Illegal Immigration and Catholic Social Teaching

  • Thread starter Thread starter markomalley
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

markomalley

Guest
Father Thomas Berg gives us his insights on CNA:
Arizona governor Jan Brewer signed the Arizona Immigration Bill (SB 1070) on April 23. The Catholic bishops of Arizona and an interfaith network of Arizona religious leaders responded with an emotionally charged statement accusing the governor of sacrificing “political courage for political expediency” and suggesting the law is an affront to human dignity and runs afoul of the basic moral precept directing us to welcome the stranger.

(snip)

To my knowledge, however, the *Compendium *does not suggest that the principle of rule of law should be subordinated somehow to the exigencies of the above mentioned rights. SB 1070 does no injustice to an illegal immigrant forced to forfeit his presence in the U.S. even when that means a temporary separation from family members already here. Such an eventuality is – for any illegal alien – a foreseeable potential consequence of breaking the law; responsibility for the attendant hardships brought about by such a breakup rests squarely on the shoulders of the illegal alien, not on the community where he resides and into which he has patently failed to integrate through the observance of the law.
The rest of his insightful article are well worth reading.
 
Finally.

I have been wondering where all of the priests that do not condemn this law were.
 
Father Thomas Berg gives us his insights on CNA:
Arizona governor Jan Brewer signed the Arizona Immigration Bill (SB 1070) on April 23. The Catholic bishops of Arizona and an interfaith network of Arizona religious leaders responded with an emotionally charged statement accusing the governor of sacrificing “political courage for political expediency” and suggesting the law is an affront to human dignity and runs afoul of the basic moral precept directing us to welcome the stranger.

(snip)

To my knowledge, however, the *Compendium *does not suggest that the principle of rule of law should be subordinated somehow to the exigencies of the above mentioned rights. SB 1070 does no injustice to an illegal immigrant forced to forfeit his presence in the U.S. even when that means a temporary separation from family members already here. Such an eventuality is – for any illegal alien – a foreseeable potential consequence of breaking the law; responsibility for the attendant hardships brought about by such a breakup rests squarely on the shoulders of the illegal alien, not on the community where he resides and into which he has patently failed to integrate through the observance of the law.
The rest of his insightful article are well worth reading.
Thank you Father 👍👍
 
I think that some Bishops are getting involved in a phony issue when it comes to Arizona law.
The US will never deport 11 million people. They each have the right to “due process”, which means they would have the right to present their **individual **case in Immigration Court. (We would all be dead before this could ever be completed. It is not going to happen.)

Per the Arizona law - the ILLEGAL immigrant would have to be suspected of a crime - other than illegal immigration - before they could be stopped and asked for their green card or other papers.

First, we must get the Federal Government to secure the Border. And only then should we discuss the process of changing our immigration laws. All Mexican workers may not want to pledge allegience in citizenship to the US rather than their mother Country.

I think these Bishops need to be concerned about the safety and welfare of everyone in Arizona.
securetheborder.org/

The Bishop is correct about Social Teachings of the Church - and the Church should give sacraments and administer to human beings regardless of immigration status.
On the other hand the Catechism clearly states that Immigrants must obey the laws of the land.

There is no genocide (other than abortion), religious persecution, or starvation in Mexico that we are aware of.
American unemployment is currently at 9.9%.
 
The Bishop is correct about Social Teachings of the Church - and the Church should give sacraments and administer to human beings regardless of immigration status.
On the other hand the Catechism clearly states that Immigrants must obey the laws of the land.

I’m glad somebody said it. The law of the land does not state that people from other countries are free to enter our borders and stay while stealing from those who are here legally through welfare programs also meant for citizens. I actually found a great story regarding immigration using a foundation in Church history.

insidecatholic.com/Joomla/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=8087&Itemid=121&ed=1
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top