Impossible situation, now separation

  • Thread starter Thread starter over_whelmed
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I wonder, have you tried making some adjustments to live as “brother and sister” in a very literal sense? Maybe you could try that?
Bingo. This is exactly what has been on my mind and I desparately want to ask him to live this way, but I am afraid to ask. I know many of the married saints (not that I will EVER be one) have lived this way, including the most important of saints, Our Lady and St. Joseph.
The trick to success in abstinence is hidden in the details, and not putting yourselves into sexually arousing situations in the first place.
And I agree 100%, but again, getting him to see this might be a bit more difficult. This is where some heavy duty prayer and fasting will have to come in.
I pray that he seeks out the confessional and that he somehow finds the strength to deal with the cross he has been given.
Thankfully he has. He goes to Sunday Mass and one weekday Mass as well.
As far as separation are you saying he is no longer living with you?
Correct.
I am not a marriage expert but I would guess there is much more trouble in this marriage then having to abstain other then twice a month. Please look into a Retrouaville retreat to save your marriage. God bless.
There is. Years of me allowing him to do as he wishes has caused MUCH resentment. There are other issues including alcohol consumption etc…but the main problem is as mentioned…sex.
 
There is. Years of me allowing him to do as he wishes has caused MUCH resentment. There are other issues including alcohol consumption etc…but the main problem is as mentioned…sex.
I’m afraid you are wrong here. If you didn’t have the other issues you would find tha sex, or rather, abstinence, wouldn’t be causing these kind of problems at all. There are couples on here and many men who admitted that once they overcame the real, deep, issues- which NFP brought to the surface- NFP and/or abstinence ceased to be such a burden.

If we are to call a spade, a spade, we are talking namely about men overcoming their selfishness and sexual disorders for THE MOST part.
 
Bingo. This is exactly what has been on my mind and I desparately want to ask him to live this way, but I am afraid to ask. I know many of the married saints (not that I will EVER be one) have lived this way, including the most important of saints, Our Lady and St. Joseph.

And I agree 100%, but again, getting him to see this might be a bit more difficult. This is where some heavy duty prayer and fasting will have to come in.

Thankfully he has. He goes to Sunday Mass and one weekday Mass as well.

Correct.

OW, I can’t offer anything but my prayers. Your life sounds exactly like mine (8 kids, homeschooling, alcohol, etc) and I started a thread because my dh is a grouchy old bear when he doesn’t have sex, and many other things you say of your dh sound exactly like mine. However, I do not have a life threatening situation to deal with, and my heart aches for you that your husband would do this to you.
I will pray fervently that you find an answer that gives you the peace you should have.

There is. Years of me allowing him to do as he wishes has caused MUCH resentment. There are other issues including alcohol consumption etc…but the main problem is as mentioned…sex.
 
Well, you can only change you and pray for change for him. He knows what he is doing is wrong and has confessed but he has more work to do and you probably do too. Being married does not give him the right to do whatever he wants. It gives him the right to lay down his life for you. When he is not doing that, you must take care of yourself.

This is difficult and painful and he will be a jerk until the Holy Spirit does the work on him. Your challenge is to love him no matter what, and love is not necessarily as our priest said yesterday “huggy bear and kissy face” sometimes love is rather austere.

But you have control over you and your actions. You can only hope he will go “Aha! I finally get it!”

It sounds like he has an addiction, which is common these days, sad to say. It may be a good idea for him to get involved with a Fraternus group if there is one close by. Also the movie “Fireproof” is good too.

You sound like you could use more counselling just to give yourself support, and it never hurts to work on your own issues. You can recommend marriage counselling, or single counselling but in the end he has a choice to make. Sometimes it does require separation to open his eyes to how beautiful you are.

God bless you in this difficult time. I am so sorry, but in the end it will form you and sometimes formation hurts.

It sounds too like you have no intentions of divorcing but you are just giving a stronger boundary in protection of both of you. You with your health and him with his addiction. He needs to see it as an alchoholic sees finally when his family leaves him.

Just because youa re married does not give him the right to do whatever he wants just because you have a lisence to do so. This separation sounds like it is for the benefit of both of you…him his soul and you your physical body…
 
L piperatus:
I wonder, have you tried making some adjustments to live as “brother and sister” in a very literal sense? Maybe you could try that?
Bingo. This is exactly what has been on my mind and I desparately want to ask him to live this way, but I am afraid to ask.
I was going to make the same suggestion, and the fact that it has been on your mind already, suggests to me that maybe this is really something you should try to do, even though you are afraid. It seems to me that a separate-bedroom/brother-sister type of agreement has several benefits over a traditional separation:
1-the children benefit by having an intact family.
2-you and he (especially him, since he is the one who is facing most of the sexual temptation) will be constantly reminded that you are still married, which will help you eventually heal this rift, and which will serve as a deterrent to moving even further from your vows (not a fail safe, but a significant deterrent from at least SOME problematic behavior)
3-(see #1)
4-(see #1)
5-(see #1)
I’m sure you get my point about it being better for the children. Although I don’t want to undermine the importance of #2, I do believe that if nothing else can keep a marriage together, the knowledge of the devastating impact of divorce ought to. And I’m sure you already know that. My point in framing it that way is to help you to gather the courage for this difficult conversation, and also perhaps to remind you that maybe HE needs to be reminded to frame this in terms of what is best for the children, not necessarily what seems more favorable to him (or you).

I am sorry you are going through this. Prayers for you.
 
Heavenly Father, in faith, I thank You for helping this dear woman, her husband, and their children during this difficult time. Amen.
 
I have suggested pursuing an annulment and I know it will NOT go over big, but hear me out. Right now we cannot have relations. St. Paul tells us if a man cannot control his urges then he should marry. St. Paul also extorts married couples that abstaining “for a time” is good if it is done for the purpose of prayer, but NOT to have it go on for a long time to keep the dev&l at bay. {all that was very loosely translated}. Since we ARE married and I cannot fulfill MY end of the marriage debt, should he not be able to find a healthy relationship whereby he can have all the things Sacred Scripture and the Catholic Church say are healthy and good for a married person?

We do have grounds for annulment, but I don’t want to go into that right now.

I did also present the option of living as brother and sister, but again, this does not solve his urges and I am not faulting him for having urges, that is how God has made men. I feel like by staying married I am participating INdirectly in a sin that he will inevitably fall into should we stay married and he need to remain celibate for the next 8-10 years.

Does that make sense?
 
Overwhelmed, what did your priest tell you about your separation? Did he support it? Did he tell you that you did the right thing, to protect your children from your DH constantly yelling at them? I understand you say that your DH didn’t really pressure you to have sex, so the abstinence part could have been handled, possibly, without separation. Overall, what does your priest tell you? Did he approve of your separation, as something necessary and appropriate in your situation?
 
I’m flipping your post upside down so I can answer it better.
I did also present the option of living as brother and sister, but again, this does not solve his urges and I am not faulting him for having urges, that is how God has made men. I feel like by staying married I am participating INdirectly in a sin that he will inevitably fall into should we stay married and he need to remain celibate for the next 8-10 years.

Does that make sense?
I know what you’re getting at, but honestly, it doesn’t make sense to me. If you had no children, or if your children were grown, I could see that there might be logic in an anulment. However, even then, a divorce & annulment doesn’t guarantee that he would get remarried, and if this all comes down to his urges, I’d question the judgment of getting into a 2nd marriage.

It is true that living as brother and sister doesn’t solve his urges, although it might reduce them in the following ways:

1-by not sleeping next to each other: I imagine the physical proximity in bed increases the desire. Also, by holding back other affections. It doesn’t turn off the desire, but I’m sure there are times when he is not in the mood, but a little wifely affection causes him to be in the mood. At least THOSE times would be reduced. It’s not perfect, but it’s an improvement.

2-by forcing him to be more accountable/transparent. His own place might turn into a “bachelor pad.” Whether there is temptation to go to bad websites, or to watch bad tv, or to subscribe to a bad pay-channel, or subscribe to a bad magazine, these things will all be more difficult to do while living in the house with your kids. In addition, by adopting the “single” life, he is more likely to be more tempted to seek female companionship in an immoral way. He is already slipping down the slope of self-gratification, could that be a step towards actual infidelity? Again, being in the house with you and the kids makes this more difficult. This doesn’t mean that you have to police him. Hopefully, he can recognize that it is better for him morally, to be in a place (literally) where sin is more difficult. Living with his family is likely to be that place.
I have suggested pursuing an annulment and I know it will NOT go over big, but hear me out. Right now we cannot have relations. St. Paul tells us if a man cannot control his urges then he should marry. St. Paul also extorts married couples that abstaining “for a time” is good if it is done for the purpose of prayer, but NOT to have it go on for a long time to keep the dev&l at bay. {all that was very loosely translated}. Since we ARE married and I cannot fulfill MY end of the marriage debt, should he not be able to find a healthy relationship whereby he can have all the things Sacred Scripture and the Catholic Church say are healthy and good for a married person?
No.

Now for the not blunt answer: Not while you have children in the home. You may owe him a marriage debt, but he owes you the same love with which Christ loves the Church. Frankly, I wouldn’t exactly describe the debt the same way you are - perhaps you have “overpaid” your debt by putting your own health at risk for the sake of that debt (and your children), and now HE is the one that owes YOU.

But aside from that, this is simply not about his right to have a sexually fulfilling marriage. There are several other souls that you and he are responsible for. No amount of “marriage debt/healthy relationship” is worth the devastation that divorce will bring to your children. The kids NEED an intact family. They are not struggling with self-control and unchastity. Why should THEY be the ones to suffer for this problem? If the marriage is not helping you or him get to heaven right now, perhaps your dh and you need to settle for using your marriage to help your children get to heaven. Perhaps others can find you some sources of info about the importance of intact families - and how even bad marriages are usually better than good divorces - when it comes to the welfare of the children.

I imagine I sound harsh here, but it seems like you and he are not currently able to do this for yourselves. So in that case, now is the time to lay down your lives for your children. No matter where he is, he is going to struggle with unchastity. Let him struggle with it in a place where his kids will still live with their mom and dad.
 
Our priest said we needed to abstain until I reach menopause.
Implicit in this advice is also that the best thing for your family would be to stay together as a family. If you could possibly manage this, without your DH endangering your life or your children’s mental health (your life - by having sex; children’s mental health - by excessive yelling and harsh treatment), it would be best to simply stay together, live in the same house, and sleep in separate bedrooms in order to stay abstinent.
 
I have** not **consulted a priest on this. The last time I consulted a priest for his opinion it led us to complete devastation of our marriage. Plus I just moved and I do not know any priests.

Regarding the children factor…I am a the product of a child of living under the roof of two parents who 1) fought constantly, 2) slept apart, my mom on the couch, my Dad in his room - this in turn gave me an extremely unhealthy view of marital relations, which I then took into my adulthood.

I know where everyone is getting at in guarding the souls of the children, but frankly, looking back over my own childhood I wished my parents HAD separated for it would have spared us kids the emotional damage we brought into our adult lives.

I no longer am allowing fear to rule my every decision. There are many children in divorced homes that grow up healthy and spiritually well. Granted, the ideal would be for a healthy, loving marriage, but since that is not the case, I feel the children are more in danger of growing up with a skewed view on marriage by their parents having an odd set up, unnatural set up.

I know folks want to be “frank” with me and use the children as the deciding factor, but really, I must do what is best for them in my own judgment. At some point I have to trust my own judgment.

Again, I respect where you are coming from with regards to the kids, but I repeat for YEARS I have let FEAR of the unknown rule my every decision and it has gotten me absolutely no where. I am letting go of the fear and relying on my judgment, prayers and sacrifices to guide me.

Regarding my spouse having a bachelor pad and sinning anyway - this will be on him…not me. HE will have to take responsibility WITHOUT me there causing any sin by my mere presence. It is NOT NATURAL for a married couple to live this way. We BOTH have to deal with the results of poor judgment and lack of insight.
 
Implicit in this advice is also that the best thing for your family would be to stay together as a family. If you could possibly manage this, without your DH endangering your life or your children’s mental health (your life - by having sex; children’s mental health - by excessive yelling and harsh treatment), it would be best to simply stay together, live in the same house, and sleep in separate bedrooms in order to stay abstinent.
I just don’t know how this is possible in the OP’s circumstance. Her husband already resents her for not having sex with him. How is he going to handle living as brother and sister when they are husband and wife? I know my husband would not be able to handle it. His anger would eventually get the best of him. He might commit adultery and feel justified in doing it, since I would be depriving him of relations. It’s one thing if one of the two people is sick or something, or they BOTH agree to keep their physical relationship on the back burner for a while, but to try and do this for 8-10 YEARS?? I don’t know of any healthy man who could accept those terms.
 
Cannot understand the refusal to consult your pastor. Your pastor is determined by where you live, the Diocese can tell you what parish boundries you are inside, the pastor of that Church is responsible for you.

You are a practicing Catholic? You do realize that your pastor can grant you permission to separate (the Bishop gives that authority to almost all pastors).

Your pastor can also clear up the idea about “grounds for an annulment”. If you are aware your marriage was invalid - that means the day you said “I DO” that a marriage did not take place, then yes speak to your pastor tomorrow. You would be wrong to have sex if you know you are invalidly married.

If that marriage was valid the day you said “I DO”, nothing you or your spouse has done can make it become invalid.

I pray that you can speak to your pastor very soon. He is there for you!
 
It’s one thing if one of the two people is sick or something, or they BOTH agree to keep their physical relationship on the back burner for a while.
She is sick in a way because she has the potential to die, leaving him alone and the kids alone. That should be enough for him, as a husband who loves his wife and children, to understand this is very serious and not just for him, but for his whole family.
 
She is sick in a way because she has the potential to die, leaving him alone and the kids alone. That should be enough for him, as a husband who loves his wife and children, to understand this is very serious and not just for him, but for his whole family.
That’s a good point. I get the feeling her husband does not view things that way. He could perhaps have some amount of narcissism, and I don’t use that term lightly. People who cannot put themselves into anyone else’s situation, cannot feel true empathy, cannot put their needs or desires aside and attend to someone else, are narcissistic. I hope that is not the case of the OP’s husband.
 
I just don’t know how this is possible in the OP’s circumstance. Her husband already resents her for not having sex with him. How is he going to handle living as brother and sister when they are husband and wife? I know my husband would not be able to handle it. His anger would eventually get the best of him. He might commit adultery and feel justified in doing it, since I would be depriving him of relations. It’s one thing if one of the two people is sick or something, or they BOTH agree to keep their physical relationship on the back burner for a while, but to try and do this for 8-10 YEARS?? I don’t know of any healthy man who could accept those terms.
Juliane, you might have a point that the OP’s husband won’t be able to handle living under one roof and staying abstinent. Frankly, the last post of the OP scares me - if my own sister came to me and said that she was no longer willing to live in fear, or let her decisions be motivated by fear, I would start wondering, what’s going on? Even if the husband wasn’t physically violent with Over_whelmed, the expression seems to betray serious emotional abuse. Why would someone need to ever live in fear? That’s just wrong, and again, if that was my sister talking like that to me, I would say to her, “Get the heck out of there, NOW, and ask questions later!”

We need to wait for Over_whelmed to come back and give us more information, but for now this is my working hypothesis: there was serious abuse and pain in this marriage, and that’s why the OP chose to separate, without even consulting her priest. Over_whelmed, could you please confirm or correct me if I’m wrong?

I also wonder, in what sense did your priest give you bad advice (cause devastation), last time you consulted him? Did he advise you against separating, but then staying together just proved too much to bear? Did he advise you to practice long-term abstinence, and then your DH blew up and started blaming you for withholding marital intimacy?

I will add this, from a man’s perspective: no, it’s not too much to ask for abstinence, for 8-10 years. If the alternative is that your wife will probably be killed by her next pregnancy, you’ve got to protect your wife. Also, that cr*p about “If you don’t want to be at my disposal, you must be lacking in faith in God”, that’s really aggravating. That sounds egoistic and childish, possibly even narcissistic.
 
I am inclined to believe you are correct. It is an impossible situation. Unless both husband and wife are quite literally on the path to sainthood, and desiring to sucessfully combat desires of the flesh, it cannot work. Unless a miracle happens.

My wife is in the process separating from me. It’s a long and sad story, and there are only victims here. One of my worst crimes is living according to true Catholic teaching on sexuality. Through our past 15 years, I have tried, in vain at times, to figure out her cycles – she had no interest in taking the responsibility herself but certainly did want “care-free” relations – and she definitely did not want another child! I had all of the responsibility for NFP, and rarely felt confident enough to have relations more than two or three times a year. This, and other things over time, has destroyed our marriage. She has “fallen out of love” with me and now reconnected with a nominally Catholic man from her younger nominally Catholic days, and they are certainly not interested in living according to Catholic sexual morals.

I could have averted the problem by joining the very large percentage of Catholic couples who secretly contracept. But I just couldn’t. I had had enough of the “culture of hypocrisy” that had consumed the church of my youth. If my marriage dies instead of thrives with a committment to Catholic living, then it is not a marriage.

We too will have no problem with a annulment, unless the tribunal has completely lost its marbles.

Is it more of a scandal to divorce and annul than to continue to pretend a sacramental marriage exists, and an unhealthy one at that? Given the turmoil you lived through as a child (I did too), and the insight you have in your present marriage and with your children, I think you know the answer to that one. We must bear witness to the truth, and if it wasn’t a valid marriage then, if you cannot in good conscience make it valid now, it leaves only one option, as painful as it is. For me, this pain will continue through the rest of my life. My youngest child, in high school now, is suffering in all of this too, but I have talked to her often and gently about the many different forms of love we must show, and that living our Catholic beliefs often comes with suffering.

My wife has a priest friend who has waffled on advice to her, but recently said, “You said those vows!” While he means well, I can only think of Mt 23:4: “They tie up heavy burdens and lay them on men’s shoulders, but they themselves are unwilling to move them with so much as a finger.” You must pray, and pray, and visit the blessed sacrament, and pray, and discern, and pray some more … and then decide, for yourself.
 
timotheos;8580155 said:
I had had enough of the “culture of hypocrisy” that had consumed the church of my youth.

If my marriage dies instead of thrives with a commitment to Catholic living, then it is not a marriage.

I’m right there with you. I am sorry that your marriage is coming to an end. I’m sorry that my marriage took place the way it did in the first place (with neither of us considering ourselves to be Catholic). Although it’s caused me great pain since, I am not sorry that God brought me back to the Church. I wish I could help my husband open his heart to the Lord, but all I can do is pray for him. I’m not the best Catholic, I fail every day, but I’m honestly trying to live the way I should have been living all along. And yes, it would be easier to do this without also having to protect our sons from the knowledge that their dad is an atheist (who hates to be labeled as one).

:hug3:
 
Juliane, you might have a point that the OP’s husband won’t be able to handle living under one roof and staying abstinent. Frankly, the last post of the OP scares me - if my own sister came to me and said that she was no longer willing to live in fear, or let her decisions be motivated by fear, I would start wondering, what’s going on? Even if the husband wasn’t physically violent with Over_whelmed, the expression seems to betray serious emotional abuse. Why would someone need to ever live in fear? That’s just wrong, and again, if that was my sister talking like that to me, I would say to her, “Get the heck out of there, NOW, and ask questions later!”

We need to wait for Over_whelmed to come back and give us more information, but for now this is my working hypothesis: there was serious abuse and pain in this marriage, and that’s why the OP chose to separate, without even consulting her priest. Over_whelmed, could you please confirm or correct me if I’m wrong?

I also wonder, in what sense did your priest give you bad advice (cause devastation), last time you consulted him? Did he advise you against separating, but then staying together just proved too much to bear? Did he advise you to practice long-term abstinence, and then your DH blew up and started blaming you for withholding marital intimacy?

I will add this, from a man’s perspective: no, it’s not too much to ask for abstinence, for 8-10 years. If the alternative is that your wife will probably be killed by her next pregnancy, you’ve got to protect your wife. Also, that cr*p about “If you don’t want to be at my disposal, you must be lacking in faith in God”, that’s really aggravating. That sounds egoistic and childish, possibly even narcissistic.
L piperatus you are a good man. Thank you for this.
 
…Frankly, the last post of the OP scares me - if my own sister came to me and said that she was no longer willing to live in fear, or let her decisions be motivated by fear, I would start wondering, what’s going on? … for now this is my working hypothesis: there was serious abuse and pain in this marriage, and that’s why the OP chose to separate, without even consulting her priest. Over_whelmed, could you please confirm or correct me if I’m wrong?
Since I have been strongly advocating staying together for the sake of the children, I feel the need to add that if the above is true, then I would support a separation as well. When there is abuse, separation is the appropriate action, for the sake of the kids as well as for the abused spouse.

If there is not abuse, I stand by my earlier argument, but I don’t think I have more to offer the discussion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top