I’m flipping your post upside down so I can answer it better.
I did also present the option of living as brother and sister, but again, this does not solve his urges and I am not faulting him for having urges, that is how God has made men. I feel like by staying married I am participating INdirectly in a sin that he will inevitably fall into should we stay married and he need to remain celibate for the next 8-10 years.
Does that make sense?
I know what you’re getting at, but honestly, it doesn’t make sense to me. If you had no children, or if your children were grown, I could see that there might be logic in an anulment. However, even then, a divorce & annulment doesn’t guarantee that he would get remarried, and if this all comes down to his urges, I’d question the judgment of getting into a 2nd marriage.
It is true that living as brother and sister doesn’t solve his urges, although it might reduce them in the following ways:
1-by not sleeping next to each other: I imagine the physical proximity in bed increases the desire. Also, by holding back other affections. It doesn’t turn off the desire, but I’m sure there are times when he is not in the mood, but a little wifely affection causes him to be in the mood. At least THOSE times would be reduced. It’s not perfect, but it’s an improvement.
2-by forcing him to be more accountable/transparent. His own place might turn into a “bachelor pad.” Whether there is temptation to go to bad websites, or to watch bad tv, or to subscribe to a bad pay-channel, or subscribe to a bad magazine, these things will all be more difficult to do while living in the house with your kids. In addition, by adopting the “single” life, he is more likely to be more tempted to seek female companionship in an immoral way. He is already slipping down the slope of self-gratification, could that be a step towards actual infidelity? Again, being in the house with you and the kids makes this more difficult. This doesn’t mean that you have to police him. Hopefully, he can recognize that it is better for him morally, to be in a place (literally) where sin is more difficult. Living with his family is likely to be that place.
I have suggested pursuing an annulment and I know it will NOT go over big, but hear me out. Right now we cannot have relations. St. Paul tells us if a man cannot control his urges then he should marry. St. Paul also extorts married couples that abstaining “for a time” is good if it is done for the purpose of prayer, but NOT to have it go on for a long time to keep the dev&l at bay. {all that was very loosely translated}. Since we ARE married and I cannot fulfill MY end of the marriage debt, should he not be able to find a healthy relationship whereby he can have all the things Sacred Scripture and the Catholic Church say are healthy and good for a married person?
No.
Now for the not blunt answer: Not while you have children in the home. You may owe him a marriage debt, but he owes you the same love with which Christ loves the Church. Frankly, I wouldn’t exactly describe the debt the same way you are - perhaps you have “overpaid” your debt by putting your own health at risk for the sake of that debt (and your children), and now HE is the one that owes YOU.
But aside from that, this is simply not about his right to have a sexually fulfilling marriage. There are several other souls that you and he are responsible for. No amount of “marriage debt/healthy relationship” is worth the devastation that divorce will bring to your children. The kids NEED an intact family. They are not struggling with self-control and unchastity. Why should THEY be the ones to suffer for this problem? If the marriage is not helping you or him get to heaven right now, perhaps your dh and you need to settle for using your marriage to help your children get to heaven. Perhaps others can find you some sources of info about the importance of intact families - and how even bad marriages are usually better than good divorces - when it comes to the welfare of the children.
I imagine I sound harsh here, but it seems like you and he are not currently able to do this for yourselves. So in that case, now is the time to lay down your lives for your children. No matter where he is, he is going to struggle with unchastity. Let him struggle with it in a place where his kids will still live with their mom and dad.