter Thread starter BroomWagon
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
But, wait! They ARE criminal detainees, as it is still, even under Obama, illegal to illegally enter the US. Am I missing something?
That is an excellent question. INS has always separated criminal detainees from non-criminal. An immigration attorney was here once and linked the law that showed deportation was not a criminal matter, unless the person has already previously been deported. It would be like saying speeding is illegal, so everyone who has ever been pulled over is a criminal.
 
Criminal history has been computerized for quite a while, unless you are suggesting that we consider that everyone, including yourself, is committing crimes until we can prove that they aren’t.
ICE and regular police do not share their records.
 
ICE and regular police do not share their records.
I have read enough ICE detainers to know this to be untrue. Any police agency, state or federal has access to the same system.
 
The WH is claiming they were involved in the decision to release these illegals, and yet they DO know they aren’t criminal detainees.

And your logic circuit didn’t explode immediately???
Why would it explode? I admit that I do not understand the reaction to this money-saving step, except it is the Obama boogyman.
 
That is an excellent question. INS has always separated criminal detainees from non-criminal. An immigration attorney was here once and linked the law that showed deportation was not a criminal matter, unless the person has already previously been deported. It would be like saying speeding is illegal, so everyone who has ever been pulled over is a criminal.
But as has been brought up, were not the aliens being held already being held because they were thought to be the criminal ones? And not the many who were perceived as not being a danger? I thought this was the policy previously.
And now this — the release of criminal illegal aliens before sequestration even happens is a cynical and unnecessary political ploy. In Pinal County, 70 miles north of the U.S.-Mexico border, Sheriff Paul Babeau told Newsmax, the release of hundreds of detainees over the weekend was “outrageous and unacceptable, because there’s a direct and immediate impact to public safety of families in my county.”
Babeau noted: “These are criminal illegals. They were headed for deportation — but now, they have received a budget pardon.”
An ICE spokesman said the detainees selected for release were “noncriminals and other low-risk offenders who do not have serious criminal histories.”
Well, that depends on how you define “low risk” and “serious.” We view all crime as serious and law enforcement and border security as an essential, not optional, function of government.
“It’s abhorrent that President Obama is releasing criminals into our communities to promote his political agenda on sequestration,” said Rep. Robert Goodlatte of Virginia, who, as chairman of the Judiciary Committee, is running the House hearings on immigration reform. “By releasing criminal immigrants on to the streets, the administration is needlessly endangering American lives.”
Read More At IBD: Using Sequestration As Excuse, ICE Lets Criminal Illegal Aliens Go - Investors.com news.investors.com/ibd-editorials/022713-646100-ice-releases-criminal-illegal-aliens-before-sequestration.htm?ven=rss#ixzz2MFhyswOE
Follow us: @IBDinvestors on Twitter | InvestorsBusinessDaily on Facebook
Even if one were to dismiss what the Representative Goodlatte says, the Arizona Sheriff Babeau likewise calls them “criminal illegals”.
 
I have read enough ICE detainers to know this to be untrue. Any police agency, state or federal has access to the same system.
Nope.

The system is NOT the same and in order for one agency to have the access to the records of the others there has to be a request for it and then the release of requested records( after the release is granted, which is not automatic at all).

Which is very far from “the same the system”.

Looks like you’ve been “reading enough ICE deatinees” on the HuffPost
 
Well, I will just have to disagree with your opinion. I know what I have read, having overseen the processing of literally thousands of deportees.
Looks like you’ve been “reading enough ICE deatinees” on the HuffPost
Never, but I am very familiar with ICE, NCIC, TCIC and our local stuff.
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by zz912
The WH is claiming they were involved in the decision to release these illegals, and yet they DO know they aren’t criminal detainees.

And your logic circuit didn’t explode immediately???

Why would it explode? I admit that I do not understand the reaction to this money-saving step, except it is the Obama boogyman.
I meant to say they were NOT involved in the decision to release them. So if they weren’t involved in the decision, then there is NO WAY that they can be certain the next day that NONE of those released were not criminal detainees. They would need time to review the decisions made, and the information on those released. The WH is lying. Either they were involved, or they have no idea if they are criminal detainees.
 
I meant to say they were NOT involved in the decision to release them. So if they weren’t involved in the decision, then there is NO WAY that they can be… Either they were involved, or they have no idea if they are criminal detainees.
Since my logic circuits are intact, I can see the false dichotomy being presented. The statement made by the White House does not have to be false. “Involvement” does not mean micromanagement. A parent is involved in the the way a house is run. This does not mean that nothing goes on of which he is unaware.

Making policy is involvement. Monitoring and enforcing policy, is involvement. Even with such involvement, it can not be assured that someone down the line will disregard police, or be careless, and goof up. However, this can already happen is inherent in all human endeavors.
 
Please educate yourself as to what the term “illegal immigrant” means. Foremost, the appropriate term is “undocumented immigrant”, meaning a person migrated to the USA without documentation. Second, just because a person is “undocumented” or as many refer to “illegal”, that status does not automatically make you a dangerous criminal. Many detainees are family men/women who have no criminal record, other than having unlawful presence.

A bit more humanity must be applied when it comes to the concept of immigration. Not just in this country, but worldwide. The world belongs to God, not to us. I do not ever recall anywhere in the Bible where it states that we have a right to decided who can come and go on the lands and seas of this wonderous creating of God’s that we call Earth.
 
If you don’t have documents, then you are here illegally. So there is nothing wrong with the term illegal immigrant.
 
Please educate yourself as to what the term “illegal immigrant” means. Foremost, the appropriate term is “undocumented immigrant”, meaning a person migrated to the USA without documentation. Second, just because a person is “undocumented” or as many refer to “illegal”, that status does not automatically make you a dangerous criminal. Many detainees are family men/women who have no criminal record, other than having unlawful presence. .
Agreed.

That is why very few illegals are actually detained. The ones that are detained are usually illegals that have committed crimes or have just been released from prison and are to be deported because of their criminal activity. The fact this administration released these dangerous criminals from custody should be the lead story on every media outlet.
ICE officers and agents who are responsible for immigration enforcement in the interior of the United States actively seek out illegal aliens as the consequence of leads, as the result of fugitive investigations, or in the conduct of cases against employers alleged to knowingly hire illegal workers,12 and, often, in their liaison with police and correctional authorities through the Secure Communities and Institutional Removal programs, which are designed to identify aliens who have been arrested or are incarcerated for crimes committed in the United States. In these cases, ICE will place a detainer (a “hold” in everyday parlance) against the subject. If and when he is ready for release by the state/local criminal justice authorities, they notify ICE, which then has 48 business hours to honor its detainer by taking physical custody of the alien.
Basically if they were being held by ICE they were there because they commited other crimes.
 
Basically if they were being held by ICE they were there because they commited other crimes.
This simply is not true. I have been involved in deportation of inmates for a long time and a great many are non-criminal. Quoting an ICE directive by no means indicate that is all that are deported. It is but one one type of inmate they place detainers on.

Also, a great number of the criminal ones are far from dangerous, the main crime where I am being criminal trespass onto railroad property.
 
This simply is not true. I have been involved in deportation of inmates for a long time and a great many are non-criminal. Quoting an ICE directive by no means indicate that is all that are deported. It is but one one type of inmate they place detainers on.

Also, a great number of the criminal ones are far from dangerous, the main crime where I am being criminal trespass onto railroad property.
The deportation process does not equal detained.:rolleyes:

Most people facing deportation are not detained for that reason many simply abscond. It is estimated over 700,000 illegals in the US have absconded the legal process to avoid deportation. You don;t do that if you are detained.
 
The deportation process does not equal detained.:rolleyes:
Of course not, though I have no idea why you mention the “duh” stuff. So do you have a lot of experience working with ICE? I sure have. Most are not criminals. most criminals are not dangereous criminals. I have no doubt that since the Republicans and Democrats are forcing a spending cut, they could find some low risk detainees to release pending a hearing.

This whole thing is indicative of yet another area that Republican politicians and Democrat politicians are the similar: they all keep ignoring that their actions have consequences.
 
I have no doubt that since the Republicans and Democrats are forcing a spending cut, they could find some low risk detainees to release pending a hearing.
Or possibly they could cut some middle management, or expense accounts, or something that’s NOT part of their core mission instead? 🙂

–Jen
 
Or possibly they could cut some middle management, or expense accounts, or something that’s NOT part of their core mission instead? 🙂

–Jen
I do not know. Across the board is across the board. That usually means cuts top to bottom. Perhaps they do not consider holding suspected illegal immigrants before their hearing part of their core mission. We have had to be more generous on releasing pretrial detainees in the past due to lack of space.

I always look at this as a matter of perspective. If one is ever accused of something, they suddenly become more open to the idea of bail and pretrial release. If you or I were out jogging without papers and picked up because we could not prove our citizenship, this option might be more attractive.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top