Illinois pharmacist ruling praised as conscience victory

  • Thread starter Thread starter Joe_5859
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Joe_5859

Guest
Here’s some good news for a change of pace.

Illinois pharmacist ruling praised as conscience victory

Washington D.C., Dec 13, 2012 / 12:06 am (CNA).- Religious liberty advocates are hailing the end of a seven-year legal battle over the required provision of abortion drugs in Illinois pharmacies as a major triumph for conscience rights.

“This decision is a great victory for religious freedom,” said Mark Rienzi, senior counsel for the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, which has represented the pharmacists in the case for several years.

“The government shouldn’t kick business owners out of the market just because it dislikes their religious beliefs,” he said in a statement.

(read more)
 
Now this is some interesting precedent in terms of the HHS mandate. The court here is saying that your freedom of religion extends to how you practice your business on a personal level:
The governor did not allow a religious exemption to the rule, saying that pharmacists who were morally opposed to the drug should find a different profession.
Several pharmacists and pharmacies that morally object to cooperating in the destruction of human life filed a lawsuit challenging the rule.
The suit argued that the rule violated state religious liberty laws, health care conscience protections and the religious freedom guarantees in the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
It charged that the rule unfairly discriminated against health care professionals seeking to contribute to society according to their principles by forcing them to choose between their constitutionally protected rights and their livelihood.

In April 2011, an Illinois trial court granted a permanent injunction blocking the rule from applying to the pharmacists. The court found no evidence that anyone had been harmed by a pharmacist’s religious objections to providing the drugs. It also noted that the law allowed pharmacies to refuse to sell drugs for many other business reasons, but not religious ones.
A state appellate court affirmed the injunction in September 2012, finding that the rule amounted to “discrimination in licensing” against those with religious objections to early abortion drugs.
 
Good news indeed.

But I wouldn’t gloat about it. Things like this usually backfire or have a fallout, especially in Illinois.
 
This is very good news, we should all pause and thank and praise God.
 
Finally. When I heard about this “adjustment” to the Healthcare bill, I was outraged. It’s good to see that we are gaining some ground in this debate. 👍
 
Finally. When I heard about this “adjustment” to the Healthcare bill, I was outraged. It’s good to see that we are gaining some ground in this debate. 👍
It may be my imagination, but it seems like the "A"CA is taking nothing but hits in the courts.
 
Good news indeed.

But I wouldn’t gloat about it. Things like this usually backfire or have a fallout, especially in Illinois.
Hey, don’t rain on our parade! 😛

But, yeah, we generally should never gloat about any victory. I still want to savor something positive, though. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top