L
Lisa4Catholics
Guest
Thank you. He’s still workin’.Can’t keep a good saint down.
Thank you. He’s still workin’.Can’t keep a good saint down.
I don’t know I had the incorruptables and lent it to someone and never got it backThis is truly amazing. I had seen pictures and heard of this before…but I never knew just how many were incorruptible. Are there any other recommended books on this subject?
Wow. Can you provide any links? About the Cardinal: they talk bad about the Pope from WWII. Fiction. I don’t know about this Cardinal but I’d like to see some evidence before I accept what they say.Does anyone know of the body of Cardinal Shuster (1880–1954), a former archbishop of Milan, which was discovered to be incorrupt after 31 years in the grave. The body was exhumed in 1985 and found to be incorrupt. The cardinal however “was anything but a saint; he was a friend of Mussolini and supported fascism and Italy’s war with Abyssinia.”
I also read this “There are, however, several incorrupt bodies of Buddhist monks which are preserved as objects of veneration.”
And last…why are some of the bodies of the incorruptibles tampered with so much? I read of St. Bernadette, that her face and hands have been covered with a mask of wax. Why?
Any commments? Thanks.
I find that fascinating, Susan, because as a convert, the whole “incorruptible thing” well, freaked me out at first. Just months after my baptism into the Church, I went on a pilgrimage with a group of contemplative monks through Europe; we saw the incorrupt bodies of St. John Vianney in Ars, and St. Catherine Laboure in Rue de Bac, Paris (site of the apparition of the Miraculous Medal). Their bodies are displayed in glass casing and they look like the might just sit up at a moment’s notice. Amazing experience.I was Protestant and I had never heard of this before I met a good Catholic friend. This was one of several factors that encouraged me to become Catholic.
Actually, it lit a fire under me.
St Bernadette was exhumed some 30 years after her death and the only thing wrong with the body was it had mold on it. After she was cleaned her skin was still soft and pliable. So yes she is perfectly preserved. Some are not so well preserved… The body of Cardinal Newman looks mummified. Testing showed he is not infact mummified and though his flesh is very dry, it is in fact, uncorrupted. Pope John XXIII was thought to by preserved also but as it turns out he is mummified and is such through natural processes.Wow! I have never heard of this before. Well maybe somewhat, but not like this? What in the world to Protestants and atheists say to this? Are these Saints really perfectly purserved?
Do the Protestants ever give a reason why they think it is from the Devil? Could it be because they don’t want it to give credence to the Catholics?As to what Protestants say…""“Its of the Devil”"
As to what atheists say…“There must be a scientific explaination”
If someone tried to say that to me I would remind them of a certain group in scripture that accused Jesus of working by the power of the devilDo the Protestants ever give a reason why they think it is from the Devil? Could it be because they don’t want it to give credence to the Catholics?
Personally, I was raised Methodist and I never even heard of such a thing before.
I have seen several Protestant posters respond to miracles in these forums with “How are you sure these are not works of the devil?” It doesn’t make sense to me that the devil would perform tricks that enhance the glory of God!Do the Protestants ever give a reason why they think it is from the Devil? Could it be because they don’t want it to give credence to the Catholics?
Personally, I was raised Methodist and I never even heard of such a thing before.
As far as proving anything about Catholicism, this is what one site says:I have seen several Protestant posters respond to miracles in these forums with “How are you sure these are not works of the devil?” It doesn’t make sense to me that the devil would perform tricks that enhance the glory of God!
Well,tell them to prove itAs far as proving anything about Catholicism, this is what one site says:
“Nor does the phenomenon of incorrupt bodies necessarily prove the claims of Catholicism. When the famous yogi Paramahansa Yogananda died in California, in 1952, his unembalmed body had not decayed and was said to emit a beautiful fragrance. Perhaps there are many incorrupt bodies of holy Protestants, Jews, Muslims and Buddhists, but we’ll never know because these religions don’t have the unusual custom of digging up their suspected saints.”
I’ve read that site and I didn’t say that the incorruptible bodies proved anything about Catholicism. I said that Protestants have asked how we don’t know the devil wasn’t at work with these miracles and my response was that I don’t believe the devil would be involved in anything that gives glory to God. We obviously are amazed at God’s power when we see incorruptibles - hardly the reaction the devil would work for!As far as proving anything about Catholicism, this is what one site says:
“Nor does the phenomenon of incorrupt bodies necessarily prove the claims of Catholicism. When the famous yogi Paramahansa Yogananda died in California, in 1952, his unembalmed body had not decayed and was said to emit a beautiful fragrance. Perhaps there are many incorrupt bodies of holy Protestants, Jews, Muslims and Buddhists, but we’ll never know because these religions don’t have the unusual custom of digging up their suspected saints.”
I have been told by many anti-catholics that all Catholic Miracles are Satanic in origin because “The devil can perform signs and wonders too”.Do the Protestants ever give a reason why they think it is from the Devil? Could it be because they don’t want it to give credence to the Catholics?
Personally, I was raised Methodist and I never even heard of such a thing before.
Yes, and if the miracle is proven to be there to debunk the Catholic Church’s infallible teachings, then that is how “I” would know they are not of Christ.I have been told by many anti-catholics that all Catholic Miracles are Satanic in origin because “The devil can perform signs and wonders too”.